HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anoncowherd

153 karma · joined August 9, 2013

submissionscomments
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
>> I don't think they understand that without individual freedoms reigning supreme, we'll have monopolies, lack of innovation, taxes, etc.

Agreed.

>> Oh, and don't forget tracking/passport/entry visas because of taxes

Yep, it's about taxes in the sense that Tax Farms want to retain their cattle, so they make it difficult for the cattle to leave, while still maintaining an illusion of freedom. Even a complete sheep would realize he's a slave if he weren't free to leave "his" country.

>> Oh and don't forget mandatory "collective" (but NOT state) schooling.

Mandatory collective schooling, but imposed on everyone by something else than the state? .. That doesn't sound right either. Anything that is based on aggressing against people is immoral.

>> Taxes = Theft

I'm fine with "robbery", "rape", and "theft" and so on. But extortion is more accurate.

>> Government = the Monopoly on Violence

Yes, and thoroughly immoral.

>> Capitalism (which is separate from the free market) = Wage Slavery and too much power

This is where we disagree, it seems. You seem to be referring to Crony-Capitalism, or "Crapitalism". Corporations buy State power and using it to their own benefit, and of course, that will continue for as long as there is power to be bought. If there's nothing to bribe, then you can't bribe.

But in reality, Capitalism is just what people do in their pursuit of personal gain: voluntary exchanges, contracts, agreements, and investments, etc. All backed by respect for property rights, of course. Without property rights, there would be just about no wealth in the world, because no one could expect to benefit from any value they might produce.

The absence of coercion ~ a free market ~ freedom ~ Capitalism. They all go hand in hand.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6920011 for some clarification. In case it helps, consider the following two ways of thinking about land as property.

1) Any land covered by something valuable that you "produced" yourself is your property. A house, a corn field, a copper mine, etc. But land in a state of nature is not. For example, 10 acres of forest in a state of nature would not be your property, because you haven't "mixed your labour" with it.

2) Even that 10 acres of forest can be your property, and you get to control (access to) it, because you need to know that you will get to benefit from any value you produce with that forest, even if it takes some time to get started, let alone "materialize" that value. Maybe you're planning to build an amusement park, but need to figure stuff out first, and make sure you'll have everything you need before starting the project. Maybe that will turn sour, and then you'll switch to some other goal with the forest. But if you don't have the right to control (access to) the forest before you do something with it, then you just won't do anything with it because you have no guarantee of getting to benefit from the value you produce. The latter case would be a loss to other people too, because something they'd benefit from (even if in exchange for a fee) would not come to be.

I think both 1 and 2 make sense.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
What's wrong with property as a means of production? Look, I'm not saying that stolen property is legitimate, even in the case of land. But that's a tricky issue, and perhaps some kind of "reset" is required (and arranged) in the future.

But if you acquire property legitimately, then there's no problem with it, even if it's not constantly in your possession, or occupied by you personally. Anything else would just not make sense. For example, if you park your car somewhere and go shopping, will the car cease to be your property just because you're not in it?

On a fundamental level, property can be thought of as "value you want to control". Something has value, and you get to benefit from it, because you've either produced the value yourself, or you've acquired it through a voluntary exchange (or contract etc). You build a house, the house has value as a dwelling, and you want to benefit from the house by either living in it or selling it to someone else.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
>> You're not actually giving an intellectual argument, for the most part. You're just... "erm"... asserting the opposite of what I said in a hand-wavy manner.

OK, here's what you said earlier: >>> I think the government should use retaliatory force, never initiatory force.

But government is based on the initiation of force in taxation. Without taxes, there is no government, and without the threat of violence inflicted on you for attempting to keep your property, there is no taxation. That is immoral, plain and simple. It's extortion.

>>> Preventing alternate defense agencies (the anarcho-capitalist idea) and levying taxes for the proper functions of government (police, courts, and military) actually are retaliatory exercises of force, not initiated force.

Who are they "retaliating" against? If A initiates against B, is B then allowed to "retaliate" against C?

>>> The threat of initiated force is tantamount to initiated force. So, retaliatory force to stop a threat is legitimate.

We agree on the first part, but who exactly is government retaliating against when taxing people? Remember, an individual is free to live all his life without aggressing against anyone, but if he doesn't give up his money to the government, then the government will aggress against him. Where's the retaliation in that? -Nowhere, that's where. It's simply clearly the initiation of force against an individual, even if he's never hurt anyone ever.

>> You cannot justify the claim that taxation is immoral

I already did, see above.

>> Yes, it is a rational idea. In a state of nature, everyone is a threat to everyone.

My point was that you can't both be sane, and "retaliate" against people who have not initiated against you. The possibility that someone, somewhere might want to violate your rights, does not make your force a retaliation if you're just aggressing against somone who's never done anything to you.

If A never actually initiates against anyone (regardless of any perceived/imagined willingness to do so), can B then "retaliate" against C? -That's roughly the idea you presented before.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
It's everyone's own personal choice what they want to learn, if anything. Everyone's responsible for their choices, and marketable skills can be acquired through experience and practice, even without any particular schooling.
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
Rights are an idea.
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
Private schools, that teach exactly what the market wants them to teach. This would not include Patriotic indoctrination though, for example.

Besides, how many percent of everything you're taught at school do you actually find interesting? -We all learn what we want to learn, and that's about it. In a free society, people would just get exactly the kind of education they actually want.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
>> No, property is defined by force.

Or, it's defined by property rights? But hey, why not make things more complicated than they actually need to be?

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
>> Well, the simple fact is, empirical studies of minimum wages just don't show their having a macroeconomic effect on employment that overwhelms other effects

You don't get it. There's no need for "empirical studies", because it's a simple matter of reasoning.

Suppose Person A is fresh out of high school or something, and Company B might be interested in hiring him as some kind of entry level worker. Person A has basically no experience in anything, so he's worth very little to the employer. He really wants a job though, because he needs to start some kind of career to get by in life.

Suppose Company B consider's Person A's meager productivity worth $6 per hour, but the minimum wage is set to $10 per hour. Will Person A get the job?

Well, no. The minimum wage prevents Person A from getting a job, and thus, getting experience and advancing his skills and future salary potential. Everyone loses. Person A has no job and no further experience, and Company B has no employee and a task left undone.

If you still don't get it, imagine the minimum wage being set at $1000 per hour. If it's all good, then the higher you set it, the MOAR good will come out of it, right?

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
Hm. Yeah, I guess that's a good point. The idea of property can be thought of as "obligations between people", but it's not the same as the idea of the social contract. For starters, it's between individual people, not some collective entity and a given individual, and second, it involves no force as long as no one aggresses against anyone.

Another difference is that the "system of property" actually works to everyone's favour - quite the opposite of "the social contract", and imposes no other obligations on you than to not aggress against anyone else's property. If "aggress" sounds out of place, let's say "interfere with someone's (exclusive) control of their property". There's lots of room for pointless bickering in moral issues, etc.

There are various sensible ways to view the concept of property. One is Murray Rothbard's idea of something becoming your property by "mixing your labour" with it. For example, if you build a house, or plow a corn field, they're your property.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
>> I think the government should use retaliatory force, never initiatory force

Therein lies the problem. Governments are based on initiatory force - extortion, to be accurate. We all pay taxes because we know we'll be forcibly hauled to jail if we don't, and our property will be seized from us. Taxation itself is immoral, and since all governments are based on taxation, all governments are immoral.

>> The fundamental cause is the natural threat of those that would violate rights

So I guess I'm allowed to initiate erm.. retaliatory force against you, because you might want to violate my rights, or.. how does this work? :P

There is no threat before someone threatens you. Otherwise everyone is a threat all the time, and that's just not a rational idea, is it? You're aware that taxation is based on (initiatory) force, and thus immoral. But you rationalize it with that neat little trick that actually falls on its face right away, upon closer inspection.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
That may be, but people are not property. Or, well.. should not be.
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
A "decentralized collective society" seems contradictory. I can't tell what you mean.
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
So you disregard my examples, declare that I need to "prove" things, and then proceed to tell me that you don't. Have a good day, Sir.
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
Property can only be defended (by force) after someone tries to take it from you. The aggressor is immoral.
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
>> The countervailing argument to "voluntary exchange" is that many trades are highly unequal

If an exchange is genuinely voluntary, it leaves both parties better off by definition. You value whatever you're giving up lower than what you're getting in exchange, because otherwise you just wouldn't go through the trade.

>> On top of that, trades that involve large quantities of capital must still rely upon law and violence to guard ownership, and therefore at least somewhat subject to public jurisdiction

Everyone naturally has the right to defend his property, through whatever means necessary. Not only that, but we all intuitively agree on what property is. An apple in your hand is automatically assumed to be your property, and so is the apartment you live in, or the factory everyone has always known you to own and run. If you see a car on the street, you don't assume it's no one's property even if there's no one in it.

>> For better or worse, we should take responsibility for the relationship between private capital and the social contract, even if it is for the purpose of maintaining private ownership.

I can't tell what that's supposed to mean. But again, your property is your property, and you have the right to defend it regardless of whether a State exists.

>> capitalism is the worst system, except for all the others

Capitalism is not a "system". It's not something that's imposed on anyone, but instead, it's just all the things people do in their pursuit of personal gain - exchanges, commerce, investments, and contracts etc. If you see problems with "Capitalism", they're actually problems with Crony-Capitalism, and caused by the State. Those evil corporations buy political power, and then use it to prevent competition, to rape nature, pass their losses on to us, and so on. All the nasty stuff.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
What does?
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
Feel free to refute my minimum wage example for starters. Here's another:

  1) you want to help the poor
  2) you confiscate wealth from other people, and give it to the poor
  3) you have just removed money from the economy 
     and caused it to get used much less efficiently 
     than it would have, and demotivated lots of people 
     from doing business and producing value 
     to the world at large.
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
No matter how much we want everyone to live, we can't try and ensure it through coercion. Besides, coercion only works for evil. You can't achieve good through coercion. Whenever you try, it has the opposite effect.

Take minimum wage for example. You want poor people to get higher salaries, but in reality, all you accomplish by raising the min. wage is preventing some lowest-skilled people from getting a job (which contributes to economic stagnation too, ofc).

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
You're overlooking a couple of important things here:

    1) Public education is shit anyway, 
       and mostly just meant to 
       indoctrinate us into the Cult of Statism.
    2) Private schools would do a vastly better job, 
       for a small fraction of the price.
I'm sure you agree on public schools being bad quality, to put it mildly. You might not agree on the indoctrination aspect, but hey, if we want to change things for the better, we can always write to our representatives and of course, vote! Vote the bums out! All hail The Land Of The Free!

As for private schools doing a better job, you probably know how competition works. You get better stuff for lower prices.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
>> How do we convince individualists that some services need to be established by the collective itself and not an offshoot (syndicate/business)?

We don't, because you're talking about imposing some "services" on other people, which always happens through coercion. We should both be aware that coercion is bad, mm'kay?

"But who will build the roads?!" is like asking an anti-slavery activist "but who will pick the cotton?!" - the correct answer is: "who fucking cares? Slavery is immoral and needs to stop."

Punishing people for attempting to keep their property (ie. taxation) is immoral too. It's plain to see, for everyone who allows himself to.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
Feel free to argue against the points presented in the video.

Capitalism is such a messed-up term these days. To me it means free, voluntary exchanges and agreements/contracts between people, but most people have been propagandized to view it as "evil capitalist pigs exploiting and oppressing the poor".

But capitalism cannot be replaced, it's what people do when they're allowed to, after all. It's about people pursuing their personal gain through commerce and investments etc, and you know self-interest is not going anywhere, regardless of what societal system happens to be in place.

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
>> There's a large body of literature that attempts to justify centralization of power

Of course there is. We've lived under centralized power for hundreds or thousands of years, after all. Why would The Powers That Be suddenly cease wanting to Be?

But centralized power cannot be justified, it can only be rationalized. If you think about the idea of the social contract for a moment, you should realize that it's not a contract at all, but merely a shackle for our minds, to keep us from finding a way out of the maze of our brainwashing.

For starters, you were never even asked, you never had a chance not to participate, and you can't just opt out of the system either. You're either inside a country, or you're freezing to death in Antarctica. It's not much of a choice, but a voluntary choice is necessary for any contract to be binding.

Read this: http://spot.colorado.edu/~huemer/book3.htm

anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
Meet Noam Chomsky - Academic Gatekeeper: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EEDf7OkRCxk&list=PLN6xa7kD9dZ...
anoncowherd··on Noam Chomsky – "On Anarchism" [video]
Your profile looks like you're an objectivist. But as others pointed out, you can't just dismiss anarchism off-hand.

As an objectivist, you're against coercion, but in favour of centralized power? Is that correct? If so, don't you think it's a contradictory idea?

anoncowherd··on Why Are Americans Staying Put?
I thought it might be about getting the fuck out of the US while the getting is good, but then I saw the domain.. :p
anoncowherd··on The NSA: An Inside View
The surveillance's purpose is not to catch criminals or terrorists, as evidenced by the recent confiscation of some NZ citizen's electronics at the airport. He had attended a meeting on mass surveillance, and is therefore considered a troublesome, unharmonious little peasant, and must be kept in check or made an example of. That is the point here. It's about power, and maintaining it through whatever means possible.

The US is showing clear and abundant signs of being a police state - there's simply no denying that anymore. So what does it matter what their rule books say about spying on people, when even the Constitution has been calmly disregarded for years?

"Here are the official guidelines for spying on people! Remember that spying on US citizens is restricted because that would be kind of naughty, but foreigners are fair game."

It's just ridiculous. But again, it's certainly not about catching terrorists. This level of surveillance would make Stalin just shit himself with joy.

anoncowherd··on Tell HN: How we bootstrapped to the #1 rated mattress on Amazon.com
>> all foam mattresses deform to some degree

So do spring mattresses, by the way, and aren't they the most common type?

anoncowherd··on Backpacker stripped of tech gear at Auckland Airport
>> I always wonder what they're actually looking for

Potential political prisoners - what else? They're only ever interested in anything that could constitute a threat to their power, however mild. It's also about conditioning us into apathy / obedience / accepting serfdom.

The original article mentioned the guy had been to a conference on surveillance, right? They know he's an unharmonious little tax slave, a potential troublemaker! That's why his devices were confiscated, not any suspicion of "terrorism" or whatever.

anoncowherd··on Backpacker stripped of tech gear at Auckland Airport
>> What can I even do if they take my electronics?

"Write to your representatives!!" .. nah, I'm kidding. You can't do shit about it. We live in an increasingly totalitarian world, as the article shows. It's fucking insane.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →