This is the practical work component of a larger curriculum carried out by civic job training programs. These programs conclude with job placement, so the startups involved simply donate work and forget about it.
1,439 karma · joined February 19, 2011
Previously: founder @ LeadGenius (YCS11), PhD @ Berkeley.
Computer scientist. AAAI HCOMP is my home conference.
http://www.crowdbotics.com
talk to me: anand [at] crowdbotics.com
This is the practical work component of a larger curriculum carried out by civic job training programs. These programs conclude with job placement, so the startups involved simply donate work and forget about it.
As mentioned in other comments, most trainees are working on basic technology skills rather than specialized job training. This is a place where even simple work like data entry, web research, and software testing can provide a useful opportunity to practice skills.
Most of our workforce consists of long-term participants working under real names in exchange for a fair wage guarantee.
It'd be great to see something equivalent emerge in the temping sector.
Software testing, online research, and high-quality writing correspond directly to marketable technology and professional skills development.
It's important to remember that these individuals often come from a low-technology background, and are training to develop foundational technology skills -- not highly-specialized skills.
Many individuals have difficulty in traditional job training in finding full-time work without practical work experience, so this resolves that problem.
Sending work to job training programs in the rest of the country lets us share the love a bit.
But it turns out that if anyone can do it, these guys can. The brick-and-mortar restaurant business is massive, bigger than many technology sectors, and prime for disruption with new food and models: there's a $184 billion global fast food market, a $2.1 trillion global market, and just about everybody needs to eat.
This has the potential elements of greatness: serious, hardcore mechanical engineers as founders, with a background in the restaurant industry. More power to John and Alex -- can't wait to try my first one.
You make an reasonable point, vis-a-vis Chow; rather than being regarded as an absolute barrier for lines of reasoning involving circuit complexity, the requirement of being a sufficiently complex proof may provide a jumping-off point for uncovering a working method.
- The author is a theory professional and not an amateur or a crank
- The author frames this as a possible proof where he's seeking feedback on the method, rather than declaring a solution up front
- The author builds on existing theory in a formerly mainstream approach that has been shown to have problems (circuit lower bounds)
- Looks like a serious and well-considered proof effort
Here is why HN should hold off on any excitement:
- This style of proof was found to be unworkable in the past. In particular, approaches to proving circuit lower bounds in this manner were shown by Razborov and Rudich to be "natural proofs" in the 1990s, which is a category of proof strategy that cannot demonstrate P/NP. It's not explained why this strategy does not succumb to the same problem -- though the author surely has some reasoning around it. (see point 6 of Scott Aaronson's "8 signs a proposed P/NP proof is wrong": http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=458. You might also see this comment from /r/math: http://www.reddit.com/r/compsci/comments/14mqqt/anyone_have_...) ).
- There is a very good community framework for evaluating proposed solutions when the author's ready. Possibly the author has already submitted the work to a journal, but it's not clear that he's confident enough yet to invite more active discussion on his effort from the theory community. I can't find any discussion of it online. It's likely he's pursuing these on his own, and conceivably flaws have been found since the summer.
- The author does not declare this as a completed solution in the same way that Deolikar did two years ago. In that case, his announcement led to an analysis by the theory community online that led to discovery of core errors. We can wait here 'til the author gives a bit more information.
- This proof joins dozens of other announced solutions to P/NP in both directions (see, for example, http://www.win.tue.nl/~gwoegi/P-versus-NP.htm) which emerge quite regularly, and close attention paid to each will leave no time for original research :)
Perhaps that's not the use case that's intended here?
But Michael's right -- there's something magical about the experience of having a combination of a crowd and an algorithm, where you get the best of scalable, automatic responses and a personal connection when you need it. It also lets Challen manage friendships with thousands of people at once. She's MySpace's Tom for the new generation.
The only example that comes to mind was Ramanujan, who made many new contributions in number theory, but it's not quite the same thing -- though his genius was unparalleled, he was also working on domains that were at the time not as widely studied as nuclear fusion is today.
But hard fusion is an area that's been looked at for decades by literally thousands of top physicists around the world, and there's little low-hanging fruit left for a tabletop inventor to come across. Multi-billion dollar efforts like the National Ignition Facility involving hundreds or thousands of scientists are where the action's at today, and they've brought together solid plans for pursuing economically sustainable fusion.
An outsider may indeed bring new ideas that have value in niche areas, simply because that's not where the majority of scientific attention is being focused -- but it's unlikely to be a replacement for the core effort of an entire movement, as the article suggests.
From the app: "Though we don't make any formal promise about secrecy, we will try to avoid disclosing your plans to potential competitors."
Have you guys thought about the outcomes for ballot initiatives, or for enterprise sales?
In particular, this kind of tech might have a disruptive impact on the initiative process in California (which costs around $1M-10M in signature-gathering costs to bring something to the voters), and on the enterprise sales cycle (which involves exchange of PDFs between multiple parties, at a lower conversion rate than a streamlined web process).
Company: MobileWorks
Positions: Account manager, 1-3 yrs experience; growth hacker
We're building the world's best crowdsourcing platform, with a social mission to battle unemployment worldwide - starting with you! We're looking for an account manager who can help us work with our top-tier clients, and a growth hacker, to help us grow the brand and client base.
Apply here: http://mobileworks.com/jobs
As a longtime follower of this space, this price point enables many more possibilities than previous robots, and using off-the-shelf computing hardware is the right solution.