HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aroberge

1,655 karma · joined November 20, 2010

contact: aroberge at gmail dot com
submissionscomments
aroberge··on My Wish for Python 4
Any code transformation is possible to do in theory
aroberge··on My Wish for Python 4
Author of the blog post here. What you describe can already be done: https://aroberge.github.io/ideas/docs/html/. For example, if you wish to use a new syntax so that you can use Decimal literals, you can install https://pypi.org/project/decimal-literal/.
aroberge··on Python’s tug of war between beginner-friendly and advanced features
I agree with you: it is a bit of a "chicken and the egg" problem. I see it mostly as a tool that would be used/suggested by teachers, and that it would possibly be integrated in some editors targeted at beginners, such as Mu and Thonny. I have had discussions with developers for these two projects who all showed some interest in doing so when Friendly-traceback is more mature.
aroberge··on FATCA Pushes “Accidental” Americans to Give Up US Citizenship
This is an overgeneralization that is clearly incorrect in some cases. Just a quick example for Canadians, from [1]:

> Usually, it is best for United States citizens to not hold TFSAs since the costs of tax reporting and compliance usually exceed any benefits.

There is no US equivalent for TFSA.

[1] https://www.taxesforexpats.com/articles/retirement/simple-us...

aroberge··on Particle Physicists Continue to Make Empty Promises
> yeah more funding and focus should start to focus on stuff like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/An_Exceptionally_Simple_Theory...

This Wikipedia entry is 1) generically about the type of unproven theoretical model without experimental support that is used in an attempt to justify investment in the next big collider; 2) more specifically, about a theoretical model that has been shown to be wrong in terms of describing what we observe.

aroberge··on Particle Physicists Continue to Make Empty Promises
Dr. Sabine Hossenfelder is an opiniated physicist who gets a lot of flak for constantly commenting on this issue. Yet, I believe she does society a service in doing so.

I have yet to see anyone contradict her basic premise with factual information. I wish she were wrong, as I would love to see a breakthrough towards an experimentally verified Grand Unified Theory, including an explanation for what we currently identify as dark matter (similarly for dark energy). From what I read, physicists that criticize her take their own wishes for reality, and prefer to attack the messenger rather than confront the reality of the message.

aroberge··on Important Open Source projects should not use GitHub
If a project desires attracting contributors, it needs to reduce friction points as much as possible. Github is the code repository with which most developers are familiar. Once you contribute to one project on Github, you can more easily transfer that knowledge to contribute to a second project also hosted on Github then on other competing site, whether they use git or no.

Given the current situation, contrary to what the author affirms, important open source project that wish to attract contributors should probably use Github.

aroberge··on Python for Kids: A Comprehensive Python Development Tutorial for Kids
I did this with Blockly in Reeborg's World [1]; I added it many years ago. What would be the advantage of using BlockMirror over Blockly? Does it support translation?

[1] https://reeborg.ca/reeborg.html

aroberge··on Ask HN: How do I feel better about working for Amazon?
Take a leave of absence from your current job. Apply for minimum-wage jobs and don't stop until you have landed such a job and worked at it for at least one full month, doing all you can to live off that minimum-wage income. This almost certainly will reset your expectations and help you feel much better about your current job.
aroberge··on Show HN: A platform for beginners to learn programming in Python
Have you considered using friendly-traceback?
aroberge··on CERN approves plans for a $23B, 62-mile long super-collider
Actually, the Standard Model is NOT considered to be "beautiful". What is considered to be beautiful are extensions that include supersymmetry for which no experimental evidence exist but which have been used as justification for building larger colliders.
aroberge··on Canadians working from home permanently should expect salary changes: experts
So, employers are going to finance wealth accumulation for people buying a house in a high cost of living area?

[House ownership rate in Canada is 65%. Mortgage payment are not tax deductible.]

aroberge··on Finally, I Closed My LinkedIn
I did the same and the amount of spam emails (trying to sell me services or products related to my job) dropped down by at least 80%. If I were at the beginning of my career, I imagine that the network effect might compensate for the annoyance, but that is not the case for me.
aroberge··on Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local Markdown files
I just joined the beta last week. I keep my notes as md files in a private github repo. I just "loaded" the folder in obsidian and it just worked. I imagine that any editor that you can use with your own storage place would work.

Edit: Someone else mentioned " ... editing to add that I'm using iCloud for my vaults which allows for very fast syncing and the ability to edit on iOS".

aroberge··on Don't set the language of your website based on user location
The comma is used as a decimal separator in many countries which makes it impossible to use csv files without special import rules; nothing to do with using utf-8.
aroberge··on Don’t require a user to be interested twice: lessons on reducing signup friction
Please, keep the confirmation email. I get tons of email sent to one of my account because people register for some mailing list or other service and enter MY email address as theirs. If I get an email to confirm, I can safely ignore it and be done with it. Otherwise, it is a major annoyance.

ReCaptcha may be seen as useful to cut down on the number of bots but it screws things up royally when trying to navigate in private mode, or using a VPN.

aroberge··on Show HN: I made a Chrome extension to stop mindless browsing
First look: I like this. I like that it will help raise awareness of time I waste on some sites, but that I can easily bypass it if and when I need to. I like that I can choose to have it work only on some sites.

I've tried to use other somewhat similar extensions or tools in the past but removed them as they often "got in the way" of what I needed to do. Right now, this seems to be just right for me.

Thanks for doing this.

Normally, I immediately delete any unsolicited emails. However, if you want beta testers for any other creation, feel free to email me (username at gmail) mentioning that you created intention. I promise to have a look at what you create and to give you some feedback.

aroberge··on Why do you need a LinkedIn account?
Perhaps, if you are at a stage in your career where you might be changing jobs somewhat regularly, LinkedIn might be useful. However, be prepared to be spammed.

I am in a steady job, nearing retirement. I used to get a lot of spam loosely related to my work. Since I deleted my LinkedIn account, the volume of such spam emails has decreased by at least 80%.

aroberge··on One corner of U.S. oil market has already seen negative prices
Short answer: much lower salaries.

The average Albertan's salary is (still) much higher than that of workers from other provinces. Thus, each Albertan pays (on average) more federal income tax than workers from other provinces. Whether a province is "have" or "have not" is based on comparing the average federal income tax collected from that province compared with the national average.

The equalization payments is the income tax that gets partially redistributed - it is not a transfer from Alberta to other provinces.

For a given salary, the average income tax (combined provincial and federal) paid by someone in Quebec (or any other province) is much higher than that paid by someone in Alberta. Add to that the provincial sales tax (not paid by Albertans) ... and you get a situation where people outside of Alberta see Albertans as spoiled rich whiners as they: 1) earn a higher salary and 2) pay less taxes.

Meanwhile, Albertans (with their lower unemployment - still today) see "their" money wasted to these undeserving lazy Easterners ("lazy" = collecting money from EI). Politicians of all stripes contribute to fanning the flames. And, in spite of all this, we are generally considered to be a nice bunch, eh?

aroberge··on Automate the Boring Stuff with Python (2015)
Thank you for writing it. I used it for the first time last week and it made my job so much easier than the other solutions I was looking at.
aroberge··on A tiny Python exception oddity
Thank you. I actually thought I was overestimated the interest. Then again, I did not think that my blog post would attract the interest of the HackerNews readers.
aroberge··on Terence Tao Proves Result on the Collatz Conjecture
The Collatz conjecture predates GEB by many years. Renaming it to something else by the author of GEB was a way to misappropriate someone else's work.
aroberge··on Python adopts a 12-month release cycle
This is a misconception that has likely been compounded by the initial advice (by core Python folks, who eventually reverted their stance) on not doing this. For example, see this blog post https://aroberge.blogspot.com/2009/08/crunchy-10-released.ht... from 2009 for a non-trivial program that supported Python 2.4, 2.5, 2.6 and 3.1. It was a bit of a pain as it dealt with lots of unicode/strings, but it was doable. It became easier to support both Python 2 and Python 3 later on, especially once Python 3.2 was released.
aroberge··on The Beginning of the End of the Beef Industry?
> we can't survive on plant matter alone.

Many people are vegans and thrive.

aroberge··on The Beginning of the End of the Beef Industry?
I've had quite a few and I find them almost on par with burgers made with ground beef. It might depends on how you cooked them.
aroberge··on My Personal Journey from MIT to GPL
I teach Physics and Math. As a student, I enjoyed the freedom to consult textbooks, learn about new computation methods and be able to use them later when needed without worrying about potential restrictions. And I want my students to enjoy the same freedom. In my first projects, I used the GPL license but have moved since to almost always using the MIT License or, sometimes and when appropriate, CC-0.

When I find some interesting looking project on github or elsewhere, I am always tempted to look at the code. However, if I notice that the code is licensed under GPL, I refrain to do so as I do not want to have to worry about finding some "cool trick" but not being able to use it later in my own code without fear of violating the license.

I do get why some people swear by the GPL license, and I respect their choice and commitment to what they see as the greater good. However, I see it as a barrier to those that simply desire to learn.

aroberge··on Researchers solve mystery of the galaxy with no dark matter
If you assume that almost all the mass of a galaxy is in its nucleus, then the only "orbits" allowed are conical sections (ellipses, parabolas, hyperbolas): there is no such thing as a spiral trajectory. You would need a very unusual mass distribution to have spiral trajectories ... and it would imply that galaxies are not stable which would contradict what we see.
aroberge··on Canada Border Services seizes lawyer's phone, laptop for not sharing passwords
This is about a Canadian case. There is no such thing as a precedent from an American court.
aroberge··on Cosmologist claims Universe may not be expanding (2013)
Forget about the expansion of the universe; you could ask the exact same question for an observer moving away from a source and detecting a different frequency (hence energy) of the light emitted due to "normal" Doppler effect in a non-expanding universe. Energy (on its own) is not an invariant in (special/general) relativity. You have the same situation for measurements of lengths (i.e. Lorentz contraction). Energy is one coordinate of a four-vector whose "length" is the true invariant.

This is similar to a situation where you draw a set of perpendicular axis on a plane and use them to give coordinates (x, y) to a point. You then rotate the set of axis, keeping the point fix. Your question about the energy amounts to asking "what happens to the x-coordinate of that point?".

aroberge··on The Guardians of the French Language Are Deadlocked
I agree with your caracterization of courriel as elegant - and I find "pourriel" (for "spam") even more so.
← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →