HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aortega

1,461 karma · joined August 22, 2011

submissionscomments
aortega··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
>Stallman not only harassed women

No proof of that.

>and made them uncomfortable

Not a crime.

>he outright fired a transgender woman from the FSF for reporting her transphobic coworker

No proof of that, no proof of the coworker being transphobic, also all of that is not a crime.

>See also https://mobile.twitter.com/_sagesharp_/status/11736371384133....

That's the same person that accused Linus Torvalds of harassment and made him quit. Coincidence?

aortega··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
>Telling someone you're going to kill yourself if they don't date you is clearly just trying to be friendly.

Exactly, it just looks like a joke, banter to lighten the situation. It all depends on context, that we don't have.

aortega··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
You really think that she's a prominent member? Next to Stallman or Minsky?

I've never heard of her in my life up until today. And a single sample is not evidence that "many" have opinions.

aortega··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
Ah yes! the "Implications".

For me, the implication of a mattress in his office are that he might sleep there. Any other implications are in the dirty mind of the accusers.

aortega··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> a woman testified that, at the age of 17, Epstein told her to have sex with Marvin Minsky.

For fucks sake, this is not even an accusation to Minsky.

Take a minute to appreciate the fact that Minsky is being called a Rapist because somebody said that some person told another person to have sex with him. And he turned her down.

aortega··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> I trust her judgment more than, say, yours

Good for you, I don't. I trust Stallman.

> I used it as evidence

You used a tweet from a single person that never worked with Stallman as evidence.

>the way he reportedly treats women

Reported by who? Is there any formal accusation or lawsuit? Did he lost such lawsuit? (because anybody can file a lawsuit).

aortega··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
>Stallman has pretty clearly lost (or never had) the trust of many members of the community,

He lost or never had the trust of some very small but very vocal group of the community.

> EFF's head of cybersecurity have described him as a "creep".

And we must take her judgement on people as accurate? why? Also, an accusation of "creep" should not be enough to erase all his life's work. What does "creep" means anyway? Asperger? Social inept person? Modern tech were built by creeps.

>He said that an underage sex trafficking victim's "plausible" apparent consent means that the people who raped her did not commit sexual assault.

He didn't said that.

>he will probably not be a very effective leader of GNU, even if he was before.

Why not? Software is created by "creeps" like us anyway, not by social activists. I don't see why a "creep" will not be effective as a leader.

aortega··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
>He's harassed and bothered dozens of women in and outside of MIT.

I also saw those accusations, but I didn't see any proof of the harassment except one girl that said Stallman asked her on a date. And bothering? you really think you can go for 60 years on this earth without bothering any person?

aortega··on Colt is ending production of AR-15s
I agree, there is so much stupidity in banning guns (even more banning a single model). Those are not shootings, those are suicides. It's just that angry men prefer to die taking some people with them. They will find another way to kill themselves, maybe more dangerous.

They are not fixing the root causes, just the symptoms.

aortega··on The Meritocracy Trap
>So when you say "the best", often what you get is "best at selling self"

Then the test is wrong. Not meritocracy.

aortega··on The Meritocracy Trap
> There is more to it than it just being “the best”.

No, there is no more to it. It's a trivial concept. If you think otherwise, then explain.

aortega··on The Meritocracy Trap
>The problem is how to measure that skill.

Then it's a testing/measurement problem, not a meritocracy problem.

> The inclusive meritocracy in the article solves that problem by expanding the definition of skilled, and by investing in a more diverse group of individuals. This results in more (in number) skilled people at the end of the investment.

There is no problem to solve. If you don't choose the best, you choose sub-optimal personal. Also the definition of "inclusiveness" is ridiculous, as it assumes that diversity means hiring different sex or race, but not diversity of thoughts or culture.

In fact, it opposes different ideas, it's exactly the inverse of diversity. It's a thought monoculture.

aortega··on The Meritocracy Trap
> tests, are easily gamed and don't in any way guarantee actual competency.

Dude...

aortega··on The Meritocracy Trap
>That's not a meritocracy but feudalism.

Exactly, there isn't any merit about being born with wealth. They are bending the meaning of the word Meritocracy.

Often, the wealthy can get better trained and have more time and resources and they end up being the best candidate for some projects, product of the advantage they had.

This doesn't negate the fact that they are still the best and if you want to get shit done right, you have to hire them. Anything else is charity.

aortega··on The Meritocracy Trap
> In the exclusive meritocracy, prestige is defined by how many people you can reject.

This is borderline doublespeak. Is not about how many you reject, Its about finding the best. Obviously you will have to reject the not-best, for that particular task.

The way this is phrased reveals it as an obvious and clumsy attempt at social engineering.

Edit: The best is defined as the optimum person to complete the required task. The "best" is found by measuring his aptitude (tests, etc.).

aortega··on The Meritocracy Trap
The optimum way to complete an activity or project is to hire the most skilled people to do it. It's a simple fact, very easy to prove.

Media is spending a suspiciously big amount of money to try to disprove this very simple fact.

aortega··on Remove Richard Stallman
It's interesting that Stallman very likely left those weird pedophilia comments on purpose, like a canary to measure how much freedom he has.
aortega··on Remove Richard Stallman
He has endured this before, thing is, the guy's old, alone, and not in the best shape mentally, and this might get him.
aortega··on Remove Richard Stallman
Obviously you would fear that, Stallman is being called a pedophile and his jobs is in danger, all without a single iota of proof, just because the internet mob made him his next target.
aortega··on Remove Richard Stallman
>That's what statutory rape means... rape.

It's not the same, or else they would use the same terms, do you agree?

Thing is, definition of crimes are better left to experts, I.E. Lawyers. It's not an easy task in any way as you can see.

> He's not wrong in what he said, but he could be wrong for saying it.

You can never be wrong by speaking the truth. And this is what RMS did.

aortega··on Musk to review all of Tesla's expenses in new cost cutting plan
Traditional car companies must be damn scared to have to publish this FUD.

Tesla cannot be possibly dying out. Don't you see Tesla cars everywhere in the US? yes they are spending money, buying things to grow as they are so incredibly successful they cannot satisfy demand. Dying out? you make me laugh.

If you spend 10M dollars buying equipment that in a year is worth 100M dollars, you are not dying out.

aortega··on First Sednit UEFI Rootkit Unveiled [video]
Isn't this computrace repurposed? this research is about 10 years old. https://www.blackhat.com/presentations/bh-usa-09/ORTEGA/BHUS...
aortega··on Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
This has happened before. Consider this: Current diversity politics is diversity of skin color or gender, but not of though. You are only allowed to think in a certain way if you want to belong to the group. This is not really diversity, it's superficial diversity.
aortega··on Linux developers threaten to pull “kill switch”
Simple: Because basically it's all subjective. The rules are not clear, and also you cannot impose new restrictive rules on people an expect to everybody be happy about it.

>Using welcoming and inclusive language

I don't know what inclusive language is. Seriously, no idea.

>Being respectful of differing viewpoints and experiences

What is being respectful? who says when I'm not being respectful? its not binary.

>Gracefully accepting constructive criticism

What the fuck is Gracefully??

You see, it's impossible to see when you are breaking the code, not all situations are black and white, and it's in the gray that there are always problems.

aortega··on Ask HN: What open source project, in your opinion, has the highest code quality?
It's not clean at all. Thousands of different styles, no single convention on function-naming, etc.

Want a clean kernel, go look at the BSDs.

aortega··on Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext
No, it is not.
aortega··on Signal-desktop HTML tag injection advisory
> Exploiting this requires the attacker to first manually place malware (a malicious JavaScript file) on your computer or on a Samba network share that your computer is already connected to.

I'm Alfredo Ortega, part of the team that wrote the original exploit. This is (unfortunately) not true. The exploit on the video was loaded from a Windows share that the victim's computer was not already connected. This is possible using "Anonymous shares" in Windows 10, and older windows versions.

To be clear, you need absolutely no additional software on the victims computers, besides having a vulnerable signal-desktop and be running on windows.

aortega··on Remote zero-click JavaScript code execution on Signal desktop
You are correct, there's also a flaw on CSP not limiting all the ways you can download a resource. And at this time, it's still not fixed. We'll publish an advisory soon.
aortega··on Large collection of Nazi artifacts discovered in Argentina (2017)
As an Argentinean I'm deeply saddened by the discovery of such widerlich artefakte. Argentina harboring nazis? ha ha that's verrückt.
aortega··on Large collection of Nazi artifacts discovered in Argentina (2017)
Also the toothbrush mustache was sexy before WW2.
← PreviousPage 7 of 19Next →