HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arghwhat

9,034 karma · joined January 12, 2017

no.
submissionscomments
arghwhat··on Why are QR Codes with capital letters smaller than QR codes with lower case?
You misinterpret - I am not saying that what you experienced was technically impossible (you saw a URL, later recreating a valid URL at least partially), but that your interpretation of what happened is neither practical nor possible in the general case, nor is it necessary. Let's try with an example:

You see a poster. "Samsung Galaxy, for real this time. Tune in on 1st of April to watch the ceremony live where we subjugate the last planet in the Milkyway.".

Scenario 1: The poster has a QR code, and a URL: https://events.samsung.com/press-room/world-domination. You memorize the hostname (events, samsung, com), and half a day later you manage to pull up a page for events, select the intended one, and get to the live feed.

Scenario 2: The poster has a QR code, no URL. You memorize "samsung galaxy", or "samsung event", or even just "samsung", and half a day layter you type this into your browser's address bar, which gives you as the first result the live feed you were looking for, or at the very least to samsung's event page.

"memorizable URLs" is not human-readable information, but computer-readable information constructed with certain rules to mimic human-readable information - e.g., the company name mangled to fit URL syntax. The original, unmangled information is easier to remember.

arghwhat··on Why are QR Codes with capital letters smaller than QR codes with lower case?
To keep an actual URL for later you'd have to write it down or take a picture of it (which also works for the QR code, either by following it later or keeping the tab open). URL's aren't human-readable or memorizable, nor is it meant to be.

"Easy to remember URLs" are just domains that mostly match the human-friendly name of the place. As you are not memorizing a full URL, you can only really go to the frontpage, and so you can just memorize the name of the place instead.

It's a different story if there's just a random QR code with no clear purpose of ownership, but... maybe don't scan that.

arghwhat··on Why are QR Codes with capital letters smaller than QR codes with lower case?
"I would love to see menus printed in OCR-A" just takes a regular human readable paper menu, and increases the success rate if you were to painstakingly scan each page to make a PDF with selectable text. That doesn't solve an actual need when sitting with the paper menu.

Taking a QR code that takes you to a URL, and writing out the URL in text does not enable anything, as you still must have an internet-connected device to retrieve the content, in which case you would most likely be able to scan the QR code anyway.

The point is to have e.g. a QR code, while still having human-readable content for those not having or wishing to use their smartphone in this interaction. E.g., just having the list of things on the menu printed in plain text (e.g., on a wall, over the counter, paper menu, ...), but also having a QR code with images and the ability to order directly to your table - stuff beyond what text would get you.

arghwhat··on BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells
> If I upgrade to the new LR and I get, let's say, 480km in the cold and at highway speeds, that would give me 2 hours and 24 minutes between stops.

480 km in the cold at highway speeds is 140 km more than your previously stated 340 km, which is an hour more at 140 km/h.

If you are driving between highway charge stops, it's a bit over 3.5 hours between stops.

> Longer range consistently tops consumer requirements

It is tied with "availability of chargers equal gas stations" in that report, suggesting that the range concern is not about roadtrips but daily convenience for households without own chargers.

Also, answers to a questionaire for "EV skeptical" people about why they haven't purchased an EV isn't representative of actual needs. People when asked about range answer that way because they're comparing to what they already have and have to make up an answer to justify their decisions, not because of need.

> You must just accept that others value different things.

And you must accept that your values does not equal the actual needs of the general population, which can be quite easily assessed based on normal worklife patterns.

I'm sure we can agree that any vehicle is objectively best if it is optimized for your actual needs, and that the more often it fit your need the better. This makes it quite simple: Does your daily driving equal roadtrips, yes or no?

If not, you will get an objectively better experience (better handling, less noise, less energy/fuel cost, less tire wear, faster charging to full) while simultaneously saving your bank account and the environment. And no, a dialy driver doesn't mean "renault zoe", it just means "smaller and lighter battery".

If you drive 1 roadtrip per year or less, it makes sense to rent the car for roadtrip to get the best of both worlds: the best roadtrip machine and the best daily driver, which are mutually exclusive requirements. The roadtrip vehicle might be a large, comfortable ICE car with below average fuel economy and plenty of space - maybe even pulling a camping wagon depending on what you want to do on roadtrips.

If you drive 2+ roadtrips per year, maybe it starts to make sense to buy a roadtrip-specific secondary vehicle. If you drive much more than that (e.g., every weekend, or daily work involves multi-hour driving), then it starts to make sense financially to compromise and use a roadtrip vehicle for daily driving.

arghwhat··on BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells
It is not at all an un-typical country. It might even be the case for the majority of the US, most of which live outside New York City.

Plus, cities in countries over on this side of the pond provide street charging and even have legislation about maximum distance to a charger. Parking garages and lots also provide charging. Not as convenient as living in a house with a charger where you can always plug in at night (and possibly use private solar cells for extra benefit), but good enough for most commuting.

arghwhat··on BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells
> My 2021 Model Y is rated at 455km in ideal conditions, but has about 340km today in cold conditions at Autobahn speeds.

So you're down to 75% capacity, with the first 10% lost to the cold of winter and the rest lost to going 140km/h.

The long range Model Y has 600 km rating in ideal conditions, and applying the same loss you'd be at 450 km. The same calculation is 466 km for the upcoming model, more than your car's ideal rating.

So seems like you already have much better options available. You can also take 10 km/h off your speed to increase range notably (in any car), and you can go further for road trips outside the winter months.

> I value my road trips going smoothly FAR more than I value my daily commutes going smoothly. For this reason, it's VERY important for me for range to be increased.

Sure, but it remains a niche use-case, which is fine but unimportant for the industry and the general population and not what cars should be built or optimized for.

Range is a liability whenever not in use (batteries are heavy), and cars are always better when optimized for the normal use-case. That's why there's long range models, and it's also fine to take such roadtrips in an ICE should need be.

arghwhat··on BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells
Yes, I am familiar and have driven the autobahn on multiple occasions, and occasionally at speeds exceeding what we discuss here.

It is irrelevant what the road is, or how fast people prefer to drive. It's not a race track, other drivers are not race drivers, the road is not maintained to race track standards, and cars and drivers are not equipped with race safety equipment. Your driving must be able to safely handle a car or truck going 80 swerving in front of you with no prior warning just as you pass it, and at 210 that's equivalent to crashing into a stationary object at 130 km/h (i.e., everyone and their cat dies).

arghwhat··on BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells
> Unsafe, depends.

I agree that you can be better equipped for driving 200+ km/h, but I do not agree that it is possible for such driving to be safe on a public road unless you are guaranteed to be alone (and with proper racing equipment).

The problem isn't you and your car, it's that you're zooming past other cars at speeds that make them practically stationary, and no amount of experience you may have make them any less likely to accidentally pull out, not noticing that a car had approached them at literally twice their speed.

Even if no one ever failed to check their mirrors on regular lane changes, someone doing 80 might be forced to swerve for emergency reasons, and if you're going 210 then it's like hitting a stationary object at 130 km/h.

Heck, even professional racing drivers have crash into each other all the time, and a check of your mirror isn't valid for very long if the speed difference is too high. Differential speeds are already not great when you mix 130 and 80 in the same direction, but mixing 200+ and 80 is impossible to do safely.

> Anyway, what I meant was that, while I haven't done any scientific testing, it seemed like the Tesla's range was impacted much more by high speed driving than ICEs I've driven despite being very low drag.

I wonder if the perceived difference isn't just a result of how much range you had to beign with, combined with the tesla maybe being easier to keep "in the green" near the rated range than an ICE car.

Taking the polo as example, if you always drove it very aggressively you might be happy thinking it went 650 km on a tank and assume that the fuel rating was just an unrealistic lie. But drive it a bit more carefully (while staying at the speed limit) and you'll get 1000+ km on a tank as advertised.

If you do the same exercise in a car that starts with a 500km range instead of 1000+, then being stuck with just 60% of the range from aggressive driving might be a lot more impactful.

(Also, always remember that drag coefficients is for a given area which can be quite misleading when comparing cars of different sizes like crossover SUVs.)

arghwhat··on BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells
Sorry, but going 210+ km/h on any public road is absolutely idiotic on every level. Not only is it unsafe (no, there is no valid argument to suggest otherwise when mingling with traffic that is driving 130km/h slower or more than you on the same road), but it is also environmentally irresponsible.

The fact that someone decides to make this trade-off purely based on their own impatience is the frustrating reason for why cars had to ship with speed limiters in the first place, and why the the autobahn might end up getting global speed limits which may or may not ruin the fun at places like the Nürburgring.

And no, the range impact is no surprise nor isolated to electric cars. Even in a diesel polo bluemotion that on a good day can do over 1000 km on a tank, my experience is that spirited highway driving easily takes off 25% of the range, and I wouldn't be surprised if your described driving would leave it with less than 50% of the advertised range.

arghwhat··on BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells
Just because you can drive 140km/h doesn't mean you should - ignoring everything else, it's noisy and inefficient in any car. There's also speed limits of 130 down to 80 in many places, which knocks down the average speed.
arghwhat··on BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells
Two hours at the Autobahn is just 200-250km in what is effectively optimal conditions (steady driving over long distances). That number doesn't check out.

Most people drive significantly less than a full charge in a given day. Overnight or workplace charging solves like, 95% of car needs. And remember, it's not much of a problem if 5% or less of road cars need to still be (efficient) fossil fuel cars.

Battery advances should mainly be used to make cars lighter at decent range, not to give more range at same weight. Electric cars are too heavy in the current state, fixing that should come first.

arghwhat··on Apple Intelligence Comes to Apple Vision Pro in April
Cooling takes up space and weight, but wiring all cameras, screens and sensors to a compute box would also be clumsy, and using a single high speed link would add more parts, losses and needs for cooling, and then the external compute module would be not be pocketable...
arghwhat··on How X-Plane Works
To be clear, even if MCAS was strictly necessary during all aspects of normal flight, it is not a defect in flight characteristics to require computerized control of flight control surfaces as long as the aircraft is properly designed for it (as opposed to acting with gross neglect for human life). See any fighter jet, or even a regular Airbus with its highly abstract fly-by-wire system.
arghwhat··on How X-Plane Works
Without MCAS, the 737 MAX has a significant pitch up tendency. You can actively trim your way out of this, but it might be a quite notable effort. It is airworthy, but that does not mean it is automatically flying straight and level.

With working MCAS, it should fly roughly like the pre-MAX version, with automatic trim adjustments to hide the significant pitch up tendency that the pre-MAX version with its much smaller engines did not have.

With a buggy MCAS with the failure conditions met, you might have sporadic significant pitch-down.

(... And with a blown load reduction device in the left engine, e.g. from a large bird strike, you'll have the cockpit filled with smoke at fatal toxicity within 39 seconds, but despite being completely avoidable by flicking one switch, and despite also affecting other aircraft with similar devices, the FAA doesn't find it worth any immediate action.)

arghwhat··on Asahi Linux lead developer Hector Martin resigns from Linux kernel
get_maintainer.pl gives you the list. Theres no equivalent in Firefox or Chromium to flag which Mozilla/Red Hat/Google/... manager does not consider your ticket an area of focus.
arghwhat··on Asahi Linux lead developer Hector Martin resigns from Linux kernel
That your experience is not shared suggests that the other "workflows" are not in fact objectively easier to deal with than the kernel workflow, but instead that there's a high variability in the frustration experienced across all three workflows.
arghwhat··on Asahi Linux lead developer Hector Martin resigns from Linux kernel
In my experience it's the opposite - the email patch usually gets dealt with within a week or two, Firefox and Chromium dragged out because it wasn't whatever Mozilla or Google prioritized right now. Or worse, it might go against an internal corporate KPI.

In Firefox you have to fiddle with Mercurial, phabricator, and their homegrown CI. In Chromium its Gerrit and their homegrown CI, and oh btw you touched code that lacked tests so tag, you're it.

arghwhat··on U.K. orders Apple to let it spy on users' encrypted accounts
They might have to settle for it. The power of a government is not equal to what legislation they pass - they are heavily limited by the economic and publicity consequences of decisions.

As such, any outcome where this is enforced will be a compromise.

arghwhat··on Asahi Linux lead developer Hector Martin resigns from Linux kernel
Having contributed a few times, I'd rate it as similar (sometimes much easier!) than contributing to Firefox and Chromium. That is to say that it is indeed extremely time-consuming and frustrating, but when compared to projects of the same scale it does not necessarily come out as more time-consuming or more frustrating - this will never be a small team collaborating on a random Github repo. A simple "swap out X workflow for Y" does not fix these annoyances, and false dichotomies and peer pressure towards is not a way to cooperate.

I cannot claim to have felt the effects on the maintainer-side of this workflow in large-scale projects though.

arghwhat··on Popular Linux orgs Freedesktop and Alpine Linux are scrambling for new webhost
The provider may be on the hook of legal consequences from authorities *if" their customer is a business offering services in Germany.

Nothing that would involve you as a third-party individual.

arghwhat··on Waydroid – Android in a Linux container
WINE reimplements windows libraries and higher level APIs to convert them to something compatible with your host kernel, providing as full a glue Windows user-space as needed to support Windows user-space applications integrating into your host system. This includes a full, Windows-centric emulated filesystem hierarchy.

Waydroid reimplements Android libraries and higher level APIs to convert them to something compatible with your host kernel, providing as full a glue Android user-space as need to support Android user-space applications integrating into your host system (such as by providing a Wayland-backed implementation of SurfaceFlinger or HWComposer). This includes a full, Android-centric emulated filesystem hieararchy.

They are equivalent, even if their targets are different. And most importantly, they are both the polar opposite of a VM setup, as the user-space is not the user-space of the VM, but a dedicated user-space that presents Windows and Android behaviors respecitvely, but implementing them in terms of your host system's window management, input management, audio management, etc.

(That waydroid relies heavily on namespaces is a technical detail, not a relevant difference between WINE and Waydroid. WINE if implemented again today would likely do the same.)

> Exactly my point. The only difference is whether or not the kernel is shared, which is a very, very small fraction of the OS.

No, the main difference is whether the user-space is deeply integrated through various glue, or whether you're emulating the whole system as-is, with its original user-space and kernel, with just a virtual screen to interact with.

arghwhat··on Popular Linux orgs Freedesktop and Alpine Linux are scrambling for new webhost
Your expectations of what you wanted from Hetzner has nothing to do with their professionalism. They most certainly acted with outmost professionalism given the situation you describe, and the behavior to be expected from any hosting provider.

I get your frustration in the situation, but even if it would have been helpful to you, it would be extremely unprofessional for a hosting provider to invervene in the operations of its customers unless the customer violates the Terms of Service (an agreement you have no part in), a court order is made, or law enforcement makes a legally supported demand. Random legal notices sent by mail from strangers are not on this list, but could lead to Hetzner evaluating if a ToS violation is in effect that must be resolved.

If the customer is a business, it could be that they have breached the Impressum laws. It would have helped you if they had the impressum, but until legal action is taken it remains undecided if there is a violation, and if there was the consequence would be that the customer is liable for a written warning and in some cases a fine, as decided by the relevant authorities or a court of law.

arghwhat··on Popular Linux orgs Freedesktop and Alpine Linux are scrambling for new webhost
You're linking this everywhere, but it has absolutely zero relevance.

Your beef is not with Hetzner, but whoever decided to run the service. Unless the customer violates local legislation or the hosting providers ToS, the appropriate action is to leave the service running, be it AWS, GCP or Hetzner.

I would quite frankly have been very disappointed with them if they had done anything in response to you request.

arghwhat··on Waydroid – Android in a Linux container
This is like suggesting that running applications in a Windows VM and running them under WINE isn't a big difference.

(One might say "but it's the same OS!" - but it's only really a similar kernel, and even that is heavily customized and not at all the same as your laptop runs. The graphical stack is also nothing like neither X nor Wayland.)

Also, rant: it's not KVM, but QEMU. KVM is a small API to deal with virtualization instructions, but while that makes VMs much faster than without (similar to how floating point is much faster with hardware support), it does very little on its own. The virtualization instructions are basically a way to let QEMU run code as is but intercept everything important - syscalls, faults, you name it - whereas without, it would have to instrument or outright interpret the executed program.

It's QEMU that micro-manages setup, execution and importantly is responsible for emulating all the VM devices - KVM just exposes memory mapped into the virtual CPU's memory space.

arghwhat··on Waydroid – Android in a Linux container
Waydroid runs Android services and applications natively on your machine in a container with apps launching in windows side-by-side with your other applications, whereas the Android emulator runs a VM with regular smartphone-esque hardware.

Quite a big difference.

arghwhat··on Apple and SpaceX link up to support Starlink satellite network on iPhones
Sure, but there's also cellular issues in the Australian outback and most of Alaska, and there you don't have infrastructure.

You need power as well as fiber.

arghwhat··on I still like Sublime Text
Was a sublime user through version 2 and 3, which were always champions of performance, but while I installed and used 4 for a bit it never quite became part of my workflow.

I think part of it was because it sat between using neovim vs. using vscode, and if I had to reach out for vscode I probably wanted to use remote code editing, code intelligence or AI integration which a default sublime setup wasn't quite offering, and the plugin game seemed stale. Maybe there were also some Wayland issues, don't remember.

Maybe I'll try again and see what you have been up to. Using a proprietary text editor in ${current_year} feels a bit weird though.

arghwhat··on Apple and SpaceX link up to support Starlink satellite network on iPhones
In all seriousness, have you considered adding an outdoor access point? They reach quite far as you usually have Line of Sight. Trying to get a centrally placed indoor AP to penetrate inner and outer walls is guaranteed to give reception issues.

Look at he stuff from Ubiquiti.

arghwhat··on Apple and SpaceX link up to support Starlink satellite network on iPhones
SNR is not a function of antenna size. The size is dictated by the wavelength, not how desperate you are to receive a signal.

Directionality does make an antenna larger as it usually involves reflectors and directors, the size and placement of which is also a fraction of the wavelength, but if they are actually able to do direct to phone with decent reception and arbitrary coverage, then that beats having to set up base stations to cover a small circle even if you get 10-15 dB better SNR.

This might give you LTE in, say, all of the Australian outback, all of Alaska, along the Andes mountain range, etc.

arghwhat··on Apple and SpaceX link up to support Starlink satellite network on iPhones
For remote areas that might still be tens to hundreds of kilometers of poles and fiber just to add coverage to one remote area. Then you move on to the next.

No one wants to do that across all of Alaska or the Australian outback.

← PreviousPage 17 of 34Next →