HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arghwhat

9,034 karma · joined January 12, 2017

no.
submissionscomments
arghwhat··on Starlink User Terminal Teardown
Note that such capture would be quite terrible for performance, not only requiring disabling any hardware offload (a great router might be able to route a few hundred megabit in large packets without offload assuming it doesn't do anything else) to make packets visible for capture, but it would also have to stream the output back to the adversary over the uplink as you would be limited to at most a few gigabytes of local, extremely slow storage, giving no means for local offline analysis...

The risk of access to the router is more that they can access your network and touch unprotected and vulnerable things rather than active monitoring.

arghwhat··on We have reached the "severed fingers and abductions" stage of crypto revolution
The lack of borders makes it more traceable as you don't run your head against a different jurisdiction bring unwilling to provide data. There's a lot of creative criminals though, and a lot of questionable creative crypto solutions that cater far too well to them.
arghwhat··on We have reached the "severed fingers and abductions" stage of crypto revolution
That has never stopped anyone, plenty of ways to launder money, quite a few of which are unique to crypto.
arghwhat··on VMOS – Virtual Android on Android
Countries who follow the Berne convention require neither "All rights reserved" text, copyright claim or year. Enforcable copyright is automatically assigned the moment the work is created.

The purpose of dating work is so that if your copyright is contested, you will have evidence that you created the work first. This is done by obtaining an officially recognized dating, which is usually done through registration with the copyright office (the registration has no other legal purpose after the Berne convention was adopted). External evidence or dating can also be used, e.g. having mailed the work to yourself and thereby having the work dated by the post office, having music be on hitlists, etc.

Writing the date on the work yourself has no value whatsoever. Dynamically injecting the current year has negative value as you are undermining the age of your work and thereby harming your ability to defend it as being the work first created.

In the case of a website, the only valuable evidence in proving the age of the content would be external content references and archive.org scapings.

arghwhat··on VMOS – Virtual Android on Android
The original Chinese website has a more recent 2024 copyright and much more content: https://www.vmos.cn/ - copyright years on websites are completely useless, people should stop doing that.

That repos haven't been pushed in a number of years is slightly supsicious, although they could just have taken things internal.

(Open source licenses do not require pushing to public github, only that someone obtaining the application can also obtain a copy of the source used to make it - can be an inquiry leading to a flashdrive by snailmail.)

arghwhat··on Apple App Store guidelines remove ban on encouraging external payments in US
Your first comment where you said "Why not?" to a comment questioning the clause that apps are required to use in-app purchases would be read as supporting Apple's restrictions, i.e. no user choice.
arghwhat··on Redis is open source again
I feel like most of the obsession over Redis came from old school cgi-esque server side apps that couldn't easily maintain state themselves...

Nowadays your webapp is often a persistent, multi-threaded web server where you can cache whatever temporary state you want far more efficiently than reaching out to a KV store.

Using postgres and caching common results becomes a non-issue even at scale. The main area where a super fast KV store shines is when you need to share a very large number of keys, where many servers only need to access a random subset and isn't interested in maintaining the full set and getting updates on a bus, where the values often change and needs to be revalidated so caching is ineffective, and where persistence is not needed so a database doesn't matter and a lighter KV store is acceptable.

arghwhat··on “Fewer Users” Warning Hurting Specialized and New Apps
That was definitely a logical way to interpret that comment. /s

The message is that the app developer in question's argument that they have nothing to update is most likely false, not that special industries is a driver for the policy.

arghwhat··on “Fewer Users” Warning Hurting Specialized and New Apps
Sure if you never accept any external input of any sort and handles no user data or input, you can assume things are fine.

But if that random game should, say, fetch user avatars from the web, then untrusted input to a way out of date image decoding library would be a nice path to a remote code execution vulnerability.

Or if the app registers any intent handlers that other apps and websites can trigger, or establishes TLS connections to any third party site, or...

arghwhat··on “Fewer Users” Warning Hurting Specialized and New Apps
Only 15 years of experience in the field and now running a consultancy company, but what do I know.
arghwhat··on Apple App Store guidelines remove ban on encouraging external payments in US
You're mixing things up. A web app does not ship a web browser, the user brings their own. You're thinking of electron apps.

When using web apps, the browser you bring is no different than, say, having to install Qt. It's a static entity shared by all apps, with each app "just" being anywhere between kilobytes and tens of megabytes.

Electron brings a browser, but even then what makes the app bloated is still design Theres a baseline amount of bulk included, but it's mostly inconsequential to the actual app behavior - similar to how a standard system has god knows how many libraries and functions available but mostly unusued.

You could easily have an app written with PyQt that's way more sluggish, bloated and complicated despite using a fraction of the disk space. Shitty apps, that's the issue.

arghwhat··on Apple App Store guidelines remove ban on encouraging external payments in US
> I'd personally never go somewhere else to pay for your subscription or content.

When "going elsewhere" means "getting stuff cheaper", people are likely going to go elsewhere to pay for any subscription even if setup is notably less convenient.

arghwhat··on Apple App Store guidelines remove ban on encouraging external payments in US
Bloated and overcomplicated are design issues, not technology issues. Plenty of native apps are bloated and overcomplicated.

Making good apps is hard.

arghwhat··on Apple App Store guidelines remove ban on encouraging external payments in US
The problem is that "shooting themselves in the foot" also translates to "earning more money for a longer time".
arghwhat··on Redis is open source again
Unless a CLA transfers copyright to the project owner, the copyright owners are every historical contributor to the project. Each contribution is owned by the contributor alone and they alone are able to grant rights to it.

A CLA often tries to mitigate this by making contributors give the project owners special rights at the time of contribution.

(Note that even if relicensed, this itself can never revoke licenses granted for prior versions unless that license specifically had revocation written into it.)

arghwhat··on Redis is open source again
That's... Pretty much exactly what you'd expect from a KV store. It's a hashmap on the network.
arghwhat··on LibreLingo – FOSS Alternative to Duolingo
> how much people invest in other types of education in the US, which I presume is what you're talking about.

No, where I live all education is provided as a free service. The US education system, putting people into a life of debt just acquire the minimum of marketable skills, is broken beyond repair and not a valid point of comparison.

On the other hand, people with qualifications also demand reasonable salaries and need to pay taxes. "Private tutoring" is not a 10 minute zoom call.

arghwhat··on Google Play sees 47% decline in apps since start of last year
Doing business and registering a company (a separate legal person) are orthogonal concepts that are specific to local legislation. You can do business as a private individual, and various "company" forms in various countries are not actually companies but just VAT/financial registrations for the individual itself and have no legal status of its own. Whether you need to register a company form depends on local rules and may be subject to e.g. volume limits (e.g., okay below 10k USD annual).

The alternative to being s business in s transaction is being a consumer (as in B2C), and you're obviously not a consumer when publishing an app.

arghwhat··on Google Play sees 47% decline in apps since start of last year
No, a single person individual can register.

Doing business is orthogonal to being a company, and depending on your country, some "company" forms are just VAT filing registrations for an individual itself with no independent legal status. What you normally call a company is something that behaves as an independent legal person.

However, it may be legally required to register a proper company if your yearly business volume exceed a certain value - check local rules - but it may also be perfectly fine to do business as an individual below that volume, in which case the legal entity is just you.

(The alternative to being a business in a transaction is being a consumer)

arghwhat··on Google Play sees 47% decline in apps since start of last year
DUNS numbers are for all legal entities including individuals, and an individual can act as a business.
arghwhat··on Google Play sees 47% decline in apps since start of last year
You read that wrong, you're the customer in Google's KYC (know your customer). They're the company.
arghwhat··on Google Play sees 47% decline in apps since start of last year
No they were set out in the contract you agreed to when publishing which has commitments and grants entirely orthogonal to your source license. Plus certain moral obligations to society.

Your license text is only capable of adding supplementary rights, and you're responsible for ensuring that your source license is fully compatible with the contract at time of publishing.

If you just want to dump stuff, leave it on GitHub.

arghwhat··on Google Play sees 47% decline in apps since start of last year
Going through hoops usually refer to an excessive effort.

Having to go through between zero (it you have needed the number before) and one free forms from a standard entity to get a widely recognized identifier used for many things is objectively not an excessive effort.

Sharing apps on app stores is a continuous commitment with various responsibilities like, such as ensuring safety of users through regular maintenance. If the idea if submitting one number is too much of a burden given the joy/finances you get out of it, then the rest of the maintenance responsibilities likely are too and maybe it's better to skip the publishing part.

Not sure what you're on about with corporate colonization. Colonizing implies forcefully taking what was rightfully someone elses. Also, in many places, making a company is just a form and standard practice even if you're just going to sell a single bogus app for 0.99 USD or whatever, so even individuals will be "corporations".

arghwhat··on Google Play sees 47% decline in apps since start of last year
Validation issues happen all the time for subsidiaries when the parent company likes to own/manage things. Always fun when e.g. EV certificate validation (sigh windows update stuff) calls the parent company reception and asks for the manager listed as owner, and they just go "who?".
arghwhat··on Google Play sees 47% decline in apps since start of last year
I haven't tried the specific flow for private individuals (seems to just be a radio button), but I do recall getting DUNS numbers as just filling in an online form with name and location and getting the number by mail, without any hoops for fees.

A bit silly to require for private individuals, and a bit annoying to have to go back and do, but not itself a big deal.

arghwhat··on Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model
multiple-input, multiple-output was horribly generic to begin with. Terms like multipath propagation and spatial multiplexing will do just fine.
arghwhat··on LibreLingo – FOSS Alternative to Duolingo
I don't think your experience here is weird - just seems like you had a good environment for practicing a bit with your wife, which I think is more important than any other aspect of the learning methodology. Now, nitpickers might argue that "better" methods would have achieved much more in less time, but eh.

Try to force some more exchanges with your wife. Make a day of the week the day you only speak her language (for at least a few hours, but don't give up from the frustration when vocabulary runs short - keep it going even if you need to point and sign).

Doubles as a silly/fun couples activity.

arghwhat··on LibreLingo – FOSS Alternative to Duolingo
Private tutoring for 1 hour, 3 times a week at the current rates offered by local freelancers where I live would be ballpark 1000 USD per month for a long time. If you start nitpicking about quality and put in some more serious hours I wouldn't be surprised if you hit two grand.

Language should not be reserved for people that can throw that kind of money monthly at their random hobbies, and suggesting that this is "the solution" is grotesque at best.

arghwhat··on LibreLingo – FOSS Alternative to Duolingo
No, private tutors are definitely better but they are no silver bullet. Having a great private tutors often and long enough to exercise sporadic conversation and gain confidence in language use - a class a few times a week at least - is also a prohibitively expensive solution suggestion for most people, making it a non-solution.

You also end in a false dichotomy.

arghwhat··on LibreLingo – FOSS Alternative to Duolingo
I have a bit of a different perspective. Sure, Duolingo is suboptimal and won't teach you a language on its own, but I'd say that language classes themselves is no better.

Specifically, I consider the fundamental missing piece to allow achieving language intermediacy or fluency to be confidence and sporadic language use, and you have to be lucky for a language class to give you this. Hearing about grammar and having Q&As is nice, but that teaches language theory, not fluency. Trying to converse about a specific topic with other non-fluent and disinterested individuals does not teach fluency, and not every conversation will be with the teacher - the only (hopefully) fluent person in the room - and even if the option is present, some might be uncomfortable with it.

On the other hand, if you have achieved some confidence and means to exercise the language - which you don't acquire from a language class - then I'd consider Duolingo to be a decent vocab and sentence exercise tool. Some cultures rely on flashcard approaches to teach their written language to locals, so it's not that silly. Duolingo does also have reading and listening comprehension tests.

Furthermore, I'd argue that newer LLM-based exercises might end up being superior to both traditional "pool of random non-fluent people" language classes and duolingo's current model, and arguably the task that large language models are most suited for.

(Note that Duolingo classes differ a lot between languages - my experience is from Mandarin.)

← PreviousPage 13 of 34Next →