HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ankushnarula

262 karma · joined August 25, 2010

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/ankushnarula; my proof: https://keybase.io/ankushnarula/sigs/iNcY5P-NpXU-NsuEXkEa88mgfADYYMNWzKQFqeEC2rw ]

hnchat.com:f7X20VDdBIG15KJNH7Ih

submissionscomments
ankushnarula··on An Open Letter to Patreon
Just to clarify, the aforementioned disproportionate representation is with "street children" not homeless youth as a whole.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street_children#United_States

ankushnarula··on An Open Letter to Patreon
Just to clarify, the aforementioned disproportionate representation is with "street children" not homeless youth as a whole.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street_children#United_States

ankushnarula··on Amazon is constantly trying new things
Peter Thiel tried to point this out to Eric Schmidt a while back: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Q26XIKtwXQ
ankushnarula··on Cybersecurity Incident Involving Consumer Information
I did the same - they are offering free identity theft protection to all US Consumers starting on some kind of rolling enrollment date beginning 2017-09-14.
ankushnarula··on Al Gore’s New Movie Exposes the Big Flaw in Online Movie Ratings
That's just one of the counter-narratives. Unlike the "97% narrative", the counter-narratives are not monolithic.

Another counter-narrative says that climate change is happening but the models to date are inaccurate and overblown.

Another counter-narrative says that man-made or not, it's hubris to assume that humans can do something about it.

And yet another counter-narrative acknowledges climate-change but says that the prescriptions for fighting climate change aren't guaranteed to work and will hurt humanity - in that we should spur innovations that continuously adapt to climate change and boost economic prosperity for all mankind while avoiding worldwide austerity controlled by an earth-worshipping misanthropic orthodoxy. (or something like that ;) )

ankushnarula··on Why Google was wrong: Did James Damore really deserve to be fired?
Singer's essay might be one of the most balanced and thoughtful commentaries on this debacle (along with the open page Heterodox Academy [1]).

[1] https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/08/10/the-google-memo-what...).

ankushnarula··on North Korea now making missile-ready nuclear weapons, U.S. analysts say
The author of the article, Mark Bowden, was interviewed by Sam Harris on his podcast: https://www.samharris.org/podcast/item/must-we-accept-a-nucl...

To call this problem intractable is an understatement.

ankushnarula··on Instagram photos reveal predictive markers of depression
Excellent. But more likely this user will see an uptick in ads for self-help products and antidepressants.
ankushnarula··on 10 page anti-diversity screed circulating internally at Google
A 2011 Norwegian documentary series had an episode called "The Gender Paradox"[1] that examined this very issue in depth with interviews with evolutionary biologists, neuroscientists, psychologists and sociologists. It arrived at the conclusion that employment disparities increase in many professional fields due to natural divergent proclivities when socio-economic opportunities become equal for the sexes.

ON AVERAGE in Norway (one of the top 5 most equal countries), females prefer more people-oriented fields such as medicine and males will favor more systems-oriented fields such as engineering. Again, this is ON AVERAGE. There are major overlaps in many fields (e.g. arts and research sciences) - and in some fields there is virtually none (e.g. nursing vs sanitation). This is not controversial amongst scientists who do their best to suspend ideological or wishful thinking.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5LRdW8xw70

ankushnarula··on The Full 10-Page Anti-Diversity Screed Circulating Internally at Google
A 2011 Norwegian documentary series had an episode called "The Gender Paradox" that examined this very issue in depth with interviews with evolutionary biologists, neuroscientists, psychologists and sociologists. It arrived at the conclusion that employment disparities increase in many professional fields due to natural divergent proclivities when socio-economic opportunities become equal for the sexes.

ON AVERAGE in Norway (one of the top 5 most equal countries), females prefer more people-oriented fields such as medicine and males will favor more systems-oriented fields such as engineering. Again, this is ON AVERAGE. There are major overlaps in many fields (e.g. arts and research sciences) - and in some fields there is virtually none (e.g. nursing vs sanitation). This is not controversial amongst scientists who do their best to suspend ideological or wishful thinking.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5LRdW8xw70

ankushnarula··on Elon Musk says Mark Zuckerberg's understanding of AI is 'limited'
It doesn't even need to be a superintelligence - Musk explains a scenario that isn't very far on the horizon here at the Governor's meeting: https://youtu.be/OYJ89vE-QfQ?t=2959 (from 51:45 to 53:50)
ankushnarula··on Building a tiny blockchain
Correct me if I'm wrong but the article is about elucidating the structure of a blockchain database - not a practical secure cryptocurrency.
ankushnarula··on A Swedish rail line now scans microchip implants in addition to tickets
While this might provide short term convenience, we lack the human ethics and the engineering discipline for this not to be abused. And even if we addressed these challenges, a regressive authoritarian government or an emergent superintelligence would instantly have a fast and efficient mechanism to dominate society.
ankushnarula··on House panel votes to split Air Force, create new U.S. Space Corps
Regina Dugan ran DARPA like a startup - or at least like an innovation incubator:

https://www.fastcompany.com/1784731/regina-dugans-innovative...

JSOC (Joint Special Operations Command) is a cross-functional mission-driven organization:

https://dupress.deloitte.com/dup-us-en/deloitte-review/issue...

ankushnarula··on Noam Chomsky: Neoliberalism Is Destroying Our Democracy
There is an absence of pragmatism and an excess of moral prosecution in Chomsky's criticisms. He can't point to historically successfully (and hence tested) societies based on his ideals. This isn't a problem as an academic exercise - but it has become fodder for the neo-Marxists/Trotskyists masked as "socialist democrats" wreaking havoc in liberal institutions.
ankushnarula··on U.S. now can ask travelers for Facebook, Twitter handles
Just under the surface, this policy seems like a long play to reduce the global virality of radical online tendencies. While it might aid in US national security, it's a small part of a broader plan to transform national and global culture away from collaboration (horizontal growth) towards competition (vertical value). This is the essence of "Make America Great Again".
ankushnarula··on Interactive Mind Map for learning
You've created a significance map of your own conception of these subjects. It is, afterall, a mind map.

On a side note, I would subdivide Philosophy into Epistemology, Ethics, Naturalism, and Phenomenology and reclassify/reassociate accordingly.

ankushnarula··on Saudi king orders that women no longer need man’s permission to travel or study
Those two links came up when I typed my initial search to verify the original source. When I later changed my query to "saudi arabia male guardianship" I found the main stream of related articles on Google News:

https://news.google.com/news/story?ncl=d8vQiW5woz_iD_MaFaFAQ...

Note: I am not evaluating thousands of sourced references per day like Wikipedia - nor do I have a partisan political agenda. In this case, I evaluated the source content and it seemed fairly apolitical. Very likely, both of my linked sources used an AP or Reuters articles as their primary source.

ankushnarula··on Saudi king orders that women no longer need man’s permission to travel or study
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4479488/Saudi-king-o...

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/saudi-ar...

ankushnarula··on Campuses must combat growing zeal for censorship
The right to protest is not equivalent to the right to shutdown other people's speaking or listening rights. The protestors cross the line when they resort to using intimidation, physical obstruction, threats of violence, and/or actual violence. In most municipalities, such violations would be addressed quickly by the police. However, universities (and increasingly large left-leaning cities) have tolerated protestors use of intimidation and obstruction. One could argue why but I suspect it's a variety of practical as well as ideological reasons.
ankushnarula··on Campuses must combat growing zeal for censorship
What about the rights of students who wish to listen?
ankushnarula··on Indian government says citizens don't have absolute right over their bodies
> ...its adjective form democratic really only refers to the processes of appointing leadership

Not only. Democratic also (but not only) refers to the rule of law, separation of powers, branches of government, bicameral legislative branch, independent judiciary, and associated checks and balances.

> what's happening in India sounds more like the gradual march of bureaucracy and its exploitation by interested parties rather than a will or even whim of the majority of voters.

Voters are a) whimsical because of and b) manipulable thru appeals to blind emotions (e.g. fear and hope). The antidote is a thoughtful electorate. This requires an educated society but more importantly a highly ethical society.

And so I believe what's happening in India is a program based on the realization that you can't have individual liberty and collective democracy without personal responsibility and civic accountability. There is and will be resentment - so until it becomes a way of life some broad coercive measures are being used to enforce policy. You can call this illiberal or authoritarian - or you can call it pragmatic. The key for it to be perceived as pragmatic is for the central government to swiftly take down any internal corruption. It will reinforce the integrity of such coercive measures and amplify the ethos of "accountability".

p.s. an ideal/utopian liberal democracy might be a fiction but so are all of our aspirations

ankushnarula··on Zuck's response
I suspect that the 99% number is a reflection of "unique number of fake content objects" rather than "number of times all fake content objects were shared or viewed".

Also, since we all have a tendency to build our intuitions through confirmation bias it's best to discount our anecdotal intuitions since they may not align with the actual numbers.

ankushnarula··on Why I’m never buying HTC again
Unless the vendor is known for exceptional customer service then don't waste your money on extended warranties and make sure you have reserve funds to replace such purchases. Yes - cynicism will not prevent or solve these problems - but it will eliminate the anger and disappointment.
ankushnarula··on Artificial Intelligence's White Guy Problem
The article begins by conflating algorithms and training data and that becomes the "sticking point" in the reader's mind even though she later clarifies this fact soon after. This is not a surprise since this obfuscation helps to back the sinister and prosecutorial tone of the piece.
ankushnarula··on A Confession of Liberal Intolerance
(The actual problem is nicely highlighted in this article's most popular Reader Picks comments)

There is a popular narrative about what it means to be conservative, liberal, progressive, etc. This narrative is a small simple band in a vastly complex spectrum of views. Unfortunately, we have come to the point where the narrative is being echoed so much that it's impossible to have a conversation framed outside the popular narrative.

We have all been trained and self-trained to pigeonhole each other based on these meaningless labels to either a) dismiss each other or b) rally together to dismiss the "other".

The one thing that we can't do is suspend our emotional biases and sincerely listen to alternate narratives.

ankushnarula··on Lightroom $4K iMac VS $4K PC performance test
Apple is delivering a turnkey hardware solution with the 5K iMac. They will also provide an upgrade path with future hardware generations. This article is the same-ole myopic view of DIY specifications and IT enterprise management. Macs are not built for people who can or want to do it themselves. Macs are built for people who ONLY want to focus on the task at hand.
ankushnarula··on Final Statement on the LambdaConf Controversy
Not at all. Blogger (where Moldbug's posts are alive and well) is a _platform_ - and it's owned and operated by Google. Using your logic, Google is "endorsing" this type of speech. Oh yeah - so is AWS, Azure, Akamai, CloudFlare, etc. when they take a neutral view of content.
ankushnarula··on Final Statement on the LambdaConf Controversy
Funny how, using your own logic, Google didn't take down Moldbug's posts. BTW, have you stopped using Google products since they endorse this kind of speech on the platform?
ankushnarula··on Final Statement on the LambdaConf Controversy
"While an intolerant sect does not itself have title to complain of intolerance, its freedom should be restricted only when the tolerant sincerely and with reason believe that their own security and that of the institutions of liberty are in danger." (John Rawls from the same link in the other thread)

So some people sincerely believe Yarvin's very presence is a threat while others find his online philosophical rants to be little more than meanderings.

With that said here's my answer to your thought experiment:

Yarvin would be uninvited if he had been proven (not alleged) to have:

* harmed or advocated harm to anyone * rallied for pro-discriminatory policies * lobbied for pro-discriminatory policies * addressed someone with discriminatory slurs

If he were to deny the evidence then it would be a done deal and he would be banned.

However, everyone gets a chance to repent in my book. So if he had been proven to do these things and he came clean (or eventually came clean) then he would get a chance to publicly apologize online for wide distribution - and again live at the conference at the start of his talk.

---

The real answer to your question is that I would not associate with anyone proven to have done abhorrent things. But I regularly associate with people who have all kinds of abhorrent thoughts.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →