HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ang_cire

2,309 karma · joined June 12, 2023

submissionscomments
ang_cire··on Protopia
Except the author did choose, which is my point. They specifically chose to only represent it one specific way, that omitted the most common or famous incarnations, because those run counter to their narrative.
ang_cire··on Tech sucks: You have to vote with your wallet, or nothing will change
Since we now have to vote with things other than our actual votes, apparently, here's some more things you can vote with:

3D printers

Torrent clients

Unlicensed radios

DJI drones

Custom firmware

(FOSS in general)

ang_cire··on Silicon Valley misreads science fiction and undermines democracy
Being and especially growing up rich tends to shield you from seeing the consequences of bad decisions, and I think that results in a lot of these rich tech bros being unable to properly analyze not just risk, but any negative externalities.

Every child starts out thinking, "if I was in charge, I could fix this. It's so simple!"

Then you actually see that when you make bad choices, you or others get hurt, and you realize that you don't always know what's best.

But these guys never get hurt, because they have the money to be shielded from it, so they end up being these delusional wrecking ball assholes, who think they know better than everyone else and don't need anyone else's consent (I.e. votes) to make whatever overly simplistic or authoritarian changes their underdeveloped brains concoct.

ang_cire··on Protopia
The hunger games is also about an authoritarian society with mass surveillance, though?

WWZ is about a literal zombie outbreak, and while I can't comment on whether the book is actually using it as a vehicle to critique or extrapolate real-world social systems, the movie sure as hell didn't.

Without going into a very long rant about Bethesda missing the point of Fallout as a universe, suffice it to say that it is also not intended to be a serious examination of what life might or even could become, ever. In fact, it was intended to be a platform for social critique via parody and caricaturism.

ang_cire··on Protopia
That *opinion* article is by a literal anti-climate-science hack. He cites none of his numbers, and it's because they're complete lies.

Here's some actual cited evidence:

The WHO fact sheet on heat and health [1] says:

> The number of people exposed to extreme heat is growing exponentially due to climate change in all world regions. Heat-related mortality for people over 65 years of age increased by approximately 85% between 2000–2004 and 2017–2021 (1).

> Between 2000–2019 studies show approximately 489 000 heat-related deaths occur each year, with 45% of these in Asia and 36% in Europe (2). In Europe alone in the summer of 2022, an estimated 61 672 heat-related excess deaths occurred (3). High intensity heatwave events can bring high acute mortality; in 2003, 70 000 people in Europe died as a result of the June–August event. In 2010, 56 000 excess deaths occurred during a 44–day heatwave in the Russian Federation.

[1] https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/climate-cha...

The author claims:

> A century ago, almost half a million people died on average each year from storms, floods, droughts, wildfires and extreme temperatures. Over the next 10 decades, global annual deaths from these causes declined 96%, to 18,000. In 2020, they dropped to 14,000.

In no universe is this remotely true, if he's attempting to be accurate about climate deaths. The US alone had 4,000 direct heat exposure deaths annually as of 2020, and an average 47,500 cold exposure deaths. As in, people literally dying of extreme heat and cold exposure. That doesn't include every other climate impact death, and, once again, that's US only.

That's from Yale [2], btw:

> In a new study, YSPH researchers found that while cold weather continues to be a leading contributor to U.S. deaths annually, deaths linked to heat exposure surged more than 50% over the past two decades. Cold-related deaths rose from about 44,000 between 2000 and 2009 to more than 47,500 between 2010 and 2020, a 7% increase. Meanwhile, deaths associated with high temperatures climbed by 53%, from an annual average of 2,670 between 2000 and 2009 to more than 4,000 between 2010 and 2020.

[2] https://ysph.yale.edu/news-article/warming-us-climate-linked...

Globally, heat deaths alone in 2023 were over 178,000 [3].

[3] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S266667582...

I'll leave debunking the rest of this misinformation to others, as this comment is already long enough.

ang_cire··on Protopia
I like how the author defines dystopia as

> reckless uprisings, a long dark age, the collapse of institutions, climate disasters, a black mirror of stunted humanity descending into chaos.

rather than the much more common understanding or portrayals like 1984 or Handmaid's Tale, which in fact feature incredibly, overly-strong institutions, and a tyrannical lack of autonomy (so not a whole lot of 'reckless uprisings').

But if you're trying to convince people that technology is in fact not the thing that's enabling mass surveillance and economic decline and black-mirror-like-drone-warfare and climate disasters and tyranny right now, then it would make sense to leave out the most common understanding of what a dystopia looks like.

"No, AI is totally gonna result in Star Trek, not the Panopticon, I swear! What's a Palantir?"

It feels like some kind of weird enlightened-techno-centrism.

ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
I agree about what happened, but I think the timescale is different.

Railroads were the tools of robber-barons even in the 1800s. Electricity was captured by the major electric companies before most millennials were born. Finance was a stodgy-suit-wearing-white-guy's game when my dad got into it in the 1970s.

I knew that's what "finance jobs" meant back when I was a kid building fan pages on GeoCities. But GeoCities and Limewire and Napster and Gaia Online never led me to think that's were I'd end up if I worked in tech.

If our boomer parents had warned us about crapitalism as kids, we might have seen it coming before we had already sunk decades into it as an interest and career path.

ang_cire··on The Claudyssey: A line-for-line translation of Homer's Odyssey by Claude Fable 5
Translation is an art form that is rapidly becoming lost, not because AI is doing it, but because there are too many translators who have apparently been trained (or likely, were never trained in it as a formal study at all) that it should be written in a way that emphasizes the translation as a standalone work more than anything else.

A good translation should attempt to communicate what the author meant, as closely as possible, even if there is no equivalent in the target language.

A good translation should be beautiful all on its own.

It's the balance of the 2 that makes a translation successful.

If you erase the author's true meaning just because you don't want to slow the reader down in having to take a moment to read an explanatory footnote if they're confused, you have failed to translate it, and have likely editorialized it.

Why do many English-speaking people know 'wabisabi' as a concept? Because someone bothered to explain it to them, and they bothered to listen. That act enriches the reader.

And don't even get me started on "localization".

ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
The problem isn't that WFO-preferenced people don't exist, it's that it aligns with the narratives of the extroverted management (who approve their own PTO) that it's better, and people who aren't extroverts dread being forced back. No one who prefers WFH is actually against people who prefer offices being allowed to go there, they're opposed to people publicly claiming they prefer that- unqualified- because they see it as a threat; a statement that will be weaponized to support management's RTO initiatives.
ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
Or, as any respectable farmer does it, it's though heavy subsidies and crop insurance fraud!
ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
Yes and no.

There were really 2 sides to the original 'tech' industry: military and consumer. The military side was always about profit, because it was just an extension of the already extant WW2 military industrial complex (and frankly, IBM falls here despite their mainframes being largely used in civilian businesses).

But the consumer side that really grew out of universities into early gaming, internet, and consumer electronics tech, was very heavily driven by design and garage-start tinkerers. That's not to say no one wanted to make money, but it wasn't MBA-bro-driven back then.

ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
Exactly. It's insane how we've come to just accept corporate profit as a valid reason for allowing people to die, or for shifting responsibility for the outcome away from the corporation.

The Joker's monologue to Harvey Dent in The Dark Knight about how one group of killings is just normal and "part of the plan", while another is shocking and appalling (specifically when it's a societal 'elite'), was supposed to be at least somewhat outlandish and overly pessimistic as an interpretation of society, but damn these people are trying to prove him right.

ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
The article isn't only about AI, and neither was my comment.
ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
Is discussing offshoring that takes away American jobs and has driven much poverty in the heartland equally political and unacceptable, or is it just the political discussions you don't like having that shouldn't be allowed?

The "no politics" rule is about not posting constant "x politician said this about tech" articles, not about banning all discussion of real-world consequences of the tech industry.

ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
Everyone makes decisions in life and lives with the consequences. Your question, as it's stated now, is simply "should we have free will?"

I never made any statement about which actions should be legal. And the facile assertion that endorsing one action is either tantamount to, or requiring of, endorsement of any action that shares an arbitrary attribute you identify is sloppy argumentation; somehow I don't think you would argue that someone supporting police having the authority to use force means they are supporting every instance including illegal uses of force.

ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
I don't know where you got the idea my comment is about AI from.
ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
That's only okay if they're a politician or business exec, right? It's fine to hold those murderers up as role models, apparently.
ang_cire··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
Because we see what's coming?

Because we watched our careers go from being in service of an industry of tinkerers and designers, to being in service of the worst people attempting to maximize wealth extraction no matter the human cost?

Because Snow Crash wasn't supposed to be the goal?

Because our daily complicity in what's happening is also a daily reminder that we're not brave enough to be a Mangione?

Take your pick.

ang_cire··on Framework discloses data breach via Metabase 0-day
These are bad examples.

Warranty status is tied to hardware* serials. It's not like there are third-party Framework sellers.

Sending a recall notice via email doesn't require name, address, dob, etc.

Companies are in a bad habit of not actually clearing customer data they don't need.

ang_cire··on Born Against, or why hobby programming communities are against LLM usage
Perhaps I'm uncommon in that I make diagrams and even sometimes pseudo-code (mostly in the form of mapping out function names, because they serve as a proxy for program flow paths) before I write actual code, but I don't find myself really going off gut feeling. I have a pretty good idea of what the program is going to look like and do before I start, and with e.g. Claude I give those to it, so it mostly looks like what I envisioned, unless it suggests changes.
ang_cire··on Born Against, or why hobby programming communities are against LLM usage
It's funny, because I would consider myself a tinkerer (and I have a large backlog of pre-LLM programs), but the coding itself isn't the main thing that brings me joy, it's the phase 2 and phase 4 combo: figure out how to solve it, see whether your solution was correct (and actually use the program for its purpose). The actual implementation is extraneous to that.

To carry forward the sudoku analogy, I care about figuring out which numbers go where, and whether I was correct, I don't care about the mechanical part of actually penciling-in the answers (coding).

ang_cire··on Universities would prefer no AI
This is a false dichotomy.

University impact on careers in the 1980s was materially different than now, and that is still "modern education".

Opposing the AI impact on universities is not equivalent to opposing modern water infrastructure, it's more akin to being opposed to a new water pipe material that is shown to improve flow but have adverse health effects.

ang_cire··on Cops Used Flock to Track a Man Across State Lines for a Pretextual Weed Search
> If all laws were prosecuted to the exact letter of the law we would not need juries. The DA will prosecute any case that they feel has enough evidence to secure a conviction, as this case had. It is the juries that determine if prosecution in each case is "just".

I think you're think of grand juries. They decide if there is enough evidence to go to trial, I.e. if the prosecution is just.

Even without grand juries, we'd still have juries that decide the verdicts. They decide if a conviction is just.

ang_cire··on Cops Used Flock to Track a Man Across State Lines for a Pretextual Weed Search
The bail jumping charge was actually dropped in the end, so weed possession was the only charge.
ang_cire··on Universities would prefer no AI
We (meaning the US) won't ever fix this ourselves, because we systematically refuse to hold businesses to any kind of standards.

Make it illegal to discriminate based on degree status in hiring (it's not like anyone is hiring an SWE without doing technical interviews anyways, so if you prove out their skills why does the paper matter?), and you remove both the backdoor socioeconomic discrimination route (which is itself a backdoor route to discriminate against protected attributes), and solve the degree 'inflation' incentive.

ang_cire··on Universities would prefer no AI
Yep, there were multiple dog whistles in this article, including framing the very intentional attack on science funding by Trump, as a tool for political leverage against universities, as being just some kind of benign priority shift.
ang_cire··on Universities would prefer no AI
That is either a logistics issue, or a mismatch in what is being purchased. It doesn't specify that they're the same GPUs. Given the way the author structures the article, I'm suspicious that this is a meaningful or even truthful metric.
ang_cire··on Universities would prefer no AI
wont to do*

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/wont

ang_cire··on Universities would prefer no AI
Yes, but that's not something universities can solve.

Universities predate capitalism (despite the author's absurd assertion that they were founded to serve the interests of businesses), and will exist after it, if any humans survive it.

ang_cire··on Universities would prefer no AI
I'm fairly certain that you do in fact have a duct that moves aqua (water) into your house, bro.

And gravity-feed systems are the best way to move large amounts of water. That's even how nature works, and nature moves much more water than humans do.

← PreviousPage 6 of 30Next →