This is not what got Apple to where it was. It was recognizing what we wanted to do to go further, individually and together, and amplified that with technology.
This literally amplifies your ass to the couch. I'm shocked. Stunned. And sad.
2,320 karma · joined May 12, 2014
This is not what got Apple to where it was. It was recognizing what we wanted to do to go further, individually and together, and amplified that with technology.
This literally amplifies your ass to the couch. I'm shocked. Stunned. And sad.
It's striking... This is a shift of epic proportions.
This is a shift of epic proportions.
Interesting overall still.
[edit] Full paper here. Issues persist, still cool. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41593-023-01324-5.pdf
(we this found out with GM doing a pilot)
[Edit] to keep it going, external cameras are how you verify parts are picked correctly and put in the right place - you don't need FPV for that to be verified either.
[Edit 2] Until a flight simulator uses VR and AR headsets as primary training, this stuff just doesn’t make sense. CAE has definitely explored with this but it’s not what they reach for
Think about its 'most compelling' consumer use case - Lifelike Avatars in FaceTime. Which one do you think is preferred, cooking in the kitchen and wearing a headset, or propping your iPhone up and FaceTiming while cooking? Where on earth does it 'change the experience' to have a real-life like avatar? We have the 'life like' avatar right now with Zooms - and the reason Zooms suck is innately the human part, not the rendering part - most meetings could be emails or 5 min phone calls.
Everyone had spreadsheets and publishing needs (Mac), portable music players (iPods), cellular phones (iPhone), headphones (AirPods), home wireless music speakers (HomePods)... think of fitbit / pebble, 1980s VR and then todays VR ?
I feel like the 'how many times do we have to tell you old man' character - hearing that the iPhone and the Watch sucked coming out and both eventually became successful.
The iPhone did not suck in any way shape or form. It was everything anyone who touched a PDA or Blackberry before that wanted - text messages in a gorgeous swipe-able full view context, visual voicemail, a phone that had contacts as a first class citizen, you could actually read the screen and not feel claustrophobic, and a frickin' full web browser! And it was your iPod too!? Dude... we all need to sit back, stop playing revisionist history, and realize how in awe we were waiting for this stupid phone to activate - it took me over a week to activate my iPhone because we all overloaded Cingular. But the swipe gesture just to unlock it, and it's beautiful screen just had me staring at the thing for the full week - so damn excited. Simple things like the highlight 'Swipe to unlock' was a designers wet dream for a few years - come on man! This was flippin' insane.
The same thing happened to me with mp3 players and the iPod. I won't bore you with a similar story - but come on! We all bought mp3 players, the experience sucked but the end goal was worth it - and when the iPod made the thing we wanted to do easy - it was a natural success. The same thing happened with Desktop Publishers and people who used spreadsheets on a daily basis for the GUI based computers.
To spell this out again, the world already had and used on a daily basis the product class Apple made great. Most people did not care for fitness trackers/watchers when they came out [see Pebble's fall from grace, fitbit's early IPO failure, etc.], nor do most care for VR and AR headsets.
Here's the kicker, I've bought almost every generation VR and AR headset trying to make these devices compelling - but every experiment just shows these 'take over a human field of view' sucks. They do nothing for us like the music player or PDA did - maybe it's an Alto issue (we need the GUI break through for these) - but I've worked on this problem from every angle for 7 years and it sucks. Even the dang architects and mechanical engineers think it sucks - and they are in the spatial computing context! I was there with the DK1 met with HTC in Taiwan and other people I can't say, and did all the BS - this tech strata sucks for what it wants to achieve. It just needs to be a beautiful hands free reader accessory - that's where it's compelling - this whole ambient computing will not be head worn, it just won't.
There’s no huge productivity shift like there was for spreadsheets to visicalc that pushes our perception for what’s possible - so something has to make this device compelling in a different way.
And I guess you’re right; the simplest argument with my taste is: VR/AR are technologies looking for solutions
* meaningful solutions. And maybe SOL and others are right that hands free readers are the most meaningful solution for these head worn devices.
[Apple Watch was always going to be fitness (everything before it was fitness). HomePod is amazing but not communicated correctly for people to know it’s there. Siri is horrid to deal with as a developer, tho dictation is amazing as an interface. There’s too much to talk about - basically Apple achieved the center of the digital life for all the devices Jobs put up on the screen in the 90s and now they need the new devices / activities and nothings been as universal as the past]
My premise is that watches failed (even though they sell millions of units) as the bar for success is higher for Apple, and they left a lot on the table by just putting a mini phone on your wrist.
So I think screens on wrists is a dumb use of compute. Then I went in a roundabout way to say, a dumb use of calories / sugar is Coke. Sugar and Compute have better uses, so their lost potential is taking issue with how their creators made the goods to be consumed.
The watch is the coke of computing - completely unnecessary for 9/10ths of the use cases and leads to bad habits. Just as a beverage can be crafted to be like Athletic Greens, so could the watch be crafted to use the wrist compute context better.
To provide some example, watch should have gone screenless and used haptics to communicate with us in new ways; and explain when it was important to move to a screen context (which is technically all it does now too) - with this view, it becomes one strata closer to excellence.
And for Siri and Alexa, you probably use ChatGPT, so you know the difference when you see it
Yes yes yes - a lot of people enthusiastically drink 3+ CocaColas a day too! Doesn’t make it a good use of technology nor dietary choice :)
Everyone who tries to speak a text message with Siri. Apple should have been brave and not reshaped messages - that screen is not meant to consume text messages at any length - they should have changed the communication to match the context.
I feel there's no idea of what the context is anymore - and that's what's killing all of these devices. No one can say 'this is the emphasis we gave these products for this reason' - because they all want the success of the iPhone, everyday use and wear.
We have to allow the pendulum to swing back to specialized devices - that's why Teenage Engineering is so captivating.
There’s just no dang reason to use these things like their creators want. Someone needs to be brave in these organizations and say “hey look, we tried pushing Siri for years and never gained the loved adoption that chatGPT has, why are we trying the same strategy here?”
If the compute offering is not excellent, it does not deserve to be in a new context. Period.
This may be a dumb question, but how would Azure ensure GPU clean tenancy and segmentation of data in these pipelines at those prices?
[0] https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/compliance/regulatory/offe...
‘Microsoft in-scope cloud platforms & services Azure and Azure Government Azure DevOps Services Dynamics 365 and Dynamics 365 U.S. Government Intune Microsoft Defender for Cloud Apps Microsoft Healthcare Bot Service’
Are they piggybacking on that?
What do we do about our formal wear then?
Yeah my use cases are in the really bad category - I’ve been building parsers for a while, and I’ve basically given up to manually stating rows of interest if present logic. Camelot got so close but I ended up building my own control layer to pdfminer.six to accommodate (I’d recommend Camelot if you’re still exploring). It absolutely sucks needing to be so specific out the gate, but at least the context rarely changes.
You're saying 'the text' without normalizing the rows and columns (basically the tab, space or newline delimited text with sporadic lines per row) was all you needed to send? I still have to normalize my tables even for GPT-4, I guess because I have weird merged rows and columns that attempt to do grouping info on top of the table data itself.
Do you feel that fear is misplaced? Or do we derive societal level benefit from the unfortunate things that could (and do?) occur?
I realize I may be unique in that all my contexts come with unique Google Workspace accounts - separate domains as well.
So perhaps my setup is what they attempt to replicate for folks with fewer accounts?
[Edit] would love an invite :D [Edit x2] I love this community, I got one, thank you!