HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arduanika

1,478 karma · joined December 9, 2014

submissionscomments
arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
If you want a citation that EA belief does, in practice, encourage crime, I would direct you to literally all the reporting on FTX.

But if I'm reading you correctly, you're asking instead for a citation of some EA materials in which EA leadership says, "do fraud". There is no such citation. That is not how this works. Looking at history, a recurring pattern is that good-sounding ideas can have bad consequences. When it happens, they rarely come out and say "do bad stuff".

> please explain why a belief or movement should be judged by what a few members do?

A belief or movement should be judged by the total impact across all members. I'm not just talking about a naive weighted sum -- that would just be more utilitarianism, which is the evil idea we need to unlearn here.

A better framing is that you're trying to infer a risk distribution based on the observed data. In so doing, you incorporate an understanding of the history of altruism, where it's way easier to do major damage than major good. Therefore, you heavily weight a downside event, because this is merely a taste of the true tail risk.

Tail risk is easy to underestimate (see the work of Nassim Taleb on this). If you throw out negative data points, you're making it even harder to appreciate the worst case.

> I am making this post because I do not like seeing groups, organizations, and movements blamed for what a few members do.

I suppose this is a fine instinct in general. And I'm all for protecting minority viewpoints and their right to think freely.

But when a group makes wild claims about how its revolutionary thought process can discover shortcuts to astronomical benefits in the distant future, then they're operating on pure ideology without much of a feedback loop. In such a case, the question of the ideology's tail risk becomes extra important.

You may notice that by my reasoning here, the lessons from FTX should have less bearing on how we view the "neartermist" cause areas, where EAs are measuring their impact and reacting to facts on the ground. This is indeed true. I believe that early EA did a lot of good, and there are still a few "neartermist" EAs left, doing decent work.

So to bring the thread full circle, this distinction is all the more reason to celebrate the end of FHI, which helped drive the shift within EA toward longtermism, where their utilitarianism is a poor fit and, I would claim, a danger to humanity.

arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
I hate to break it to you, but these scholars are not going to jail for their bad ideas. That's not how a free society works. We'll have to settle for general disrepute.
arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
The philosopher David Thorstad keeps a blog with critiques of EA and related ideas. His writing strikes me as fairly patient and in good faith. (Or at least, it's more measured than some of my own comments on this thread!)

He wrote this good dissection of the Bostrom email controversy, and why the apology doesn't cut it:

https://ineffectivealtruismblog.com/2023/01/12/off-series-th...

That said -- it did happen way back in the 90's. There has to be a place for forgiveness, even for imperfect people offering imperfect apologies. My sense is that there's plenty of other things to criticize that are more recent and more central to this general school of thought.

arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
Sorry, you've lost me here. Which part of my argument are referring to?

I'm not criticizing a group, btw. I'm criticizing ideas. Ideas have specific consequences. Some ideas inspire good actions. Some inspire bad actions that outweigh the good.

When an idea claims to have big consequences in the distant future, we can look at its consequences in the present day to help us guess the likely nature of those future consequences.

Oxford deals in ideas, and gets to decide which ones to host and fund. Sometimes they get it wrong, mistaking bad ideas for good ones. That's unfortunate, but it's nice when they come around to the right assessment eventually.

arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
You're correct that reputation laundering is a thing, but in the FTX case, the facts do not match that pattern. These were true believers.
arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
> to assume that SBF only turned to a life of crime because the EA movement lured him into it.

It's not an assumption. It's a matter of record, understood by anyone who knows the basics of the FTX saga. SBF is a lifelong utilitarian, and his co-conspirators were also committed EAs. Anyone who obscures that fact is abetting the campaign of obfuscation.

> Many of the people involved seem to have good intentions

Yup. That includes Sam and his friends. How did that turn out?

> a lot of money has been donated

To borrow your language, "it's quite a leap to assume" that anyone donated money just because EA lured them into it. How do we know they weren't going to behave altruistically in the absence of the movement?

Why is there an isolated demand for rigor when confronting the movement's adverse effects? Do you think that Sam is inherently a criminal, with ideology playing no role, whereas EA donors aren't inherently generous?

> to objectively good causes

Fair enough. I will concede that there were a few of these. In some cases, early EA principles may have helped people arrive at these good ideas in a way that wouldn't have happened without the movement.

It's just that, I get annoyed when people dismiss the downsides, writing them off as aberrations or lone bad actors. And given the major flaws in the philosophy, it's hard to shake my suspicion that most of their longtermist explorations are worse than just "squishy". It seems quite plausible that they're doing more harm than good.

arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
Sure, and Beria is different from Marx.

Nobody in this entire movement wants to take responsibility for what anybody else does, and it's honestly exhausting. They have this dense belief that once a thinker releases his ideas into the water, he bears no responsibility for the crimes and excesses they inspire.

arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
Everybody who disagrees with me is incompetent.
arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
At least Lewis admits it. For me, that goes a long way.
arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
While I do appreciate this reference and agree with CS Lewis here, I think it's a bit of a stretch to draw a connection between him and the present day Oxford philosophy faculty. He was a single don from nearly a century ago, who now really belongs to the canon at large rather than a single university. Perhaps the current faculty all hold some special reverence for him, but it seems more likely that modern mainstream philosophers (not only at Oxford) merely share with Lewis some basic grasp of common sense, which informs their skepticism of FHI and EA.
arduanika··on Future of Humanity Institute shuts down
Good riddance to these ideologues. It's a shame that the announcement shows no trace of remorse for the crimes they inspired (e.g. at FTX) or the lives that have been ruined by the cults to which they lent academic legitimacy. Instead, their demise is chalked up to some bland moaning about "administrative headwinds".

Realistically, we're probably only looking at a brief respite before they regroup under some other benevolent-sounding name. Be on the lookout for their next incarnation, and let's hope that Oxford won't repeat the mistake of allowing them to evangelize under the seal of a great university.

(Edit in response to causal's question below):

They legitimized longtermism and pseudo-rational AI panic, which transformed much of EA into an apocalyptic sect, with all the high-demand group dynamics that come with it. Their research created an air of urgency and expediency which, among other bad outcomes, inspired the devoted EAs at FTX to justify their crimes to themselves. These crimes resulted in privation and a few suicides for their innocent depositors. To this day, there are EAs who rationalize these crimes against their outgroup as not that bad, considering that the "Future of Humanity" is at stake.

You can look at the movement and find plenty of other negative effects of this urgency and expediency, but for me personally, the FTX crimes are what woke me up to the true nature of these hazardous ideas.

arduanika··on Summers: Inflation Reached 18% in 2022 Using the Government's Previous Formula
The pandemic was worldwide, and every other central bank has been printing, too. Depending on which currency you're trading against, that could be a factor. For a while in 2021-2, non-dollar currencies were inflating even faster, so DXY actually went up even as the dollar weakened against goods and services. Even if the tables have turned and the dollar is weakening faster now, it's not like everybody else has actually reigned in their own printing.
arduanika··on The return of never-ending job interviews: 'It can go beyond the pale'
Where exactly is the reference to colonization in the Mackenzie quote? This one: "when we would be blessed beyond the pale of reason, we are blessed imperfectly". Sorry, I'm not seeing it.

"Many people believe..."

Name one. Have a free do-over: pick a source you actually agree with this time. Make sure it doesn't quote any reference books that you distrust.

arduanika··on The return of never-ending job interviews: 'It can go beyond the pale'
Indeed, we're even curious enough to read your link! And to discover that it says the opposite of what you claimed! What you're seeing is in fact a strong emotional reaction to misinformation.

And your implicit call to action was crystal clear. Don't be coy.

arduanika··on The return of never-ending job interviews: 'It can go beyond the pale'
Hmm, so if you're interested in my answer, I guess I would ask you how you want to proceed. Do we want to accept that OED is an trustworthy catalog of etymological facts, or not? If not, why? Do you think the quotes it pulls from the 1700's are fabricated? Do you think it's suppressing an earlier usage of "pale of settlement"? What is your claim, exactly?

You're the one whose source was quoting from OED, so you tell me. It'll be easier if we're starting from a shared ground truth.

arduanika··on The return of never-ending job interviews: 'It can go beyond the pale'
That claim is not supported in the source you linked. In fact, it's directly contradicted several times. For example, toward the end, it quotes the OED:

"The theory that the origin of the phrase [‘beyond the pale’] relates to any of several specific regions, such as the area of Ireland formerly called the Pale … or the Pale of Settlement in Russia … is not supported by the early historical evidence and is likely to be a later rationalization.”

Throughout, your source draws a distinction between the histories of the separate phrases "beyond the pale" and "pale of settlement".

So I guess your statement might be true in the narrow sense that "many believe" the false etymology, just as you can find many who believe that the earth is flat. But that's not a good reason to go around chiding people for using a common expression.

arduanika··on Avoid blundering: 80% of a winning strategy
Sure, and he makes this point right there in TFA:

"This observation applies only to amateur tennis. In professional tennis it’s just the opposite: 80% of the rallies are won rather than lost, as unforced errors are infrequent. This is true in chess as well, as high-level players don’t blunder, and thus it really is that litany of other skills that results in high standing."

arduanika··on Daniel Kahneman has died
Only insofar as it's "kinda weird" to run a service where you notice interesting new things that happen in the world, and then write professional, mostly-reliable words about them, to share with your general audience.

In past centuries, this was a fairly common business model, but I understand the concept sounds pretty jarring to modern ears.

arduanika··on Daniel Kahneman has died
One of a kind! A life that will never be replicated.
arduanika··on Daniel Kahneman has died
At least, they sound that way to your System 1!
arduanika··on Grok
Woah, not bad.
arduanika··on YouTube now requires to label their realistic-looking videos made using AI
Is there a word missing from the title here? Requires whom?
arduanika··on Grok
CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md has only five words. :)
arduanika··on The later we meet someone in a sequence, the more negatively we describe them
Sure, but I learned about this after primacy bias, and now both effects seem very salient to me. I forget if there were others in between.
arduanika··on What Extropic is building
Back in the day, there was a saying that went something like: Steve Jobs was really good at what he did, and also an asshole to people. The former is really hard to replicate, so instead you'll find a lot of people going around and imitating the latter.

Today, it's a very different situation. Now we have Elon Musk, who is really good at what he does, and also tweets a lot...

arduanika··on What Extropic is building
Oh wow, hello!

Seems like it was quite a time to be online. I mostly know of it through this version of events. Not sure how accurate you'd find it:

https://aiascendant.substack.com/p/extropias-children-chapte...

The word "extropy" itself seems to go back several decades before the mailing list, if I'm reading correctly here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extropianism. Still, I wouldn't be surprised if many/most of the original mailing list members found this usage a corruption.

arduanika··on What Extropic is building
Is this sarcasm? (Genuinely can't tell.)

And also, are you the real Eliezer?

arduanika··on The Fine Art of Baloney Detection (1995) [pdf]
There was an interesting counterargument on an old blog. If you can look past the uncivil language in the title, the author makes some good observations about how "baloney detection" tends to show up in the wild:

https://web.archive.org/web/20140219225908/http://plover.net...

A snippet: "In the real world, it's not sufficient simply to identify a fallacy in an argument. You've also got to think why the fallacy is a problem in that particular instance, and what consequences it could have for the rest of the argument; often it will have less consequence than you might think. If you think you've dismissed an opposing argument just because you think you've seen a fallacy, then you're deluding yourself."

I never found out who this "plover" author is, or why they took down their blog. Maybe someone here knows more.

arduanika··on Welcome to the "neomedieval era": are states becoming obsolete?
Xi is the surname, FYI. Not Jinping.

Doesn't help with the actual problem you're talking about, which I agree sucks.

arduanika··on Why is the mouse cursor slightly tilted and not straight?
Nor did they mention Mark Zuckerberg, who is still holding his head up high in the face of negative press:

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2024/03/faceboo...

giving the appearance that the mouse is tilted.

← PreviousPage 14 of 21Next →