7,213 karma · joined August 28, 2007
When an LP "invests" $100M in a VC fund, said LP only sends a small fraction of that $100M at signing. The LP keeps the remainder until the fund does a capital call. Even then, that remainder isn't all sent at once. Funds do several capital calls during the investment phase.
Note that management fees are WRT the paid-in capital, so VCs do have an incentive to get money invested.
https://www.oyez.org/cases/1940-1955/317us111
The explanation is: "Congress may use its Commerce Power to regulate or prohibit activities provided the economic effects of such activities are substantial."
Note that "substantial" is not wrt what an individual does but "what if everyone did that?"
Says who?
Eric Clapton said that he learned guitar to meet girls and that was well before the thing with George Harrison.
There's probably a point of diminishing returns but ....
If the solar company has to pay, it might not bother at the end of the lease term.
This can turn into a very low price to sell the panels at that time.
In other words, part of the payback/value is letting people say/think "I'm a good person."
We can argue about whether the additional solar demand due to virtue-signaling had good effects but it did produce additional demand.
That's only when new roads satisfy pre-existing demand.
The fact that someone can't do something doesn't imply that they don't want to do it.
You do know that the population density of the US is a fraction of that of the countries that you're comparing it to, right?
Move those goal posts. The original claim was "easy walking distance I.e 5-10 minutes walk."
> can span 20-40 city blocks
20 NYC blocks is a mile, which is 20 minutes walking.
https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/average-walking-sp...
> convenient (but high costs) parts of Manhattan.
If it's so efficient and/or desirable, why only a fraction of NYC?
The answer is that those areas are a luxury good, with, as you put it, "high cost".
Note that the streets, which is the whole of "planning for autos", don't have any effect on what's in the streetfronts. And, since the high cost areas were also "planned for autos" ...
Okay, so there are 10 buildings (out of several thousand) with woodworking in Minneapolis, but how many of them also support what my spouse likes to do?
This is a case where you don't want it in the building, which gets us to the "there's not enough space within a 5 minute walk for a wide range of `want to do's."
It might be "nice", but it's not possible without a very restricted definition of "every amenity" and even then there's an assumption that amenities are fungible and you're ignoring efficiency.
If there's a grocery store every five minute walk, it's relatively small, which means that it has a crap selection AND it's expensive to run because it doesn't have any economies of scale. (Compare NYC's bodegas with even a crap Walmart and god help you if you're not the dominant community near your bodega.)
The number of places to eat/drink within a five minute walk is limited and/or they're tiny. Again, crap selection and no economies of scale.
Then consider our musician friends. Do you really think that NYC supports enough instrument stores to have one, let alone a good one, every five minute walk? (Remember, you need guitars, flutes, pianos, etc.)
And, musicians aren't special here - the same is true of any interest, such as books.
Green's claim is related.
"Github is a private corporation and has no obligation to host anything." is not true when Github is acting as a US govt agent.
Disclosure, if this gets past the motion to dismiss, will be interesting.
What does "vacant during [a month]" mean?
As I said - I'm there on weekends. Is the house vacant? How about if I miss a couple of weekends because I'm in the hospital? Or, because the plumbing is out while I have some work done.
If I have a house-sitter, I'm good, right?
> Keep in mind that if the workforce left because they are priced out, your vacation paradise would no longer have shops / fueling stations / paid activities, as there would be no one left to provide those services. Driving down the mountain every week for groceries and gas will probably become tedious. Want pizza? No one is going to deliver with X hours round trip.
You really don't understand how vacation houses work.
Moreover, folks with vacation houses use very little of the infrastructure that you're so concerned with.
I find it "interesting" that you're so concerned with whether a "rich person" can get a pizza or has to travel to get things. You don't care about their other needs, so why do you care in this situation?
The answer is that you don't - you're just flailing around for an argument.
Ah yes, "let's define away the problem."
> Of course some portion of the taxes go to Disney. Who do you think pays for the air travel system that brings people to Orlando or LA? Who pays for the freeway system that brings in the food?
The typical argument is that Disney doesn't pay enough for those things. No one thinks that such things are "money going to Disney", which just goes to show the absurdities that you have to accept when trying to paper-over the problems with Georgism.
> I am very curious to hear your examples of improvements/activities on land that become part of the unimproved value of land at a fast enough rate to matter?
Who said that "improvements/activities" are the only way for the unimproved value to change rapidly? The land around Disneyland is a counter-example.
As to your suggestion that there aren't examples that fit your absurd restriction, I'll point you to the super-fund sites where SV fabs used to be.
As I hinted earlier, having a cute equation is no substitute for critical thinking.
> Obviously the unimproved land has a market price $X and then the land + structures on it have a different price $Y.
The question is not whether they have prices, it's whether they can be determined.
It's reasonably easy to determine the market price for their sum. How, exactly, do you separate them?
BTW, you're probably assuming that improvements necessarily have non-negative value. That's actually wrong.
If there's an exponential at work here, it has a vanishingly small exponent.
People who don't get paid for access to their capital don't make said capital available to others.
Note that all capital starts as "I made x but I'm going to spend less."
How, exactly, do you get from improved land value to unimproved land value?
It's arguably possible to approximate the value of a hotel+land across the street from Disneyland. How, exactly, do you determine what fraction is hotel (improvements) and what fraction is land?
Looking at other hotels in the area just tells you (an approximation of) the difference between the hotel values. That's not enough to determine the absolute value of any hotel.
What's "vacant"?
Is my house "vacant" if I'm there on weekends?
How about one weekend a month?
How about two months out of the year?
If I have to rent during the other ten months, can I evict when I want to be there? (Those two months happen to be the high-demand time for housing.)
Georgists, which are the subject of this thread, explicitly say that taxes should not be NOT based on improvements, just the "land value". So if the improvements have significant value, buy sell doesn't work.
I'll let you fight that with them.
> Profitability (no matter whether your abstraction for ownership is property or political favour) as a fundamental concept is a tax on the poor to the benefit of the wealthy.
Twaddle. The garbage man doesn't show up unless he's paid. Farmers don't grow enough food for others unless they're paid.
To first approximation, no one provides any essential service for free.
You do know that that is not true, that the value of land often depends ON things that happen on that land, right? (It's not hard to come up with examples.)
But, I do appreciate an example of something that I didn't mention, namely the propensity of Georgists to make claims that they find self-evident and profound but are actually are false.
> Why should someone who happened to own a random piece of land and did nothing with it for 4 generations get a multi-million dollar windfall because Disney accomplished something nearby?
The taxes aren't going to Disney....
> Re the valuation of land separately from the improvements, these are already separated on the vast majority of appraisals.
And that separation is mostly a fiction, as anyone who owns real estate knows.
Note that Georgists don't tell us HOW the value of this "land value tax" is determined. It certainly isn't uniform across the US, but where does it change and why?
In addition, Georgists insist that "public infrastructure" drives value. Ask the folks who own motels near Disneyland whether they'd have a business if Disney left.
Note also their assumption that "maximizing value" (as they define it) is the only important goal. It isn't.
That's why they go for insults for anyone who doesn't behave as they'd like.
For example, a "speculator", who Georgists hate and want to punish, is someone who says "hmm. There's more value in the future if I preserve things now." In other words, it's more reasonable to point out that Georgists are (at best) short-term maximizers.
Then there's the small detail that Georgists fundamentally believe that everything should be at the average/the same. If one apartment house is the highest value near a given location, they want to punish anyone who doesn't have apartment houses near that location.
You'd think that they'd get called on that by the "everything should be walkable/bikeable" folks, but I suppose there's some sort of tribal loyalty at play here.
It's often good to go for a "within 10% of best" solution.
[0] Every sustainable business sells for more than it pays.
[1] Central banks won't make that money available directly to me.
Before you say "fewer stops" (or its equivalent), remember that if you don't stop someplace, someone who wants to get to/from that place has to find an alternative, and that alternative may well involve 101.
If I don't understand what is happening to data without stepping, the code is too complicated.
If it's too complicated, I don't understand it now, won't understand it later, and it's probably wrong.
If I was working (again) in embedded systems, I might use a debugger as a substitute for print.
One nice property of asserts is that they keep working even when your attention is elsewhere.
You also want to have multiple instructions writing a given architectural resource live at once. That's tough if top-of-stack is a buffer location.