HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anonyfox

2,005 karma · joined August 7, 2013

https://anonyfox.com
submissionscomments
anonyfox··on How close is AI to human-level intelligence?
There is zero reasoning in it so far, everything up to today is perfectly explainable with advanced statistics and NLP. Its large _language_ models after all, no matter the hype.

Still I find it excellent when exploring new knowledge domains or cross-comparing cross knowledge domains, since LLMs by design (and training corpus) will spill out highly probable terms/concepts matching my questions and phrase it nicely. Search on steroids when you will, where also real-time doesn't matter for me at all.

This is not intelligence, yet hugely valuable if used right. And I am sure because of this, a lot of scientific discoveries will be made with todays LLMs used in creative ways, since most of scientific discoveries is ultimately looking at X within a setting at Y, and there are a lot of potential X and Y combinations.

I am exaggerating a bit, but at some point (niels bohr?) had the thought of thinking about atoms like we do about planets, with stuff circling each other. Its an X but in Y situation. First come up with such a scenario (or: an automated way to combine lots of X and Y cleverly) and then filter the results for something that actually would make sense, and then dig deeper in a semi-automatic way with actual human in the loop at least.

anonyfox··on Rails is better low code than low code
I don't know. I recently am drawn more and more in pure Go code, which is conceptually as simple as it gets, yet I can achieve basically everything imaginable in it without hitting walls/limitations. Add some (embedded) SQLite for small/quick/cheap things or postgres for when it gets more involved or critical (horizontal scaling, backups, ...), and everything is quickly possible. Now with LLMs, its outright trivial to make them generate functionality at will immediately, and (pure) Go is exceptionally friendly with LLM codegen, due to the language being stupid simple and the stdlib being "complete" for years.

Essentially I prefer staying at the "you need to be a coder" abstraction level, but the general tooling nowadays makes becoming one very easy. Once you mentally lift the requirement that something needs to be configurable by some non-technical end user or even needs an UI at all, 90%+ of all dev effort can be saved directly. Plus there are no showstoppers in capabilities or usual barriers like too bad performance/config hell of "no code"/"low code" I encountered quite often. And if you don't use the latest webdev fads, things can be maintainable for decades (looking at Go compared to NodeJS).

Rawdogging basic programming (yes, also no framework if possible) made more "business" projects first succeed (and then stay alive easily) much more than either a web framework or any kind of lo-/no-tool, at least the things I encountered in the wild. Even bad spaghetticode monstrosities can now uploaded to an LLM and refactored into sanity quite efficiently.

The worst kind of projects (with lots of pain and regret) have been either JS-based, mis-used framework projects (including rails!) or Salesforce setups. Often you're stuck in a dead-end here.

anonyfox··on Maybe Bluesky has "won"
Not to disagree with your post, but I'd *love* to support a renaissance of RSS. It was/is essentially peak distribution of content in a proper decentralized manner, putting users first and letting providers use whatever they want freely to generate it. No walled gardens. No restrictions.
anonyfox··on Algorithms We Develop Software By
A thing that took me several years to agree to is that almost everything can be coded within 24 hours if really needed - gun to the head situation. Will it be perfect/efficient/beautiful/... probably not. But it should roughly work like its supposed to.

If something cannot be coded within that 24 hours, something else is odd, not the feature. Transitioning from SWE to DevOps and then Leadership roles, most of my day actually is spent with all the reasons/excuses why "it cannot be done", and try to eliminate them. Probably my developers hate me for it, but I always push hard for an immediate first solution instead of doing days of soul-searching first, but over time we encounter and solve enough roadblocks (technical, social, educational, ...) that it actually happens more often than not to have surprisingly fast (and good enough) solutions. That speed is a quality in itself, since it frees up time to come back to things and clean up messes without the shipping pressure mounting up over days/weeks - something working is already there on day two.

The trick is of course to _not_ sell this 24 hour solution to upper management ever, or else it will become a hell of a mess fast once this becomes the outsider expectation.

anonyfox··on Ease of maintenance is a feature
Nowadays i come to my conclusion that "ease of maintenance" is the most important feature to have in a project. More critical is only that the project in itself is valuable enough, so many engineers optimize things that shouldn't exist in the first place.

Easy to maintain is not only about keeping something alive with minimal effort over longer periods of time. It also plays a pivotal role for scalability in any direction. Adding more engineers/teams, adding more unforseeable features, iterating quickly in general, surviving more traffic/load, removing technical bottlenecks, ... everything is so much easier when the project is easy to work with and maintainable.

anonyfox··on How I write code using Cursor
Personal observation from a heavy LLM codegen user:

The sweet spot seems to be bootstrapping something new from scratch and get all the boilerplate done in seconds. This is probably also where the hype comes from, feels like magic.

But the issue is, that once it gets slightly more complicated, thinks break apart and run into a dead end quickly. For example yesterday I wanted to build a simple CLI tool in Go (which is outstandingly friendly to LLM codegen as a language + stdlib) that acts as a simnple reverse proxy and (re-)starts the original thing in the background on file changes.

AI was able to knock out _something_ immediately that indeed compiled, only it didn't actually work like intended. After lots of iterations back-and-forth (Claude mostly) the code balooned in size to figure out what could be the issue, adding all kinds of useless crap that kindof-looks-helpful-but-isn't. After an hour I gave up and went through the whole code manually (few hundred lines, single file) and spotted the issue immediately (holding a mutex lock that gets released with `defer` doesn't play well with a recursive function call). After pointing that out, the LLM was able to fix it and produced a version that finally worked - still with tons of crap and useless complexity everywhere. And thats a simple straightforward coding task that can be accomplished in a single file and only few hundred lines, greenfield style. And all my claude chat tokens of the day got burned for this, only for me at the end having to dig in myself.

LLMs are great to produce things in small limited scopes (especially boilerplate-y stuff) or refactor something that already exists, when it has enough context and essentially doesn't really think about a problem but merely changes linguistic details (rewrites text to a different format ultimately) - its a large LANGUAGE model after all.

But full blown autonomous app building? Only if you do something that has been done exactly thousands of times before and is simple to begin with. There is lots of business value in that, though. Most programmers at companies don't do rocket science or novel things at all. It won't build any actual novelty - ideal case would be building an X for Y (like Uber For Catsitting) only but never an initial X.

Personal productivity of mine went through the roof since GPT4/Cursor though, but I guess I know how/when to use it properly. And developer demand will surge when the wave of LLM-coded startups get their funding and realize the codebase cannot be extended anymore with LLMs due to complexity and the raw amount of garbage in there.

anonyfox··on 1 in 6 Companies Are Hesitant to Hire Recent College Graduates
The most important signal of a degree is a written proof that a person somehow managed to show up to something for a longer timespan without being physically forced to constantly. Basically a minimum baseline of reliability and self-organization.

The reality is _a lot_ of applicants without any proof like that don't last long and thus wasting lots of company resources (including rehiring). Of course there are many very great folks without a degree and also a lot of idiots with a degree, but I learned to trust that heuristic until a strong signal otherwise pops up.

anonyfox··on The quiet art of attention
the concept of freedom itself kind of is hard even in a stricter context like politics.

like, I cannot freely choose to do X today, because (iE: capitalism environment) demands me to do certain other things that bring in money to live comfortably. I could make a tradeoff somewhere, but that very tradeoff itself limits actual freedom.

therefore to maximize actual freedom, we're looking at eliminating constraints that limit freedom, like the need to make money somehow, which would be a dramatic society change not everyone agrees to.

its hard. and wonky. so everyone uses it only through a personal belief lense.

anonyfox··on Nobel Prize in Physics awarded to John Hopfield and Geoffrey Hinton [pdf]
Currently I'd flat out refuse to give any sort of prize to musk, that could be a tipping point for his mental "stability" completely breaking down. The last few years really had a toll on him. Fallen from idol to conspiracy rightwing idiot crashing his companies more and more.
anonyfox··on Silicon Valley, the new lobbying monster
I think money is simply like mass: it has some kind of gravitational force, so people are drawn to it (the more money the stronger the pull), and it attracts itself (money tends to accumulate like a black hole), if left unchecked.

The only way to interfere with it is by using other unrelated forces, like kindness, just like we can move masses around with electromagnetism.

anonyfox··on OpenAI is closing in on raising $6.5B. Largest VC raise in history
I jump between ChatGPT, Claude 3.5 and Grok2 on a regular basis, and I'd say its not "worse" in the general sense. I find it much better on anything sentiment-analysis related or for shortcutting customer research, and image generation is really good.
anonyfox··on I Am Tired of AI
You should really have a look at Marx. He literally predicted what will happen when we reach the state of "let machines do all work", and also how this is exactly the way that finally implodes capitalism as a concept. The major problem is he believed the industrial revolution will automate everything to such an extend, which it didn't, but here we are with a reasonable chance that AI will do the trick finally.
anonyfox··on Crows are even smarter than we thought
Biological Jackpot advantages, or: sheer luck.

1. we do not live underwater, so lots of tools and stuff possible (iE: fire).

2. we have usable hands with thumbs. This allows much better tooling. Ravens only have their beak and are comparatively handicapped in technical developments.

3. we do not die during/after reproduction. This allows for accumulation of knowledge instead of every generation starting to learn from scratch. That’s octopus handicap.

4. we have reasonably enough raw strength and compensate weaknesses with social groups and tools/weapons to eliminate basically all competition where we lived. And managed to increase food production for exponential population growth, again some way of tooling ultimately.

… so it for me boils down to the fact that we, among several intelligent species, have been the lucky ones to leverage tooling in the most efficient way.

And especially ravens/crows are absolutely in the ballpark of humans when it comes to intelligence. They have actual language to communicate facts to others, they have social structures/rituals similar to ours, they make tools to accomplish goals, even with multi-step-plans. Heck, they even „use“ other animals like wolves: since they are not capable of opening a fresh deer corpse to get to the meat, they search for the nearest wolf and guide him to the corpse for win-win food sharing… some wolf packs have even been seen essentially protecting raven flocks/eggs, so ravens literally can have kinda dogs.

anonyfox··on Meta cancels high-end mixed reality headset after Apple Vision Pro struggles
It struggles mostly because it’s far too expensive, which also prevents bootstrapping some ecosystem of usecases.
anonyfox··on The surprising cause of fasting's regenerative powers
thats not always the right thing to do. drugs can mess with what you feel/want for example. we meatbags do have really bad sensors at times.
anonyfox··on Artificial intelligence is losing hype
indeed, but prices have been falling dramatically in the last 2 years, and I think the latest smallest gpt4o-mini is already in the "mostly don't care" ballpark.

I am happy if we somehow get this down even more orders of magnitude, to the point where I can `npm install llm` and have it run alongside my normal code on a $5 VPS, without a GPU, and still handling (resonable) requests/minute with it. Yes I know we are _very far_ from that still, but one can dream.

anonyfox··on Artificial intelligence is losing hype
The sweet spot of the current LLMs (not whatever the next gen might or might not improve on) for me is similar to suddenly having an army of idiots at my fingertips.

There are a lot of smallish tasks/problems people/systems needs to deal with, some of them even waste notable real engineering capacity, and a highschooler could do manually quite easily by hand.

Example: find out if a text contains an email address, including all kinds of shenanigans people do to mask it (may not be allowd, ... whatever). From a purely coding standpoint, this is a cats-and-mouse game of improving regex solutions in many cases to also find the more sophisticated patterns, but there will always be uncatched/new ways or simply errors that produce false positives. But a highschooler can be given a text and instantly spot the email address (or confirm none is in there).

In order to "solve" these types of small problems, LLMs are pretty much fantastic. It needs to only be reliable enough to produce a structured answer within a few attempts and cheap enough to not be a concern for finance/operations. Thats why for me it makes absolutely sense that the #1 priority for OpenAI since GPT4 has been building smaller/faster/cheaper models. Automators need exactly that, not genius-level AGI.

Also for me I think we're not even scratching the surface still about many tasks can be automated away within the current constraints/flaws of LLMs (hallucination, accuracy, ...). Everyone tries to hype up some super generic powerful future (that usually falls flat after a while), whereas the true value of LLMs is in the many small things where hardcoding solutions is expensive but an intern could do it right away.

anonyfox··on The Right Kind of Stubborn
> But the obstinates are mostly failing

I believe there is a "trying too hard". Solving a worthwhile problem itself might be difficult enough to begin with, but trying to map out a solution plan and stubbornly make every checkpoint a success along the way statistically leads to failure.

Every single step has a chance of ("perfect") success that is not 100%. The more steps, the lower the overall chance of hitting the original problem/solution with the exact path of steps. And if the original plan contains a dead end one could not foresee, people give up at some point alltogether.

But persistence simply means more like "lets take multiple shots at solving the problem", discovering stuff along the way, pivot the strategy or change direction, but ultimately just trying to solve the problem X times, which over time increases the chance of solving it.

anonyfox··on Gen AI: too much spend, too little benefit?
if you want to achieve some greater good, capitalism is not the ideal model to begin with. it creates a lot of wealth, but needs strong external forces to not only focus on profits or destroy everything in the process.
anonyfox··on To the Bored All Things Are Boring
Thanks for those kind words, much appreciated!

Personally I am like 9 years away from FIRE, so there is some light at the end of the tunnel, but still bitter about the whole system, especially when thinking about the future for my kids.

anonyfox··on To the Bored All Things Are Boring
Definitely, quite a few things, especially related to career. Which then would change subsequent things I did and had to make decisions that might be rational today but still feel wrong.

Basically I played the current game with the hand given to me as good as possible, and quite successful measured by some standards. But most things still feel utterly useless after all, even though well paid. Can fully reasonate with the "bullshit jobs" narrative.

_So many_ people are desperately trying to extract money from a system without providing any substantial value to society beyond a vague narrative, argumented as "if its useless nobody would pay for it!" that doesn't really reflect reality today.

anonyfox··on To the Bored All Things Are Boring
agreed in general! however, thats the crucial point for me.

example: time with kids.

when there are tradeoffs everywhere, and assume I am in the more money/less time spectrum, there are situations where I simply have to kill time with the kids or get them engaged somehow. Its not quality time at all, its mostly a distraction while other duties are piling up on top. I feel guilty, and the kids probably won't have a great time.

This is a vastly different situation when there are no conflicting duties in that moment, and I can freely decide to spent quality time with them, and be creative upfront about what cool endeavor we could tackle together.

The point is that I want to be always in the latter state, without making any sacrifices on amenities/comfort because of that.

Aligning everything perfectly in todays world as-is basically means hitting the lottery jackpot. The high paying jobs are either bullshit/boring or the good ones extremely rare, there are market reasons why they're paid highly in most cases after all. So its either sucking it up or make sacrifices elsewhere.

anonyfox··on To the Bored All Things Are Boring
while I do agree with the reasoning, this _still_ is a matter of justification after the fact for me. Aka: here is the stuff you need to do in order to get to X. Who defines that path/checkpoints? Its mandated by the system we operate within basically. Similar to "just accept things as they are" and try to make the best out of it - which is of course what I am doing right now, I am not an idiot and have to provide for a family.

Still I question the rules/system as a whole.

Speaking very optimistically: we're about to enter a phase of abundance, where "robots do the work" including "robots build more/better robots" can likely happen in the next decades. The very idea of everyone having to work at all in this scenario is outdated, even if it might need a forceful/violent redistribution of wealth (again) to not end up in some weird dystopia.

Basically I'd like to everyone (not just me) to have a default comfort level that is at least my current baseline, without and tradeoffs/sacrifices to be made elsewhere in ones life. And then the decision process should start about what to do with life, and very likely the outcome would be vastly different for many people compared to right now. And I strongly believe quite a lot of people would fill their days with what we now would call "work" or pushing boundaries in various areas - but decidedly so.

Imagine the sheer amount of innovations that could happen if the current top tier talent that works on marketing/ads today would spend their time doing actually useful/cool things instead of hunting the money of their current jobs. Even just a fraction of those people. It might introduce a new Renaissance in society to free up the cogwheels from the rat races!

anonyfox··on To the Bored All Things Are Boring
well the first thing is that having to earn an income is not something that was optional really. Sure you can decide to not do it, but then you have tradeoffs in how comfortable your life situation is. its kind of a free time XOR money situation when you're not born wealthy. free time without money sucks differently than money without free time.

and with making money, some amounts of duties are attached, depending on how you do it. more like a "pick your poison" situation instead of being optional entirely.

also I have sold too many visions to too many people by myself professionally to actually believe the "change the world" bullshit anymore, ever. organizations first and foremost exist to make money, even charities at some point either prioritize it to some extend or they cease to function, and charities also tend to not pay well compared to real industry jobs, so again trade-offs.

you can say "well thats the system" or "thats how capitalism works!" - and then you have it, "the system" forced these duties onto myself.

I personally would prefer an environment not focussed on money, being able to live comfortably and being able to do things that are interesting or truly helpful for others instead. But hey, most people can imagine the literal end of the world easier than the end of capitalism, even though the concept itself isn't that old or "god given" to begin with.

people discussing the "future of work" in the face of rising AI and robotics really should have a look at Marx again how this will play out.

anonyfox··on To the Bored All Things Are Boring
Personally I chase being in a bored state.

Adult life with all the duties is exhausting and drains mental/physical energy every day, to the point that nothing _meaningful_ can be achieved really. No, usually work is pointless exchange of time/energy vs money in order to live comfortably, sometimes sugarcoated in a higher "mission/vision".

Being in a stressed state also favors a mindset of "getting it done" with the actual goal of getting rid of the task at hand, aka "productivity", and some people think that a series of these completitions are a trajectory towards something rewarding - for me it isn't.

But when there are these moments where duties (work, kids, household, ...) are actually done, when there is no desire to play/watch the latest thing right now, this is when the good kind of boredom kicks in for me:

aimless reflection. mentally consolidating myself into the world, where am I, where things are going to, where I want to be next, how to probably get there. Going through it feels very relaxing, and activates some very existential kind of creativity (not the "solve the problem smarter thing), and fuels my energy a lot more than anything else in life. Being in this bored state is a precursor of feeling control over life again, and adjusting the inner compass to get updated directions to follow.

... but this doesn't happen when being busy/distracted, a state that drains my energy, and even accumulates dread every single day until the stressors are gone again and I feel "bored".

anonyfox··on 40 out of 60 German climate greening endavours fraudulent
social media bubbles are working here.

especially right wingers (fuelled by russian money, as confirmed more and more) need a doom&gloom environment + some targets to direct the anger/fear to. there is a lot of misinformation spread around, to an extend that group-thinking has already kicked in and confirmation biases are already at play.

the mental gymnastics are sometimes just outright insane: people with quite comfortable household income situations living in peaceful suburbs feeling close to take up arms to revolt against the evil government and those criminal foreigners everywhere (so against hated laws that don't exist in reality, people they never experienced themselves in their hood, general developments that don't affect them or also are not true/framed badly).

the reality is that life in general is good in germany, much better than in many places of the world considering the complete picture, its not getting more dangerous (criminal statistics overall are mostly flat/sinking over the last decades). there are problems, sure, but nothing spectacularly new, like aging population and pension stuff.

could it be better? always, yes. but it seems that any party that slightly tries to solve on of the actual problems gets a devastating amount of public fire (shoot-the-messenger-style) thats nearly to impossible to defend against, nowadays amplified by social media bots to a large extend, which many people are not able to identify.

anonyfox··on Norway discovers Europe's largest deposit of rare earth metals
no, more like ideal lunch time temp, lower is okay, above 20 and I start to feel miserable. Yes very cold is also okay :-)

The only thing that sucks is hovering around 0C for a long time, since this means oscillating between frozen/mud

anonyfox··on Norway discovers Europe's largest deposit of rare earth metals
> where very few people want to live

just as a sole data point: been there a few times, and my personal ideal weather _is_ cool/gray/wet with ideal outside temperature of 15C. I can withstand the cold, but find it hard to tolerate heat (as in >20C).

Purely from a weather perspective, I'd move there. What holds me back is that I also need dense urban surroundings nearby with all the buzz it brings (cyberpunk style) - norway is lacking that, including Oslo. _Too_ quiet/beautiful/peaceful for my liking.

anonyfox··on AI in software engineering at Google: Progress and the path ahead
not every developer knows how exactly his modern CPU oder memory layers work, or how electromagnetic waves are building up a signal.

people use tools to make things. Its okay. Some "hardcore folks" advance the "lower level" tooling, other creative folks build actually useful things for daily life, and mostly these two groups have very little overlap IMO.

anonyfox··on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (June 2024)
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Remote: yes when timezone is reasonable

Willing to relocate: no

Technologies: Rust, Elixir, Go, JS

Résumé/CV: https://anonyfox.com/cv

Email: max@anonyfox.com

—-

Either Fullstack (senior/…/principlal), DevOps, or Team Lead, whatever - I grew up with having to do all the roles back in the day. What matters most is doing something _real_, not another purely digital product/service or crypto stuff. Connection to something physical I could touch, that also has a future.

← PreviousPage 4 of 24Next →