510 karma · joined March 25, 2009
I'm sorry but where are you getting this from? Google has categorically stated that they do not share data without court approved mandates. There is no mass "targeting" that is going on, no matter what the nationality.
And yes if you examine the documents as much as my post you'd have seen that they are indeed based on little to no evidence.
By the way have you called your local rep yet?
These accusations are seriously getting out of hand. This is also seriously getting so illogical that I've considered whether it's even worth posting a response.
Is accusing someone with a badly created powerpoint presentation now enough for such a massive storm?
Yesterday, Larry gave a thorough point to point denial to the Washington Post article. Conspiracy theorists@HN moved the goalpost and started talking about how if Google isn't doing X they must be providing data to NSA servers. Now that David Drummond has come out and denied that Google's not doing Y, some HNers start complaining that he's lying even though there's no evidence to the contrary.
Google has committed its fair share of mistakes but as employees inside the company we have always stood by our users and a lot of these attacks are indirectly questioning our moral character.
Larry and especially David have created a culture where we push back when the government makes overreaching user data requests. These push backs have been happening for years. Google has even gone to courts questioning the constitutional validity of NSLs. (source: [1]). There are times when courts uphold the Government request. Google publishes these in its Transparency report ([2]). The claim that these guys are willfully lying on this issue is completely out of character with what their actions have been till date.
You say that government has already admitted that they access the data. Where? Do you mean the Verizon CDRs? Or are you using the flimsy PPT as evidence? Maybe your source is one the myriad of articles that have used the powerpoint as their source. Or maybe your source is one of those of another articles that use other badly sourced article as their sources. Maybe you mean Obama's statement that the government does track emails. In that case, being in technology, I hope you realize that being a MITM email snooper is one of the easiest things to do. That's why you never ever use email for secure communication. Maybe you don't understand these "nerd-y" things (yes, I was a shocked too when a HNer threw that at me), but I implore you to logically think about this story.
Yesterday, there were a flurry of posts that were seeing a conspiracy in how Mark Zuckerberg's and Larry's response were similar. Why have we HNers turned into conspiracy theorists now? It was only later when some sane voices pointed out that they were each responding to the specific points raised by the original WaPo article, that that controversy died down. Of course no one seems to mention that the original WaPo post has retracted several claims especially about companies being in the know. [3]
Some conspiracy theorists@HN have even talked about spies infiltrating as Google engineers. Are you guys serious? The level of control/monitoring/logging that happens to employees at Google when accessing any data at Google (even when you're just trying to debug why processing that data is crashing your server) is so huge that this just won't be a feasible strategy for these spies. Also, with all these checks in place it's impossible to get hold of information without a lot of flags being raised. Even if we assume that all US based engineers at Google are somehow government spies (a preposterous claim which I'm sure someone must have made on HN by now), Google has engineers outside US. Engineers who have access to the same alerting/monitoring systems that would alert them if such unauthorized data access was happening. Those engineers would not be bound by any US government imposed gag order that conspiracy theorists here seem to claim.
I've even had someone claim on HN that because Google worked with NSA to protect Chinese human rights activists from spying attempts/hacking attacks, Google's helping NSA spy on US citizens. This is so illogical that it makes no sense to me.
I've had the opportunity to have worked with Yonatan's team and I have immense respect for him. I also completely mirror his feelings [4]. Any massive data sharing/accessing would be really hard to do without this turning up in some shape or form in front of me and if this were happening I would not be at Google. Most of us engineers would not be.
Enough with the personal attacks questioning our values.
Now to the bigger question, if a democratically elected US "government" is making and forcing private individuals and organizations to follow extra-constitutional norms. Shouldn't you actually take this issue up with your local senator/representative? Contact them: http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_c... http://www.house.gov/representatives/ Doesn't being in a representative republic mean that that's how you solve the problems you're having with your government. I was one of those who were mystified by the current president's oratory. Yet, I also believe that if something is not right it's time to use the proper channels to have your voice heard. How many of you are US citizens and have written multiple posts here on HN since yesterday but haven't called your local representative yet? Now is the time.
These witch hunts without evidence, all these conspiracy theories, the attempts to find fault with every statement being made; these are not what HN should be about. Let's actually do something to bring about some real change.
Sources: [1] - http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-57587003-38/judge-orders-g...; [2] - https://www.google.com/transparencyreport/ [3] - http://www.forbes.com/sites/jonathanhall/2013/06/07/washingt...; [4] - https://plus.google.com/103389452828130864950/posts/huwQsphB...
The strange thing is that just having a presentation is usually not enough for the HN crowd. If it would have been, I would never have to execute on any of my ideas beyond the presentation stage. Personally, I really don't think some making a presentation is really evidence of anything.
I'm really not sure why HNers reacted differently in this instance though.
How is that related to helping the US government spy on its citizens?
First, I'm not a US citizen. So, it seems I just have to assume that NSA is certainly tracking me.
Now to the topic of spying on US citizens, considering how no one seems to have ever heard about PRISM, the breaking of this story based on flimsy evidence seems to me like an attempt to side track from the real and confirmed story of NSA accessing Call Data Records from Verizon of millions of citizens (The industry calls it CDRs, why have we started calling it "Metadata" since yesterday).
I wouldn't be surprised (though I have no evidence at all) that the PRISM story was planted to change the public discourse.
Google+ does support nicknames and pseudonyms now, but yes there is a preference for users to use their real names. Also personally, I don't really think real anonymity truly exists on the web anymore and in such a scenario I trust the bigger companies more than the thousands of tracking companies but I'll write that rant sometime else.
Coming back to real names in Google+, I'm not entirely sure why Google+ prefers it, but I think it ties in with generating better social signals. Facebook really showed the way here. If people use their real names it's easier to find real friends. I also would care about signals/content created by friends with real names.
I'd care more what a particular friend I know has recommended more that what rockstar_spongebob has. Also if I'm rockstar_spongebob on a website, I'd lose the incentive to connect with only people who are my "real" friends and I'll end up adding lots of people at random. I think this is what happened on Digg and these "friendships" had no true affinity (atleast on Digg). I truly would never have cared about restaurants recommended by my Digg friends. Of course these reasons are just my guesses and I really have no research/data to back it up.
I think Google+ could be understood better once you realize that Google+ is not a social network in the traditional terms. Google+ is truly a social layer across all Google services.
The average users who are just looking for a chicken recipe (as you mention) would always love to find the particular chicken recipe that their friends have recommended. Even more relevant to me (since I don't cook) is that if a friend finds a todo app useful, I'd definitely want to know.
If Google has this social layer, it'll really unleash more expressive search results that would help the vast majority of users. This is what Google+ is.
Google+ is literally Google Plus More.
Of course, to get these benefits you really have to start using Google+ on different Google services. I guess this is the reason that Google employees who actually use Google+ services continue using it and prefer if their friends do it too.
In this particular instance, the GNOME dev was pretty rude and if that behavior is supported by the GNOME community, it needs to be publicly called out.
I as a user would not want to support any open source project where developers act like asshats.
It was this reason that Adobe could never launch a flash enabled browser on iOS.
"I have a copy of a May 18, 2007 (not April) email from Jeff announcing his project on a wide-distribution list. It does not have the subject line "Google OS"; it's actually called "Guppy needs testers". Given that it begins, "I'd like to publish my Linux distro, called Guppy, for some testers to try out and provide feedback. Guppy is a little side project to build a Google distro of PuppyLinux for USB.", I'm inclined to believe it's the first such wide-distribution email. The phrase "Google OS" is never mentioned; neither are "browser" or "Chrome" or "Firefox" or "webapps". The closest we get is the single sentence two thirds of the way through that "I set up some desktop shortcuts to Google Apps", which is literally the only time the email mentions anything close to Jeff's claim above that "all of the functionality came from webapps; performing any operation on the desktop launched a Chrome window to one of many webapps." In fact, the email explicitly mentions that you can install OpenOffice if you want, which seems to contradict this portrayal a bit."
Theora was supposed to be the unencumbered alternative, then it was VP8 and now it's Daala. Unfortunately, all these and even closed/patented codecs have just muddied the waters rather than being the "alternative" that solves it all.
Getting adoption of codecs is much harder in today's world than it ever was. The online, mobile and browse worlds are so divided than no company would ever want to give another an advantage by adopting the other companies codec.
Also, your whole idea that only the affected should protest in a society is grossly simplistic and if I might say then naive. A society exists to protect all its members including the weaker sections. This has nothing to do with communism.
Social evils are fought by the society as a whole. Should men not fight for women rights, should straight people not stand up for LGBT rights, what about priveliged races against racism?
I think you need to think your argument through without getting needlessly worked up.
I'm invoking Godwin here but this quote is thoroughly apt.
When the Nazis came for the communists, I said nothing; I was, of course, no communist. When they locked up the Social Democrats, I said nothing; I was, of course, no Social Democrat. When they came for the trade unionists, I said nothing; I was, of course, no trade unionist. When they came for me, there was no one left who could protest.
In this article, for instance, only the poorest of the poor are truly starving and the vast majority just doesn't care enough to protest. While the middle classes are too busy with their own lives, the poorest and most disadvantaged people are too busy trying to eke out a basic living to actually protest about it.
Let me try to list some reasons as to why.
India has no real opposition party in the centre or most of the states. Most ruling parties end up having uncontrolled power.
Corruption has become so pervasive in the Indian pillars of governance that we don't really have a Law & Order System anymore. The Police are corrupt and the judicial system is corrupt. Criminals thrive, as long as they have money.
Failure of the Law & Order system encourages corruption in the political class. The times that an opposition party does become a bit powerful, they end up being just as corrupt as the ruling party. Most Indian election candidates use the support of various mafia and unscrupulous businessmen to win elections. Once they win this way, they need to help such people now that they are in power.
Over a period of time, these issues have become so pervasive in the Indian system that today the educated and the middle classes stay away from politics. They live in their own laissez-faire life with private utilities, security and medicine. They pay their taxes but don't expect much from the government in return as long as the government doesn't interfere or hinder them.
The powerful media is too busy and is rarely anti-government because government advertising forms a big part of their revenues. So they don't carry such stories for long. The media has their own pressures since they have to keep circulations high by keeping the prices virtually free.
A section of the civil society had been trying to hold anti-corruption protests in recent times. They started with a lot of support but soon the media lost interest in them and nobody really pays any attention to their rallies anymore.
Now for all these reasons, the middle classes are mostly apathetic to the plight of the poor or the fact that the rich are exploiting the nation.
Personally, I don't think that looking like a newspaper/magazine and adopting a techmeme like share mechanism is a significant enough change that the market would need.
Today, my real name and the location that I had had in Google+ is appearing as my Google Talk name and status rather than the old nick/status that I had set.
Just to add to your last statement about internet companies being relatively bribe free, I've heard pieces (rumours) from well places influential people in the government that this is changing fast too.
Allegedly, the recent court cases against Google and Facebook asking them to block content was an attempt to get them to fork over some money.
Also, the recent banning of websites of companies like dailymotion and vimeo was our not so clean judicial system at work.
Linus has always been pretty adamant about not breaking API behaviour even undocumented ones. But in this case, undefined behaviour had been previously documented.
Also, was it him or Ulrich Drepper who were against changing memcpy undocumented behaviour. (mempcy used to work with overlapping regions too.)
PS. This mailing thread is from 2010. It's really old.
I use a combination of swift's to-do list, gmail tasks and lazymeter to keep track of my TODOs. I find the todo list a very important tool in my productivity arsenal.
Support for the few pieces of linux software that they used to make (prior to joining the Foundation) has now stopped/ gradually being wound down.
Most commenters on the Android Open source story also raised some pretty valid concerns. It's not a lie that Google has been loose with term "open", commenters were ready to point that out.
There is no reason to get all worked up about valid negative points (most of which are not opinions).
On many fronts including security, I think Adobe lost a marketing battle to Apple.
Nothing to be proud of but for the last couple of years, Apple products have had as many security vulnerabilities as Adobe products, if not more. Adobe still gets much more flak owing to their ubiquitous nature (maybe they should). On the other hand, the market treats Apple like a security expert's dream (which it is not).
They were one of the few publications who were extremely pro-IIPM when investigative bloggers were pointing out that IIPM was a degree mill. It turned out later that the IIPM family was a big contributer to Tehelka.
I've heard that in some rural areas, banks do give loans on religious lines i.e. Banks in some muslim predominant areas only give loans to muslims and in some Hindu predominant areas to only hindus. Though I heard that the government is trying to curb this.
Personally, a lot of it seems to be anti-Indian propaganda. In India, our media tells us that such anti-India propaganda is quite common in Pakistani media. (Yes, I understand the dichotomy that I am dependent on Indian media for a lot of my raw data)
I really doubt that that code could be replaced easily in a single pass.