> This is the S1 in Berlin
The vast majority of people in the US do not live in places that are at all comparable to Berlin, or NYC for that matter.
> Shopping should be local,
Which means that you're limited to what's popular enough in your local area. And, it usually leads to small stores, which are inherently less efficient and thus more expensive.
> The US model of consolidating all schools into superschools and the move them deep into the subburbs surounded by parking lots is literally the worst.
Suburbs have schools because suburbs have lots of kids. FWIW, there is a tendency for folks to move from cities to suburbs when they have kids.
That said, city kids go to city schools. Yes, there is some "city schools are so horrible that we'll let some city kids go elsewhere" but it's [1] in the noise and [2] caused by crappy city schools/govts, not urban design.
Crappy city govts cause lots of problems, not just crappy schools, but if those govts could be easily fixed, it would have happened. (FWIW, almost all of those crappy city govts have been super-majority Democrat for decades.)
> Sightseeing, how else would you go sightseeing if not with the train. I dont get it. Would any place you want to go to be just full of parking lots?
No.
You're assuming that every place you go sightseeing has lots of people. That might be true in Europe, but it's not true in the US.