HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

andrewxdiamond

1,789 karma · joined October 18, 2019

Engineer at Amazon Kuiper.

Happy to chat

me@andrew.diamonds

submissionscomments
andrewxdiamond··on NYC Votes to Close Rikers Island
Additionally,

> and it's not like most of these criminal sorts haven't had 18 years of second chances and resources being thrown at them

A lot of these kids _haven't_. You're assuming everyone grew up in a middle class neighborhood with good teachers and was never pressured by gangs and never mistreated by authority. That's simply not the case. If you examine the personal history of many imprisoned people, you'll find a common pattern of poverty, limited chances, and family issues. All of which aren't the fault of the individual.

andrewxdiamond··on NYC Votes to Close Rikers Island
> I will not believe this when a person is involved in violent acts, rape, murder, etc. which nobody "needs" to do to survive.

Agreed. There is a spectrum of individuals, and not everyone is good. However, if you break down the types of crime, non-violent crimes are very much the majority (0). Most people don't like hurting other people.

If you want an example of a working system with the mentality of "Rehabilitate over Punish", see many of the Nordic countries (1).

> in the past decade, the number of Swedish prisoners has dropped from 5,722 to 4,500 out of a population of 9.5 million. The country has closed a number of prisons, and the recidivism rate is around 40%, which is far less than in the U.S. and most European countries.

You can argue this is due to other factors such as overall wealth of the nation, but that further proves my point that crime is more often an act of desperation rather than one of sadism.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_the_United_States

[1] https://www.mic.com/articles/109138/sweden-has-done-for-its-...

andrewxdiamond··on We moved our servers to Iceland
Do you have any proof or other verifiable evidence of these claims? Or are you just assuming that those statements are true?

As far as I'm aware, there is no evidence at all that the commonly recommend encryption algorithms have any serious vulnerabilities when used properly. Now, it's easy to say that researchers would be given gag orders if they found the "magic back door", but that's all just speculation and fear-mongering really.

Additionally, it would be in the US's best interest for there to be no backdoor. Any vulnerability in RSA for example could be exploited against them.

andrewxdiamond··on I'm Resigning as a Stack Overflow Community Elected Moderator
He recently announced he is stepping down

https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2019/09/24/announcing-stack-o...

andrewxdiamond··on NYC Votes to Close Rikers Island
As it turns out, not many people commit crimes because they are fun.

Deterrents like hash punishments work, but only to the extent that the person has an option. Many people who turn to crime have no or few professional skills, and would struggle to make a living completely legitimately. Hence, they do what anyone would do in that situation, and commit crime to survive.

And when individuals are locked away in prisons for years at a time with no rehabilitation, nothing's really changed. They are still in the same situation as before, except now they have a criminal record, making their situation even more dire.

This leads to a revolving door effect where many individuals end up back in the same prison they just left. Not only does this ruin the person's life, it also costs the public in both lost productivity, and costs associated with housing imprisoned individuals.

Many modern countries short circuit this cycle by educating and rehabilitating imprisoned individuals so by the time they leave their cells they are ready to join the economy as an effective worker.

Think of it this way, if your child was struggling to get passing grades in school, what would be more effective? Locking them in their room with a book, or hiring a tutor?

← PreviousPage 13 of 13