HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

appreciatorBus

1,483 karma · joined June 8, 2023

“Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.”
submissionscomments
appreciatorBus··on The revenge of the philosophy majors
If service to others and to society mean anything to you, working in Starbucks or any fast food job will teach you more about humanity and human society than most college grads learn from a humanities degree.
appreciatorBus··on Resetting Xbox
Just because they already spent the money yesterday, it does not follow that the best decision today is to just carry on as if was still the correct decision. Yes they cannot get that 70B back, but if they have to choose between:

1. a long dragged out distraction over decades trying to make it work

2. a painful but quick 40B write down and the ability to refocus the company on better projects tomorrow

.. then they are, quite rightly imo, going to pick #2. In fact I would assume this going to be the next announcment.

appreciatorBus··on The Private Capture of Public Genius
Imagine that AI lives up to its promise, gets captured by unaccountable bureaucrats and socialist dictators, ushering in a world of untouchable über-oligarchs that de facto rule the world. Would it have been worth it then? Can this problem even be solved?
appreciatorBus··on Real-time map of Great Britain's rail network
How is it surveillance for an organization that operates a fleet of trains, to know where the trains are?

Even if there were no such thing as GPS, simply the act of running a fleet of trains or trucks or buses on a schedule, means that anyone could do a bit of math and roughly calculate the position of every vehicle based solely on the schedule.

appreciatorBus··on Building relationships with customers through support didn't turn out as hoped
What you neglected to mention is that your app is free.

If this is something you’re able to do and people like it, I think that’s great.

However, the post is about a paid app and that’s going to have a significant influence on the type of support requests you get, and whether or not it makes financial sense to develop according to those requests.

appreciatorBus··on Building relationships with customers through support didn't turn out as hoped
This is poster’s last show HN; homepage features some 16,000 user claim. App appears to be free, which I suspect will rather drastically change the composition of incoming support messages.

https://macrocodex.app/

appreciatorBus··on Google Books (or similar) all book scans – $200k bounty (2025)
Copyright is not an unalloyed good.

In small doses, and short terms, I might agree with your classification.

But when copyright is 150 years It no longer has anything to do with reward for the author or encourage you creativity, it’s just a cartel.

appreciatorBus··on Rage of the Falling Elite: How downward mobility fuels radical politics
There is nothing about collectivism, socialism or communism that guarantees they would be any better stewards of our environment than the status quo. Again, there’s a track record and it’s not good.

There are many ways our economic system is entirely compatible with stopping global warming, but it would require putting prices on things people consider sacrosanct like unlimited driving and unlimited municipally treated water for lawns. Wake me when the socialists are willing to talk how they will equitably tell citizens that they can’t do environmentally destructive things when the citizens are telling them that they want to do those environmentally destructive things. I’m not saying there’s an easy answer, in fact, I’m convinced that there isn’t. He had every day we are told that if only we have a revolution, suddenly these hard problems just disappear, and I don’t think that’s true. After the revolution, people will still be selfish. Perhaps the selfishness won’t be measured in dollars, but it will still exist.

appreciatorBus··on Rage of the Falling Elite: How downward mobility fuels radical politics
That people of means could assist those who do not, does not at all imply that people of means who say they are assisting are actually assisting. The road to hell and involuntary collectivism is paved with good intentions.
appreciatorBus··on Rage of the Falling Elite: How downward mobility fuels radical politics
> These were not people starving; they were aggrieved that they were in the 90th percentile rather than the 99th. Surveys show progressive activists are wealthier, whiter, and more highly educated than the average American. They are nearly three times as likely to hold a postgraduate degree.

> Many assume the central conflict in society is between the haves and the have-nots. In reality, much of the struggle is between the haves and the have-mores—people who are already doing well but want the money, resources, and status of those above them. They often disguise this ambition as concern for the have-nots.

> The affluent were the most likely to agree with statements like “I want a position of prestige.” Elsewhere, a University of Edinburgh study found that malicious envy—resentment at others’ success—was one of the strongest predictors of support for coercive redistribution. The impulse, in other words, is not to lift up the poor but to tear down those who are one rung higher.

appreciatorBus··on Archivegenocide.com: view the footage collected from Gaza in one place
It does, but then we have to decide which context is relevant, and who decides which context is relevant, which quickly gets us back to "me good, you bad" unless you have something else to bring to the table. History did not begin in 2022, 1948, 1095, 135 AD, or even 3021 BC.
appreciatorBus··on Archivegenocide.com: view the footage collected from Gaza in one place
"My violence is good, your violence is bad"
appreciatorBus··on Archivegenocide.com: view the footage collected from Gaza in one place
Will there also be footage from Oct 7?
appreciatorBus··on Bring back crappy forums
> I want to pose a question: Is it possible that online users just have nonstop shiny object syndrome, and even if forums worked correctly and did the job, users would still move onto something else because we’re never happy? I think the argument is pretty strongly yes.

This is definitely part of it, but the other side of it is the network effect that allows a minority of the population who happen to be especially afflicted by shiny object syndrome, to drive population scale moves from one platform to another. I feel a good analogue is the way that new restaurants become the hot place, the place to see and be seen, but they can usually only sustain this for a time and then the buzz moves elsewhere. The difference, of course, is that the scale is much much larger, and restaurants generally don’t have a way of attempting to directly addict their users.

appreciatorBus··on Show HN: Searchable directory of 22k+ products from worker-owned co-ops
Why does it seem more ethical for the organization that makes your daily bread to be democratic?

I have no doubt that there are people who wish to attend meetings to vote and argue about minutia involves in the running of bakeries and other organizations. But just because people exist does not mean that the most ethical organization is one that gives them the most opportunity to exercise their particular interest in attending meetings.

The vast majority of people do not want every organization their lives to run like a mini democracy. Not only is this not necessarily more ethical than other alternatives, but it is definitely less efficient and that matters when it comes to the supply of material goods. I don’t want a vote on whether or not my bakery puts sesame seeds on the bread. I just want to buy a loaf of bread thanks.

appreciatorBus··on Show HN: Searchable directory of 22k+ products from worker-owned co-ops
There is nothing inherently ethical about co-op owned organizations nor anything inherently unethical about privately owned organizations.

The party vanguard of the worker co-op is exactly as capable of selfish or abusive behaviour as the private owner.

appreciatorBus··on Why don't tech workers see themselves as workers?
Use of the word "workers" as class implies precarity and vulnerability, making it a useful category to organize around politically, regardless of whether your political ideas are good for such workers or anyone else. But this distinction loses meaning when starting salaries for such "workers" are at several multiples of national median income.

There will always be injustices in the world that require people to organize political support to fight. However using this as your sole lens risks putting the cart before the horse - are we trying to organize tech workers because they are marginalized class, or because your political ideas require overthrow and rich tech workers would be useful foot solders if you can recruit them?

appreciatorBus··on Scientists find molecular-level evidence for two structures in liquid water
[flagged]
appreciatorBus··on 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech
I think all of this hinges on whether or not you think it was a protest. If they had been peacefully sitting outside the facility holding signs, I think you'd have a case that the sentencing is insane. But if they were actively planning a break-in & preparing to use deadly force, that's quite another matter. I haven't spent a lot of timing reading about it, but what I have read suggests it was much closer to the latter.
appreciatorBus··on Historical memory prices 1960-2026
> you need to pair it with some kind of demand data for it to actually tell you anything.

Again, this is entirely dependant on who is consuming the statistic and for what purpose. For some use cases, yes demand data will be quite crucial. For others it will not. It's quite apparent the site's author doesn't see this as crucial and for the purposes I need to consider memory pricing, I agree.

appreciatorBus··on Historical memory prices 1960-2026
But relative usefulness is entirely subjective, making it a meaningless unit. Depending on your use case you may need 256 GB or 0.5 GB.

The audience who would benefit from hypothetical $/usefulness would be people who don’t know what memory is and don’t know what’s inside of their computers, or what it does. This is a fine audience to be in and to serve, but obviously not the audience of that website and not HN.

If you think that audience is under served for memory market statistics, I encourage you to make such a website and serve that audience.

For people on HN, who do you know what memory is, $/GB is a fine metric.

appreciatorBus··on Wikipedia's Cofounder Has Been Banned from Wikipedia
A couple of well researched examples

https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/how-wikipedia-whitewashe...

https://archive.ph/ZqHRu

To be clear, I'm sure anyone who wants to can dig up examples of other types of bias, and of course, truly excellent articles on non-political topics. If you restrict your reading to avoid anything related to contentious political narratives, you'll probably do ok. It just seems like the organization as a whole tilts in one particular direction, and this seems bad for something that is supposed to be a neutral source of knowledge.

appreciatorBus··on Wikipedia's Cofounder Has Been Banned from Wikipedia
Liberal, yes. Progressive/left, no.
appreciatorBus··on Israeli founder faces backlash on mobile OS launch
People like dumb shit all the time if they think they are scoring points for their team. The concept of backlash implies that a change in opinion but I suspect those 187k likers would have liked just about anything you care to post that was anti-israel, anti-west, anti-us, pro-hamas, pro-forced-collectivism, etc. I don't think anyone's mind was changed by the quote tweet.
appreciatorBus··on The AirPods Effect
Yeah, I have noticed this as well. When I’m trying to solve a difficult problem, it seems that way more ideas arrive to me unprompted when I take a break from heavy listening.
appreciatorBus··on Noise infusion banned from statistical products published by Census Bureau
This is silly.

An argument about whether or not to deploy differential privacy on large statistical databases has no bearing whatsoever on whether or not you give your address to have a package delivered. If you want the package delivered, you have to give your address.

On the other hand, it’s not at all clear that people should have to involuntarily, my force of law, offer up all sorts of personal details about their lives. And questions about whether the use of differential privacy can or should justify the collection of sensitive information are quite valid.

The census is justified by the idea that it will help us plan for the future. But the track record of central planning is poor to disastrous.

A small example: in theory population changes could inform land use decisions. In practice however, the ability of population to increase is softly capped by the amount of housing that exists, or will exist. If you restrict or frustrate housing, you will also restrict people from living where they want to live. Then the planners will point to the census data and tell you that nobody wants to live there and therefore there’s no need for change.

Ironically, if you wanted to measure where people want to live in order to get information for planning purposes, the number is right there and doesn’t require any personal data collection at all - it’s the price. (in this example $ per square foot of floor space). But in my experience people who like central planning don’t believe in prices so they ignore that and they look at their reams of personal data and they conclude that all is well in the world. It is hard for me to be sympathetic if one day folks like that had have less data to look at.

appreciatorBus··on Noise infusion banned from statistical products published by Census Bureau
> Differential privacy makes this trade-off explicit, and thus impossible to ignore.

I think he has it backwards here.

Techniques like differential privacy hide the fact that a trade-off exists, except for a small cadre of experts who live and breathe this stuff.

I don’t know enough to defend this decision, but it strikes me that if there is a real trade-off, not having access to these techniques will force people other than statisticians to confront the trade-off.

If data about the public is so dangerous that we must disguise the results, then perhaps its data we shouldn’t be collecting in the first place.

appreciatorBus··on Noise infusion banned from statistical products published by Census Bureau
Then maybe the data shouldn’t be collected in the first place?
appreciatorBus··on An Ohio Valley 100k-watt FM signal is severed in broad daylight
Sure, it’s impossible to misconstrue that the statue of that size has or had value to someone. But that still doesn’t mean it will have value to you.

Someone who’s never seen it before, who has no exposure to the cultures that produced it or the discourse around it, can be impressed by the size, but otherwise not care.

Worse, if such a person is actively hostile to the cultures that produce it, then learning that it is valuable to that culture will lead them to assign negative value to it.

appreciatorBus··on The company I work for is losing all of its humanity, I don't know where to go
We should abolish zoning so that people can live closer to work.
← PreviousPage 3 of 22Next →