HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arduanika

1,478 karma · joined December 9, 2014

submissionscomments
arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
Huh, I don't know much about this site. Maybe I should. From reading up on the author, it looks like this is where they invented the term "snowclone", which is pretty cool I guess.

But this particular article rubs me the wrong way, for whatever reason. It just seems to miss the point.

arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
Sure, but he is packaging it in this superior snark. He is aggressively dismissing the very real thing that people actually mean when they say "avoid passive voice". A technical explainer on its own would be fine, but at least to my ears, this piece reads as narrow-minded and bitter.
arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
Yes, a linguist. All the more reason why he ought to know how to construct a sentence clearly.
arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
In layman's terms, he's saying, "I am very smart and George Orwell is a blowhard." You can decide for yourself which author you'd rather read.
arduanika··on The passive in English (2011)
This was clearly written by a pedant of the worst kind, boasting of how great he and his friends are at "mocking people who denigrate the passive without being able to identify it".

It is understood by basically everybody that there are two different things meant by passive vs. active: on one hand, the technical grammatical distinction, and on the other, the broader spirit of the phrase. Edge cases are very easy to construct: passive clauses where the agency is well-identified, and active clauses where responsibility is totally diffuse. This technical clarification is needed by nobody, because a rule-of-thumb like "avoid passive voice" is meant to be used holistically, not literally.

At the end, a parting shot is fired at George Orwell and E.B. White. Naturally, the superior intellect of the author of TFA is driven home.

arduanika··on That's not how email works
Not only a distraction, but also fails to distinguish HSBC from pretty much any other bank, so the "the" comes off as crankish and aggrieved.
arduanika··on SEC obtains final consent judgments against former FTX and Alameda executives
They = the people? Not precisely. Each of the perpetrators did certain things, agreed to certain things, and knew things at certain times. But I was responding to the notion in the parent that CE was just "running an investment firm" whereas SBF was running a company doing different stuff. It turned out to be all one co-mingled entity, contrary to how it was marketed. One company, and all of the main perpetrators knew things about both sides.
arduanika··on SEC obtains final consent judgments against former FTX and Alameda executives
No. Alameda and FTX were the same company, in the end. Co-mingled, and no separate governance. Legally speaking, all of the inner circle people ran both companies, and they all knew about the crimes.

The difference is the plea deal.

arduanika··on SEC obtains final consent judgments against former FTX and Alameda executives
The reduced sentences for Ellison, Wang, and Singh make sense in light of their cooperation. This is how plea deals work. The conviction of SBF seems simple in retrospect, but when the SDNY inked these deals, they did not yet know how just easy SBF would make their case for them, with all the tampering and perjury and obstinance.

Nonetheless, we should not be fooled by a sort of "Svengali defense", where Caroline or the others claim that they were beguiled by a dark charismatic genius who forced them into the crimes. The entire inner circle is super guilty of flagrant crimes. The shorter sentences are an artifact of plea bargains, and not a sign of lesser guilt.

arduanika··on SEC obtains final consent judgments against former FTX and Alameda executives
The customers were not fully repaid, except in an artificial accounting sense using post-crash marks. Nevertheless, the recovery was far more successful than most people expected at the time.
arduanika··on SEC obtains final consent judgments against former FTX and Alameda executives
It was all one company in the end, through co-mingling and lack of controls.
arduanika··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
I think we're talking less about the aspect of Bismarck where he won 3 big wars and lost none, and more about the part where he set up a delicate system that was maybe too complex for his successors to maintain, especially under idiosyncratic leaders. We're not talking about financial crises. Bismarck did not stop the Panic of 1873 (in fact, you could wave your hands and argue he indirectly caused it).

As far as "who set up the US empire, in all its complexity?", I'd argue for the 4 guys I named in my other comment, but your list might differ. And if you're just interested in the dollar system per se, I'd probably go with Harry Dexter White, who strangely enough turned out to be a Soviet spy.

Oh, and if you want a pretty clear analogy from Bismarck's system to earlier US monetary history: Benjamin Strong got the Federal Reserve System up and running and figured out a bunch of the right tricks, but he died in 1928 without getting his successors up to speed on how to run things. They failed miserably in next couple years. Bad timing!

arduanika··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
JQ Adams, Elihu Root, George Kennan, and Henry Kissinger.
arduanika··on How to wrangle non-deterministic AI outputs into conventional software? (2025)
"when interacting with an LLM in any capacity, remember your own cognitive biases. You often want the response to work, and while generated responses may look good and fit your mental model, it requires increasingly obscene levels of critical evaluation to see through the fluff."

100% this.

Idk about the far-out takes where "AI is an alien lifeform arrived into our present", but the first thing we know about how humans relate to extraterrestrials is: "I want to believe".

arduanika··on Google engineer says Claude Code built in one hour what her team spent a year on
Just you wait. In Claude Code future, AGI aligns you!
arduanika··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Let him cook. He's playing 2D chess.
arduanika··on I wrote the manual Karpathy said was missing for agentic AI
You almost had me there, I'll admit, but then I looked at your (short, new) comment history for a Poe's Law check. A much-needed perspective around here! Keep it up, and good luck staying on the right side of the site guidelines -- your shtick is close to the edge, but very refreshing if done well.
arduanika··on I wrote the manual Karpathy said was missing for agentic AI
Fair point, but neither is this lying "Nicola Sahar" character.
arduanika··on I wrote the manual Karpathy said was missing for agentic AI
Ah. My bad, yelling at the messenger. But the actual "author", who might also be the submitter (nick = Nicola?), has some explaining to do. There's a lie in the submission title, and the same lie in the github readme intro.

Thanks for helping alert us all to the sloppiness and deceit. And thanks to all who flagged.

arduanika··on I wrote the manual Karpathy said was missing for agentic AI
Come on and what? We are dazzled by this cool new tech and so now precision in speech no longer matters?
arduanika··on I wrote the manual Karpathy said was missing for agentic AI
Okay, so the submitted title is a lie? "I wrote the manual..." Would you consider changing it to something more honest?
arduanika··on Straussian Memes
I can't tell whether your question here is satire. I want to believe it's genuine, by the power of HN norms, in which case congratulations, you are one of today's unlucky 10,000.
arduanika··on How to make sense of any mess
Sorry dang, but I have to disagree. Nothing about this site design is "too common to be interesting." The whole thing is highly irregular. In an extreme case like this, the weirdness of the layout has to be considered a *principle feature* of the website, not a side distraction. Another commenter mentioned Time Cube, and that's not far off.

Commenters are correct that the whole thing reads like a meta joke, where the site itself is a mess. We have to at least consider the possibility that the author is in on the joke.

Petition to eliminate this stub, and merge this discussion of *the website's primary distinguishing feature* into the main conversation.

arduanika··on Bach Cello Suites (2024)
Yeah, that mostly tracks with my understanding. But can both of our stories be true?

The initial obscurity of the cello suites was part of the larger disregarding of Bach's work, in the shift from baroque to classical style. But did the "re-"regarding of the cello suites happen at the same time as Mendelssohn? Or did Mendelssohn only start the process, by rediscovering a few good pieces, while other pieces like the cello suites waited another ~hundred years?

arduanika··on Austria hails 'brain gain' in luring 25 academics away from US after cuts
Meh. Your joke here, like a kangaroo, has too many leaps. None of these were even born on the West Island.
arduanika··on Austria hails 'brain gain' in luring 25 academics away from US after cuts
Yeah, I could tell. I was playing dumb while pointing out some good Austrians.

Didn't know about [Show Dead] though, thanks for the tip!

arduanika··on Austria hails 'brain gain' in luring 25 academics away from US after cuts
Waltzing Johann Strauss, not Matilda
arduanika··on Austria hails 'brain gain' in luring 25 academics away from US after cuts
The throwaway's comment has been flagged. Who was he joking about? Mozart? Freud? Arnie?
arduanika··on Bach Cello Suites (2024)
Beautiful pieces.

My understanding is that for centuries after Bach's death, they were disregarded. They were seen almost as etudes, for cellists to use for practice to hone their technique. They didn't really gain their current status as respectable concert pieces until Pablo Casals dug them up in the early 20th century and produced his classic recordings.

arduanika··on Shiller PE Ratio
Huh, I guess that's so.

Well, can we at least agree on the part about most structured products being a rip-off?

← PreviousPage 6 of 21Next →