HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anandkulkarni

1,439 karma · joined February 19, 2011

CEO @ Crowdbotics – AI-based software generator.

Previously: founder @ LeadGenius (YCS11), PhD @ Berkeley.

Computer scientist. AAAI HCOMP is my home conference.

http://www.crowdbotics.com

talk to me: anand [at] crowdbotics.com

submissionscomments
anandkulkarni··on Ask HN: What service would you pay $1k/mo for?
I've done this (remote full-time assistant). It's well worth it.
anandkulkarni··on Why VCs sometimes push companies to burn too fast
Dave McClure laid out a model for playing Moneyball on startups – investing well before product/market fit, when other VCs didn't see value. Today, that's 500 Startups. http://500hats.typepad.com/500blogs/2010/07/moneyball-for-st...
anandkulkarni··on The P=?NP Poll (2002) [pdf]
>> complete absence of progress in proving P != NP

We've ruled out a number of techniques and also have shown that any solution must fall into a category avoiding a number of conditions (natural proof, algebrization barrier). Note also Ryan Williams' result separating ACC0 and NEXP. All of that is progress as I see it.

It's simply that construction of practical approximation algorithms or heuristics that work on large instance is (in general) much easier than separating proofs for complexity classes.

anandkulkarni··on Scale (YC S16) is an API for human labor
I love this product. We're big believers in what you guys are building, and the need is real.

As someone who once struggled extensively to use AMT, I think the need here is genuine and I'm glad to see someone doing it right.

anandkulkarni··on DeepMath – Deep Sequence Models for Premise Selection
How close is the state of the art here to discovering novel and interesting theorems?
anandkulkarni··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (July 2016)
LeadGenius | Berkeley, CA | Full Time | ONSITE | leadgenius.com/careers

LeadGenius (YC S11) is the operating system for outbound sales, merging data curation and machine learning with crowd computing at massive scale. Our customers are some of the biggest sales & marketing teams in the country. Our not-so-secret social mission is to attack poverty by creating lots of fairly-paid jobs in data curation. You'll be working with a team of smart, good-hearted people, with awesome benefits, and we'll relocate you to the Bay Area if you're anywhere else in the country.

Interview process is a phone screens followed by a half-day onsite.

anandkulkarni··on Ask HN: teaching basic coding and web design offline, solely via iOS devices?
Ben - fascinating problem, and kudos to your wife for looking at this question. There are analogous programs that have led to successful outcomes here – ie, https://thelastmile.org/ These may have useful learnings.

It's quite possible to teach sophisticated computer science without computers at all, so the first question is what the most useful skillset will be. Basic frontend engineering is probably the most in-demand skill today and allows individuals to see their product on the web right away. Young inmates may also be interested in coding as a path towards entrepreneurship and this can be bundled into a curriculum.

You can code with just a text editor and view results in a web browser without internet access.

Here are two apps that may prove useful as text editors:

1) https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/diet-coda/id500906297?mt=8

2) https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/codetogo/id382677229?mt=8

It may also be possible to take the iPads out and upload the content to the web yourself, provided staff review & clear the content. This can lead to effective outcomes.

-Anand

anandkulkarni··on Thank you, Y Combinator
Garry is one of the most incredible people we worked with at YC. Thanks, Garry!
anandkulkarni··on “The Robot and the Baby” by John McCarthy
I believe he's referring to Berkeley's Hubert Dreyfus, and perhaps John Searle, who are well-known for their critiques of the prospects for AI.
anandkulkarni··on Silicon Valley 40 under 40: Garry Tan
Go Garry!
anandkulkarni··on Ask HN: What's the best place to buy survey responses from a specific niche?
www.aytm.com is what you want, based in Berkeley. Tell them Anand sent you!
anandkulkarni··on Rethinking the PhD application in Computer Science
Fascinating -- the author uses YC admission as a proxy to evaluate potential as a grad student!
anandkulkarni··on Smoothed Analysis: Why the Simplex Algorithm Usually Takes Polynomial Time
Yes, Spielman and Teng showed that the shadow-vertex variation of the simplex method has a smoothed polynomial complexity [1]. It's worth noting that while other LP methods are known to be weakly polynomial, the polynomiality depends on the size of the largest coefficient involved in the problem instance rather than on the number of rows and columns of the LP.

Finding a purely polynomial algorithm for linear programming or establishing that none exists is a major open question for linear programming, and indeed, for all of mathematics. It's not a Millenium problem, but it's the next best thing [2].

[1] This paper has an even better result, finding a polylogarithmic simplex variant. http://www-personal.umich.edu/~romanv/papers/simplex.pdf

[2] It's Smale problem number 9. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smale's_problems

anandkulkarni··on Mechanical Turk is Insecure
Not quite: in MobileWorks, work is assigned to private workers, so nothing is public. The same goes for CloudFactory, TaskUs, and the other non-marketplace crowd platforms.

You're right that challenge work does a reasonable job of screening tasks from search engines, though!

anandkulkarni··on Mechanical Turk is Insecure
Worse yet, the tasks are public on the web, and anyone can see what's being posted: there's not even a minimal level of privacy.
anandkulkarni··on I 'Hired' A Virtual Personal Assistant To Do My Job
Ha, that would've been sneaky! As it happens, I was pretty insistent that we stay out of the process, and that the experiment run naturally.

The reason was that I've seen this kind of thing go awry when the company interferes to try and make itself look good (ie: http://www.fastcompany.com/1773610/column-was-crowdsourced-s...). Our writing pool and management system is solid, so there was little to worry about.

The other reason that this worked well is that Dylan wrote from a set of notes that outlined the story he wanted to tell, rather than letting them write something totally from scratch.

anandkulkarni··on How to get your first 10 customers
Couldn't agree more. Unfortunately, there's a gap between what many lean approaches advocate (Adwords), what startups think they need (features/press) and what actually works.

The most effective way to learn is to go out and find the people who should be using the product, and talk to them.

anandkulkarni··on Show HN: We built manual user acquisition as a service
Thanks! We actually do mean a contact who is interested and primed. There are two stages: first researching leads, and the second reaching out to them to schedule contacts. The $2000 plan incorporates both pieces.
anandkulkarni··on LeadGeni.us: User acquisition as a service
Customers requested it, actually, even knowing that it'd use more time. It's more useful at the end of the day anyway -- lead data is often not contact information, but a good body of background information that can be used to determine if someone's a good fit for a particular product or service.
anandkulkarni··on Show HN: We built manual user acquisition as a service
That's useful feedback! It depends on whether your users can convert automatically based on information from an email. It takes some domain expertise to describe potential users, so we prefer to leave that to clients. We might step in that direction at some point -- I'd like to see us positioned somewhere between Adwords and true outsourced sales.
anandkulkarni··on Show HN: We built manual user acquisition as a service
Thanks for that useful comment -- much appreciated!

We might benefit from introducing some specialized vertical pages, and we'll provide some more color on who's doing the research work.

The part of the process that's masked is research and strategizing around likely customer sources, which varies significantly per business category. Users might definitely prefer to pay per lead, but that's much harder for us to model from a cost perspective – some users might be easy to target, others might be harder, and some might be impossible to uncover at all.

anandkulkarni··on LeadGeni.us: User acquisition as a service
Thanks a lot, Mark!
anandkulkarni··on Show HN: We built manual user acquisition as a service
Thanks for the constructive feedback! Many of our clients have tried lead databases like Data or Jigsaw and haven't found them nearly specific enough, which is why they come to us. There are a few examples in the blog post that are well beyond the scope of Data/Jigsaw (http://blog.mobileworks.com/leadgeni-dot-us-user-acquisition...) -- researching Github, analyzing payment platforms, finding new businesses as they emerge, and more. From your comment it sounds like "lead generation" isn't the way you'd describe these kinds of activities – could you suggest something more accurate?

Here's a more sophisticated use case: suppose a crowdfunding service is trying to construct a list of accredited investors in Los Angeles eligible for solicitation in particular domains of interest via the JOBS act. These lists don't exist in databases today -- generally the research element is the more complex part.

anandkulkarni··on Show HN: We built manual user acquisition as a service
Thanks for signing up! We'll see if we can make it clearer on the front page. It's the former -- we'll be finding potential leads, curating the list, and emailing them using a variety of formats to see what works the best.
anandkulkarni··on LeadGeni.us: User acquisition as a service
Get in touch with me and we'll get you sorted out! anand@mobileworks.
anandkulkarni··on LeadGeni.us: User acquisition as a service
Nope, they don't -- users and leads are produced fresh for each client as a work-for-hire, and they're the property of the customer who purchases them.
anandkulkarni··on LeadGeni.us: User acquisition as a service
We mean that lead lists aren't shared internally inside LeadGenius. All the work that's carried out is considered work-for-hire, and remains client property. It's more work for us, but this protects our clients who sell similar products into the same segments.
anandkulkarni··on LeadGeni.us: User acquisition as a service
Thanks, Austen. You make a great point -- below a certain customer point, paid UAaaS doesn't make sense!

We try to help people determine their ROI for lead generation out of the box, but LTV is something that a company has to figure out for itself!

anandkulkarni··on LeadGeni.us: User acquisition as a service
Sorry you had a bad experience! We always cheerily offer refunds or set things right when things don't work. I'm happy to look into this myself -- feel free to get in touch with me directly if for some reason this didn't happen and we can figure out what went wrong.
anandkulkarni··on LeadGeni.us: User acquisition as a service
There's certainly more than that, but SDRs (as we call them) are a piece of it. Excellent -- let's chat further! Drop me a note directly.
← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →