HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arduanika

1,478 karma · joined December 9, 2014

submissionscomments
arduanika··on Online age verification is the hill to die on
What he had in mind. I have no clue what the suggestion was.
arduanika··on Opus 4.7 knows the real Kelsey
> Claude Opus 4.6 insisted on Elizabeth Sandifer

Off-topic, but this guess was hilarious. Like, all the other wrong guesses were people like Yglesias who are maybe half a degree removed from Piper herself, in her same camp, and then one model guesses Sandifer who hates all their guts.

arduanika··on Online age verification is the hill to die on
Absolutely not!

> How would it read?

Sounds like you don't really care for this idea, so maybe just have Claude write it for you.

arduanika··on Online age verification is the hill to die on
Holy crap, I only just saw your license agreement. Oh no. We've argued on here before, although this time we're in agreement. Please don't use this hidden license to dox me!

(It's an unenforceable joke, right? There's no way I'm bound by anything here other than maybe the site ToS.)

arduanika··on Online age verification is the hill to die on
Caring enough to put in the effort of thinking and writing is not a "tangential issue". Laziness is a substantive defect, and sadly, I think that kelseyfrog has clocked this one correctly. There are borderline cases, but the cadence of this tweet thread is unmistakeable.

We don't have to live like this. We don't have to accept it. We don't have to upvote it even if we agree (as I do) with the explicit point. The medium is the message, and the message that this poster is putting out here is that online age verification isn't actually worth getting that worked up about.

arduanika··on A Man Who Invented the Future
And all we got was this wide-ranging essay that introduces about 140 different characters.
arduanika··on A Man Who Invented the Future
What a fun little essay. It takes a lot of skill to write such a nonlinear story of ideas and history, and to have the structure and the actual point emerge gradually like this. It also takes some attention and some faith on the part of the reader, and it sounds like a few people here got frustrated that it doesn't feel like a normal essay that tells you upfront where it's going and why.

One commenter saw the long second sentence and assumed that the author had messed up somehow, instead of clocking the heads-up that this is piece is going to be a bit unusual and demanding. We're slowly getting used to how LLMs keep every sentence short enough to digest without much effort.

An LLM could never write this, as others here have pointed out, at least not without some very involved, nonstandard prompting. I think it's going to be important for our brains to keep reading stuff like this that is structurally unique. It almost reads like a miniature Benjamin Labutut story.

arduanika··on John Ternus to become Apple CEO
Tapping a hardware guy as CEO sends a good signal, at least to me, looking in from the outside. The company is leading from its strength, and getting back to its roots. I wonder how Woz feels today, seeing this.

But somewhere in the mix, Apple could also really use another great product mind, like the other Steve. It has been too long since the last era-defining product from Cupertino.

I have no idea what that next big thing would be. And of course, a bad product mind in charge is worse than none at all! If the next big leaps come from other companies while Apple just keeps doing what it does best in the hardware categories that it already dominates, then I guess that's fine, too.

arduanika··on Tim Cook to become Apple Executive Chairman. John Ternus to become CEO
Yeah. Can we get a title change please?

Among the dup stories submitted, this one has the best content but the worst title.

arduanika··on John Ternus to become Apple CEO
He already had the trail of his retirement mapped out, and picked the perfect moment to blaze it.
arduanika··on Stop trying to engineer your way out of listening to people
> 2. To truly listen means to place yourself mentally and physically in a vulnerable state. Because you will likely hear things that run contrary to your experience, beliefs, and worldview. Judging people is often a self protection mechanism; which means you will almost never listen to someone.

A gem, thanks.

This can be especially rough for fans of early pg essays. You might find out that you didn't actually keep your identity so small after all. A double whammy!

arduanika··on Stop trying to engineer your way out of listening to people
Depends on the context. Maybe consult with one of the tone poem people before trying to play hardball at office politics.
arduanika··on Stop trying to engineer your way out of listening to people
There is a well-documented spectrum from direct to indirect styles of communication, among both cultures and individuals. The "tone poem" observation is a true description of that fact, even if it's a bit hyperbolic and colorful.

> Language is a representation of our world...we all... will use different words to describe similar-ish concepts...

Strangely enough, both the direct and the indirect communicators live under the postmodern condition, and yet somehow, the stylistic differences persist! Somehow, despite all the smart-sounding things you could say about semiotics or relativism, individuals are all different!

The problem (or at least, one of the problems) with what the manager did is that he dumped his employee's prose into the LLM in a one-size-fits-all way.

arduanika··on 10 years ago, someone wrote a test for Servo that included an expiry in 2026
Thanks! I think about this concept a lot, and now I know there's a name for it. "Preparedness paradox". I'll have to remember that.

And to your point, Y2K is right there on the wiki page for it.

arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
> ignoring the billions of people who don't commit violence

> taken as evidence that the whole group is violent

Where did I say that?

I am not the one who put forward a categorical statement here. You're the one who appealed to a fantasy world where "the only people that reach your conclusion are ones that don't actually subscribe to the philosophy". The categorical claim is yours, and the error is yours, but rather than own it, you tell yourself a creative story about what I believe, and you continue saying all this inane stuff about how there's violence in every group.

As I have already told you, I am happy to consider all those inane, obvious points. It's important context! But first, I want to see evidence that you are capable of noticing and learning from your own sloppy, wishful thinking here. You have to actually admit that these ideas have consequences, before we can start relativizing them away.

arduanika··on Airline worker arrested after sharing photos of bomb damage in WhatsApp group
Interesting, thanks. I guess I'll carry on feeling marginally superior for choosing Signal over the others as my default, while remaining bleak about the overall landscape.
arduanika··on Airline worker arrested after sharing photos of bomb damage in WhatsApp group
> The UAE government owns majority holdings in telecom companies Etisalat and Du. This gives security services the power to observe all communications on their networks.

> The Arab state has also used the Israeli-developed software Pegasus which allows agents to listen into private calls and read messages, even if they are shared on encrypted apps like WhatsApp,.

This seems to be the key part from a tech standpoint. Notice that it doesn't come out and say whether Pegasus played a part in this particular arrest, or the telecoms, or both, but it seems to be implied.

Also, I'm intrigued by the punctuation error at the end: "...like WhatsApp,." Did an earlier draft go on to list others? Does Pegasus help governments read messages from Telegram? Signal? It would be interesting to know more.

arduanika··on Good Sleep, Good Learning (2012)
Closer to the Time Cube of sleep!

It's an impressive achievement, really. Here's a shorter page of his I've found more digestible:

https://supermemo.guru/wiki/Curing_DSPS_and_insomnia

arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
None of this is responsive to my point in the comment you're responding to.

My point is, why would you be talking about a counterfactual world where people did not attempt to kill for this philosophy? Why would you be entertaining a categorical claim like, "the only people that reach your conclusion are ones that don't actually subscribe to the philosophy", when that claim is manifestly violated by a violent act just a few short days ago? How is it inconceivable to you that someone might read the dire doomer rhetoric in the way that Moreno-Gama did?

The only way you could write something like that is if your head is in the sand. I am willing to entertain your relativism, your base rate logic, your analogy to Jesus, sure, obviously there's some merit to that line of argument... but first you need to please pull your head out of the sand.

We can only talk about base rates if you stop trying to invalidate the data.

arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
Fair enough. Retry: What I'm objecting to is your brilliant, insightful point, to which you are attached enough that you've injected it into this thread where it is, by your own admission, irrelevant. They're resorting to violence because they're unpopular, not because democracy failed to do its job here.
arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
> "If the only people that reach your conclusion are ones that don't actually subscribe to the philosophy, then it doesn't matter, because no one is actually acting on those conclusions."

What an odd thing to say right after young Mr. Moreno-Gama reached that conclusion and did subscribe to the philosophy, when it does matter, because he did actually act on those conclusions.

How odd to introduce a hypothetical that amounts to, "what if this philosophy didn't ever lead to violence?", right after it did.

Or are you trying to pull a No True Scotsman on me here?

arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
I am aware of their arguments, yes, but what I'm objecting to is that you're bringing this irrelevant hobbyhorse into a discussion of a truly fringe ideology. We're not talking about a classic G&P-style issue where the voters and the elites disagree. Nobody cares for the AI doomers -- not elites, not voters, nobody.

When you talk about "participatory democracy" in a thread like this, you are enabling them in their delusion that people do care. The AI safetyist think tanks put out these pushpolls trying to convince themselves that voters care about AI doom. They seal up the walls of their echo chamber, and they believe themselves to be heroes. Then one day, one of them throws a Molotov, and nobody is surprised.

arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
It is true that only Yudkowsky gets to say what the rational conclusion of his ideas are. Nobody else gets to speculate. Only the pope of rationalism, because he's the rational one here. See? It's right there in the name!

> this piece of slop

Citation needed. Or maybe we need to update the title of that children's book for internet arguments: Everyone Who Disagrees With Me Is Slop.

The Yud post you linked is not slop, either. It's not LLM-generated, nor is it insincere. But I do have to point out: He's the one who is slinging the tsunami of words here, not Alexander Campbell.

arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
> "fix participatory democracy"

Ah yes, a popular codeword for "I did not get my way".

There is no electoral majority behind the AI doomer cult. It is not a failure of "democracy" that they haven't gotten what they want. It is a failure of their activism, or just the general unpalatability of their wild ideas, or both. They don't get to throw Molotovs just because they lose.

arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
Upvoted because this is an interesting take, but I disagree at least somewhat. I think you should be wary whenever you've narrowed down your options to, "in order to solve the top-priority problem X, our only hope is solution Y."

I agree that some technological solution might be the key to dealing with the climate, and that maybe robots would be part of such a solution, maybe powered by similar techniques as the current wave of AI. It's not an insane scenario, but it's worth keeping your perspective open to other possible developments.

arduanika··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
This has been decades in the making. We had premonitions of the violence that would come, for example with the Zizians. Get ready for what happens when a million blogposts worth of bad philosophy, bad analogies, and anti-institutionalist hubris are deeply indoctrinated into a vast, decentralized network of highly capable engineering minds who lack common sense and normal restraints.

They hate the framing that LLMs are just stochastic parrots, which is ironic, because Yudkowsky's many parrots are (latent, until now) stochastic terrorists.

arduanika··on Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident
https://xkcd.com/1053/
arduanika··on How NASA built Artemis II’s fault-tolerant computer
I'm not sure you really understood my comment. A large portion of the kind of value I'm talking about comes from attempting the hard thing. If these chickens do not hatch that will be tragic, but we will still have learned something from it. In some ways, we will have learned even more, by getting taught about what we don't know.

Anyway, let's all hope for a safe landing tonight.

arduanika··on How NASA built Artemis II’s fault-tolerant computer
You could even say that part of the value of Artemis is that we're remembering how to do some very hard things, including the software side. This is something that you can't fake. In a world where one of the more plausible threats of AI is the atrophy of real human skills -- the goose that lays the golden eggs that trains the models -- this is a software feat where I'd claim you couldn't rely on vibe code, at least not fully.

That alone is worth my tax dollars.

arduanika··on How NASA built Artemis II’s fault-tolerant computer
Please, this is hacker news. Nothing else is hard outside of our generic software jobs, and we could totally solve any other industry in an afternoon.
← PreviousPage 2 of 21Next →