HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arctic-true

434 karma · joined December 19, 2025

submissionscomments
arctic-true··on Gemini 3.8 Flash and 3.8 Flash Cyber
I’m very curious about your esoteric public figures benchmark, do you ask it in English or Korean to identify the person? Does it change the result? I wonder if having data labeled in only a given language (or web sources in only a given language) change the output.
arctic-true··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
I think that is tied to the general trend that people see themselves as far less replaceable than others. And I’m not sure that people who don’t need a salary are exactly objective about it - unless you mean people who live off the state or something, those are people who need their capital reserves to continue to appreciate in order to sustain their lifestyles, and are thus relying on the destruction of white collar work to justify the valuations of the technology companies which are underpinning the strength of the markets. It’s like saying in the 19th century that only the propertied classes should be allowed to make decisions about labor policy, because the laborers themselves have their judgment clouded by their position.

But I take your point, and I only brought up the o3 example to emphasize that people on both sides of the booster/doubter debate can be prisoners of the moment. There are boosters eternally convinced that the utopia (or armageddon, for the doomer-inclined) is either already here or imminent, and there are doubters eternally convinced that we have reached the peak. One of them will eventually be right, but neither has been yet. You can’t fault one of them for calling their shot if you’re not willing to see it happening on the other side.

arctic-true··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
This is exactly right. Now, that does mean something about Zitron: he’s a pundit, not an expert or a forecasting genius. You could point to any number of analogous booster types. Twitter/X somehow loves pushing these people onto my recommended feed. I remember reading breathless threads about how o3 was going to single-handedly end white collar work. There are just more of that sort of person, so none of them in particular gets the same amount of attention as Zitron, who seems to be the only person willing to go on the record against AI. Maybe his overall worldview is sound, and maybe it isn’t. But he’s not really making confident, specific predictions about the future.

Which leads me to a criticism of the piece: several assertions are described as “Wrong,” with no explanation or citation, which are not obviously wrong to my mind. For example, the assertion that “DeepSeek has commoditized the [LLM]” is at least debatable. It is a prospect that the major labs seem to have at least considered.

arctic-true··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
To commit fraud you have to lie, deceive, or conceal. All of this bonkers financing is happening in broad daylight, announced to the markets, and met with rave reviews. I tend to agree with Zitron that the whole thing is a castle made of sand - not because the tech is bad or useless but because the financing, in its scope and structure, is so outlandish - but you can build a castle made of sand as long as you don’t tell anyone it’s made of steel.
arctic-true··on Judge rules Trump administration’s blacklisting of Anthropic was illegal
A lot of folks here are misreading “irreparable harm,” which means “something that cannot be fixed with money later.” Even if this somehow screwed Anthropic so badly that they lost the AI race and Dario was relegated to the permanent underclass, that is an injury which could in theory be compensated with money - a jaw-dropping quantity of money, but money nonetheless. Irreparable harm can never be fixed even with infinite money. For example, if you think you’re the rightful owner of a piece of real estate, and someone else tries to sell it to a third party, you are faced with the prospect of irreparable harm: all the money in the world can’t FORCE the buyer to sell it back to you if the transaction goes through, and a piece of real estate is completely unique and non-fungible (at least in the eyes of the law), so no amount of money could get you the same thing.

Edit to add: Anthropic did show a risk of irreparable harm because their opponent is the government, and the government typically can’t be forced to pay damages (subject to limited statutory exceptions).

arctic-true··on Where did all the public bathrooms go?
It began in 1953 when thorazine was introduced on the premise that it would allow previously institutionalized people to live normal lives with only outpatient care. This turbocharged the movement to shutter mental institutions, and their populations began to crater around 1956. [0] For a lot of people, thorazine and its descendants have been nothing short of miraculous and have lived up to the promise. But not for everyone, and in the name of charity and respect for individual autonomy, we have chosen to allow these people to either live in awful conditions and fend for themselves or do something prison-worthy. So, while there isn’t great data on homelessness from before the 21st century, the root cause of much of it - a societal refusal to recognize certain people as requiring lifelong care for mental illness - begins in 1953. [0] https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?refe...
arctic-true··on Australia passes law to levy tech giants that fail to pay for local news
It would be very difficult to enforce, but a mechanism to force scrapers to pay would probably be more effective than this. The social media sites can live without local news. Web search and LLM providers cannot live without new data and up-to-date information about the world.
arctic-true··on Should AI labs be treated like the owners of dangerous animals?
Difference there is you need a physical body firing the ghost gun. There can be witnesses who saw a shooter, you can look at cameras to track their physical location, and if they discard the weapon they leave fingerprints.
arctic-true··on Should AI labs be treated like the owners of dangerous animals?
How are you going to figure that out? You can’t capture an agent in a jar and convince it to confess. As we saw with the HF incident, even highly sophisticated actors need a good chunk of time and manpower to trace these things. And I suspect the folks who are going to have the most success with LLM-powered cybercrime are going to know how to cover their tracks reasonably well.
arctic-true··on Americans are rallying against data centers. Surprisingly few are getting built
I think the “in their neighborhoods” thing is really the key. These things have got to be poison for property values. Younger, less wealthy people have economic anxiety about AI for fear of displacement and oppose data centers on that basis - more data centers = more AI. Older, wealthier people have less intrinsic reason to oppose the technology. But anything that threatens property values, be it a data center, a jail, a landfill, et cetera, must be resisted at all costs.
arctic-true··on The AI Demand Bubble
Unfortunately I agree and I think we are going to be trapped in a double whammy scenario: genAI is good enough to justify significant layoffs without being profitable enough to justify the investment. The pain on the stock market will cause employers to adopt AI to shrink their workforces even more than they might have otherwise.
arctic-true··on The AI Demand Bubble
The failures of past doomsayers are important to keep in mind. It’s hard to say “well, but we know things they didn’t know at the time, but this time that won’t happen.” I will observe, however, that Uber’s revenues come from consumers. Consumers are never going to be willing to spend enough on AI to justify OAI and Anthropic’s spending, even if a single company captured all of their demand. They recognized this and pivoted to software engineering and enterprise customers. These are much more sophisticated buyers than someone trying to catch a cab or get a burrito delivered, and more able to be patient or expend resources to find a better, cheaper provider.

It also bears mentioning that if any particular AI lab manages to survive and succeed in the way Uber has, there will be several multibillion dollar corporate gravestones behind it. In fact, I don’t even think that nobody can be the Uber of AI. I just think it can’t be OAI or Anthropic. The debt is too great and it’s priced under old assumptions.

arctic-true··on The AI Demand Bubble
Here again you have network effects, though. I personally have an iPhone because it’s what all my friends and family use and there are communication functions that are much easier to engage with if you all have the same sort of device. It’s also not trivial to switch, you need to, at minimum, go to the store or wait for something to get delivered - to say nothing of the wasted money from buying multiple phones. If I have unused OpenAI tokens I can burn them on side quests or something. If you have an unused iPhone you need to find a way to sell/return it or eat the cost. There’s also potential violations of your contract with your mobile carrier, etc.

If I’m using ChatGPT and I decide I want to use DeepSeek instead, I am only a couple of keystrokes away from doing it, and that’s if I have never used DeepSeek before.

As for your “corner the market” scenario, it’s possible, but unlikely. It is too easy to enter; even if you somehow got all of the major players to commit to growing their margins - and somehow manage not to violate the antitrust laws in the process - a newcomer could spoil the party far easier than it could in an industry like mobile phones (where you need tons of components, manufacturing capacity, network relationships, etc.) or ride sharing (where you need a large user base to justify your existence).

arctic-true··on The AI Demand Bubble
The cash burn is not the problem. You can’t build a big business without it. The difference is network effects. With ride sharing apps, you need a lot of drivers and riders collected on one platform. It is nearly always better, for both drivers and riders, to switch to a larger platform. Thus, it was worthwhile to spend the money to become the biggest fish. Once this was accomplished, Uber could raise prices because switching to a smaller rival would mean less availability, and thus less utility (for riders) or less earnings (for drivers).

With AI, by contrast - at least in its current state - there is no benefit to be gained from using the same model provider as somebody else. Switching is trivial for most use cases. Since they can’t capture consumers using network effects, the labs only have the levers of price and quality to pull to acquire and retain customers. To pull the price lever, they have to reduce their revenues; to pull the quality lever, they have to increase their expenditures. Indeed, they are sowing the seeds of their own demise by making inference cheaper and more efficient: since they can’t exercise pricing pressure, efficiency gains will be passed on to the consumer, which is unsustainable if your GPU debt is priced based on yesterday’s efficiency expectations.

arctic-true··on The AI Demand Bubble
Several top level comments are attacks on the author’s credibility that do not engage the substance of the piece at all. I think the fundamental problem for people on all sides of the various debates surrounding AI is that “AI is a powerful, transformative technology” and “Anthropic and OpenAI are both doomed, and this poses risks to the broader economy” are compatible statements of fact. Just because you believe (1) does not justify dismissing (2) out of hand.

(2) is the point of this article. OAI and Anthropic are spending by far the most money of anyone in the space, as the article rightly notes, but they have no path to becoming profitable, meaning they cannot occupy that position forever. The other entities that rely on their spending to support their own margins - in this case the major cloud providers - are vulnerable to revenue collapse if OAI and Anthropic fail.

The premise most would disagree with is that the labs have no path to profitability. Two points support this: demand for inference is functionally infinite, or at least is so great that it is not meaningful to discuss its limits; and the labs are profitable on inference and are only taking losses to compete with one another. Some would extend this further and say that once the tech is good enough it will be able to drastically reduce their costs by some combination of speeding up research and creating efficiencies to reduce compute spend.

These are valid criticisms. But “AI has gotten better since he started saying ‘AI bad’” is not a reason to ignore the fact that major cloud computing providers are taking on massive new debt while becoming increasingly dependent on only two customers who face meaningful margin pressures. Unless OAI and Anthropic can find a durable moat and a means to exert pricing power, this is a serious issue going forward. That is true whether we wind up with a machine god (although we might have bigger problems in that case) or if we plateau at current capabilities.

arctic-true··on Study found that young adults have grown less hopeful and more angry about AI
This is an underappreciated point. The economy would likely be in freefall without AI.

Yes, things look bleak for current college grads. The bitter pill to swallow is that they began college in the boom times of 2021-22, and they saw the college grads of those years walking straight off campus into high-paying jobs which don’t exist anymore. They only existed because of the obscene gobs of money whizzing around the economy post-COVID. Whether the shrinkage is due in part or in whole to AI is in the eye of the beholder. But if we had fallen into a broad-based recession, the numbers would look a lot bleaker. Plenty of companies that could automate away entry level positions with current tech haven’t done so, whether due to organizational inertia or ignorance or whatever. That organizational inertia would’ve been much more easily overcome by a market collapse.

arctic-true··on Who is Satoshi Nakamoto? My quest to unmask Bitcoin's creator
China probably doesn’t accept Dominican pesos, either, and yet you’d be hard pressed to say that somebody with 100 billion Dominican pesos just has some random numbers. If you can exchange something for another form of value, then it has value. I think the trouble here is that there’s just nobody out there who would actually give you $100 billion worth of value for this particular asset. At least not as a lump sum.
arctic-true··on Who is Satoshi Nakamoto? My quest to unmask Bitcoin's creator
I tend to agree, but for the sake of argument: it’s possible that he’s such a true believer that he’d see cashing out as a betrayal. Alternatively, he might understand that cashing out would significantly aid the (clearly large number of) people engaged in unmasking him. Further, he may simply realize that liquidating holdings of his size would drastically alter the market in ways that could end with the whole thing coming apart.
arctic-true··on ML promises to be profoundly weird
This is a limitation of the training data. If you were uncertain about something, you wouldn’t write a book about it. The kinds of people you’re talking about tend to generate far more text in their lives than others, because they can spend more time generating - writing books, blogposts, whatever - and less time thinking and working and actually doing things. The models never say they’re uncertain because we never say we’re uncertain, or at least we don’t write it down anywhere.
arctic-true··on AI helps add 10k more photos to OldNYC
Do you have any recommendations for colorization tools? I agree that all of the popular image models subtly tweak faces, it is very uncanny when working with pictures of people I knew before they passed. In a pre-GPT age, there were some good but not great colorization tools, and as far as I can tell you can’t get better-than-2020 performance unless you’re willing to get your expression adjusted or your eyebrows redone.
arctic-true··on 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit
Until the humanoid robots gain the ability to process caffeine, then we’re all hosed.
arctic-true··on How the AI Bubble Bursts
The demand is real. The tech is real. The economics are completely unsustainable. Switching costs and barriers to entry are too low, operating costs are too high. And if the tech improves, it actually makes it even easier for competitors to swoop in and take market share. Not long ago, an agent that was 80% as good as SOTA was not usable. A year from now, an agent that is 80% as good as SOTA will be better than the best agent is today. We have it on good authority that today’s agents are very good, very useful. Why bother paying full price?

This is deeply ironic in a way. Because the whole premise of AI labor replacement is that AI does not need to be better than human labor, it just needs to be cheaper with acceptable performance. But the same is true one step down: discount AI doesn’t need to be better than bleeding-edge AI, it just needs to be cheaper with acceptable performance.

arctic-true··on How the AI Bubble Bursts
I’m not talking about training costs. I’m talking about startup costs. You have to pay for GPUs (or to rent data centers). You have to pay for the electricity that runs those data centers, and in a lot of cases these frontier labs are building the data centers on credit, so you need to pay for the construction, the materials, etc. If it was as simple as “running the GPUs costs less than we charge for it,” I might be inclined to agree. But the GPUs don’t just appear by magic.
arctic-true··on How the AI Bubble Bursts
Profitable on what basis? They generate more revenue than the cost of electricity? Does that factor in the cost to service the massive, multi-layer cake of debt that was necessary to even begin to serve inference in the first place - not from a training perspective but from a hardware and facilities perspective?
arctic-true··on How the AI Bubble Bursts
The difference is switching costs and the viability of alternatives. Even open source models are only a few months behind the frontier labs, which is a long time in tech but practically no time at all in the eyes of a business consumer. At best, one of the frontier labs will survive and get to flex its hegemonic muscle. But billions and billions of dollars worth of investments still get wiped out in that scenario, which I would still qualify as the bubble popping. This would be doubly true if the winner winds up being Google or Microsoft.
arctic-true··on How the AI Bubble Bursts
But this is exactly the problem - we have to take it on faith that inference is profitable because nobody actually knows. It’s hard to even define what that would mean, and while I am suspicious of claims that frontier lab CEOs are just out-and-out liars or bad people, defining and calculating the real cost of inference would be time- and labor-intensive in its own right and there is no strong incentive to do it other than “tech reporters are curious.” Until the IPO, we just won’t know.
arctic-true··on Anthropic Update on Session Limits
The winner will be the last man standing. The company which is able to continue subsidizing tokens after all others have been forced to throttle and raise prices. Soak up the market share, wait for your rivals’ investors to get cold feet, then raise prices the morning after the last one folds. (It’s Google it’s always been Google)
arctic-true··on The AI Industry Is Lying to You
Not sure it qualifies as an “LLM prediction,” but he was adamant that Nvidia would not come through with the $100 billion funding round, and sure enough they did not.
arctic-true··on OpenAI Has New Focus (on the IPO)
I found Gemini to keep asking the same follow-up questions regardless of my responses. In discussing a health topic, it repeatedly offered recipes for healthy snacks - 4 times, before I finally affirmatively said “no, I do not need snack recipes.” It dutifully stopped. Not quite clickbait, but it had very clearly decided where it wanted the conversation to go.
arctic-true··on I was interviewed by an AI bot for a job
I had this experience when I was trying to find an apartment - multiple different buildings very clearly had AI-generated responses. (To all you builders out there: quick replies are great. Instant replies are suspicious.) I immediately stopped considering them as options. If you can’t be bothered to have a human respond to my email when I’m trying to give you my money, what level of service can I expect once I’m already obligated to pay rent?
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →