HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

antonovka

1,517 karma · joined July 29, 2009

submissionscomments
antonovka··on The Outsiders
Your demonstrated antisocial behavior validates the original poster's opinion.

Moreover, how is his opinion of your clear anti-social pretenses an attempt at 'hegemony' (specifically, the dominance of one state/region/political group over the other)? Is it because you feel that you are persecuted as an 'outsider' by the 'normals'? (This is also evidence of a psychological problem. If this is genuinely worrisome to you, you should see a shrink.)

antonovka··on Startup Visa
I agree with you that there are a lot of people who are extremely valuable to an economy despite not having a degree. However I would suggest that a degree is still a good bar to have in place.

Why is a degree any less of an arbitrary requirement than requiring extensive real-world experience (thus restricting opportunities available to many recent graduates)?

I think it's simply naive and foolish to exclude candidates based entirely on secondary indicators of their skills. First-pass filtering is easy enough based on primary indicators.

Moreover, due to the rapid increase of college attendance post WWII (starting with the introduction of the GI bill), college degrees are no longer a rarity -- without further context, they are not really a suitable secondary indicator of much of anything. Now you have to get a phd to stand out from the crowd.

antonovka··on French Ideal of Bicycle-Sharing Meets Reality
CityCarShare is fantastic if you live somewhere with sufficient density that driving is (truly) not necessary for most trips.

We use bicycles, public transportation, and walking for nearly all of our trips, but rely on citycarshare for shopping, moving furniture, occasional weekend trips, etc. We also use a corporate car share account to move servers to/from the colocation facility.

It's a fantastic service -- far cheaper than owning a car, and zero-hassle. I hated dealing with the complexities of car ownership, from insurance and DMV registration to regular maintenance, speeding/parking tickets, and the general agitation of driving.

If you've never lived without a car, it can be surprisingly liberating to sell yours off.

With the money you save not owning a car, you can afford higher rent for a more desirable area, longer-term car rentals for one-off trips, etc.

antonovka··on What's Going on at the Bay Bridge
The engineering issues are very interesting, but I find the social issues even more intriguing. What would happen if the bay bridge only re-opened to commercial traffic, and BART service was radically increased?

The bridge carries 280,000 thousand cars daily -- that's a lot of traffic driving around our city, people eating at restaurants, etc. Could we maintain that level of commerce while relying almost solely on public transportation?

antonovka··on Ask HN: What's the deal with mailing lists?
Lots of places log IRC and host the logs. That might not be your cup of tea, but it's far from hard.

In addition to privacy issues (many individuals don't approve of logging of what they perceive to be ephemeral 'hallway' conversations), there's the simple fact that these types of conversation don't lend themselves to well thought out messages -- as you noted with: "you can't really 'write up' something in IRC the way that you can compose an email."

Why not create a web forum/usenet/mailinglist gateway?

I'm sure nobody would object if you did -- Jive Forums (when the product still existed[1]) used to support both web-based and NNTP-based access.

[1] Jive Software was profitable[2] and engineering focused, and Jive Forums was a great product. They had both large and small customers, ranging from Amazon, Apple, and EA to numerous small businesses that required quality collaboration software -- jabber, forums, etc.

Then they took a massive, unnecessary $15 million investment from Sequoia Capital in 2007, hired a Chief Marketing Officer, completely fouled up their product line in "simplifying" it, and wound up having to raise another $12 million in series B funding in 2009 to keep the now-bloated machine running. They had to lay off a (reported) third of their staff in 2008 (but kept the 'CMO' position).

Waste of a good company with a solid set of collaboration products and a solid engineering team. Trimming down their product lines and raising their prices has left them out of reach of SMBs, and the "one size fits all" product completely ignores this straight-forward e-mail/forums/web problem space.

It also leaves a large market opportunity for someone to write a forums system that doesn't suck -- a surprising number of large corporations are still slaved to Jive Software's increasingly hefty licensing fees.

[2] http://www.jivesoftware.com/jivespace/community/jivetalks/bl...

Why did we raise the money?

Since the beginning, we have had a vision of open collaboration and how it can fundamentally transform the way a company works. Now the market is starting to agree with that vision and is seeing the benefits. We're proud of how we have grown this business over the last six years. We've been profitable since inception and have put good money in the bank. We have made our share of mistakes and missteps, but we haven't sacrificed our values and ultimately those mistakes made us stronger and smarter. This year we struck a mighty vein with Clearspace when we launched in February. Now the growth is in high gear and bringing on a funding partner is a step towards becoming the provider of choice in the market.

antonovka··on Ask HN: What's the deal with mailing lists?
While there's absolutely nothing wrong with coding for yourself, it doesn't usually pay the bills either. And (sadly), its rarer then it should be for someone to be able to print money for themselves by making things for themselves.

Feel free to treat "pay the bills" metaphorically. That was my intention.

I reiterate: If different users are asking the same question repeatedly, perhaps its an indicator that there's something wrong with your software, not your users?

Perhaps. But more often than not it's an inherent complexity in the problem space itself.

Oh, and, incase you don't know, not all software needs to expand until they can read mail. Multitasking has (sans the iPhone, if you want), been around for decades. People are more than capable of having one program open at a time. There's nothing wrong with this.

I don't follow your meaning ...

My personal preference for this sort of thing is IRC.

IRC is real-time and ephemeral, which makes it considerably more difficult to engage in conversations with contributors in other time zones, and refer back to design discussions that occurred 5-20 years ago.

Also, forums are easier for end users to figure out then mailing lists.

I thought we already established that project communication channels are primarily optimized for the project contributors who use them daily, not for once-off questions from end users.

antonovka··on Ask HN: What's the deal with mailing lists?
Never underestimate the propensity of the younger generation to blithely discount the previous.
antonovka··on Ask HN: What's the deal with mailing lists?
Theres more reasons to want to get support for something then your own selfish needs. Maybe you want to start hacking on the project but don't want to step on someone else's toes?

Then join the mailing list and participate in the discussion.

Why shouldn't the process be frictionless?

There's very little software that supports both fly-by questions on the web, and proper discussion via e-mail, so we optimize for ourselves, not users.

Web forums aren't frictionless. In fact, they're totally shit for the purpose of carrying on detailed conversations over the course of days without requiring constant attention from all the participants.

There's a reason why most forums will e-mail you when your watched threads are updated. Why not just have the e-mail be the thread?

Why do you want to make it difficult for people to start using or get help using your software?

Users don't pay the bills, and questions are usually incredibly repetitive and dull, no matter how easy-to-use or well documented the project is.

I'd rather the users that are unwilling to invest in the mailing list self-segregate by posting their one-offs to sites like StackOverflow.

antonovka··on Ask HN: What's the deal with mailing lists?
In general I think the problem is just laziness; the people running the project optimize it for themselves (active participants) rather than their users.

Unless your users are actually contributing money or time (most won't), I'd call that smart, not lazy.

antonovka··on If you had 5 dollars and 2 hours, how would you make as much money as possible?
I'm not so sure that it does. It relies on filling the tables at the restaurants. The restaurants don't care if the people who come to fill your table aren't the same ones that originally booked the reservation. Nor do they care if a certain number of reservations are no-shows, if the number of no-shows is smaller than the number of people waiting at the door.

Restaurants are in the business of filling their tables by making customers happy -- those customers will return, tell their friends, and the tables stay full. By filling up available spaces (thus resulting in customers being told that a very long wait is to be expected) and providing a paid line-cut (who enjoys being cut in front of while waiting 60 minutes?), you're going to make a lot of the restaurant customers unhappy, both directly and indirectly.

If this was an ethical business, they would have told the restaurant what they were doing and received approval before they decided to lie to the restaurant to achieve their aims.

antonovka··on If you had 5 dollars and 2 hours, how would you make as much money as possible?
As far as a restaurant is concerned, why would they really care? It might annoy customers, but as long as the tables are still filling up, I feel the restaurant is more than happy, because they're still making the best of their available resources (tables and wait-staff).

You answered your own question -- to the customer, it's annoying.

... and to the restaurant owner, it discourages walk-in traffic.

It's immoral in that it's dishonest (We have a word for reserving space at the restaurant by claiming to be a party of two, but not being one -- it's called lying). If you wanted to do this in the moral clear, you need to speak to the restaurant owner first, and see if they'll pre-allocate you tables.

antonovka··on Silicon Valley: Abandoned
Or, maybe you can point out how I'm wrong. You know, provide some evidence supporting "stupid". I'll help. If you're "stupid" as "you're mean, I don't like you, and I'm not going to respond to your arguments", I'll agree.

Stupid, as in: In the context of the sentence, the use of "force" was clearly in terms of market forces, and didn't "concede" anything about the rationality or reality of investing in cleaner energy and processes.

It's clear that any discussion with you devolves into responding to ridiculously irrational devices of rhetoric, so I'll stop here.

antonovka··on Silicon Valley: Abandoned
Seems like you just want to hit someone over the head with your indignance, not actually discuss anything rationally.
antonovka··on Java directly on Xen
Java (or Erlang) as the main process can't (easily) configure the network adapter, add routes to the routing table, access/configure the IPMI module, modify firewall/IP forwarding rules, etc, etc.

There's still a lot of shell-script automation that has to be done via tools like chef/puppet/cfengine.

antonovka··on Java directly on Xen
You'll need some mechanism to re-deploy major updates that cannot be accomplished via custom mechanisms, and that's most likely to still be ...

Why wouldn't the virtual machine bootstrap itself from network loaded code -- then it wouldn't be necessary to update the root Xen image.

Why couldn't I write a network service (also on the VM) that runs on other Xen instances and serves up the netboot code?

Why would updating the root VM require SSH? Couldn't I have a nice web management UI that I can just upload a new bootstrap JVM image to (on the rare occasions that I need to?). Perhaps systems could directly self-update the root Xen image on reboot?

I don't know why I'd have turtles-all-the-way down and then require some ugly update system that involves editing RC scripts.

antonovka··on Java directly on Xen
The future of general purpose VMs is a Python bytecode in an LLVM-backed branch of CPython?

That doesn't make any sense. It's only a generic VM in the sense that it's turing complete.

You're going to implement Ruby on top of this? Or is everyone just going to get their own incompatible re-implementation of the same VM services?

antonovka··on Java directly on Xen
Except that LLVM isn't actually a high-level VM. You have to bolt on quite a bit to even begin to run Python, Java, Scala, etc, and achieving interoperability between those has yet to even be approached.

LLVM is the best thing since sliced bread -- and there's even work to provide an alternative to Java's c1/c2/interpreter backends using LLVM -- but it's not really a direct replacement for the JVM or any other high-level virtual machine.

Something like this might be: http://vmkit.llvm.org/

antonovka··on Announcement: YC alumni will help us read applications
I can't tell if you're insinuating that I am using sophomoric platitudes, but I hope you respect that I have been trying to speak mostly about my personal experiences.

No, my intention wasn't to slight your concerns; I was attempting to articulate my opinion of sexism in technology and the justifications often used to support it.

antonovka··on Announcement: YC alumni will help us read applications
I would be interested to hear how you see your art and technology interests converging.
antonovka··on Announcement: YC alumni will help us read applications
Since the beginning, I have found this sexism.

Yes, it's incorrigible and often justified with sophomoric platitudes, even here on HN.

... well, you learn from past experiences.

However, the presupposition that someone will be prejudiced against you on the basis of their gender can also be damaging to social interactions -- such as this one.

antonovka··on Announcement: YC alumni will help us read applications
I know that there are VERY FEW female YC founders and I know that having male coders looking at my application is going to totally work against me, if for no other reason than they don't relate to me.

Individuals tend to internalize negatives. If you tell them that they aren't going to relate to you because they're men, they're going to internalize that and have trouble relating to you.

There is plenty of overt and veiled sexism in technology -- much of it, you can't control. However, if you come into every scenario projecting an assumption of sexism, that's likely what you'll always find.

antonovka··on Silicon Valley: Abandoned
"force to invest" concedes the argument that these "investments" don't make any economic sense absent artificial costs, aka a govt mandate. As a result, the resources used by these "investments" would have been better used elsewhere.

You're twisting an out of context quote to provide a stupid strawman worthy of attacking with your worldview.

... these "investments" don't make any economic sense absent artificial costs, aka a govt mandate.

There are real costs to pollution (pollution is not 'artificial'), but those costs are levied against communities (and world) without any recourse against those who externalize them.

antonovka··on Java directly on Xen
What I like most about this idea is that system administration via init scripts, et al, can just go away -- presumably one will have APIs for interacting with the available hardware, necessary 'OS' services, etc.

It'd make automated deployment of systems even more manageable -- turtles all the way down.

antonovka··on Silicon Valley: Abandoned
Even if it would "create" a great deal of jobs for construction engineers, it would take away resources from _useful_ production.

In the U.S., we have no shortage of "useful" production, and no shortage of not-very-useful production (see also: Cougartown).

Reducing pollution is useful production. I appreciate the idea that we'll assign a cost to traditional externalities whose cost is usually foisted on society at large, at which point the market will be forced to find new ways to decrease those costs.

The increased demand for carbon licenses does not come out of thin air. Someone does pay for it - while reducing other expenses!

It will also force incumbent, stagnant industries to invest in research and development, and disperse wealth more broadly, both of which pay significant future dividends beyond simply a reduction carbon output.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
Nobody is asking for "quickly". It's way too late for "quickly". How about making a proper good-faith effort to reach an amicable resolution in a remotely timely fashion, instead of general stonewalling?
antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
Surprised at the downvotes. Clearly you people have never had to deal with trying to get anything done with Apple or any other similar massive inattentive bureaucracy (like, say, immigration services?).

It's one thing to, in good faith, work through an outstanding issue with someone over the course of months, another to simply ignore any/all requests until they go through extraordinary measures to capture your attention.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
I think you are missing an absolutely crucial point here, Apple already tried paying him, several times now.

With the wrong name (ie, not the name he entered on the bank account form). Which was the original problem.

Is Apple reporting the payment to the tax service? What's to prevent Apple from switching the account to a personal one, or transferring it to an additional legal entity? Why are they taking many months to find any resolution?

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
This.

It's so easy to screw up Apple's registration process, it actually pisses me off to see people that have never had business dealings with Apple trying to push the blame off to you, referencing some imagined "oh my god tax evasion" scenario that doesn't exist.

People: Apple is an unmitigated pain in the ass. They will not respond to your e-mails. They will brick-wall your support calls. Unless you are a large company, they will absolutely ignore your situation unless they are faced with legal, financial, and/or PR ramifications. If you are a large company, you might get someone on the phone, but you'll still find them to be a capricious and pig headed organization.

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
The company I work for does a lot of cross-border financial activity and it's all anonymized - you don't know who your counterparty is and they don't know who you are, we're the middlemen and we take care of everything. Something like this would definitely set our alarm bells ringing.

At which point, you would presumably enter into a dialog to resolve said alarm bells?

antonovka··on YC: Help, I quit my job, now I cannot get Apple to pay me out for iPhone Apps
If you thought you could just use a bogus company front and cash the checks on your personal account with no records, well, you don't deserve much help.

They aren't checks. They're wire transfers. The mistake is understandable, and really -- it's not that big of a mistake. Apple hasn't paid anything out yet, the documentation can almost certainly be changed -- Apple simply needs to respond to his queries.

Why work so hard to blame the person who makes a simple mistake and gets stuck in an endless bureaucracy? The process is intimidating, poorly documented, and incredibly confusing. Apple provides very little assistance when things go wrong, and quite often, mistakes made in the web UI can not be rectified without going through human support -- who will, more often than not (from experience), simply ignore you.

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →