HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aroberge

1,655 karma · joined November 20, 2010

contact: aroberge at gmail dot com
submissionscomments
aroberge··on Whitespace killed an enterprise app
> Are there things my users really don’t need to see right now?

Yes, what about the ridiculous amount of space taken by the header and footer on that page.

aroberge··on Slack closes account of an Iranian user living in Canada
> That's not what happened at all ... when they just made a geoip check ...

It sounds as though you have access to data that the rest of people on HN do not. Would you care to share your source? Are you certain he would not have been banned by Slack if he were not an Iran citizen (just Canadian) but would have (possibly) used Slack when travelling to Iran?

aroberge··on No, negative masses have not revolutionized cosmology
We have definitely not observed spontaneous creation of virtual pairs in a vacuum. I do not blame you for thinking so as it is often described this way.

Almost no computation in Quantum Field Theory can be done exactly. What physicists do is using perturbation theory which is very similar to doing Taylor series in introductory calculus. Feynman, in a genius inspiration, found a way to represent the various mathematical terms that occur in these types of calculations as pictures which could be described in words. In this pictorial language, one would say things like "this term correspond to the creation of a virtual pair of particles", etc." The perturbation expansion is a mathematical "trick" done so that we can do obtain approximate results. Each individual term in that expansion has no physical meaning - in spite of the pictorial language used.

aroberge··on Google’s smart city dream is turning into a privacy nightmare
Toronto, the city mentioned in the article, is in Canada. "Fisa courts" are a U.S. entity which has nothing to do with what is being done in Canada.
aroberge··on Are Black Holes Actually Dark Energy Stars?
> However, because our world is cosmological and the big bang does actually pick out a preferred reference frame, Lorentz Invarience has to be approximate in some way.

A particular solution to a set of equations does not usually have all the symmetry of the equations. In fact, I would say that, any solution to GR equations with energy and/or matter (assuming homogeneity on large enough scale) you will find something that looks like a preferred frame of reference.

aroberge··on Simple Thought Experiment Shows Why We Need Quantum Gravity
Dark matter is also required to make the predictions of primordial nucleosynthesis correct and modeling of the large scale structures of the universe.
aroberge··on China now the most prolific contributor to physical sciences, engineering, math
?? Canada's population is roughly 1/10 of that of the US and the article count shown for Canada is also roughly 1/10 of that of the US. Exactly how is it surprising?
aroberge··on Why Is College in America So Expensive?
The numbers do not (fully) support your argument. We have a similar situation in Canada in terms of expectations ... but the for the price paid by students which is signficantly lower. And, the participation rate is 54% for Canada compared with 44% with the U.S. - so, by your argument, university education should be much more costly in Canada than it is in the U.S.
aroberge··on ‘We’re taking a look’ at whether Google searches should be regulated
1) How many popular sites point back at Breitbart? At least initially, Google's search algorithm appeared to be based on the number of such backlinks. I imagine it still does to a certain extent. I doubt very much that the net traffic to a given site plays an important role in Google's search algorithm.

2) Have you tried to do the same search with other search engines?

aroberge··on PyPy.js: Python in the web browser
Tested on Brython (with Firefox) - http://www.brython.info/tests/editor.html?lang=en

    Iteration 0 took -0.9660000801086426s
    Iteration 1 took -0.9519999027252197s
    Iteration 2 took -0.9499998092651367s
It is about 10 times slower with Chrome on my computer.
aroberge··on Facebook Wanted Gizmodo to Kill Investigative Tool
I'm old enough to have lived with a phone number published and not have to worry about it. Then came the telemarketers. Still, long distance calls were expensive and such calls were relatively rare. Next, long distance calling became effectively free and telemarketing calls were becoming frequent. However, it was still only a dumb phone - so nothing to worry about. Then, smart phones came along, storing personal information and being potentially vulnerable to threats. They were also used for authentication. But hey, not to worry, since it's just like before: everybody used to be in the phone book ...
aroberge··on Ask HN: Choosing open source project licenses when not legally-minded?
I am not a lawyer ... Patreon allow people to get money from their "fans". You could make one or one hundred different app, each with their own licence, and it would (should) be irrelevant for support you get through Patreon.
aroberge··on How PEP-572 would change the standard library
That patch is not meant to be applied. It has been created to demonstrate the difference that the new syntax would make on code actually used in production.
aroberge··on Pythonic switch statement
To implement Option 3, it most likely suffices to remove any mention of self.fall in https://github.com/aroberge/experimental/blob/master/experim...
aroberge··on Pythonic switch statement
Given that Python has "break" as a keyword and "Explicit is better than implicit", I thought it was Pythonic to have it this way.
aroberge··on Pythonic switch statement
Author of the blog post here: this is just me having fun with import hooks in Python. The code written for this specific example is just a quick prototype which should not be used as an example for anything serious.

Still ... it's fun! ;-)

aroberge··on We're Baking ‘Have I Been Pwned’ into Firefox and 1Password
So, you conclude that it is a pointless tool because people can consult the HIPB website directly. Meanwhile, Troy Hunt, the creator of the HIPB website himself writes that this is a good idea.
aroberge··on Carlo Rovelli on the ‘greatest remaining mystery’: The nature of time
> It's been almost 100 years since the initial clash between classic mechanics and quantum theory, and how much closer are we to unification?

There is no problem with, to use your words, unification of classical mechanics and quantum theory

Classical Mechanics is recovered from Quantum Mechanics in the limit of h-bar (Planck's constant) goes to zero. In our day to day experience, Planck's constant is so small as to effectively be zero. The non-intuitive effects of Quantum Mechanics occur when we probe areas where the non-zero value of Planck's constant cannot be ignored.

There has been enormous progress in the last 100+ years in understanding how the world is described by Quantum Theory. In some ways, the so-called Standard Model of Particle Physics can be seen as the crowning achievement of that work.

The only remaining question on that front is the absence of a testable theory that describe gravitation as a quantum theory. String Theory appears to be a leading candidate for this, but it has not, so far, made any testable prediction outside of what we already know from other theories.

aroberge··on Carlo Rovelli on the ‘greatest remaining mystery’: The nature of time
Wow ... Since you are so certain that time does not exist, why don't you write a paper showing the implications for quantizing gravity, and why the standard spacetime picture of both Special and General relativity is wrong?
aroberge··on Path to a free self-taught education in Computer Science
> We really need to quit forcing programmers to take calculus. ...

This is a resource to learn Computer Science - not computer programming. Calculus and many other advanced mathematics topics are very much needed if wishes to learn Computer Science.

aroberge··on F.C.C. Repeals Net Neutrality Rules
The comment you replied to mentioned the USA. North America is a continent that includes 23 countries, only one of them is the USA. Living in one of the other 22 countries and looking at the USA, I would tend to agree with the comment that you were replying to, as the USA is becoming more and more an oligarchy, and less like a democracy.
aroberge··on Is billionaire VC Peter Thiel trying to break up Google?
The person I was replying to was referring to a study about the U.S.
aroberge··on Is billionaire VC Peter Thiel trying to break up Google?
Canada would disagree with you. One in five people living in Canada was born in another country [1]. Canada is officially a multicultural country [2]. Yet, there is a lot more trust and a lot less social strife than in the U.S., to use a comparison with the article you quote from the U.S.

[1] http://www12.statcan.gc.ca/nhs-enm/2011/as-sa/99-010-x/99-01...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Multiculturalism_Act

aroberge··on Show HN: Periodic Table of GitHub
I'm surprised to see this kind of things here, of all places. I'm even more surprised to see all the positive comments (so far).

The most important feature of the periodic table of elements is that it is based upon some underlying structure of the elements. It was initially used to make predictions about the existence of elements that had not been found at the time.

The "true" Periodic Table was truly a stroke of genius, equivalent in many ways in coming up with a scientific model/theory to describe nature.

The "periodic" part refers to the fact that some properties reappear as move from element to element, from the lightest to the heaviest: this is related to the filling of the atomic orbitals and their effect on chemical properties.

There is absolutely nothing of the kind in this so-called "periodic table" or its various cousins (I have seen some for "design" and other topics). There is no hidden structure revealed, no predictive power to be made if one were to actually leave one of the squares unfilled. It takes a wonderful communication/organisation scientific tool, keeping only a superficial visual element and leaving all essential meaning behind.

aroberge··on Convert Pure CSS to React Style or JavaScript Literal Objects
I don't get it. You take a solution (pure CSS) that does not require JavaScript to run, so that users that turn off JavaScript for security or other reasons can see the page styled as intended, and you convert it to something that will require JavaScript to be enabled so that it can be displayed properly.
aroberge··on Critical security updates for Git, Subversion and Mercurial
This may be of interest to people using git on Windows and have malwarebytes installed.

I tried to install a new version and found I could not as there was another version that was present. Git did not appear anywhere as a program to uninstall. I tried to delete it (from an admin account) and it failed with an access denied - and no other information.

The solution was to use LockHunter (https://lockhunter.com/) which informed me that malwarebytes was the program preventing me from deleting it. Using LockHunter, I removed the lock and successfully removed the old version of git.

aroberge··on Ask HN: Projects that don't make you money but you're doing it out of sheer joy?
http://reeborg.ca/reeborg.html is a site to learn programming (using either Python or Javascript).

However, unlike other similar sites, the focus is equally on making it easy for students to use AND making it easy for teachers/mentors to use, adapt and create their own learning material. To this end, I am currently writing an online book as a "Teacher's Guide":

https://aroberge.gitbooks.io/reeborg-s-world-advanced-world-...

This is a project that started out 13 years ago as a free desktop application (http://rur-ple.sourceforge.net/) and which I have been working, on and off, during all that time just for the joy of it and knowing that people have found it useful.

aroberge··on Canadian cable companies interrogate, search Montréal software developer
Perhaps it is based on the fact that Quebec law is known in French as the "Code civil" as opposed to the English-based "Common law" and so, would have little to do with what the English speaking world know as "civil cases".
aroberge··on Transfer of atomic mass with a photon solves the momentum paradox of light
All that the "Big Bang" refer to is 1) the fact that the (visible) universe was once much hotter and denser than it is now and 2) if we extrapolate back in time, using the theories that we have, there was a point where the density was infinite.

Of course, we know that our theoretical model break down before that (since we don't have an experimetally verified theory of gravity compatible with quantum mechanics). Physicist that work in the field (and I used to be one of them) are well aware that we cannot extrapolate past the regions of validity of our theories and no one claim that there was indeed a singular point ("Big Bang") as mentioned in descriptions aimed at a non-expert audience.

aroberge··on Transfer of atomic mass with a photon solves the momentum paradox of light
No, there are too many observations that are consistent with an expanding universe. For example, primordial nucleosynthesis [1] would either not have occurred in a non-expanding universe, or would not have stopped so soon. In fact, it can be used to show that it is consistent with having only 3 families of light neutrino species.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Bang_nucleosynthesis

Some relatively small effects of so-called "tired-light" scenario could likely be accommodated, but it would not change the main picture.

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →