HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anamax

7,213 karma · joined August 28, 2007

submissionscomments
anamax··on How Shadow Banning Can Silently Shift Opinion Online
> Personally I don’t think the platforms being private matters - at their scale the big social media platforms are public squares, and should be regulated like that.

Malls and shopping centers in California are treated as public squares for 1st amendment purposes. It's unclear why Facebook et al aren't given the same treatment, at least in California. (Note this is California, not Federal, law.)

https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/pruneyard-shopping-c...

anamax··on Windows Returns
Windows 11 won't run on my current desktop.

Also, Windows 10 is the last Windows OS that supports many "not subscription" services. (Desktop Quicken 2016/2017 does everything I need, so why should I pay for a subscription?)

anamax··on D-Expressions: Lisp power, Dylan style [pdf]
In Python, the "." in "target . method" is an infix operator.

Note that the "(" in (a, b) is also an operator. (There is some special parsing because otherwise you could do things like args = (1, 2, b=3); target.method args.)

As to whether <thing from target.method><thing from (a, b)> is postfix, I'm not sure how you get there. Yes, there's an implicit funcall at the end, but there's something similar with (+ a b) or ((. target method) (arglist a b)) and we wouldn't call them postfix.

anamax··on Show HN: I built a website to create financial models for any stock online
> Warren Buffet supports this idea for retail investors.

Everything that Buffet says falls into one of two categories: [1] He has no relevant knowledge. [2] He/Berkshire makes money from it.

[2] Is the most common. (His railways transport oil. His insurance companies make money from the inheritance tax, a tax that his estate won't pay. Etc.)

anamax··on Mortgages are a manufactured product (2022)
> A thought I've had regularly is that any financial product so widely required ought to be provided at cost (base rate of interest) through central banks. Why bother with middlemen?

In the US at least, govt has problems running "retail." (It also has problems running wholesale, as evidenced by the give-aways to BlackRock, but ...)

anamax··on The Iberian lynx doubles its population in just three years
> The human race is not going to go hungry because a farmer gave 50 sheep to the cats.

How about you give sheep to the cats?

> create a seperate fenced off area for unwanted farm stock.

All farm stock is wanted/used at some level.

anamax··on EU Joint Debt Is a Slippery Slope, Nobel Economist Sargent Says
Need doesn't imply possible.
anamax··on Thinking out loud about 2nd-gen email
You're right - I thought that you'd made one fatal error (sender registries) when you'd actually made a different one (introducers).

> spam is generally understood to be unsolicited email

Not so fast. If spam is universally disliked and should be eradicated, it can't include all unsolicited email.

That's because people LIKE some unsolicited email. Unless you can distinguish unsolicited email that someone will like from unsolicited email that they won't like ...

FWIW, you come across like the "advertising should be banned" people. (That's another group that confuses the existence of a problem with the existence of a solution that doesn't have any downsides. They fixate on their solution and try to define-away its downsides.)

Advertising is a lot like spam. It is product information. If you don't care about the information, it is unwanted, but if you do.... The thing is, there's always someone who cares.

FWIW, every time I've physically met someone who claims to be anti-advertising, said someone has happily displayed several pieces of advertising for products that said someone liked. When I point that out, "that's different" or "I don't mean that kind of advertising."

anamax··on Thinking out loud about 2nd-gen email
Attendee? What year is it in your world? (Also, time-limited is stupid for this case.)

This isn't an edge case - people pass out addresses expecting to be contacted by randoms all the time.

And, most contacts are second-order or further, so introductions aren't even possible because there's no common link. (I pass on "you should contact {other person}" to groups that I don't control all the time.)

I get that you're proud of your introductions hammer, but you don't get to ignore the existence of screws.

anamax··on Stoke Space: 100% reusable rockets
Will SpaceX sell/rent first stages? How about first stage engines?

I ask because Stoke is reinventing 80% (the first stage) to reinvent 20% (the second).

anamax··on I Couldn't Escape Poison Oak. So I Started Eating It
When the shit hits the fan, you'll either be saved or doomed by one of those "dumb guys".
anamax··on Thinking out loud about 2nd-gen email
That relies on introducers/mutual acquaintances, which isn't enough.

Here's an easy problem that it doesn't solve. I'm giving a public talk and want to provide an email address so that people can contact me.

How do you [1] let legitimate responses get to me AND [2] block illegitimate responses. (Note - I have no control over the audience.)

anamax··on Thinking out loud about 2nd-gen email
> If email didn't need fixing, spam wouldn't exist.

Let's start with something easy - [1] define spam. [2] Can spam be identified with a purely mechanical (no humans involved) process?

Do you have a definition of "spam" that is substantially different from "mail that I don't want."

It's also interesting that you assume that spammers can't generate new identities. (Yes, you seem to think that introductions solves everything, but it doesn't)

I ask that because "I don't want" requires mind-reading by the sender.

anamax··on Urban renewal left the U.S. too scared to build
> This is the S1 in Berlin

The vast majority of people in the US do not live in places that are at all comparable to Berlin, or NYC for that matter.

> Shopping should be local,

Which means that you're limited to what's popular enough in your local area. And, it usually leads to small stores, which are inherently less efficient and thus more expensive.

> The US model of consolidating all schools into superschools and the move them deep into the subburbs surounded by parking lots is literally the worst.

Suburbs have schools because suburbs have lots of kids. FWIW, there is a tendency for folks to move from cities to suburbs when they have kids.

That said, city kids go to city schools. Yes, there is some "city schools are so horrible that we'll let some city kids go elsewhere" but it's [1] in the noise and [2] caused by crappy city schools/govts, not urban design.

Crappy city govts cause lots of problems, not just crappy schools, but if those govts could be easily fixed, it would have happened. (FWIW, almost all of those crappy city govts have been super-majority Democrat for decades.)

> Sightseeing, how else would you go sightseeing if not with the train. I dont get it. Would any place you want to go to be just full of parking lots?

No.

You're assuming that every place you go sightseeing has lots of people. That might be true in Europe, but it's not true in the US.

anamax··on Wind farms can offset their emissions within two years, new study shows
Domestic cats don't affect the food supply of large raptors because those cats are where people are, and where large raptors, for the most part, aren't. (The peopled places that have largish raptors also tend to have a surplus of pigeons.)

Raptor hunting has been illegal for decades in the US.

anamax··on A ‘plague’ comes before the fall: lessons from Roman history
> The only places that got shut down by the government were bars, restaurants and schools.

At least one SoCal city filled a skate park with sand.

There's a video of harbor cops going after a guy paddle-boarding in the ocean. (There was no one within 50 yards until the water cop on the jet-ski showed up.)

There were also churches where arrests happened.

California closed hair salons/barbers, but personal stylists were okay if you were connected. Then again, neither did the restaurant closing. (See Newsom, French Laundry.)

anamax··on The Downfall of DeviantArt
I see a lot of information about how to distribute content and revenues, but I don't see how you ensure that enough revenue comes in.

Wordpress' Tumblr problem is that costs exceed revenue, not distribution.

Note that "decentralized" doesn't reduce total costs - it just spreads them out. Server costs do not go down with the number of owners.

anamax··on Wind farms can offset their emissions within two years, new study shows
Cats rarely kill large raptors.
anamax··on Kibibytes are silly and we should all use them
DRAM and SRAM capacities are in binary, but storage device capacities (from device manufacturers) are decimal. (I thought that storage device capacities were actually mixed, that is, decimal kilobytes, so a megabyte is 1000 * 1024, but I can't find a source for that.)

I think that Windows and Linux both use binary for disk space.

Most of the usage for kibibyte that I see is in articles advocating its use.

anamax··on Work begins on a $12B high-speed rail line between Las Vegas and Los Angeles
To be fair, Germany is fairly small (by US/China) standards.

The continental US (no Alaska or Hawaii) is > 22.5 times as big as Germany but has only 8.8 times as many miles of "navigable waterways." (However, it's not clear if the US numbers include the Great Lakes or the oceans; LA to Seattle and Miami to NYC goes by ocean, not some river.)

But, that doesn't leave much for the rest of Europe.

anamax··on Work begins on a $12B high-speed rail line between Las Vegas and Los Angeles
> The line between Kiruna and Narvik is so beautiful I’m not sure why you’d want it to go faster.

That makes it a tourist line, not a transit line.

There's nothing wrong with tourism, but it isn't transit.

anamax··on Work begins on a $12B high-speed rail line between Las Vegas and Los Angeles
As your link shows, money that is spent on making a good freight rail system is mostly money that doesn't help with passenger traffic.

You claimed that there were "many" countries that had both good freight and passenger rail, but have yet to come up with one. (Sweden isn't an example - its "good freight" service (mines to ports) is where there's insignificant passenger service.)

anamax··on Work begins on a $12B high-speed rail line between Las Vegas and Los Angeles
A given rail system can do freight or passenger well, but not both.

The US system is optimized for freight.

It's not obvious that passenger is a better choice.

anamax··on The Seattle Public Library is reducing maximum digital holds
> I would also settle for a loophole that would allow the library to OCR a physical copy they own and then own the resulting digital copy.

That was what the Internet Archive was doing.

They got sued and the last I heard, had lost at every level. That said, I don't know that the lawsuits are over yet.

To be clear, no one claims that IA digitally lent out more copies than it physically had. The publishers argued that IA couldn't make a digital copy and lend that instead of the physical copy.

anamax··on The failure of the Domino's 30-minute delivery guarantee
They're double-apping because they want more business than they can get from either app alone.

It's unclear why that's a "flaw". If Uber has to pay idle drivers, it has to charge more for rides.

Do you want there to be only one such company?

Do you object when a grocery story carries more than one brand of bread? How about when a given brand of bread has more than one type of bread?

anamax··on What's New in Go 1.22: Cmp.or
Lots of zeros is good.

One big problem with null pointers is that there's only one of them. (One of a given type doesn't help.)

Hoare's "NULL was my biggest mistake" rant proposed the wrong solution, namely no null.

anamax··on AI for Data Journalism: demonstrating what we can do with this stuff
"Leatherman Tool" is a good comparison, as pretty much every "blade" in a Leathermann is a crappy tool, better only than the Swiss Army knife equivalent.

The Leatherman's reason for existence is that you have it with you for unexpected problems.

anamax··on Anti-municipal broadband budget amendment gets nixed in New York
> Independent redistricting commissions

Define "independent".

I note that California has an "Independent redistricting commission" and it gerrymandered the state more than the previous "by legislature" system. (Exactly how do you determine "independent" in a way that isn't easily gamed?)

Of course, there's also the "define gerrymander" question.

The typical answer is some variation on "minimize the perimeter of districts." That's measurable but why is it good? For example, it doesn't follow interest group lines

anamax··on Ask HN: How do you ask users about their pain point?
[0] "What problems do you have?" is too vague.

[1] The response rate correlates to the product of how painful the problem is and whether the potential responder has some faith that you have a solution.

anamax··on Presence and collection of DNA from air and air conditioner units
Bad joke: Loki is the Norse god of mischief, trickery, and deception (traditional). In the Marvel Universe, he occasionally tries to take over.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →