HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arghwhat

9,034 karma · joined January 12, 2017

no.
submissionscomments
arghwhat··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
To be clear, a derivative work is copyright of the one creating the derivative, not the original author.

The question is whether creating the derivative work of that specific transformative nature is allowed. Unlike assets taken verbatim, this requires evaluating the exact instance. A binary decompilation is importantly not a simple translation, as that would be entirely unusable - rather, it is like creating blueprints for a finished building.

This is in part why licenses aim to manage and in part restrict you through a contract with the author, using a formally granted usage right to the entity as leverage for complying with a bunch of conditions, orthogonal to the copyright.

Your point stands though, my statement was not as accurate as it could have been.

arghwhat··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
Note that copyright holders for an open source project is often a very long list of people that would all need to approve of having their contribution relicensed. It's a bit of a complicated matter.

Considering attribution was removed, I doubt it was approved, but it's not impossible that they somehow learnt and decided not to care as enforcement can be unreasonably cumbersome.

arghwhat··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
Note that reverse engineering does not have to be clean room, poking at hardware without ever seeing any software. In many places, poking at the proprietary software, decompiling it, tracing it, and so forth is fine despite what unenforcable EULA's might suggest. What is not okay is taking the binaries or decompiled source verbatim and re-distributing it.

Note that e.g. copyright does not apply to decompiled source code (the original authors did not write the decompiled source, unlikely assets taken verbatim - maybe that's where the arguments you mention stem from - although note that there may be regional regulatory differences). Instead, the things that might cause issues are things like the enforceable parts of the software license, any enforceable patents on the functionality, or enforceable platform license restrictions for applications built based on decompiled source.

arghwhat··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
Being active doesn't matter, the copyright holders still hold the copyright.

How much they profit off the stolen portion is also questionable, and open source licenses weren't meant to extort money but to grant us rights to the code. What they should do is add attributions and fix their licensing (libogc needs to be GPLv2), or remove the code. Willingly, yesterday.

arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
Our timeline is not an ordered series of preconditions followed by inevitabilities. It does not hold that if some other civilization says "B", it must first have said "A" and follow by "C".

RF equipment is not built or designed by people working with or having understanding of quantum mechanics. Understanding waves could come from observing liquids, or if audio exists to them, that. Designing around noise can be done empirically as we do. Quantum mechanics in this area only matter due to our current chip manufacturing process, but who says they use semiconductors?

On the other hand they could also have a better understanding of light and photons and never build RF into their core technology stack, thereby not having people observe and analyze the hydrogen line.

The only strict order is that we know now that our previous theories were complete garbage, and we are still waiting to discover why our current theory is complete garbage.

arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
(Not to mention that the hydrogen line was only discovered in 1951, as a result of years of hearing it using radio equipment invented half a century prior. Even things as basic as the proton took until 1932 to discover.)
arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
Not to mention that several dozen new cults formed around the plaque.
arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
The prevalence of the 21 cm wavelength is something they would likely discover should they be in a part of the universe similar to ours. What I find laughable is the means of trying to communicate this wavelength and using it as a means to indicate our size.

Now if you go the other way, referenced 21 cm as a well known quantity (say, by making the plaque 21cm wide and referencing its diameter) and used that to describe the hydrogen spin flip in order to teach or communicate our level of physics understanding rather than depend on a shared understanding, then I'd say it makes more sense.

arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
That's the "discovery by another civilization" part, so yes.
arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
The period you're describing is that of old quantum theory, which was hugely inconsistent and predates our theories of modern quantum mechanics which is post 1925 or so.

The inventor of the arc converter was 18 at the time radio waves were discovered, 34 at the time he invented the arc converter, but 56 and with only 17 years left till his death when the era of modern quantum mechanics started with the invention of wave mechanics. It's a lifetime apart.

Some discoveries were made during that period that are of course still relevant.

arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
Indeed. Say, maybe a civilization didn't start out with trying to build the world of particles of progressively finer size, but started directly with a model of fields, waves and charges and therefore never had a concept of a discrete elemental particle, and in turn a system built around that to categorize elements.

Or to them, an atom is as large an arbitrary macro structure as proteins are to us, and so they would never consider two empty circles with a single line to represent something so big and chaotic. Or maybe they had the crazy idea of building everything of vibrating strings!

Who knows what the abstractions and approximations would be when the foundation of it all isn't "getting hit on the head by an apple".

arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
Making the data fault tolerant to the discovery by another civilization, its collapse and later rediscovery by another civilization seems a bit of a stretch goal. :)
arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
There is no relation between the ability to communicate and a shared understanding of our concept of quantum transitions - case in point, our invention of the technology we use to communicate with deep space far predates us learning these concepts ourselves.

I'd also hold that the only thing this plaque could ever give is clear sign of artificial creation, and by virtue the (possibly past) existence of some entity capable of creating it. Maybe they'll get a vague idea of what we look like, but if "their" culture does not commonly depict themselves in 2D as we do, or "they" have vastly different morphologies, even that would be unclear. The context needed to understand our attempt at showing our location might also be lost if the thing went far enough.

arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
(I was sarcastically pointing to the plaque itself, a physical entity of a well known size to anyone capable of observing the drawing on it, unlike the space craft or physics riddles.)
arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
I sarcastically referenced the plaque itself, which is a convenient disc of a known size to anyone observing the drawing, unlike the space craft or physics riddles.

Using quantum transitions is quite ridiculous in my opinion due to requiring not only the observer to have a perfectly compatible understanding of physics (even a more advanced understanding might not be compatible - maybe they don't categorize elements by electrons, or even treat elemental particles as a quantifiable entity), combined with the sheer number of deductions required to understand what was meant with two circles and a few lines.

I doubt we would ever have decoded this had we been the recipient rather than author, and that's with a perfectly compatible understanding of physics.

arghwhat··on io_uring based rootkit can bypass syscall-focused Linux security tools
I wouldn't consider it a second line of defense - as a rule of thumb, it will only catch old and overused attack vectors, and rarely well.

Anything novel will fly right past it, and it will have false positives. Plastering ineffective or mildly effective security everywhere in the name of "defense in depth" can have negative value as it reduces diligence in applying more relevant security measures that aren't just a random package install.

arghwhat··on One quantum transition makes light at 21 cm
If only we could somehow share a physical entity of known dimensions to reference together with the drawing so that we did not need to use a physics riddle to indicate scale...
arghwhat··on io_uring based rootkit can bypass syscall-focused Linux security tools
The title is somewhat misleading, as it suggests an io_uring issue when there is none - it's just that anti-virus solutions like Microsoft Defender try to monitor syscalls but don't monitor io_uring.

They're far from guaranteed to catch things they monitor anyway, and I feel they mostly just exist to let enterprise pretend they care about security by buying ineffective band aids and duct tape. I guess a legal defense is more important than a technical one.

arghwhat··on Native visionOS platform support
They could also throw money out their window, light it on fire, let their employees do whatever they want instead of regular Apple work, etc.

A lot of managers (and legal) have to approve and allocate significant budget to bad ideas. Companies generally try to avoid doing bad ideas that are a net negative.

arghwhat··on Native visionOS platform support
A big feature like this will be at most 20-30% done when you open a PR, because the rest of the work is in collaboration to suit upstream which will as always require notable changes and rewrites.

Spending manweeks to manmonths on new upstream work that won't see any practical use until half to a whole year later, after getting legal to work things out, is a significant investment in new development.

This has nothing to do with suppliers or partners. They are not dumb enough to measure a product roadmap in number of random PRs, but will look at first party software and hardware roadmap.

arghwhat··on Native visionOS platform support
No you can't. Upstreaming a large feature like this requires at the very least allocating a number of manweeks to the upstreaming process, and that's without accounting for actually writing the feature in the first place. Making a PR and not following up would be worse PR (heh) than doing nothing, which is also costly.

If they had dumped a tarball or a fork somewhere with a hacked up PoC it could have looked like they just dumped what they had, but even that requires approvals and time from legal, and so someone has to decide its worth investing in.

(I have no interest in speculating about the Vision lineup itself, just commentating on open source contributions.)

arghwhat··on Native visionOS platform support
Official upstreaming efforts are a significant investment even if they have internal PoCs. You can't just "release what you've got".
arghwhat··on FreeDOS 1.4 Is Here
Not anymore, it's either signed EFI binaries or handled live from user space (with LVFS covering the Linux side). Sometimes vendors still ship boot images, but nowadays it's likely a small Linux live ISO.
arghwhat··on FreeDOS 1.4 Is Here
No, the technology serving what you're describing is microVMs, or taken even further, unikernels.

FreeDOS has no technical relevance other than its intended purpose of continued support for legacy DOS applications on modern hardware - which is perfectly fine.

arghwhat··on Android phones will soon reboot themselves after sitting unused for three days
> Major upgrades

Major version upgrades are a different type of upgrade altogether. They are optional while the previous major is still maintained.

Minor upgrades is what should always be automatic.

> Flash wear

No, it doesn't matter.

Total write endurance (i.e., the number of bytes written the device is designed to handle under some standard load) is usually a large multiple of the chip size itself - say, 200x-400x, so e.g. 100TB of writes for a 256GB setup. A particular workload is only really meaningful to flash wear if it is in the scale of several full storage rewrites during the lifetime of the device.

The exact write endurance depends on the exact configuration (specific chip selection, allocated reserve), but even microSD cards have wear levelling these days.

Your device is going to die or be retired with a certain flash write wear, but I find it extremely unlikely that your device will die of a flash write wear. The wear endurance is dependent on the specific flash setup.

A much larger cause of wear is app caches (e.g., streaming video continously overwriting a disk cache, browsing social media). If you take pictures, those might end up written multiple times as first the original is written, then the automatically processed version, then any edits you make, then if storage saving measures is enabled maybe its deleted and a compressed version is written, if you later open the app the original is downloaded and written again, ...

arghwhat··on Android phones will soon reboot themselves after sitting unused for three days
This is default on iOS and on many Android versions.

It's often configurable, but e.g. carrier policy or local vendors can enforce it.

To have updates automatically install overnight is the maximally desirable scenario - waiting for user approval usually result in open vulnerabilities, and if you interact with a prompt you are by definition using your device and it is therefore a much worse time than while you're asleep.

arghwhat··on Ask HN: Why is there no P2P streaming protocol like BitTorrent?
Yes that's the intended behavior of HLS - the content provider advertises which streams are available and at what bitrates, and the client picks which to use based on the current stream performance and its own capability.

The server can control the stream by advertising a customized manifest to individual clients, although it's a bit silly. HLS is designed to be extremely easy to load distribute and throw CDN/cache proxies in front, and it's a bad sad that content providers are this bad at load management. :/

Either way, the assumption here is that you would swap out the client doing HLS with a client designed to use a P2P protocol, including the seeding portion and network health management.

arghwhat··on Ask HN: Why is there no P2P streaming protocol like BitTorrent?
This is not a "punishment", and what clients to differs greatly.

The original spec for the original client allocated a portion of its bandwidth to random peers instead of known-good/preferred peers, so if you had no chunks you were basically bandwidth and/or peer restricted.

If you take the arch linux ISO right now and put it into aria2c to be a new, unknown client with no data to offer, you'll find that while it takes a few seconds to join the network, fetch metadata and connect to peers, you'll quickly saturate your connection completely without ever uploading a single byte.

If you wanted, a streaming network could use direct access or low-hop access as seeding incentive - seed to get slightly lower content latency. When the streaming client is controlled by the content provider, seeding is easily forced and topology could be controlled centrally.

arghwhat··on Temu pulls its U.S. Google Shopping ads
That tariffs are in use is not proof that it is untrue. Even with the current dumpster fire we still trade with the US, but that obviously does not mean there has been no harm.

For countries, tariffs is not something that is just shrugged off as it impacts their economy, there will always be political countermeasures to strongly discourage that tariffs are applied that harms them. Retaliatory tariffs, impact on other negotiations and relationships, etc.

For companies, tariffs harm profits and fair competition on both supply chain and consumer side, depending on where the tariffs are located. The company would strategize for maximum profit margins, circumventing tariffs, remove countries from their supply chain, and focusing on more profitable markets.

It wouldn't be a boycott the same way it is now of course. It would be a slower process. But tariffs is a way to force the market and always have wide negative effects. One just hopes that certain long-term side-effects (like high import cost causing focus on driving down local supply cost) is worth the impact (local cost of living increase, drop in investments, drop in friendly reputation).

arghwhat··on Ask HN: Why is there no P2P streaming protocol like BitTorrent?
You are not required to seed immediately, nor even the same asset. Unless the rules have changed, you would usually just be required to maintain a particular minimum seed lifetime ratio that is easily achieved by idle seeding a library.

The point is to ensure network health with a metric that is simple to understand and verify: that you have been a productive. If you aren't seeding, someone else has to pick up the slack and the network didn't benefit from you obtaining the blocks.

The community itself benefits by giving members a guarantee that stuff there is available with abundant bandwidth, instead of relying purely on the unpaid goodwill of others.

← PreviousPage 14 of 34Next →