sj is nowhere near on-par with sf, but it's not dead. changes are coming, but that takes time. i live in the downtown area and enjoy one of the safest environment in a big city. last time i was in the city, a walk in broad daylight through some parts was scary.
it's a way to let a certain set of people express themselves, a translation of a social process to the internet. while some of us have outgrown it, we haven't forgotten what it was like for us: phones, chat rooms, geocities.
i'm a firm believer that the web browser in its current incarnation isn't suitable for mobile. trying to consume desktop content on mobile screens is like drinking one tiny sip at a time: great in a pinch, but tiresome otherwise.