HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

analog31

21,863 karma · joined July 14, 2013

Physicist, computer & electronics enthusiast, musician.

Gadgeteer.

Passionate about understanding how things work, and making things work. Hoping to learn about tools and techniques that will make my work more productive / fun.

submissionscomments
analog31··on The Legend of von Neumann (1973) [pdf]
Oddly enough, I got a physics degree, and then happened to teach the engineering course for one semester many years ago while in between jobs. I'm sure this varies from one college to the next. My impressions at the time were:

The physics version was much more mathematical, and did things like solving everything in spherical coordinates. It also kind of served as a preparation for solving corresponding problems in quantum mechanics.

The engineering version was more nuts-and-bolts, covering things like transformers, motors, and transmission lines. (Antennas were for a later course).

As a consequence, teaching the engineering course required me to quickly learn a whole bunch of stuff that we glossed over or ignored in the physics course. While also teaching it. Fortunately I was an experimental physicist and had also done some work in industry, so the topics weren't utterly unfamiliar.

analog31··on "The only intuitive interface is the nipple" (2012)
In addition, a lot of first time mothers died, as did their babies.
analog31··on "The only intuitive interface is the nipple" (2012)
>>> lactation consultants...

In my experience, weekly trips to the lactation consultant had no effect except for a growing sense of shame.

analog31··on Coltrane's Tone Circle
This makes it a perpetual challenge for me, and I've never mastered it. Doing something sensible on double bass is hard enough without it always having to be at some unmusical tempo.

On more straightforward changes, I can usually internalize the melody and harmonic motion well enough to form a sensible solo, but I've got my limits. Fortunately the era of "Giant Steps" getting called on every gig has more or less passed.

analog31··on Ask HN: What are you reading?
Moby Dick. I'm further through then I've ever gotten before thanks to a long airplane ride.
analog31··on Solving a corn puzzle with CP-SAT
The first thing that came to my mind was: Tetris with periodic boundary conditions.
analog31··on Flock Wants the Most Detailed Map of Its Surveillance Cameras Taken Offline
Indeed, power over one person is different than power distributed over an entire country. Good to point that out.
analog31··on Flock Wants the Most Detailed Map of Its Surveillance Cameras Taken Offline
I think there's a balance that needs to be struck, in proportion to actual power. A senator or cabinet member deserves more scrutiny than a small town city clerk. Also, there are private individuals who knowingly exercise more power than that clerk.
analog31··on As A.I. makes law firms more efficient, clients ask: 'Where's my discount?'
The other version of this joke:

Customer: $500 for 10 minutes of work? That's more than I make as a brain surgeon.

Plumber: It's more than I made as a brain surgeon too.

analog31··on Alan Kay's answer to “Did the ENIAC have a BIOS”?
Processes like this are where "boot" comes from. The machine was pulling itself up by its bootstraps. The ROM was sometimes called the "bootstrap loader."
analog31··on Replacing the old battery on rechargeable bike lights
I do some optical engineering, and once took a course on lighting design. Indeed, bike lights are unregulated, and therefore, un-engineered. During the winter on my commute home from work, I usually have to cover my eyes on the bike path to avoid being blinded by oncoming cyclists.

I think Germany has regulations on this. I've bought lights on AliExpress that have a cut-off.

analog31··on Replacing the old battery on rechargeable bike lights
Amazon has the Shimano dynohub for $125. Then you have to build a wheel. You might be able to re-use your rim if it's got 36 holes.

I explored dynohubs in the past, but LEDs and LiPo batteries have really narrowed the gap. In my garage, I've got a super long USB cable that we all use for charging our lights. I've used cheap lights from AliExpress, and they are actually quite durable.

analog31··on How I changed teaching after AI managed to do all my homework assignments
Learning and understanding were always and option, and still are.
analog31··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
This works at the office too.
analog31··on Plunging test scores are a slow-moving catastrophe
Indeed, and some countries have whole word writing.
analog31··on Plunging test scores are a slow-moving catastrophe
When my daughter was in kindergarten, it was common to walk your kids to school, then let them play in the playground while chatting with the other parents, until the bell rang.

One mom told me: "I like the American school. It's like Singapore, but with fewer beatings."

analog31··on We're gonna need a lot more mathematicians
To me, "domain knowledge" seems to resemble a primitive form of "slop filter" to use the modern parlance. In any field, the majority of possible ideas are slop. This has always been the case. People somehow learn to navigate through the slop, to find things that are worth working on.

Even before the AI era, we were flooded with a veritable DDOS attack of slop, in our in-boxes, meetings, etc. Managers believed that innovation was held back by quantity of ideas, or by the domain experts being "resistant to change." This led to day-long group brainstorming sessions that yielded nothing. Part of the transition from student to junior to senior is learning to filter your own ideas, and to guide others in the search for ideas that are likely to be fruitful.

The criteria for slop filtering have always been subjective, arbitrary, or driven by institutional culture. That's what we've got. Any means of generating ideas produces slop in the absence of filtering.

What will slop filtering look like when the AI can generate tera-proofs per second? What does it look like already for our e-mail inboxes? We are asymptotically trending towards slop filters that look more and more like "ignore everything." I already read none of the business memoranda that I receive. I don't answer my phone. The number of workers needed to read and assess business memoranda is zero.

The slop filter still functions in math. Problems are pre-filtered for being of interest. Somebody expressed enough interest in the Navier-Stokes problem to give it a name and attach a prize to it. There are still plenty of "prize problems." Here are some:

* Quantum gravity

* Improvement of superconductors that don't need helium

* Practical generation of power from fusion

analog31··on Gravity seems holographic. What does that mean for reality?
This is cool, but I've noticed that an idea of a "holographic universe" makes the news roughly once a decade.

Maybe fifth time's the charm. ;-)

analog31··on Back and shoulder surgery is often worse than useless
Waiting 10 weeks for an MRI is consistent with my experience in the US. This could be a regional thing. When my mom lived in her home state, she had nearly same-month or even same-week access to specialists. Now, living in my state, most appointments are booked more than a year out. She has talked about flying back to her home state every year to have her annual appointments. This is medical tourism within the country.

Not only did I have to wait for my MRI, but as the date approached, I got a call saying that they had canceled it because the insurance refused to cover it. I offered to pay out of pocket. Nope, they simply canceled it.

Of course if you can pay for quicker care in another country, it will seem like care in that country is quicker, but the people living in that country might not have the same privilege. Most of the people I know who move here from outside the US think our system is insane.

There's a billboard on my way to work for a private medical imaging service that offers shorter wait times.

analog31··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
They can move to Afghanistan. I'm not sure the wealth leaving the state, or the country, is such a bad thing.

Meanwhile, when you're in an "already too late" situation, it's already too late. You still have to deal with it.

analog31··on Tutoring company tells parents to save their money and 'use AI instead'
This time around, AI being able to do student homework means that AI is replacing students not teachers.
analog31··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
Are fossil fuels net profitable after subsidies, wars, and externalities are considered?
analog31··on Meta’s Muse has a serious 0-day
Well if nothing else, idiocy that's as old as time started on day zero.
analog31··on The Advisory Group on Mathematics and Artificial Intelligence
There might be a paradox here. We need closed communities to weed out slop. But we need open communities to weed out corruption.
analog31··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
Even rats. They are supported by our food and garbage.
analog31··on Whirlpool Washer Transmission Repair (2007)
I've repaired all kinds of stuff in my house, including appliances. Calling someone to fix something could cost me more time than fixing it myself. Also, I can time-shift when I do it myself, for instance working during hours when I'm unlikely to get paid to do something.

An example is bike repair. If something breaks, getting it fixed would mean driving it to the shop and back again. Doing it on my own terms and schedule, I can fix it at night, often in a few minutes. If it needs a part, I ride a spare bike until the part arrives.

I decide on a case by case basis. I don't change the oil in my car because I can drop it off on my way to work, and in that case, I am getting paid while the car is being serviced. Also, some kinds of work involve more tools and space than I want to own. And mess.

The home furnace, in the middle of winter while my elderly parents are vising... yeah call the guy.

analog31··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
But there will be fewer of them, because we generate their food.
analog31··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
In my observation, most programmers and engineers lose their math chops over time. The math they need is mostly baked into their tools, such as CAD. If a problem requires more advanced math, it's given to a "math person" in the department. Often, the "math person" is also not allowed to touch the production code.
analog31··on The Millennium Problems for Biology
In a sense all experimental science has an element of engineering. For instance the first problem, "the origins of life" is framed to require an experiment to show that any proposed mechanism actually works.
analog31··on If math is more than proof, we need to better celebrate the rest of it
Fortunately proofs were still part of the curriculum when I was in school. Typically, geometry focused on proofs. When my kids took geometry, proofs took a back seat to problems. This also got us to the point where the college math curriculum has to include a class on how to do proofs.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →