HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anthuswilliams

985 karma · joined September 15, 2010

anthuswilliams at gmail dot com
submissionscomments
anthuswilliams··on You can increase your intelligence
#4) Do things the hard way. It's hard for me to agree with this. In principle, I want to bemoan the decline of my ability to spell as a result of auto-correct. But I think that casts an unfair negative light on the idea of doing things "the easy way".

Think about math. There is no question that the Arabic numbering system makes doing math easier. Why should I to go back to scratching out base-60 cuneiform? I can challenge myself just as easily by pushing on to more powerful and abstract mathematical concepts made possible by timesavers like the Arabic numbering system.

I'm sure that having access to high-level languages limits my understanding of the bits and bytes. But I can use these new tools of abstraction to do things that I would have found impossible if I were writing machine code. I'm not sure I see the value in doing things the hard way, when my brain will be challenged enough probing the depths of what these new innovations have made possible. I think the author misses one crucial part of intelligence - intelligence, insofar as it is about abstract thought, is positively correlated with the sorts of things I can do without thinking about them.

anthuswilliams··on [dead]
The author is no exception. The last sentence is that "Video games, movies, and TV are not the problem. It is the homes in which they are being viewed." He's blaming parents the same way that he complains that others blame video games. But I have the same question. What about all the people from broken homes who are not shooting up schools?

My parents raised me with nothing but love and understanding. But I'm young enough that if I murdered/raped someone, they would be blamed. They were abusive/neglectful. They left me alone at home watching Grover too often. Or something like that.

anthuswilliams··on Paul Buchheit: Four Reasons Google is still Awesome
With what justification? Google has made numerous innovations in terms of search. Think Instant, Goggles, and their shiny new (painfully unusable) implementation of Image Search. Plus they've got a bunch of micro-innovations--the AROUND operator, for example, and the reading level filters.
anthuswilliams··on [dead]
I don't know why this article is on the front page. There is nothing interesting or informative about it. It's just a smear campaign against a couple no-accounts.

The author is not even in communication with this kid any more, yet he feels the need to go publicize his version of a sour business deal with an unscrupulous cybersquatter. This article is petty and vengeful in a way that is IMHO every bit as shameful as the scumbaggery the Turkette kid engaged in.

anthuswilliams··on Kevin Connolly's guide to American culture
For some reason, I always thought this phenomenon was imported from Europe. I lived in a European tourist mecca for a few years, and whenever I would thank a European for something, they wouldn't say "you're welcome" or even an "mm-hmm". Usually they just smiled and nodded.

I can see how it might appear a little brusque though. Americans, particularly here out west, tend to put on an air of stoicism, so our "mm-hmm" probably comes without a smile or even a glance in your direction. But I've interpreted that to mean that I am being helped as a matter of course, not for the sake of propriety or some sense of obligation.

anthuswilliams··on The disposable academic: Why doing a PhD is often a waste of time
You've missed the point. The article readily concedes that PhDs are good for society as a whole. The argument is that they are generally a bad idea for individuals.
anthuswilliams··on Columbia University vs the little guy
It's important to note that the valuation assigned by government appraisers is often well below what the property would be worth on the open market. When I was young, my grandparents were caught up in an eminent domain suit. They were to be paid about two thirds the worth of their home (the worth of their home, in this case, being based on mortgage appraisals[1]). If they had run a business, they would have also had to factor in relocation costs, downtime, etc. Insofar as the seizing body is an interested party, or operates via political pressure from an interested party, the "fair market value" is prone to work in the buyer's favor.

[1] - obvious disclaimers - This is anecdotal evidence, and it happened in the 90s. Perhaps there was a tendency amongst lending institutions to inflate their appraisals so as to justify offering loans with higher profit margins. But I still think my point holds.

anthuswilliams··on Columbia University vs the little guy
It's not a really good deal, because if it was a really good deal they would try to persuade you directly rather than asking the legislatosaurus to do it for them.
anthuswilliams··on What will kill Facebook?
Even social sites with lock-in can still lose market share because you can socialize on multiple platforms. I still have a yahoo email address cos my grandmother likes to send me email forwards. But when I make new connections, or reconnect with old ones, I don't do it on yahoo.

Grandmothers won't save Facebook. They'll allow Facebook to linger on like a maladapted dinosaur or the old VAX your IT department uses as shelf space. But in a post-Facebook world, just because we all keep Facebook accounts to maintain ossified relationships doesn't mean Zuck still has social relevance.

anthuswilliams··on Web Programming Is Hard
Maybe it's the "computer scienciness" of the term. I'm a practical programmer with a tiny bit of industry experience, and have only just started attending university. And I'm intimidated by it all. Memory allocation! Pointers! My brain shuts down and I imagine anything I say will put McCarthy in the grave and cause Dijkstra to rise from it.

But the first time I read some blogger ragging on interviewees who didn't know how to reverse a linked list, I read the first sentence of the wikipedia article and realized it would be easy to do (albeit probably not elegantly): just loop over the list doing push/pop operations.

It's a pretty easy solution, and already runs in O(n) time, so I'm not sure why I doubt myself. It's probably that although I'm used to devising solutions for complex problems, I'm unused to problems that are formally defined.

anthuswilliams··on Web Programming Is Hard
As a cheap programmer, I disagree. An expert may spend 90% of his time doing something he feels is drudgery, but he does it properly, so as to prevent the 10% all-hands-on-deck emergencies from occurring.

If you hire cheap programmers to handle the 90% under the expert's supervision, the expert still has to painstakingly review the work so as to ensure it was done in a way that at least sort of resembles the method the expert himself would have used. And having reviewed other people's code, I am of the opinion that process is sometimes soul-crushing.

As a cheap programmer, I appreciate the consideration, as I like to feel I have some utility. But as an entrepreneur, I think it's a bad idea.

anthuswilliams··on What does it feel like to be stupid? An anonymous Quora user explains.
I went through a period like this, and it was awful. Diabetes isn't a particularly rare illness, but I am the only one I know who has it, and I had no idea what symptoms to look for. Since it took a while for me to develop the good sense to check into an emergency room, I spent six months essentially insulin free, shedding muscle mass, water weight, gasping for breath, and exerting every ounce of energy I had to climb flights of stairs.

I was basically incapable of complex reasoning because I couldn't expend the required mental energy. I did not become laid back or socially competent; instead, I was irritable and frustrated at my shortcomings. People could take advantage of me more easily. I generally stopped being interested in esoteric things of any sort. I don't think I derived anything of value from the loss of my mental acuity.

One tangential benefit I did receive, however, from having DKA, was an increase in motivation and willpower. I had taken my health and cleverness for granted, and now it was slipping away, and I didn't know why. All I knew was that I wanted it back. I forced myself to slog through, to finish the CRM I was working on, and I started working out more. It didn't help me health-wise at the time, but now that my condition is being managed, I find I am much more aggressive and resourceful in the way I conduct my life.

anthuswilliams··on Things to hate about OOP
Perhaps the reason OO has gained such a following is because it seems (to some) like the solution. Businesses have found they are bad at hiring programmers, because middle managers don't know how to spot the bad ones. So the best solution, in their minds, is to limit the amount of damage a bad programmer can do. In an imperative language, a bad programmer can wreak havoc. In OO, so the thinking goes, the disease is quarantined to a predefined set of functionality. Good programmers complain because OO ties the programmer's hands. But maybe that's the point.
anthuswilliams··on Excellent analysis of Assange's Wikileaks motivations (from the horse's mouth)
Yes, exactly. And if the expectation of secrecy is nonexistent, Assange claims, those in power will act with de facto integrity because the probability of being caught committing a crime (even a boring one) is so palpable. Hence the claim that the purpose of WikiLeaks is to make WikiLeaks obsolete.
anthuswilliams··on Excellent analysis of Assange's Wikileaks motivations (from the horse's mouth)
But as he points out, the objective of WikiLeaks is not to foster popular opposition, as Assange believes that occurs naturally. If public outcry was his intention, he probably wouldn't have bothered with banal diplomatic cables. He is of the opinion that consistent leaks heightens intra-government paranoia. As each conspirator becomes more fearful of information being leaked, s/he shares it less, thus depriving the conspiratorial machine of the information it needs to survive. I'm not sure I agree with him (this will require some thought), but I think your analysis might be off.
anthuswilliams··on How Obama Raised $60 Million by Running a Simple Experiment
Of course the digital divide is affected by income, but you're missing key pieces of the story.

1) The digital divide between classes is negligible compared to the divide between rural and urban dwellers, particularly wrt broadband access[1]. Also, n.b. class based Internet analytics is prone to error, since the poorest segment of America lives in remote rural areas where broadband access is unavailable to begin with.

2) As I pointed out above, the OP was in reference to 2007, when the Democratic candidacy was still up in the air. Further, Barack Obama drew support (particularly individual campaign donations) from young Internet-savvy people, whereas the real blue-chip donations went to Hillary Clinton (and to a lesser extent, Chris Dodd). Your data is from the exit polls in 2008, after the Democrats had (more or less) formed into a united front.

This makes your larger point untrue[2]. The data from the Obama campaign indicates that these particular videos were less effective than the images, and to assume this is due to bandwidth complaints is specious at best.

[1]http://pewinternet.org/Media-Mentions/2006/Rural-areas-laggi...

[2] Well, it is true that you can't generalize from this one example, and that video may still be a good choice for web startups, but not for the reasons you suggest.

anthuswilliams··on AI may be better than natural intelligence at coping with battlefield chaos
Keeping humans in the loop doesn't do as much as we think, because humans have a natural inclination to trust computers. In a high-stress situation, such as a battlefield, a human will defer to a computer even if the computer reports information that, under normal circumstances, would be obviously false. In 1988, for example, the USS Vincennes shot down a civilian airliner because its AI targeting system had misidentified it as an enemy aircraft. Giving individual humans access to an off-switch is a pretty suboptimal way to prevent AIpocalypse.
anthuswilliams··on How Obama Raised $60 Million by Running a Simple Experiment
I didn't downvote you, but I do think you're mistaken.

1) Your source cites the November 2008 exit polls. The campaigning mentioned in the article was being done through 2007, when Hillary Clinton still had her hat in the ring. Now, it's hard to use campaign donations as a gauge of support for presidential candidates (particularly among people who are too poor to even afford broadband). However it's easy to point out that Hillary Clinton's platform was more beneficial to the working class, whereas Barack Obama's vague Yes-We-Can appealed more to broadband-connected hipsters like me. As you can see from About's (pro-Clinton) US Liberals blog[1], half of the Obama campaign chest going into 2008 came from individual donors, whose email addresses were harvested on websites just like the one described in the OP.

2) I'll also dispute the claim that the poor have less access to broadband, having grown up so debilitatingly poor myself. In America, internet access is cheap, and even for the poor, the value of a fast, reliable internet connection far outweighs the cost. Those who are remain on dial-up connections are residents of low-density rural areas where broadband is unavailable. These people are a) unlikely to have been Obama supporters, and b) unlikely to have gone around donating campaign money on the Internet.

3) Barack Obama's was the most Internet-connected campaign in US history. If dial-up users were as large a chunk of his support base as you say they were, he would have spent a lot more time going door to door in Des Moines, and a lot less time on YouTube.

[1] I wanted to link to the New York Times article, but it's probably more informative all around if I just link to a blog which quote-mines it. At least About.com doesn't make you log in. http://usliberals.about.com/b/2007/07/19/hard-truths-about-d...

anthuswilliams··on Many teachers...grading...for compliance - not for mastering course material
Duly noted (and upvoted). I should have made it more clear--my belief is that their actions reflect poorly on the RN who supervises them.
anthuswilliams··on Many teachers...grading...for compliance - not for mastering course material
I think this is an argument for grading students on knowledge rather than compliance. Forcing students to serve time in the school system as though they were felons doesn't teach social awareness. It doesn't teach you how to navigate the bureaucracies in society. It teaches you to submit to authority.

When I talk about 'navigating the bureaucracy', I do not mean 'following the rules'. I mean something more analogous to 'hacking the system'. My definition of social awareness is, to some degree, not allowing arbitrary societal restraints to prevent you from making wealth and meaningful connections. In this sense, the single best lesson a student can learn wrt bureaucratic hurdles is that there is a better way.

anthuswilliams··on Many teachers...grading...for compliance - not for mastering course material
I attend a podunk university in southern Utah, where college life resembles an episode of 'Community', and the phenomenon you describe is apparent.

60% of the students are seeking acceptance into the nursing program. The school claims it is one of "the top nursing schools in the country". This claim is based on their graduation rates (for those accepted, around 80%). The school inflates their graduation rates by leaning on biology teachers to increase the rate at which people pass their classes, and by making the most difficult classes (e.g. Microbiology) optional.

The problem is that community and liberal arts colleges are small enough that the only significant measure of success is the rate at which students graduate. In my school, at least, nursing tends to (by and large) attract the sort of stupid people who are only interested in the certificate. In this the program is surpassed only by Elementary Education. Thus, economic pressures overpower academic concerns.

Side note: I worry about our nurses. I spent the first three days of June in in the Intermountain Hospital, and I caught the CNAs inadvertently giving me someone else's prescription. Twice.

anthuswilliams··on The unbearable lameness of web 2.0
That was precisely what I was thinking while reading the article. Facebook already does a bit of multidimensionality, e.g. 'So and so and 12 others like this.' The problem is, being in Utah, a huge portion of the social scene is Mormon. So vast swathes of my social graph jumped on board the LDS fan page, with the result that I get PMs and ads from Mormon.org. A lot. Perhaps I am an outlier here, and everyone else's social profile coincides nicely with their own personal interests. But I doubt it. Freelancers end up friending their clients, employees friend their coworkers, tenants friend their landlords, and we expect all these varied interests to work as predictors for one another?

The problem with using our friends' activities as predictors of interest is that Facebook has no way to distinguish between strong and weak friendships[1]. There is a marked difference in my life between Facebook friends and meatspace friends.

[1] - Sure, they can determine which of my friends I spend the most time talking with on Facebook. But that says more about our relative Facebook activity than the quality of our friendship.

anthuswilliams··on 15-minute writing exercise closes the gender gap in university-level physics
I don't think it supports the idea that men have better control over their emotions than women. Rather, I think it illustrates the effects of stereotype anxiety. The article also mentions the same phenomenon wrt black students taking standardized tests.

Although I don't have the source on hand, Malcolm Gladwell wrote a piece a few months ago reporting a similar effect in the performance of white basketball players relative to that of blacks in American high schools.

anthuswilliams··on Swastikas and context
He's not criticizing the defenders of free speech. He's challenging the internet iconoclasts who defend the viewpoint itself, and worse, do so dishonestly.

The thing is, I have a chickenboner uncle who defends the use of the word 'nigger' by citing its (supposedly) non-racist etymology. He emphatically claims he is NOT racist. I'm not so sure, but let's do a thought experiment. If he's at all reasonable, he'll probably make the same assumption I do when he encounters someone who uses the word frequently: thar be a skinhead.

Toulouse is right in pointing out that most of these people are Americans who are presumably familiar with western opprobrium wrt the swastika. If they saw a guy on the street with it tattooed on his chest, Toulouse argues, they would cry neo-Nazi, just like the rest of us.

I happen to disagree with the guy on the issue of the swastika, because I know that its disgracefulness is largely a western phenomenon. But I know that online gaming is not a suitable forum to challenge cultural norms. It's interesting to note that many Indians I talk too are far more understanding of the swastika's inappropriateness in that context than these reddite Americans are.

I'm all for challenging normative cultural symbolism, but I know that's not what this is about. As Toulouse points out, the same arguments are made regarding the term 'fag', and the fact that means 'cigarette' in the UK. The issue is not free speech; it's intellectual dishonesty.

anthuswilliams··on Ask HN: contribute to an idea: teams of unemployed programmers into startups
This describes an open-source project. Since these developers are looking to make money from the project, their goal is to seek widespread adoption (just as a startup would), and then market themselves as (extremely) highly-paid consultants charging top dollar for their expertise in the system they designed.
anthuswilliams··on 200 students cheat on senior midterm exam, many blame professor
I wouldn't have stood up and said that, unless the tests were identical (i.e., questions were in the same order, with the same pagination, same ordering of the multiple choice answers, etc.). Even if some questions were identical, if I had not endured an experience like yours, there is nothing about the situation that would suggest to me that what was happening was ethically murky.
anthuswilliams··on 200 students cheat on senior midterm exam, many blame professor
I've been in several university classes that issued practice exams which contained questions that showed up word for word on the test. It's actually pretty common.

I suppose if I found the actual test listed the questions in the same order as the practice test, that would be worth noting. But it doesn't sound like that's the case. The professor and his students merely pulled from the same test bank. Since it is so common for questions to be recycled, even years later, I have a hard time finding fault with the students. I think the professor is entirely to blame.

anthuswilliams··on Do the non-religious have greater brand loyalty?
...tech-centric news forums?
anthuswilliams··on Do the non-religious have greater brand loyalty?
His point is not contradicted by the data. He's questioning the paper's claim that people self-identify using corporate brands, saying instead that nonreligious people stick with brands that have worked for them in the past whereas religious people believe whatever the label tells them.

Obviously, he's not expressing that claim as true. He's using it to point out that, given imagination and a sufficiently broad brush, this set of data can be interpreted to cast aspersions on any group you wish.

anthuswilliams··on Do the non-religious have greater brand loyalty?
We're talking brand loyalty, not brand slavery. You can be a loyal Apple customer without buying Apple EVERY time.
← PreviousPage 6 of 7Next →