HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

annexrichmond

1,232 karma · joined July 4, 2017

submissionscomments
annexrichmond··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
And Maduro was never in violation of international law? Why didn't anyone enforce the law?
annexrichmond··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Would you have said the same thing in the 40s if the US were able to capture Hitler?
annexrichmond··on A website to destroy all websites
From the homepage: The author’s position is that one must adhere to their politics or be killed.
annexrichmond··on How uv got so fast
> This reduces resolver backtracking dramatically since upper bounds are almost always wrong.

I am surprised by this because Python minor versions break backwards compatibility all the time. Our company for example is doing a painful upgrade from py39 to py311

annexrichmond··on X Just Accidentally Exposed a Covert Influence Network Targeting Americans
> you don't have control of the X algorithm

There is literally a timeline that only shows the feed of people you follow.

annexrichmond··on X Just Accidentally Exposed a Covert Influence Network Targeting Americans
This is mostly why I stopped going on Reddit. At least on X I have more control over what I see and mostly just follow trustworthy accounts. I just assume most of the commentary on mainstream American subreddits like politics is infiltrated by foreign actors and bots.
annexrichmond··on Helm 4.0
Helm is the necessary evil for Kubernetes chose YAML
annexrichmond··on Rockstar employee shares account of the company's union-busting efforts
Are you aware of any resources for how to combat colleagues aiming to start a union? I am personally opposed to being part of a union.
annexrichmond··on Trump pardons convicted Binance founder
I agree this isn't a very satisfying answer, but realistically how else do you expect Presidential pardons to go? Trump has pardoned over 1000 people and Joe Biden has pardoned over 4000. Do we expect them to know the intricate details of every single case?

And I mean, wasn't the last Administration effectively Autopen? Yes, the President receives recommendations and tries to make the best judgement on those.

What would Biden's answer be for pardoning Fauci?

annexrichmond··on Trump pardons convicted Binance founder
It feels like HN is slowly turning into reddit with the comment section becoming mostly snide remarks

Instead of just commenting about being dismayed with the state of things, how about step back and speculate as to why he did this pardon, and what the implications of it are.

I don't know the answer to either, but I surely didn't learn much from what used to be an insightful, intelligent crowd

annexrichmond··on New York Times, AP, Newsmax and others say they won't sign new Pentagon rules
This includes full Israeli withdrawal to a buffer zone, Rafah crossing reopening, and Hamas giving up weapons and control of Gaza, with US/Arab-funded rebuilding.

If you don't understand the difference between now, and those events, then I can't help you.

annexrichmond··on New York Times, AP, Newsmax and others say they won't sign new Pentagon rules
I didn't say it directly ended, I said it was aided by.

> "I think it really started when we took out the nuclear capability of Iran," Trump said, referring to the June strikes on Iran’s nuclear sites. "When you look at what they had, you couldn't have made this deal with someone sitting over there with a nuclear weapon over your head." [1]

[1] https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trump-credits-iran-nuclear-...

annexrichmond··on Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified persons', no warrant
The G&M is a left-wing propaganda paper. What's your point?
annexrichmond··on An open letter calling for a hard fork of Rails to remove DHH's influence
How is it racist? Native Brits are anyone who was born there. This is more about culture than race.
annexrichmond··on Are touchscreens in cars dangerous?
I find using CarPlay more dangerous than my phone. At least with my phone I’m using a familiar interface and I can use at any angle. With CarPlay my panel is awkwardly positioned, the UI is confusing, and I have to pay far more attention to what I’m doing.

I’m not suggesting at all it’s ok to use your phone while driving, and is unlawful for a good reason. Yet CarPlay, a dumbed down phone bolted to your dash, is totally fine, despite being no more safe IMO

annexrichmond··on Beyond Meat headed to Chapter 11 bankruptcy
Not everyone likes Indian food. I think most people like familiar flavors. Western people didn't grow up eating veggie-based food so I don't know why this is surprising. People just want to eat familiar things.
annexrichmond··on ICE Deports 3 U.S. Citizen Children Held Incommunicado Prior to the Deportation
Strawman. You're talking about wages and jobs in aggregate which wasn't my argument at all. Nothing you said addresses how my salary is affected in the industry the person is joining.

Sure, in total, other jobs may be created and growth is increased -- it's essentially a tautology.

annexrichmond··on ICE Deports 3 U.S. Citizen Children Held Incommunicado Prior to the Deportation
You are really twisting things to make your argument sound plausible in the general case. More supply means less wages. Why focus on low paying jobs? Are you seriously suggesting that if we import every software engineer from India that wants to come here that my salary will increase? If so, that's very interesting why tech CEOs are lobbying so hard for this.
annexrichmond··on Kagi – Introducing Fair Pricing
yeah that's interesting. $5 for 35/day could be better as well
annexrichmond··on Fair Pricing
Kagi is awesome, but the thought of having a limit led me to use it less and less and I eventually unsubscribed.
annexrichmond··on One of Florida's most lethal python hunters
Hey it’s not my fault my company chose Python!
annexrichmond··on PEP 760: No more bare excepts
Maybe before enforcing such nonsense, they should standardize function docs like javadocs. How are you supposed to know which errors to "except" if it's not documented anywhere anyway?
annexrichmond··on Apple Watch sleep apnea detection gets FDA approval
The battery life is what got me off. I don't have good charging habits, and nothing was worse than not being able to use your activity tracker for your workout because you forgot to charge it. I got a Garmin and I hardly ever have to think about it now.

Having to plan your day around when to charge your Apple Watch doesn't sound like a good experience to me.

annexrichmond··on Why are Texas interchanges so tall?
I see this "induced demand" critique a lot, and I am curious - if it's wrong, how is it different than adding housing to a region to make it cheaper?
annexrichmond··on New Apache Airflow Operators for Google Generative AI
We only use KubernetesOperators, but this has many downsides, and it's very clearly a 2nd thought of the Airflow project. It creates confusion because users of Airflow expect features A, B, and C, and when using KubernetesOperators they aren't functional because your biz logic is separated. Eg., if your biz logic knows what S3 it talks to in an external task, how can Airflow? So now its Dataset feature is useless.

There are a number of blog posts echoing a similar critique[1].

Using KubernetesOperators creates a lot of wrong abstractions, impedes testability, and makes Airflow as a whole a pretty overkill system just to monitor external tasks. At that point, you should have just had your orchestration in client code to begin with, and many other frameworks made this correct division between client and server. That would also make it easier to support multiple languages.

According to their README: https://github.com/apache/airflow#approach-to-dependencies-o...

> Airflow has a lot of dependencies - direct and transitive > The important dependencies are: SQLAlchemy, Alembic, Flask, werkzeug, celery, kubernetes

Why should biz logic that just needs to run Spark and interact with S3 now need to run a web server?

[1] Anecdotes from various posts - https://medium.com/bluecore-engineering/were-all-using-airfl... - https://eng.lyft.com/orchestrating-data-pipelines-at-lyft-co... - https://dagster.io/blog/dagster-airflow

> Airflow, in its design, made the incorrect abstraction by having Operators actually implement functional work instead of spinning up developer work.

> By simply moving to using a Kubernetes Operator, Airflow developers can develop more quickly, debug more confidently, and not worry about conflicting package requirements.

> Airflow lacks proper library isolation. It becomes hard or impossible to do if any team requires a specific library version for a given workflow

> There is no way to separate DAGs to development, staging, and production using out-of-the-box Airflow features. That makes Airflow harder to use for mission-critical applications that require proper testing and the ability to roll back

> Data pipelines written for Airflow are typically bound to a particular environment. To avoid dependency hell, most guides recommend defining Airflow tasks with operators like the KubernetesPodOperator, which dictates that the task gets executed in Kubernetes. When a DAG is written in this way, it’s nigh-impossible to run it locally or as part of CI. And it requires opting out of all of the integrations that come out-of-the-box with Airflow.

annexrichmond··on New Apache Airflow Operators for Google Generative AI
Airflow owning the scheduling, retry, task branching/dependencies is fine. But a few issues: to take advantage of Airflow's core features (XCOMs, task mapping, etc) your biz logic/tasks must be in the same venv, which is not sustainable as teams grow. Once you have external tasks, you now have a more complex system to operate and test, and your Airflow installation is now very overkill (you need a pool of workers just to monitor external... workers?).
annexrichmond··on New Apache Airflow Operators for Google Generative AI
Yes, but that means you are forced to build EDA on top of Airflow, which may not be ideal for many cases. You are stuck managing your pools/workers within Airflow's paradigm, which means all workload must (a) be written in Python and (b) have Airflow installed on the venv (very heavy pkg) and (c) be k8s pod or Celery (unless you write your own).
annexrichmond··on New Apache Airflow Operators for Google Generative AI
I'm well aware that's "possible", but if you have to build your own abstractions and CI/CD to make it usable this way, it doesn't seem very well designed.
annexrichmond··on New Apache Airflow Operators for Google Generative AI
That might be fine for small teams, but any 100+ person company would already have their own abstractions and don't need to reinvent those wheels just for Airflow. But even if you're smaller I still think you're setting up for failure if all your biz logic is within Airflow unless you are careful about making it reusable/shareable for other contexts. Eg, what if you want to convert some scheduled pipeline to some event-driven architecture with other systems? That means needing to refactor everything out. It's not interoperable or modular and that's why it should be avoided.
annexrichmond··on New Apache Airflow Operators for Google Generative AI
I've done a lot evaluation of such frameworks, and I hope to publish more on it. It really depends on your requirements. I would look at Prefect, Flyte, Dagster, and Temporal ahead of Airflow, though.
← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →