HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

apcragg

677 karma · joined December 4, 2017

submissionscomments
apcragg··on How well do cars do in crash tests they're not optimized for?
Is that not outright fraud? Just because you can hack something doesn't make it right or legal.
apcragg··on Oldest 'nearly complete' HIV genome found in forgotten tissue sample from 1966
Fuck you
apcragg··on Twitter hides Donald Trump tweet for “glorifying violence”
Don't be so disingenuous. The phrase is famous and it obviously is obviously not intent on trying to quell violence. I know to be contrarian and radically 'rational' is popular among tech types but it doesn't mean you have to bury your head in the sand when what is being said is so clear.
apcragg··on DuckDuckGo Billboards
It seems like it. They've also been advertising heavily on NPR member stations and podcasts.
apcragg··on IKEA's shopping malls arm plans U.S. entry in major play
The one in Atlanta is next to Atlantic Station which is a large business and residential development with rapid bus transit. It is also near Georgia Tech and Midtown though to get to Midtown you have to cross the highway which is not bike/ped friendly.
apcragg··on Pentagon official: FCC decision on 5G threatens GPS, national security
The new standard supports more concurrent users by using the available spectrum more efficiently. There are new modulation and timing "modes" that enable better coverage at cell edges and in dense urban environments. There is better support for multi-antenna systems which means better coverage and more efficient spectrum usage. End-to-end latency has been dramtically reduced and the next 5G NR iteration (rel 17) will add a super low-latency mode. There is now a mode for IoT that enbales low-power communication. Most of these changes aren't going to give you 1Gbps downlink speeds but they represent huge improvements over even LTE-A.
apcragg··on Pentagon official: FCC decision on 5G threatens GPS, national security
Your first 3 points are all based on a complete misconception of what 5G NR is. You are talking about mmWave which is an accessory component of the 5G NR standard. Low and mid-band 5G use ~ the same bands (or n71 which is the old TV band in the case of T-mobile) as LTE. Some Network Providers have been doing mmWave first because it is easier to deploy but their networks will also be mid and low band when they finish build-out.

Maybe don't make blanket statements about a standard you clearly aren't familiar with.

apcragg··on Trading halted as U.S. stocks plummet
You are wrong about that. See T5, T6, and H10 halts.
apcragg··on A new firm says it can link satellites to ordinary smartphones
Saving 50% gets you 3dB. You'll need something on the order of 20dB. The inverse-square law bites hard.
apcragg··on Walmart Gets Into Health Care
Maybe it is different where I am but in my experience, it is always an MD on staff.
apcragg··on Students defeat new 'Barnacle' parking clamp, skip fines and get free internet
No, it isn't. The literature department is a fundamental component of the university. Providing land and infrastructure for students to store their property in the middle of campus is not - especially when campus is accessible through a variety of modes of transit. Sure, if the university is in a cornfield in Iowa then parking costs are less of an issue given the low cost of land but the majority of campuses I have been to are limited in land. The university has to make a choice between using that land to educate people or for letting people store their cars.
apcragg··on Students defeat new 'Barnacle' parking clamp, skip fines and get free internet
A spot in a multistory parking desk costs upwards of $30,000 per spot. Even if you oversell permits by 2x and assume a 50-year lifespan with no maintenance, that is still $300/yr per parking permit. Why should students who want the exclusive right to leave their property on campus be subsidized by students who take more space/environmentally efficients modes of getting to campus?
apcragg··on GNU Radio first steps: a FM receiver
That is a good point that you don't need a radio but I work extensively with GNU Radio and I would do all of those experiments using MATLAB / Octave. GNU Radio is very much the wrong tool for that job.
apcragg··on Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't come true
That is an incomplete summary. Their conclusion is that despite this larger than normal selection bias, the minimum wage appears to have no impact on unemployment. The paper's abstract, discussion, and summary all mention this as part of the central thesis - why leave it out?
apcragg··on Offshore wind will be a $1T industry by 2040, but it's needed now
It isn't though. Thats how we talk about installed power capacity. The capacity factor is important but seperate. Nobody says we installed a 2.5 MW* wind turbine accounting for capacity factor. They say we installed a 10 MW wind turbine. It is assumed, especially given this publications audience, that the power factor is a seprate point. The person I replied to said that the sentance was so wrong it was "cringy" which is not true.
apcragg··on Offshore wind will be a $1T industry by 2040, but it's needed now
What is wrong with that sentence? As of 2018 there was ~98k MW of installed wind capacity [1]. Reaching 100 GW of installed capacity in 2019 make perfect sense. It seems like it's you that doesn't understand the difference between power (watts) vs. energy (watt-hours / joules) yet are confident enough to call a journalist out even though they are correct.

[1](https://gwec.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/GWEC-Global-Wind...) Page 29

apcragg··on Don’t Call Me a Pessimist on Climate Change. I Am a Realist
Is there any evidence that this ever happens? Or at least happens more frequently than say, a 1979 style fossile fuel shortage?
apcragg··on Nuclear energy is a vital part of solving the climate crisis
Which newer plants? I'm still paying for the cost over-runs at Vogtle here in Georgia which is a 'modern' plant. Granted, Westinghouse went bankrupt but Wind/Solar builds don't have the same risks concentrated in a single manufacturer.

Sure, we have some research reactors which use (the now meme'd by armchair scientists) thorium reactors but we need power today, not in 2035. Why pour billions into unproven technology when we have proven technology that gets cheaper every year. Additionally, Lazard just put out their LCOE report for 2019 and for the first time new-build unsubsidzed wind can be cheaper than the marginal costs of a fully paid-off nuclear plant.

apcragg··on Nuclear energy is a vital part of solving the climate crisis
Not to mention the capital costs of building a nuclear plant far excede renewable new-builds. Why spend 20 billion and deal with the costs/risk associated with 50-year financing when you could spend a few tens of millions and throw up a few smaller renewable builds where they're needed and start seeing returns on invetment in 2-3 years rather than 15.
apcragg··on Cities Are Saying ‘No’ to 5G, Citing Health, Aesthetics, and FCC Bullying
I mean my sources are the actual 5G Standards, the test equipment I've used, and my knowledge of cellular systems stemming from experience and and formal education so yeah, I think it's a fair assumption that my knowledge is more than "some things I heard". My job does not depend on the success or failure of 5G, I don't know where you got that from.
apcragg··on Cities Are Saying ‘No’ to 5G, Citing Health, Aesthetics, and FCC Bullying
Not my area of expertise. The main study I'm aware of showing some harmful affects uses an unrealistic amount of power and curiously only showed effects for male mice. I'm hesitant to dismiss it, because effects from heating caused by non-ionizing radiation are well documented but that amount of power is just not present in cellular systems whether that's LTE or 5G NR.
apcragg··on Cities Are Saying ‘No’ to 5G, Citing Health, Aesthetics, and FCC Bullying
Being confident enough to trash-talk based on hearsay is just being arrogant.
apcragg··on Cities Are Saying ‘No’ to 5G, Citing Health, Aesthetics, and FCC Bullying
Not for the big telecomm's but I design parts of the radios and DSP algorithms implementing the major cellular technologies.
apcragg··on Cities Are Saying ‘No’ to 5G, Citing Health, Aesthetics, and FCC Bullying
In short - some but not really. 5G NR allows for extremely efficient resource block allocation and can handle ~10x more concurrent users than 4G. The latency should not degrade as long as the carriers don't do weird things with traffic allocation - the standard allows for ~4ms worst case latency.
apcragg··on Cities Are Saying ‘No’ to 5G, Citing Health, Aesthetics, and FCC Bullying
You have heard wrong - it's amusing that you're so confident in its failure despite having the wrong information.

There are two phases in the 5G NR standard. The first phase relies on some elements of the LTE control plane to coordinate data services. These data services use new numerologies for their OFDM modulation, vastly more flexible resource block, allocation, improved error control coding, lower maximum latency, better channel allocation, and standardized MIMO support - all of which will improve reliability and throughput, especially in crowded channel conditions.

Phase 2 formally introduces millimeter wave signaling - this is what does primarily propagates through line of sight (LOS) channels. Clever beam forming and beamsteering can alleviate this to an extent but these cells are intended for dense urban environments or interiors of large buildings. These will supplement the lower frequency bands when available but 5G NR devices will still use the lowband when mmWave is unavailable. Phase 2 also switches over to an entirely 5G NR backed control plane (Standalone, or 5G NR SA) which has its own reliability and throughput improvements though these will all happen in the lowband since mmWave isn't suited for these tasks.

apcragg··on Should Disney World Have the Right to Build a Nuclear Power Plant?
The thing is, nuclear power straight up isn't profitable to build now. 15 years ago, sure, but according to Lazard's most recent analysis, nuclear power is beaten by alternative sources with storage. The cost of financing projects on such large timescales is huge, not to mention the risk of fiascos like the one going on in South Carolina and to some extent Georgia. We should keep the plants we have running, but use the available funding for new renewables. If we really want to go to the nuclear power route, the government should just do what France and China did by nationalizing new nuclear plant construction. The prviate sector is past the point that it makes sense to choose new Nuclear plants over gas baseload or renewables.
apcragg··on JetBlue explains to a passenger how it got a photo of her face
Privacy concerns aside, I can't wait to read the "Facial Recognition let me on the wrong flight when I got in the wrong line by accident" articles that are going to come out of this. Unless these systems have some fantastic (1e-6) P_{false alarm} rate or better, people are going to be mistaken for other people and let on the wrong flight sooner or later.
apcragg··on A Conspiracy to Kill IE6
Did you see the chart of browser usage correlated with this incident? The only precipitous drop in any browser usage occurred when they launched this banner. It was already on a downward trend, but an immediate drop like that is pretty hard to explain away as anything else.
apcragg··on Emoji, part 6c: to infinity and beyond?
Very active on Twitter, actually.
apcragg··on Emoji, part 6c: to infinity and beyond?
Huh that's weird. It's been my experience that I see far,far more comments from people like you who are upset over "manufactured outrage" than people who are actually outraged. It's odd how much people feel the need to signal that they don't get Outraged™ like everyone else.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →