HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anandbaburajan

201 karma · joined March 7, 2022

anandbaburajan.com
submissionscomments
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
I like Roam Research too! However, it's not a tool for complex discussions.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Thanks for sharing the laws!
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
You meant going back to the first thread? If yes, you can just horizontally scroll (using trackpad or scroll wheel + shift). If not, go back where?
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Thanks so much! Loved reading this. Both of the problems are very interesting and it would be fun to go deeper into them. Would love to stay in touch with you. Can you send a hi at anandbaburajan@gmail.com?
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Wow, beautiful point! Very LessWrong-esque. Will definitely explore more.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Not really.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Yep.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
And neither Slack nor Zulip are suitable for complex discussions.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Interesting, can you send a link to a pic? I haven't used it and can't seem to find the visualization on Google.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Keyboard shortcuts coming soon! :D Also, curious to know where exactly you wanted to use arrow keys: moving horizontally between threads?
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Wow, thanks for that detailed answer!
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
TLDR seems like a good idea, will explore more, thanks.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
I didn't get you. What is how comments are ranked?
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Can you elaborate?
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Are you facing the issue on the blog post or the demo? Or can you open a issue for the same with a scrennshot on our GitHub? Thanks.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
CQ2 is for those 25% who like threads (and complex discussions).
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Thanks! Will look into it.
anandbaburajan··on The best way to have complex discussions?
Can you share which page you faced trouble with?
anandbaburajan··on Why does having discussions on chat platforms suck?
> Because this sounds like an ad so it should be disclosed?

I wonder whether we would be having this conversation had I asked a random friend to post this instead of my brother (and hence you wouldn't have found out that the OP is a relative of the creator). Would you then have said that my friend should have disclosed that they're friends with the creator? However, I would agree that it might sound like an ad, but more importantly, he also asked for feedback.

> "all these other platforms suck but look at this one!"

I do believe that discussions on all other chat/forum platforms (telegram, slack, discourse, reddit, etc.) suck and want to share about CQ2's approach and get feedback on it, and there's nothing wrong with that.

Also, this is more about the interface/approach than the product. I myself wish that existing chat/forum platforms had an option for that interface instead of needing a different product just for complex discussions. I don't know when/if those platforms would implement that, hence decided to build a product.

anandbaburajan··on Why does having discussions on chat platforms suck?
> I felt like I was thrown out at sea 20 miles without a lifejacket

Interesting. I've now put a helpful toast/hint on the demo. Hope that helps with interacting with the interface.

> I am not sure how you square "hyper-focused" with not "losing context"

By hyper-focused, I meant one can discuss one topic at a time in a particular thread. By not losing context, I meant one can clearly see (in the thread to the left of the current thread) where that topic arose from. In regular chats/forums, one needs to keep the context of who quoted what from where in their head. In CQ2, it's clearly visible.

> As a newcomer to this interface and this discussion the need for the big picture with context is much greater than the need to zoom in close (how do I know that I care enough to zoom in close w/o the the context?)

In CQ2, one would read a message fully, and if the message has quoted threads arising from it, one would decide themselves which thread they want to go deeper in. Does that clear your doubt or did I misunderstand something?

> Not so sure lesswrong is the best example if you want a broad range of people to feel included.

I just took an example of a complex public discussion I found. Only other examples I have are either personal or private team discussions. Curious to know why you think it matters whether the example is from lesswrong or not? Or maybe you can share what better kind of example would you suggest?

> experiments with running YOShInOn against comment feeds that were really promising so better interfaces for comments have been on my mind

Interesting! Will drop an email and would love to see what you have in mind.

Thanks for all the feedback!

anandbaburajan··on Why does having discussions on chat platforms suck?
Hey, creator of CQ2 here. Yes, he's my brother. I'm curious about why you think it was necessary to disclose that. AFAIK, friends share each others' stuff here. Also, he isn't fully convinced about the UI but finds the approach interesting and relates with the problem, so I had asked him to post and ask about others' feedback.
anandbaburajan··on Why does having discussions on chat platforms suck?
Hi, creator of CQ2 here.

> no explanation of how it is going to solve the problem.

I didn't what you meant. The explanation is mentioned on the site: "CQ2's unique sliding panes design with quote-level and n-level threads helps you hyper-focus on one thing at a time. No more losing context. No more copy-pasting quotes.".

> another confusing interface

Interesting, did you try the demo (https://cq2.co/demo) as well? I've simulated a real LessWrong discussion there and I think it turned out much more organised and focused, because of its interface.

anandbaburajan··on Show HN: CQ2 – a tool for thoughtful and coherent discussions
> Andy Matuschak?

Hadn't heard of him until now. Just checked his site, looks cool!

> small teams and discussions with a high ratio of long, analytical comments over multiple levels

Yep, that's my initial target group, and I believe there would be interest from beyond that group as well, given the growing number of people in knowledge-based roles.

> Anyway, thanks for making this open source !

Thanks for the feedback!

anandbaburajan··on Show HN: Kukkee – the free, open source and self-hostable Doodle alternative
Kukkee has public polls too which won't require users to have an account.
anandbaburajan··on Show HN: Kukkee – the free, open source and self-hostable Doodle alternative
Understandable, and thank you!
anandbaburajan··on Show HN: Kukkee – the free, open source and self-hostable Doodle alternative
Moreover, Kukkee is built to be self-hosted. Hence, you won't have to worry about sharing any private info.
anandbaburajan··on Show HN: Kukkee – the free, open source and self-hostable Doodle alternative
Kukkee's features like protected polls (to avoid impersonation), and many of our upcoming features like inviting participants through Kukkee (without having to share the link), calendar integrations, video conferencing integrations, etc., would require having a verified account since our users would need more control over their scheduling. Thank you for letting us know about the password requirements!
anandbaburajan··on Show HN: Kukkee – the free, open source and self-hostable Doodle alternative
Creating an account on your self-hosted Kukkee is a simple process and it gives you access to more features. Moreover, without an account, you would need to keep track of the 'admin' URL. Kukkee is built for people who need more control over their scheduling, hence having an account is crucial. But I'm happy to hear how creating an account is a pain point for you.
anandbaburajan··on Show HN: Kukkee – the free, open source and self-hostable Doodle alternative
It's working. Thanks!
← PreviousPage 2 of 2