HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

andrewlgood

150 karma · joined April 21, 2020

submissionscomments
andrewlgood··on Layoffs Don't Work
I understand the trade offs you mention. I do disagree with your assertion that “Life is much harder for some of us.” You have chosen a different payoff - your family, certainty of health insurance, etc. You get the benefits that children bring and the joy of being a parent. The “young, childless people” have made a different choice - more freedom in employment decisions but no joy from children. Everyone has their own cost/benefit analyses on these issues. That is life.
andrewlgood··on Ask HN: What can LLMs not do?
People hallucinate as well
andrewlgood··on Genetic Discrimination Is Coming for Us All
I must confess this does not seem to be a problem to me. Private insurance is not meant to be a welfare product. It is meant to be a risk transfer. In a competitive market the expected value should be slightly negative to the consumer as the insurance company needs to make a reasonable profit. An important aspect of the transaction is information symmetry. If you knew you had a terminal disease and only 3 months to live and could buy a $1 million life insurance policy after finding out the information and had no obligation to share the diagnosis with the insurance company, life insurance companies would all go bankrupt. If they raised their rates high enough to cover this scenario, non-terminally ill people would never be able to afford it (significantly negative expected value). This is the same issue with health and long term insurance. Once the genetic test is completed and the individual realizes they have a higher chance of getting ALS, the rate for their specific insurance should go up. They have a greater chance of having it pay out.

Any other method either leads to bankrupt insurers. In my opinion, what Bill should have done is bought the long term care BEFORE he had the genetic test done.

andrewlgood··on Ask HN: How do you find a mentor in software engineering and in life?
IMHO, there are career conversations you can and should have with your boss and job change discussions you should not. A good manager should help you improve your resume and every year. They should discuss where you want to go with your career and how they and the company can help you achieve those goals. They should assist in your development.

I would not discuss a specific job change outside the company with your manager. You put them in the untenable position of trying to be helpful to you and doing their job in representing the company. If their are matters which cause you concern about your job by all means discuss them with your manager. However, if you are evaluating pros and cons of leaving the company it will most likely permanently impair your situation at the current company. Even if your manager convinces you to stay at the company, you have put them on notice that you are looking around and were about ready to leave. Depending on your role, that will likely cause your manager to look elsewhere when selecting people for key projects, advancement, etc.

Coming to a manager with a discussion about another job, especially if you initiated the search (out of the blue offers are not so bad), feels like an ambush. Usually the manager has little time to respond with a counteroffer and must use lots of political capital to make it happen. They cannot help but wonder why you did not discuss the issues that are causing you to leave earlier when they could have done something about them.

andrewlgood··on Ask HN: How do you find a mentor in software engineering and in life?
I am near the end of my career and have mentored many people along the way. I have also had several mentors. Mentors can be incredibly helpful and provide a genuine advantage to their mentees. I think it is very important to understand what you are looking for in a mentor and in what aspect of your life. For simplicity, I would segregate it between a work mentor and a non-work work. The non-work mentor would help you matters such a relationships, family matters, work/life balance, etc. I have not had much success with non-work mentors. I tend to turn to friends and family instead.

Some companies will assign you a mentor, particulary if you are in a group that historically does not utilize mentors much. I have not seen this work very well. First of all, there are never enough senior people to be mentors to the vast number of mentees that participate in the programs. Each mentor has to "cover" several mentees leading to less time spent with them and less investment by the mentor.

A good mentor is someone relatively senior and definitely not your boss or your boss's boss (grandboss?). You want someone who has seen/experienced many things. Someone who has seen and understands things like office politics. You also want someone who will be honest with you. You need them to be invested in you.

These relationships can start from either side. I have seen young, talented people that look like they could use some assistance and reached out to them to offer my help. Usually they accept as I was a relatively senior person by the time I started doing this. I was looking to pass on my hard-earned experience and knowledge to someone I thought would use it and benefit from it. The best relationships I had as a mentor occurred when the mentee asked me and not as part of a program. In these cases they were motivated to learn and improve. Most importantly, they acted on what we talked about. To be clear, a mentor does not tell you what to do. They are a sounding board that has seen many more situations than you and can help you think things through. If you never act on their advice or always argue against it (Hey Boomer!), you are simply wasting their time. A good mentor always has other things to do - their time is a valuable gift.

As for what you can learn from a mentor, it depends upon the mentor and for what you are looking. I found mentees frequently did not understand how decisions were made at the senior level and/or what the corporate strategy was. They did not understand how what they did fit into the bigger picture and how important what they did was to the company. Some, usually new managers, wanted to understand how to motivate and retain their employees. Others wanted to understand KPIs that they could design a measure for their team. Others wanted to understand how they should think about promotions and differnent job opportunities (even outside the company). Each one was different.

The single best mentee I ever had was at a company where we all worked remote. We had regular Zoom discussions every couple of weeks (in office jobs, I preferred to go to lunch or get coffee with a mentee to get away from the office). He showed up prepared - an informal status on what was going on with him and his team, a list of questions/topics to discus, and feedback from implementing what we discussed in prior meetings. He was very thoughtful about what he wanted to learn - how to be a better manager, how to prepare himself to be better positioned for promotion, how to consider various career opportunities. After a year, he surprised me with a summary of what we had discussed, what he had done differently as a result of our conversations, and what was the impact. He even walked me through his metrics to describe his success. It was phenomenal. Incredibly satisfying for me as the mentor. I was definitely invested.

One final thought in the long post - mentors who are invested in you will work to advance your career when you are not around. They will recommend you for positions of which you are not aware (this is how many positions are filled). They will refer you to friends and associates at other companies where they think there is a great opportunity. They will advocate for you. This is an incredibly valuable aspect of the mentor/mentee relationship.

For success in mentorships you need to be invested, you need to get your mentor invested, you need to be comfortable having honest discussions with them and believe that nothing will be repeated to others, and you need to act on what you discuss.

andrewlgood··on Show HN: I made a cheap alternative to college-level math & physics tutoring
I agree with your assessment re this being similar to fiverr/upwork. I do think the economics can work for tutors that generate high credibility/success ratings. Codementor.io focuses on providing programming mentors to help people solve a very specifc question or class of questions. It is not meant to be a weekly scheduled session, but rather an on-demand service.

Additionally, many of these services could be useful as incremental money for the tutors rather than the primary income source. Definitely would pay better than UberEats!

andrewlgood··on Show HN: I made a cheap alternative to college-level math & physics tutoring
I am always curious regarding new education solutions. I firmly believe the US pre-college education systems are fundamentally broken most benefit from edtech (huge fan of Khan Academy).

As an MIT alum myself ('89), I am surprised to hear your description of your experience at MIT. Did you experience this across all classes and departments or only for a few (e.g. 18.01 which is required for most freshman)? While certain professors were not the most helpful, I found most of the teaching staff to be incredibly helpful when I made the effort to engage them. No doubt the focus was on attendance in lectures.

In addition to lectures there were: - Recitations - each class of the larger classes had recitations with a TA to allow smaller groups the opportunity to ask specific questions. - Office hours with the lecturer. I did not avail myself of them as I considered them useful for bigger questions (should I be a physics major if I don't understand this) rather then review of homework questions. - Bibles. Each living group (I was in a fraternity but dorms had them as well) had a library of class notes, exams, quizzes, etc for each class assembled by people who previously took the class and did well. Often the Bible author was still available for questions. - Friends/Fellow Students. MIT has an incredibly open policy on working together. My recollection is some classes could not be reasonably completed by people working alone (e.g. Aero/Astro's Unified Engineering). A fellow student may simply have looked at a topic from a different perspective which drove their comprehension.

Today, MIT offers OpenCourseWare (ocw.mit.edu) which hosts complete courses online (video, lecture notes, syllabi, additional readings, quizzes). This is an incredible resource that I have found helps my lifetime learning goals.

Again, I am always excited for edtech. I think its development needs to be tempered with an understanding of why current systems are not working. What problem are you solving? Is your solution simply remote tutoring? If so, how is it different that a job board with zoom?

andrewlgood··on Success to the successful
This is what Malcolm Gladwell wrote about in his book, Outliers. His examples are more insidious as they can happen based on non-success based criteria such as birth dates.
andrewlgood··on Ask HN: What are your favorite sci-fi books?
I loved the series the first time through. Great concepts. First use of “dark forest” that I am aware of. Very specific arc of what could happen in the deep future.

I went to read it a second time and found I simply could not get through it. That which I found so exciting was significantly less so the second time around.

andrewlgood··on Ask HN: Which books do you consider real gems in your field of work/study?
Principles is a thought provoking book in that it gets one to think of running a business like running a machine. Invest in computers and programming to perform checklist tests constantly so you can ensure your business is operating in the manner you expect. This will require you to think hard about how you expect your business to work. It will also allow you to identify what activities really require your attention.

The Visual Display of Quantitative Data is great as it gets you thinking about different ways to present ideas effectively. The map of Napoleons march to and from Russia is exquisite.

andrewlgood··on Ask HN: Which books do you consider real gems in your field of work/study?
I read Magister Ludi or The Glass Bead Game several times in my younger days. I was a Hermann Hesse fan. I echo the recommendation but would add what I found most appealing about it is the idea that all knowledge is related. Once players study for years, they realize mathematics and music theory are related. Architecture and geometry are related. By analogy all knowledge is related and one can glide from one concept to another (in a Glass Bead Game) and tell interesting stories. Very influential to me on universality of learning and knowledge.
andrewlgood··on Ask HN: Are we building a tech dystopia?
I agree one could pick silly metrics. The point is to pick a metric that you have thought about and care about the results. It is difficult to discuss/debate the proposition "I feel weird about the direction of society." There are so many aspects to discuss. Technology impacts a great many of them. My suggestion is to sit down and think about a metric you would like to improve. Why do you want it to improve? What has it been doing over some period of time? What do you think it will do in the future? This can help step away from simply having feelings because the press reports the climate is changing, ai is taking away jobs, kim kardashian broke up with pete davidson.
andrewlgood··on Ask HN: Are we building a tech dystopia?
I think kelseyfrog has it better with the term 'subjective' rather than 'political.' Different people will have different morals and different views of what a well operating society looks like. It does not mean they are political, just different.
andrewlgood··on Ask HN: Are we building a tech dystopia?
I do not disagree that income inequality is objectively measurable. My point is your choice of whom to include for comparison (e.g. US inequality is very different than comparing US vs Yemen inequality. Moreover, low inequality with everyone below the poverty line may not be preferred to higher inequality but everyone above the poverty line. These are all personal, philosophical decisions - there is no objective right or wrong.

My point in suggesting metrics is they force you to think about what is important and to look for data to measure it. This helps to mitigate the "I feel bad..." scenario that could simply the be the result of negative press cycles.

For clarity, I agree with you that there is no escape from the subjectivity trap as only you can declare what is important to you and your view how society/the world should work.

andrewlgood··on Ask HN: Are we building a tech dystopia?
While I understand the sentiment, it is an incredibly broad statement. What defines better / worse for you? On a macro level, it seems the world is getter better every year - fewer people die of starvation, lethal diseases are cured or rate of spread slowed at least, less man hours are required to feed, cloth, and shelter the human race.

That being said, it seems many people are upset because the benefits are now evenly spread. That seems to me to be a very philosophical topic. There are many articles about income inequality, wealth inequality, etc. They do not seem to acknowledge that being able to watch tv, fly in an airplane, have air conditioning are things kings and queens did not have 100 years ago.

How about picking some objective metrics that you care about and see how they are trending? It will give you a more objective starting point to ask the question of whether things are getting better or worse.

andrewlgood··on QA workers at Blizzard Albany are unionizing
The gist of the Washington Post article is they could not hire sufficient staff for the store. They dedicated two recruiters to the task and were still unsuccessful. For the staff they did have, there was "excessive call outs and lack of availability..." I do not have any facts beyond the article, but would not surprise me that an understaffed store (described as in a remote location) would enter a downward spiral that leads to a shut down.
andrewlgood··on QA workers at Blizzard Albany are unionizing
Not quite a balanced representation of what happened. The store had been closed for a month due to an inability to hire people. Washington Post article has fuller explanation of both sides - https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2022/07/20/chipotle-...
andrewlgood··on Ask HN: I got into MIT. Should I go?
UROP can be an amazing opportunity. Professors are looking for freshman (and older) to participate in real research opportunities. For many graduating MIT, they describe it as the most impactful aspect of their time at MIT.
andrewlgood··on Ask HN: I got into MIT. Should I go?
As an alum of MIT, I highly recommend attending, if you are going to put in the work to be successful there. The fact that you have been admitted means you probably will.

In 30 years of working after college, with numerous job interviews along the way, the item most discussed in every single interview was that I went to MIT. Right or wrong, that is what has happened. To be clear, MIT teaches you how to think and that is what employers are looking for.

As for the cost, I agree with those above who stated that you should attempt to negotiate more financial aid from MIT. I also agree that MIT is one of the few (with the Ivy League schools, Stanford, and CaltTech) that are worth the cost. You will more than recover it over your career.

Finally, you can learn as much going to other schools such as Z. But, you will have to push yourself much harder whereas at MIT, the school will push you. It can make a big difference.

BTW, Boston is an amazing city in which to go to school. So much to do. So many other college age people there.

andrewlgood··on Let's democratize the United Nations and make it relevant again
I do not see the nations with large militaries turning over control of their militaries to the UN. How would a separate UN military be funded? manned?
andrewlgood··on Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?
Phenomenal book. One of the few books I have gifted to friends over the years. Gets one to think about the randomness of situations (geography, diversity of flora, etc) that lead to critical outcomes (advancement of a society).
andrewlgood··on Netflix paid just 1.1 percent in Federal Tax
Not sure what the fuss is. Any company publicly registered in the US has to provide a reconciliation of its income taxes. Netflix 2021 1.0-k can Be found here: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1065280/000106528018...

The relevant section is Note 10 Income Taxes which starts at the bottom of page 57.

The biggest drivers of the reduced taxes were stock options and the Tax Cuts and Job Act (TCJA). Stock options are just timing while I presume the TCJA are true credits.

This is not a mystery.

andrewlgood··on Tell HN: A Conversation Needs to Be Had over Subscription Software
Some financing leads to ownership. Leasing a car does not lead to ownership - it is an extended rental.

I am not a fan of products that make it difficult to unsubscribe, but I do like the variable cost aspect of SaaS. Generally quick to start using and quick to stop.

I have not seen it commented on, but my sense is security is easier with a SaaS model. How many pirated versions of software have you come across in your career pre-Saas?

andrewlgood··on Inequality, Interest Rates, Aging, and the Role of Central Banks
Interesting article. The arguments re inequality seem to lead to an inevitable need for Universal Basic Income (or whatever else you want to call it) as a smaller group of people continue to generate the vast majority of income and control an even larger percentage of wealth.

Combine the impacts that increasing income and wealth inequality have with the discussions of the impact due to investment in greater automation - reduction in labor and more returns to owners of capital - and it appears inevitable that we will need to ensure a safety net covers everyone.

It seems to me that some countries will figure this out before others. There will be a global race to become the destination country for those with the income and wealth.

andrewlgood··on Use Spreadsheets Everywhere
Agree. Also hard to beat the ability to create pretty reports as well. This is why many financial forecasting systems have connectivity to Excel to allow for the creation of reports.
andrewlgood··on Use Spreadsheets Everywhere
I do not think the point is software engineers hate spreadsheets. Software engineers would approach their use of spreadsheets very differently than a financial analyst. I think the point is software engineers hate inheriting spreadsheets that are developed by others who do not use a more sophisticated developer approach
andrewlgood··on Use Spreadsheets Everywhere
I agree with the your statements. Would add that it is important to understand most developers of spreadsheets have never taken a programming class and do not fully understand many of the issues discussed in this thread.

Also, there is little motivation to the spreadsheet user to change. In the examples given by the author, the original creator of the spreadsheet is long gone by the time the problems surface.

andrewlgood··on Use Spreadsheets Everywhere
How would you put guardrails on the spreadsheets to make sure spreadsheets do not accidently damage the database performance through bad calls? In the hierarchy of skills, SQL is significantly less prevalent that spreadsheets.
andrewlgood··on Use Spreadsheets Everywhere
When contemplating shifting end users to something other than spreadsheets, one needs to keep in mind how many spreadsheet users there are and what there motivations to change.
andrewlgood··on Use Spreadsheets Everywhere
Article covers a great point, just does not provide a framework to make decisions regarding when to use spreadsheets.

I am a CFO that has used spreadsheets my entire career (30+years). They can definitely have a vital role in any company and can also cause incredible problems.

A few thoughts that were not mentioned in the article:

   1) in many companies the users of spreadsheets are not allowed to use anything more powerful than spreadsheets (or maybe MS Access which causes more problems).  To get a SQL/Python (or other programming language) solution requires submitting a request to IT and then waiting two years to work up the priority queue.  This is not a complaint against IT and the priority process.  The reality is most spreadsheets do not start out as important enough to warrant high priority.  
   2) Spreadsheets are great containers.  Not only can they hold a model, but also the raw data, and even emails regarding the model/inputs/etc.  This makes them very handy for keeping everything in one file regarding an analysis.
   3) IME, most significant spreadsheets get rewritten as they evolve, especially when they change hands.  This is both good and bad.  While the rewrite allows correction of built up badness, it is rarely done with the discipline one sees with refactoring in more traditional code.  Moreover, when a hand off happens, the rewrite is generally done because the recipient does not fully understand how the existing model works.
   4) Large spreadsheets cannot be effectively audited outside of locking/password protecting non-input cells. Very rarely is this actually done.  As a result, you get the scenario the author describes of hard-coded values in cells that once contained formulas.  These are almost impossible to find in worksheets with large numbers of tabs and thousands of formulas.  
  5) Spreadsheets generally do not use true version control.  For most of my career, one simply used "File Save As" to create a new version.  In the early days it was due to a fear Windows would crash and you would lose your work.  Later, it became a way to step through changes and determine the impact of the change.  While this method provides some ability to go back to a prior state, people really do not track properly what each version contains and what are the true differences (would love to find a way to use Git effectively on spreadsheets).
   6) Most spreadsheets do not have test cases.  They certainly do not increase the test case universe as modifications are made.  As a result, cannot tell if things break when changes are made.  
Given all of these things, I recommend using spreadsheets for ad hoc analyses and to pilot analytics that will become part of a routine process. The latter point is the point the author is making (and the point of his title). I would add that the analysts need a plan and methodology to determine when they need to convert from the anything-goes freedom of spreadsheets to a more disciplined, maintainable, controlled program.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →