HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

andrewia

430 karma · joined October 28, 2020

submissionscomments
andrewia··on Stadia Bluetooth Mode
I assume it requires something hosted, and can't be open sourced due to licensing restrictions*. Hopefully it can be reverse engineered.

*I've heard from firmware engineers inside and outside of Google that licensing is the biggest reason why stuff isn't open sourced.

andrewia··on MacBook Pro featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
Yes, although that's a MacOS restriction, and MST is already used in MacOS to carry multiple streams to a single high-resolution monitor. And as Asahi Linux keeps getting more usable, I hope it can be a viable alternative, so Apple's hardware can be used without MacOS's arbitrary restrictions.
andrewia··on MacBook Pro featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
Not to mention DisplayLink can be broken by MacOS updates. Tunneling video over USB was a clever hack back in the day, but with USB-C and TB3/USB4 docks, things are much less software-dependent.
andrewia··on LosslessCut: lossless video/audio editing
There's a beta feature to exactly cut, and re-encode just the affected "block".
andrewia··on Caterpillar offers phone with built-in FLIR camera
This phone has been out since Spring 2022. Any reason for the post?

If we want to talk about the utility of a thermal camera, I found it neat. I used a $150 Seek camera to diagnose poor insulation in my bedroom, and one contractor even offered free advice over email since the images were clear enough. I've also used it to find hot ICs on a PCB. The resolution of these lower cost modules isn't great, which you can see by all the postprocessing they advertise. But it's enough to see which wall is leaky, or which IC needs a heatsink.

andrewia··on Estonia saved its citizens 820 years by moving public services online
In addition to public computers and physical offices, smartphones are owned by a large portion of homeless people (especially if younger) because they're quite affordable. It looks like a basic Estonian phone plan, plus financing for a budget smartphone, is only 20 EUR/month. Estonia has no free phone plan (like the "obamaphone" program in the US), but low income people can submit 200 EUR of expenses per year for essentials.
andrewia··on AMD’s Zen 4, Part 2: Memory Subsystem and Conclusion
Maybe it will get resolved in their monolithic mobile CPUs, then carried over to the next generation. It's like how Zen 4's IO die was ported from Ryzen Mobile 6000 (which also made it easier for them to toss in integrated graphics). DRAM efficiency is an obvious target for improvement too.
andrewia··on Framework Laptops now have 4 Thunderbolt 4 ports
I don't recall them advertising Thunderbolt compatibility, it was always an unadvertised feature.

The blog post made it clear they're shipping all the Thunderbolt firmware improvements to the 11th gen as well, it's just minor hardware differences that are blocking a few test cases and official certification. It sounds like you can enable Thunderbolt relatively easily if you're okay with that caveat.

andrewia··on iPhone 14 Pro camera review: A small step, a huge leap
I think it's processing power and engineering effort. I got a Sony RX100M2 for my mom and it has the same computational photography techniques that Google released the following year (https://ai.googleblog.com/2014/10/hdr-low-light-and-high-dyn...). But Sony's image stacking is only in "Superior Auto" mode, and is only used when necessary. Google's implementation does a lot of advanced work, including selecting and blending parts of the photo depending on motion, that Sony doesn't do. I assume Sony's imaging engineers have less expertise in advanced processing, and didn't have the resources to implement the features that Google did. Sony also has to devote engineering resources to other features - a lot of their sales are to photographers that will edit in post (RAW), and later, videographers. So features that are only in "auto" mode may have limited budget.
andrewia··on Boeing Needs an Act of Congress or Something Worse to Get Max 7 and 10 Flying
I'm assuming they meant "extendable". In which case the longest MAX model already did this, but it was avoided by other models due to engineering cost. https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/71500/why-wasnt...
andrewia··on Boeing Needs an Act of Congress or Something Worse to Get Max 7 and 10 Flying
https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/71500/why-wasnt...

TL;DR that adds engineering complexity and/or would trigger redesigns of other components. The MAX 8 was supposed to be an economical refresh - a stopgap until the Y1/"New Midsize Airplane" was ready. (The sales/economic failure of the Y1 "787 Dreamliner" means the Y1 project is paused while Boeing waits for next generation technology to become available. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Yellowstone_Project )

andrewia··on Boeing Needs an Act of Congress or Something Worse to Get Max 7 and 10 Flying
But in this case the "new thing" is a warning system that is found in almost all modern planes. It's not new to Boeing or its pilots, is an industry standard, and doesn't require novel engineering practices. It sounds like Boeing painted itself into a corner once again (this time with the Southwest orders), and doesn't want to eat the engineering/certification cost to get out "the right way" by implementing this system in its existing avionics. Boeing should feel the consequences of its actions, including lost profits, and play by the rules.
andrewia··on Users without a cell connection find they can’t get back into their Zipcar
A lot of cars completely disable the modem when service expires (which makes sense since they don't want to pay $5/month to keep it active) which makes your car harder to exploit. But if you want more assurance, it takes less than an hour to unplug the antenna in your car. Look for leaked service manuals, repair videos on YouTube, or search for a replacement module so you can look at diagrams on parts websites.

Once you know where it is, you can pry the interior panels and find the module (it should have an IMEI on it). Then find the cellular connector (it's often a standalone coaxial antenna/cable).

For example, my Hyundai has cellular connectivity integrated into the head unit. I removed 2 screws to pry off the dashboard trim, removed 2 screws and 2 bolts, and pulled out the head unit (10 minutes). There were multiple coax connectors (such as for the FM antenna and satellite radio), but the cellular module was clearly visible through the ventilation slats so I yanked its connector (5 minutes). I taped the connector to the wiring harness so it doesn't rattle and reassembled everything (10 minutes). Less than 30 minutes overall, not bad for a hardware mod!

I'm not against these systems because they offer a lot of convenience for people who need them. Some people need to pre-cool/pre-heat their car when it's parked several blocks away from their home or office, or they need warnings if they absentmindedly leave a window open or a door unlocked. Not to mention you could get to your car quickly and deter a thief if it sends glass break notifications. That's not worth the software vulnerabilities nor $10/month to me, so I disconnect the antenna for peace of mind. But some of my family members are glad to use these features because it improves their QoL. So I'm in favor of legislation that mandates a few years of security updates, and requires that a disable switch will actually disconnect the modem.

andrewia··on Improving Firefox Responsiveness on macOS
Are there reasons that the "Simple Tab Groups" extension isn't suitable for you? It seems to be well-maintained, cleverly uses Firefox's "hide tabs" API to keep a single window behind-the-scenes, and has integration with lots of other features like Firefox's containers. I think it's an indirect descendent of the old Tab Groups extension when it was spun out of Firefox.

https://github.com/drive4ik/simple-tab-groups

andrewia··on Lufthansa bans AirTags in checked luggage
Interesting. Since AirTags use standard CR2032 batteries, that means you could swap in an alkaline-based battery and avoid that regulation.
andrewia··on Framework Laptop 2.5Gbps Ethernet Expansion Card
Framework is just making a laptop that is both repairable and modular. These just happen to be use cases for it. I find business laptops like Thinkpads "repairable enough" and am okay with the upsides and downsides of a fixed selection of ports, so I don't own a Framework. But my friend owns one because they would rather have a limited number of very customizable ports - for example, when they need to charge the Framework while connecting to a TV, they can swap around the USB-C and HDMI ports to the side closer to each. And when they need to dock to a bunch of stuff at their desk, a USB-C dock is a more suitable solution. This obviously isn't for everyone, but it satisfies their niche.
andrewia··on Framework Laptop 2.5Gbps Ethernet Expansion Card
It seems that the NAND doesn't need much space, but the support components do. https://guides.frame.work/Guide/1TB+Expansion+Card+Throttlin...
andrewia··on Framework Laptop 2.5Gbps Ethernet Expansion Card
Then the Framework just isn't for you. The Framework was designed to be a portable laptop that is also modular and repairable. Apple's design philosophy seems to most closely match yours - only USB-C ports with separate dongles.
andrewia··on Framework Laptop 2.5Gbps Ethernet Expansion Card
There has always been a trade-off between modularity and size. Each card is effectively a USB-C/Thunderbolt dongle, so they need to be big enough to fit a reasonable amount of electronics (like 1TB of NAND, or an Ethernet IC) plus the shell and connectors. If your needs are basic (just USB, 3.5mm, 1x HDMI etc.) then you should get the Thinkpad. But if you want modularity for special cases (e.g. triple HDMI, double Ethernet, or triple MicroSD readers) or if you like to move your ports to alternating sides of your laptop, then the Framework's expansion system is for you. Framework is inherently a compromise between thickness and modularity (also why I assume it uses an internal battery) in a 14" portable laptop. Perhaps a new generation could shoehorn in a non-card USB-C port, although that would break their design rule that all ports support Thunderbolt.
andrewia··on FTC proposes rule to ban junk fees, bait-and-switch tactics plaguing car buyers
Most of the chips I've seen are guilty of this, from Trader Joe's to the popular Veggie Straws. They're essentially baked/popped chips with no extra nutritional content. "Veggie" is definitely deceptional to the average consumer, who expects vitamins and minerals.
andrewia··on Walmart Sells Fake 30TB Hard Drive That's Two Small SD Cards
Of course I could eventually come to my own realization without TikTok. But TikTok accelerated this by about 3 years in my estimate. That is an immense amount of time and energy saved. I will explain how TikTok's dynamics differs from other social media sites, and how it uniquely helped me.

Twitter tries to algorithmically sort your feed, but some users (including myself) find it buries too many interesting posts, and use the old chronological feed. Twitter is sparing about showing users and posts you don't follow (except for retweets from your followed accounts, of course). This leads to accounts becoming "curators", who you follow because they retweet interesting content. This adds a nice human touch, but also limits discovery to other users' interests. Interactions are generally limited to retweets/quote-retweets, and comment treads, both of which rarely have a deep discussion because the UI isn't designed to promote it. Twitter has small sidebars to recommend other users to follow, but this is a very slow method to discover new content, and these sidebars are smaller or nonexistent on mobile clients. Tumblr is quite similar, so I group its community and discovery dynamics with Twitter.

Reddit is community-based. Subreddits are formed, users follow them, and posts are voted up and down. A subreddit can dominate its hobby, and there is no way to fine-tune the content you see. For example, I like seeing the deals in /r/frugalmalefashion but have no interest in the higher-priced designer shoes that can frontpage. This reduces the signal to noise ratio for my interests, and there isn't another active subreddit that would more closely match my tastes. The comment sections are the highlight of reddit, since discussions can go quite deep and low quality comments are downvoted out of view. Discovery is generally limited to commenters organically suggesting other subreddits, especially in mobile clients where there "isn't room" for algorithmic recommendations.

Facebook is quite different. Your friends feed is very broad-purpose, and groups are very specific. Groups are often smaller than comparable subreddits, and there will be less experts present in a discussion. This can hamper discussions on things like deal-hunting, where more frequent users can summarize community opinion or relay their deeper experiences. In other words, you have to do a lot more reading to find the information you want, giving Facebook a much worse signal-to-noise ratio. Comment sections can be more informative than Twitter but more shallow than Reddit, and communities are less interested in liking informative comments to bring them to the top to discussion threads. There is minimal algorithmic discovery, with only small recommendation sidebars.

Instagram is a mix of all these sites. You follow specific users like Twitter, but reposts are limited to the Stories feed, and are therefore deprioritized. So you generally follow each of these users for their original content (or occasionally curation, if they like to manually repost others' work on their feeds like a "meme page"). Comment sections can be lively but shallow, and I find discussions are generally superficial. There is an algorithmic discovery page that can find some good recommendations, but you browse it by thumbnail, limiting discovery.

YouTube is also interesting. You generally follow creators' channels like Instagram, and there is no easy way for "curators" to promote others' content without making a "meme compilation" video (and getting copyright strikes). Comment sections are second best to reddit, but not quite as good. Discussion is limited by the fact there has to be a relevant video for everyone to comment under - there's no way to make a quick post about a hobby without making an entire video, or making an oft-ignored text post. Discoverability is also very good, with the algorithmic feeds and recommendations being very accurate. But they lack variety and don't seem to try and dredge up old interests. When I watch a lot of automotive content for a week, I find recommendations about my other interests (like architecture) quickly disappear and only resurface for viral videos that don't align with my interests.

Finally, we have TikTok. You can follow creators and access a dedicated feed of their videos, but the primary method of consumption is the "for you page". There's some semi-scientific tests by users A/B testing videos (and comparing feeds to friends with similar interests) that lead to a general description of the FYP algorithm. The algorithm seems to form groups of users that like a particular cluster of videos/creators. Your new videos are shown to a few users in each of your clusters, and if some engage with your video, it is shown to more of that cluster and is tested against adjacent clusters. This significantly improves discoverability by letting obscure users' videos go viral, including one of my own quickly achieving 50k views (while all my other videos remain below 2k views). This is unique because it allows every hobby to have subcultures and nuance. I like car technology and engineering but not street racing or showy designs, and so I am clustered accordingly. It's obvious that there are racing and show-car clusters (some videos appeal to many clusters and the comment sections reflect that), but I am rarely shown that content.

This FYP algorithm can also help discovery about adjacent clusters. If you like videos about hikes, it will test videos about other activities like camping, and adjacent hobbies like environmentalism. This isn't hard coded - those are all just naturally occurring, adjacent clusters that each have overlap with hiking enthusiasts. So when I kept liking content about mental health condition "A", it because steady component of my FYP. Also interestingly, having a different condition "B" puts you at a 30% chance of having condition "A", despite the two having very separate communities on sites like reddit. So content from people with both condition "B" and "A" also appeared on my FYP, and I watched/liked the videos most relatable to me. As I began to see more content exclusively about condition "B" (and found some of it to be relatable), I began to consider if I also had that disorder. This wouldn't have been possible on other sites, since the subreddit for disorder "B" is quite heady and difficult to be easily introduced to. And I have a subtype of disorder "A" that is less common, so its community was less useful too. The communities on sites like YouTube or Twitter is so scattered to be practically useless.

Once I had a strong list of symptoms for each disorder, and some new vocabulary to help describe certain symptoms, I found a very qualified psychiatrist to evaluate me. The TikTok algorithm isn't perfect - I though I also had disorder "C", but after evaluation, it was determined that my symptoms don't match and may actually be from an unrelated issue.

No other social media app/site has the ability to navigate a large and varied community to find the parts that best fit each user. And no other social media app is as good at finding overlaps between communities and allows users to navigate them simply by interacting with content. For those reasons, TikTok is the best site for my browsing style, since I like to hop between communities and discover new ones that best suit me. It accelerated my exploration of existing thoughts and feelings so I could explore them to their fullest and see if each disorder's community matched my experiences, without requiring the effort of reading hundreds of posts and comment sections.

andrewia··on What would a “good” WebMD look like?
I disagree. There is lots of useful information around the internet that is hard to find. A lot of content simply doesn't have the keywords it needs to be discovered.

For example, somebody could search for "best rewards credit card for married couple with normal lifestyle" and find some listicle full of referral links that's a few years old. But the best advice might be in a Reddit or Twitter discussion titled "what's a good card for my P2 with no AF, low MSR, and at least 2CPP" whose replies are terse comments like "CSP?" or "BofA Custom; select CNP transactions as the 3% category and order everything online. they give high CL if you want to AU instead". There's enough jargon and levels of understanding that Google can't find the best advice, only good keyword matches.

I recently had a similar issue when I searched for something well-phrased and generic ("how to stop wood joints from squeaking"). The results were lackluster, but after a few attempts, I found the most helpful results were actually under a specific application ("how to stop a bed frame from squeaking").

So what's my point? It's not Google's fault. They are trying their best of optimize text search, with some fancy word associations and other stuff to help. But it's going to take a lot of effort to make an efficient, scalable, general-purpose AI that can achieve near-human understanding of text and then find the most relevant articles related to that. This "super-Google" would have to comprehend every post and comment on the internet, contextualize the knowledge ("a squeaky bed is caused by squeaky wood joints or fasteners, so this advice is useful for any kind of squeaking wood furniture"), and quickly generate results for every query.

It's not WebMD's fault they have ad revenue that lets them hire writers to SEO their articles with the best keywords. Nor is it Merck's fault that they are using specific language that doesn't cover all the phrases that a person could search. Nor is it Google's for making a search engine without human comprehension. It's just a technological gap that can't be bridged in the present day.

andrewia··on Walmart Sells Fake 30TB Hard Drive That's Two Small SD Cards
I've found it to be 50-50 or less in my recent experience, but there's an interesting reason why. I recently shopped for a fidget ring and found AliExpress had lots of options, but none that fit my size 14 fingers. So I checked Etsy and was pleasantly surprised to see only ~20% of their listings were rings from AliExpress. Another 70% of listings were for rings that all had similar designs but were slightly unique from each other, each with unique listing photos, and all with minor flaws from being handmade. Eventually one seller had an honest bio that describe themselves as a "jewelry making village near Jaipur, India". I believe many pieces are actually handmade to a degree, in what I presume to be a series of small rural workshops with correspondingly cheap labor. They are probably given order lists by middlemen who run their own Etsy stores and are willing to deal with the logistics and customer service.
andrewia··on Walmart Sells Fake 30TB Hard Drive That's Two Small SD Cards
This has become the norm. I am a TikTok user* and there's a lot of ads and organic posts about "innovative new products" that are exposed as dropshipped items from a warehouse in China. And you may have seen "get rich quick" gurus promoting their strategies for opening Amazon stores to resell stuff from AliExpress. I've seen quite a few AliExpress sellers advertise dropshipping ("just send a spreadsheet and we send packages with no receipt") and/or bulk order discounts (to ship the goods yourself with faster, domestic shipping).

To be fair, not all direct-from-China goods are cheap crap. I've received excellent USB cables, noise cancelling earbuds, and much more from various sellers. And the middlemen selling on Amazon are offering the convenience of easy returns, fast shipping, and excellent customer service from Amazon. Depending on the seller, [their profit margins can actually be quite thin because Amazon charges a lot for their customer service, warehouses, and return handling](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Yhc6mmdJC4).

* I know TikTok is quite controversial, for good reasons like data security, lack of ethics, and algorithmic infobubbling/censorship. But I am still a fan and use it because its algorithm was the only thing that was able to string together my liked posts and begin showing content/advice about what mental health disorders I might have. That significantly sped up my diagnoses with my psychiatrist, who confirmed 2 of the 3 disorders.

andrewia··on Walmart Sells Fake 30TB Hard Drive That's Two Small SD Cards
I have become an AliExpress enthusiast and agree. It works best when you are willing to wait a variable amount of time for your items. Often, it will only take 2-3 weeks for them to arrive at my home in California. But every 6th package (or so) will slip through the cracks, often at their warehouses in LA County.

It's still the best for pricing, and is pretty close to the sources (unless you're hardcore enough to translate Taobao listings and get your own mail forwarding). For example, I got a new smartwatch and wanted some bands in specific colors, and a screen protector. Listings with the exact same images on Amazon were $9-12 instead of $3-4. (And when you compared reviews and pictures, they were probably from the same factory.)

Some small notes about AliExpress:

- Although most of AliExpress's lower prices come from lower cost warehouses and less middlemen, some of it comes from exploiting discounted postage. [That has been improved since 2019](https://www.parcelandpostaltechnologyinternational.com/opini...) but I still get a ton of Kyrgyzstani-labeled parcels that originated from Guangdong or Shanghai/Hangzhou. I don't know if that's above-board or not.

- Sellers can sometimes be deceptive. When I was shopping for LED interior lights for an old car, some lumen ratings seemed accurate and even had videos of it being tested. Others had obviously inflated brightnesses despite having a similar number of LEDs are power consumption. In addition, some sellers will sneak an unrelated cheap item into variants of another item, so the listing has a lower price in search results.

- Packages now take a few days to be consolidated. This is great for efficiency and often means you get slightly faster delivery in your home country. But these packages can still get lost, so you may have to dispute up to a dozen items at a time. I might have to do this soon with all my smartwatch accessories, and in the meantime, pray my screen doesn't get scratched (or eat the inflated Amazon/eBay price).

- Compared to Amazon, they have fewer customer reviews, and don't stack listings for the same item. In disputes, customer service won't always favor you or offer a complete refund for bad items.

- Compared to eBay, they have much worse search filtering. You may wish to consider eBay for a balance of cheap prices and faster shipping, especially when you filter for sellers within 100 miles. Sometimes Chinese eBay sellers are cheaper than AliExpress sellers.

andrewia··on Solving my truck’s TPMS sensor problem with the help of an RTL-SDR dongle
They are battery powered. The battery lasts a few years, and conserves charge by only reporting pressure every minute after motion is detected.
andrewia··on Solving my truck’s TPMS sensor problem with the help of an RTL-SDR dongle
This is a really interesting article. One question answered for the author: I believe TPMS sensors have an RFID-style mode, so that handheld programmers can access them without waiting for the slow reporting period.

I have experience with how finicky these sensors can be. I installed a radar detector in my car (legal in my state, and wise considering the unusually aggressive speed enforcement that appears once every few weeks along the highway I drive). I stashed the radar detector's control box in some empty space between the glove box and an air duct. The TMPS receiver module is also located in this area and cannot receive signals while the radar detector is powered on. I assume this is broad-spectrum EMF and I need to layer the control box in aluminum foil.

andrewia··on HP LaserJet Tank – Refillable laser printer
It seems unlikely that HP will add DRM after the fact. Even if the printer has the hardware capability to enforce DRM, it isn't upon release, so you could simply keep it VLAN-ed off of the internet so it can't update its firmware to a version that begins enforcing the DRM chips. Adding DRM would also create a subpar UX where old, DRM-less HP refills stop working because the firmware thinks they're knockoffs.
andrewia··on HP LaserJet Tank – Refillable laser printer
Looking at the manual, the toner refill kit is entirely passive and has no electrical contacts or other authentication. That's just verbage to scare you into buying their refill kit instead of the inevitable generic version.
andrewia··on HP LaserJet Tank – Refillable laser printer
Bad news from the Q&A section of one of the printers:

> With the enhancements giving the new drum a 50k page life it's no longer intended to be a user-serviced part and won't be sold via retail channels. That said, it is still able to be replaced through an HP Service Center or HP Parts in the event it is needed to be replaced.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →