HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anon84873628

2,542 karma · joined July 1, 2022

submissionscomments
anon84873628··on We must pace the frontier
I've followed it enough to see the argument go in this same circle over and over again. The agents weren't "rogue", they were a neglected experiment by OpenAI who likewise allowed them to keep spinning GPUs without question.

The LLM vendors need to know who their high spend customers are, not allow malicious workloads, and especially not when those workloads are coming from inside the building.

anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
Considering how to deal with people brandishing weapons in a Waymo is not just imagining a scenario, since it has already actually happened.

I also grew up in the 90s and did things like throw eggs out of cars. We wouldn't have done it from a taxi or Uber. Your comment really makes no sense.

anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
So don't use it? You seem to want the benefits of the service but without having to comport your behavior accordingly.

Other countries already have highway cameras track speed and automatically issue citations. I am happy for Americans to petition their government against implementing that, but I won't pretend it's anything other than a desire to break the law for personal gratification.

anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
Fortunately the Fourth Amendment has mostly established the answer for us already.
anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
I meant to imply that it's ridiculous because no one is trying to make that happen...
anon84873628··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
>serious companies will be unable to stop it.

Unable or unwilling? All they have to do is stop serving the LLM requests.

Or maybe the issue is that these companies are not "serious"...

anon84873628··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
12 hours later and no replies besides this one...
anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
That's the same as the police getting security footage from any random building.

The problem with Flock is that they let police hop on and look at whatever they want whenever they want. Completely different operating modes and intentions.

Also, Google and Waymo are different companies under the same parent. Google's policies are irrelevant.

anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
Teen accounts are supposed to be governed by the parent account.

I understand the appeal. Parents I've spoken to feel safer putting their kid in a Waymo than and Uber. And I guess the time savings of not driving them around yourself are too compelling.

anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
I understand Waymo having this position for now. I also think it is reasonable to push them to refine the rules for the situations you mention.
anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
The number of people expecting drivers to calmly & accurately distinguish between real threats and not is wild.
anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
You can raise that argument when they actually prevent you from owning your own vehicle.
anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
Good thing Waymo yells you you're being monitored then.
anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
>its solution is worse than non-autonomous travel

Citation needed. Assaults and abuse against public transit and taxi drivers is a common workplace hazard. Why are we subjecting humans to that? Why are we ok expecting them to decide if a gun is fake or not and call the police?

>Does Waymo benefit society enough to carry the tradeoffs?

Absolutely.

anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
So? In the real scenario, the underage passengers were drinking alcohol. Also, the 14-17 teen accounts are supposed to be monitored by parents, otherwise all riders need to be adults or their guests. That means they need to exercise judgment not brandishing what might look like weapons. The same way you need to exercise that judgment in a public park.

And I'm not even convinced that human drivers would be more discerning or rational about it. They could easily overstate the issue to police and create a more biased situation.

anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
Are you aware of BART Police or MTA Police? All trains have conductors who monitor passenger behavior and enforce rules/laws.
anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
Well for one, so far they've only called the police on people who chose to use the service.

When we have evidence that Waymo is contracting its external cameras out to local governments and allowing abuse, then we can criticize them for it.

anon84873628··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
Would you do any of those things in a regular taxi or subway car?

Imagine the alternative headline saying the murderers used Waymo for their drive-by assassination. There is only one option for Waymo here, and the idiocy of the US police is not within their power to solve.

anon84873628··on We must pace the frontier
Well a big reason that we criticize OpenAI for that is because they were the ones giving it access to the massive compute necessary for the LLMs to think. If they had been responsible about their experiments or what types of workloads they allow their LLMs to operate, it wouldn't have happened. Very few companies could enable those workloads.
anon84873628··on We must pace the frontier
Yeah, I don't get it. Are they imagining this happening just with the open weights models running on however many GPUs the bad actors can cobble together?

For now, all the scary hacking things still require an API key to one of the LLM providers. Surely they should take some responsibility for how to turn off the tap.

anon84873628··on Growing proof that autonomous cars save lives
Which autonomous vehicle company has that as their motto?
anon84873628··on How I advertise malicious software on Google Ads
A true full-time Google employee is like three layers of outsourcing removed from touching these operations. The people doing the work have been given zero latitude to actually help someone.

And then the design and implementation of the process itself is split across access silos mediated by lawyers and program managers. It's deliberately physically impossible for a motivated employee to improve the system for users.

anon84873628··on The Education of a Doomer
We're assuming the oligarchs control the government so they can be rich and powerful and use that to lead lavish lives. Well with these hypothetical AGI imbued robots, they could just construct lavish lives directly.

Not much different from the feudal era. You still need access to good lands (energy production, minerals) but an army of computers and robots instead of serfs and knights. Like Asimov's world of Solaria.

anon84873628··on The Education of a Doomer
At the risk of being incredibly banal, the current US government shows you absolutely can consolidate enough of such psychos.

Game theory is a helluva thing.

anon84873628··on The Education of a Doomer
And even then, reaching "I, Robot" levels is unrealistic. Machines are fragile. It would take a very long time to bootstrap the entire automated robot construction and maintenance supply chain, which would also require energy production and resource collection too.

Until then it is vulnerable to disruption. So of course you will need the robot army to forcibly take and defend resources around the world. How will that war turn out?

Robot labor will be more valuable than humans for a very long time. Heck, we still have many towns in the US that have humans running around throwing trash bags into the back of the truck, because they haven't switched to the standardized containers and hydrologic arms. Let's not even get started on the rest of the "developing" world.

anon84873628··on What is Nueralese and Why is it Bad
Scott Alexander article from 2022, "ELK And The Problem Of Truthful AI"

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/elk-and-the-problem-of-trut...

It discusses "Eliciting Latent Knowledge" which is "a technical report / contest / paradigm run by the Alignment Research Center". The research investigated whether it would be theoretically possible to build a "trustworthy" AI to interpret the thoughts of another AI.

anon84873628··on What is Nueralese and Why is it Bad
Turtles all the way down:

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/elk-and-the-problem-of-trut...

anon84873628··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
Wow, you must be one very unique and special person if you converse the way you write. By definition, a carefully written and edited piece will be much more refined and cogent than an extemporaneous conversation.

Just watch an interview with a famous author. Or compare a legal brief to what court actually sounds like.

anon84873628··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
I suspect the commenter prefers the concise, factual summary of an LLM.

It is true that modern journalism on the web is trying to get ad impressions. After all, this is how we ended up with clickbait. Sure you still have the Economist and Atlantic (which aren't beyond criticism), but your local county paper is an absolute mess. The content is stretched, meandering, and designed to keep you scrolling through more impressions.

anon84873628··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
I would almost never transmit LLM output without a decent amount of editing. But I also don't understand people who paint it as this horrible offensive unreadable slop.

Calling it better than most journalists is extreme (and probably the reason for down votes), but it must certainly be better than the average person.

We're hearing this criticism from the highly educated professional class people who bother to have their own blog or otherwise spend their time talking about technology online. I mean come on.

To most people, the LLM must feel incredibly empowering, like us wearing a mecha suit. Would we always show restraint and only apply our newfound enhanced physical strength in carefully considered situations?

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →