HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anuraggoel

1,703 karma · joined December 11, 2008

submissionscomments
anuraggoel··on YC Rejected: Please read.
I am all for preserving HN's sanctity, and I agree with and appreciate most of the points you make. But your tone makes the whole thing sound almost exclusively like "losers, please keep your rejection sob stories away from HN". I wonder how rejected applicants will take your well-meant advice.

Rejection has a human angle, and refusing to acknowledge that people respond to it in (seemingly) irrational ways doesn't help those who need encouragement, validation, or just knowledge of the fact that they are not alone. How is asking other hackers 'which web framework to use?' any 'better' than asking other YC applicants rejection related questions, given that this is effectively the only public YC forum?

anuraggoel··on Savory: Native Kindle epub and PDF Converter
Implementation: http://www.kindlefeeder.com/

> Kindlefeeder is a service for Amazon Kindle owners that lets you aggregate your favorite feeds and have them delivered to your Kindle in a convenient, easy-to-navigate format. You can also have your feeds delivered to your Kindle automatically on a schedule.

Your comment is breaking the page layout.

anuraggoel··on Sleep is Garbage Collection
I wasn't aiming to go that deep, but to answer your question I meant the ability to perform any given set of tasks.

Deriving the second conclusion needs a lot more data. Assuming there is no analog for swapping to disk, the biggest missing piece is the rate of GC. Is it the same for everyone? Additionally, is a given person's GC rate constant? When I go without sleep for two days, I usually need more sleep than when I missed sleeping for just a day. Does this mean there is more memory to reclaim? Or that my GC rate has been impaired? Or both?

More interestingly, how do 'brain-building' foods and activities affect sleep requirements?

anuraggoel··on Sleep is Garbage Collection
Sleep = GC and more available synapses = smarter*

So smarter people need less sleep?

Is the converse true?

* http://www.telegraph.co.uk/scienceandtechnology/science/scie...

anuraggoel··on Linux is Obsolete [1992]
Adding [1992] to the title would be much appreciated.
anuraggoel··on Flickr Co-founder Unveils Her New Startup: Hunch
Calling Hunch 'silly crap' is a bit harsh, especially if you haven't tried it out yet. Let us ignore the fact that they have 'MIT scientists with backgrounds in machine learning' on their team, and that they started working on it in 2007 and launched only today. I just signed up to check it out, and the results look promising even with the limited amount of data it has about me and everyone/everything else.

Crowdsourced machine learning isn't new, but because Hunch has enough weight behind it, it might eventually become much more useful than a lot of other 'silly crap' out there. A native iPhone client for Hunch would then be quite welcome.

anuraggoel··on Flickr Co-founder Unveils Her New Startup: Hunch
From http://www.hunch.com/fact-sheet/

"The presence of a link to a retailer has no effect on the decision outcomes Hunch proposes. Within a given decision topic, it's likely that some result pages will link to an online retailer, and others won't. Some topics don't have these sorts of links at all."

anuraggoel··on 'Slacker DB' shootout: SimpleDB vs. CouchDB vs. App Engine vs. Persevere
"Now that disk space is so cheap and many of the data models don't benefit as much from normalization, JOINs are easy to leave behind."

JOINs and data normalization were not created to get around disk space constraints.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_normalization#Objectiv...

For the average web application not running on app-engine like infrastructure, I believe the following order of questions would be more prudent:

   1. Do I need a database?
   2. Can I work with a relational database? SQLite? PostgreSQL/MySQL?
   3. Now, do I really need the new hotness?
And if you do need the new hotness, may I also suggest Tokyo Cabinet? I am afraid I can't rate its 'value' on a scale of 10, but I'd say it's pretty high for a free product.
anuraggoel··on Ask YC: Where I can learn the basics of a startup.
Read Founders at Work.
anuraggoel··on Undo Send in Gmail
It is adjustable (from the main settings page after you enable it) but the only options for me are 0 and 5. Zero?

Anyway, they are probably going to introduce 10, according to this article:

http://news.cnet.com/8301-17939_109-10200370-2.html

...but Coleman also told me there's an option to increase the un-send time window to 10 seconds. "We may decide to add longer options," he said.

anuraggoel··on Major Book Publishers Start Turning To Scribd
"But these options aren’t conducive to sharing content that you’ve discovered on the web, as they don’t allow your to embed them in your blogs and websites."

False. The Google Book Search API allows you to do precisely that: http://code.google.com/apis/books/

Scribd allows user uploads though, and that seems to be their biggest differentiator right now.

anuraggoel··on Confessions of a terrible programmer
To me, the author is like someone who will never really learn to swim well because he can't let go of swimming aids. Dependence on crutches like compile time checking and programming assertions might let you fake it, but there are more productive ways (and languages) to write working code.

1. Compile time checking can't catch most non-trivial bugs. Even if you swear by it, given the advances in Java IDEs, I would have to be quite lazy (or careless) to write Java code that doesn't compile.

2. Programming assertions - really? That's what unit testing is for. I like his point about being a testing masochist, but it doesn't sound like he's going about it the right way.

3. Having other programmers inspect your code can be helpful, but to me it's a luxury that you often can't afford.

"If I could bring this kind of a system to fruition, meeting all its requirements and budget and schedule constraints, just by conscientiously applying a slew of techniques for uncovering my programming failings before they got into the final product, then I knew that I would be able to fake it for the rest of my career."

The author claims his techniques have allowed him to create a good end-product, but at what cost? I could 'fake it' for the rest of my career, or I could invest more effort in learning how to write better code faster in the first place.

anuraggoel··on Has anyone realized Google is creating a Social network right under your feet?
Has anyone realized Yahoo has been creating a Social network right under your feet for years?

http://help.yahoo.com/tutorials/prof/prof/prof_start1.html

anuraggoel··on Sergey Brin has a mutation of the LRRK2 gene.
Previously: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=308623
anuraggoel··on The Innards of Erlang
You made my day. But Google obviously doesn't know the meaning of 'innards'.

Edit: Too bad your joke was so good it ruined HN for the rest of the day.

anuraggoel··on Girl wants to work for Twitter. Creates site.
Relentlessly resourceful. Twitter's new Founder Associate?

http://twitter.jobscore.com/jobs/twitter/founderassociate/bQ...

anuraggoel··on Be Relentlessly Resourceful
And I was beginning to think reading your essays and HN comments was sufficient to authoritatively reason about your motives.
anuraggoel··on Be Relentlessly Resourceful
I guess the (surprisingly) restrained reception to 'How to be an angel investor' forced pg to explicitly point out its key takeaway for founders and write a whole new essay for it. He just doesn't stop trying to do good - a different kind of relentless resourcefulness.
anuraggoel··on "Good to Great" Circuit City finally dead, could be managed with Quickbooks.
Steven Levitt (Freakonomics) commented on Circuit City, Fannie Mae and Wells Fargo in this context here:

http://freakonomics.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/07/28/from-good-t...

"These business books are mostly backward-looking: what have companies done that has made them successful? The future is always hard to predict, and understanding the past is valuable; on the other hand, the implicit message of these business books is that the principles that these companies use not only have made them good in the past, but position them for continued success.

To the extent that this doesn’t actually turn out to be true, it calls into question the basic premise of these books, doesn’t it?"

anuraggoel··on Ask HN: Please review my webapp: Da Button Factory - create shiny buttons
Cut him some slack; he's French :-)
anuraggoel··on On Building an Efficient, Indexed Search Engine With a Word Proximity Algorithm
If you really want to write your own search library, Manning and Raghavan's introduction to IR is highly recommended (and freely available)

http://www-csli.stanford.edu/~hinrich/information-retrieval-...

If you just want to use a search library that gives you word proximity (and more), it would be a lot less work to look at existing open source implementations. Xapian and Lucene are both quite useful and can be invoked from PHP, among other languages.

anuraggoel··on Google Launches New Service - TipJar: a collection of money saving tips
The title, though factually correct, is quite misleading. It's like saying Google launches interactive Python shell service at http://shell.appspot.com

The real service is Google Moderator: http://moderator.appspot.com/

TipJar is just a featured series on Google Moderator, just like the Shell is a featured application on the App Engine. It looks like Google 'seeded' Moderator with Tipjar, along with several other moderated discussions.

anuraggoel··on Amazon's Kindle for iPhone hits the App Store
This is great for people who buy Kindle books from Amazon. But Amazon does not let you sync all the content on your Kindle - it leaves out, for instance, the free/public domain stuff that you didn't buy from Amazon. Non-Amazon content is a large part of my Kindle library - partial sync makes this app useless for me, unfortunately. Stanza/eReader are much more useful from that perspective.
anuraggoel··on Airtel, one of the biggest Indian ISPs, is intercepting HTTP requests to display ads
This is not surprising. The concept of customer service in India is very different from what we accept as the norm in the States. Indian businesses have always treated consumers like crap. The socio-economic reasons for this are beyond the scope of this post, but I do want to point out some examples to illustrate the general attitude, and help align the frame of reference better.

My mother lives in New Delhi and often visits me in the States. She still can’t get over how easy it is to return stuff to stores here. In India, once you’ve purchased something, it’s yours for life. You can’t get a refund if you are not 'completely satisfied with your purchase’. Keep or trash; there is no ‘like’. This applies even if the product is defective. If you are lucky, or willing to yell at the store manager, you might get store credit.

You don’t like the movie selection on Delta? I once flew a ‘discount carrier’ from Bangalore to Delhi and had to stare at a 6" display ad for a refrigerator three hours straight, because it was pasted on the back of the headrest in front of me, and the seat next to me, and every other seat on the plane.

If your server in a San Francisco restaurant isn’t friendly, you give the restaurant two stars on Yelp. In India, if my server is friendly, I have reason to be suspicious. Surprisingly, I have seen this attitude towards customer service even in Indian stores and restaurants in the Bay Area. Note: if you’re white, your Indian server in an Indian restaurant is more likely to be friendly and hospitable. Not so much if you’re Indian, perhaps because they know you know, or perhaps because awe of the ‘white-skinned colonizing foreigner’ is still deeply entrenched in our culture.

Airtel, and pretty much all wireless carriers in India often send you ‘free’ text messages advertising their newest ring tones, pricing schemes and partner offers. "AT&T does that too!" you say, but not twenty-five times a day. I don’t know if people even understand the concept of opting out.

Let’s talk about less superficial issues - landlines stop working arbitrarily. There are times when I can’t reach my mother because her phone (and hence DSL) service has been knocked out by rain or wind or the latest ‘big dig’. Even when the phone lines work, DSL doesn’t work well and VoIP is spotty. Hour-long power outages are common. Four hour outages are even more common (and I'm talking big cities here). Running water around the clock? Only for the tiny new economic class that gets written about in the New York Times. I think it was the mid-nineties, when I heard about a week-long power outage in a Delhi neighborhood and the consequent lynching of local power grid officials by an irate mob.

Having grown up in the Indian middle-class, I am used to bad customer service, though I must admit the States is softening me. So when I see complaints about Airtel intercepting client HTTP requests, I can empathize, but it makes me wonder about much bigger customer service issues that never make it to the front page of HN.

anuraggoel··on Fliggo Lets You Build Your Own YouTube [YC S08]
I know techcrunch is(are) full of shit and Arrington is on vacation, but their posts aren't even spell-checked anymore? teh, athough, sItes, Wrodpress?
anuraggoel··on New AWS Public Data Sets - Economics, DBpedia, Freebase, and Wikipedia
If like me you're wondering how you could use some of the new datasets, here are some pointers:

http://www.freebase.com/view/freebase/featured_application

http://wiki.dbpedia.org/UseCases

Highlight: Powerset - semantic wikipedia/freebase search acquired by MSFT for $100mm

anuraggoel··on A Note About Sabeer Bhatia's Interview in Founders at Work
I found Sabeer Bhatia's interview one of the less useful ones in the book, though it was still worth reading. He sounded too negative about VCs, became a Google fanboy for no reason multiple times during the conversation, and gave too much importance to the notion of the 'killer idea'. Compare this to (say) Mitch Kapor's interview, and you see two completely different personalities, only one of which I would enjoy working with.
anuraggoel··on YC Applicants: Q&A with Abby and Ivan Kirigin of Tipjoy
Good stuff. Some more advice from the same folks:

http://tipjoys2cents.blogspot.com/2008/03/how-to-hack-togeth...

http://tipjoys2cents.blogspot.com/2008/03/yc-applications-ar...

From others:

http://leavingcorporate.com/2008/03/24/how-to-get-accepted-f...

http://mattmaroon.com/?p=247

anuraggoel··on Twiddla: Zillon Percent Better at UI Design
Not quite. Balsamiq has significantly more UI controls and buttons. Mockups aren't Twiddla's focus, so they will never fill the same need that Balsamiq fills (and vice-versa).
anuraggoel··on Did Last.fm Just Hand Over User Listening Data To the RIAA?
"Incidents like this highlight how the social Web can sometimes bite back if you are not careful"

Incidents like this highlight nothing but the need for 'a cure for the disease of which the RIAA is a symptom'.

http://ycombinator.com/ideas.html

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →