HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arthur_pryor

283 karma · joined October 7, 2015

submissionscomments
arthur_pryor··on Why American Construction Costs Are So High
less constructively: taxpayers who complain about bad infrastructure but who don't want to pay taxes to fund better infrastructure can shut the fuck up.

please, <municipality>, take my money. build me a decent public transit system and provide high quality services.

arthur_pryor··on Why American Construction Costs Are So High
ha, i did not see this comment before posting mine, but the irony was not lost on me.

or rather, is it even ironic? it seems totally germane to a forum full of geeks with a wide spectrum of interests, many (most?) of whom are software devs.

arthur_pryor··on Why American Construction Costs Are So High
besides the inherent difficulty of estimating the resources required to finish a large project that hasn't been done before...

i think what willie brown describes here is also part of the problem providing estimates for the time required to complete software projects: if we gave more honest answers as devs, bosses and people signing contracts would blanche, so instead of standing firm, we go lower, or cut corners, or both.

i think the two things compounded together (inherent difficulty of estimating large unique projects, aversion to seeing real costs) are why estimates so often skew too low when we're trying to predict how long it will take to write a thing.

arthur_pryor··on Facebook moderators in America
the janitors at my office don't get paid enough, and don't get valued enough. AFAIK, we contract out our janitorial work, so that we don't have to pay benefits, etc. it's shameful.

> Janitorial work always has been under-appreciated. But cleaning up shit tends not to be high skill work.

the latter is a non-sequitur, IMO. work that causes that sort of personal injury should be well compensated, regardless of the skill level. it takes a lot of a person. we should try our best to make that person whole again, or to not take so much from them.

arthur_pryor··on Consumer Protection Bureau Aims to Roll Back Rules for Payday Lending
the point is, by removing the "least bad" option of an 8 year old working a coal mine, we were forced to improve our labor practices overall.

if kids don't have a better option than working in a coal mine at 8, society needs to come up with that better option, rather than giving the kid/family the current "best".

arthur_pryor··on Google’s Secret China Project “Effectively Ended” After Internal Confrontation
> However, free speech and oppression of democracy is not a moral wrong.

i and many others disagree with this statement.

> "Free speech" in the west means the Government shouldn't censor speech,this is a relativly new concept almost unheard of in history. It certainly isn't a human right. If a legitimate government of a country censors speech they're merely excercising their authority unless their laws restrict them from doing so as in the west. Whatever your view may be, a corporation does not get to decide social norms and what should be legal in any country.

why should the sovereignty of a national government supersede the inalienable rights of an individual? what makes a particular government "legitimate"?

if a totalitarian government decided that ethnic cleansing against a minority population was the correct course of action for itself, and if it carried that out entirely within its borders, would you consider that to not be a moral wrong, because the nation was exercising its own sovereign power? i'm just trying to figure out how much sovereign government power justifies in your moral framework.

arthur_pryor··on Google’s Secret China Project “Effectively Ended” After Internal Confrontation
why downvote this comment?

i'm not saying you have to agree with it, but this seems like as universally accepted an answer to "what are basic human rights?" as any that might be given (i'm assuming there is actually no universally agreeable definition, but this seems like one of the more respectable and frequently cited sources).

arthur_pryor··on NAACP returns Facebook donation, calls for boycott on Tuesday
that does not sound like a realistic course of action for a resource constrained group whose primary mission is not technology development.

a minority group should not have to deal primarily with people in that group just to be treated fairly while making their way in society.

arthur_pryor··on NAACP returns Facebook donation, calls for boycott on Tuesday
> We do, but it’s a broader problem than simply “minorities incur racism”. Racism manifests in all directions and while it’s valid to have support for minorities, it is nonetheless divisive that our society only takes racism seriously in one direction.

this implies to me that you believe racism against white people is as much of a problem as racism against minorities. i think this is an absurd claim to make, and i think there is ample concrete evidence in the form of both statistics and anecdotes that shows that racism is much worse for people of color (and yes, in particular, black people).

racism against white people is not a serious problem. at this point in our history, we need no organized effort to combat it.

> All humans face turmoil and struggle because of societal implications, racism simply being one of many.

i don't see how this implies that we should not specifically fight racism. should all problem solving be labeled at only the most general level? should we not have organizations dedicated to fighting racism against minorities because it's only one of the many problems a human might face in the world?

arthur_pryor··on Winamp 5.8 Release – First update in 5 years
i'd also be super interested in seeing this put up. if i'm being honest with myself i probably wouldn't be able to contribute (lack of time, don't have much C++ experience and even less graphics experience). but i always loved milkdrop, and i'd very definitely use a version that ran as a standalone app off any audio input.
arthur_pryor··on Can We Survive the Next Financial Crisis?
i don't see anything here that contradicts the parent.

which is to say, preventative and maintenance care are important, and i don't see any of that in what you described. parent's talking about emergency care. you're describing emergency care.

arthur_pryor··on Peak Valley?
> The people who would want to nix such a shelter would probably want it nixed whether it was in their proverbial "backyard" or not

i guess i don't have any more hard evidence at hand than what you present here, but my gut feeling is totally the opposite on this. i think there are a lot of people in SF (in the SF bay area in general or the city in particular) who would get behind this sort of program in principle, but who would be scared to be close to the implementation of such a program.

i think this particular flavor of NIMBYism (overblown fears about e.g. safety and/or property values) is more prevalent in the burbs, and especially the more affluent suburbs, but i'm sure you get some of it in the more affluent neighborhoods and gentrified pockets of other neighborhoods in SF and oakland too.

arthur_pryor··on Conference call simulator
this thing is great. don't have time to listen to it right now and see if it's changed at all, but when i listened to it last summer, i loved it. feels all too real.

i opened a radio show with 5 minutes of it once. then i sent it to some friends and half of them thought my email had been hacked and used to send out a phishing link (i felt bad after the fact for making it seem a little more ok to click on sketchy links).

arthur_pryor··on National prison strike launches over underpaid labor and prison conditions
> Rehabilitation isn't transactional, and a debt to society isn't something that can be repaid with cash.

well said. concise and correct, IMO.

arthur_pryor··on National prison strike launches over underpaid labor and prison conditions
i agree that's one way to read it, but it seems plausible to me that the intent really was just as a winnable end-run around abolition.
arthur_pryor··on Introduction to Augur, an open-source, decentralized betting marketplace
> > Some economists hope that we could use prediction markets to make difficult political decisions.

> Political decisions aren't verfiable fact questions, so they aren't really subject to prediction markets. You could use them as a tool to get possible answers to fact questions supporting policy decisions, but there is no real compelling case for them being better than the best available other methods in most domains for that, and in any case getting answers on fact questions related to policy decisions isn't even the hard part of getting good policy decisions.

i wish this comment/POV had gotten more traction in this thread. i am increasingly of the opinion that building consensus on values and goals is more of a problem in politics than is building consensus on facts.

arthur_pryor··on Tactics of Psy-Group, Black Cube Revealed in Canadian Court Battle
only if you just claim to live there for tax benefits, but don't actually reside in the state.
arthur_pryor··on Stripe is building a Ruby typechecker
amen to that.

i appreciate type checking so much more now than i used to, and i find that i disliked it most when i needed it most (i.e., i blanched at it more when i was a worse programmer, even more likely to make type errors than i am now).

there are categories of checks in application code (as well as whole categories of simple unit tests) that i just wouldn't have to write with a static type checker. additionally, as other comments have pointed out, it'd make it easier to automatically refactor things.

i started coming around on it with groovy a number of years ago (after sorta hating the type checker in java/c/c++ for years before that). i'd find myself writing a bunch of untyped code, but then i'd also find myself going back and specifying types as i wrote tests, because it was often easier to just specify the type than to write a test for the possibility of the wrong type coming in.

as someone who mostly writes ruby code these days, i'd love to see an optional type checker get added.

arthur_pryor··on Thousands of AI researchers are boycotting the new Nature journal
i'm moderately hopeful that we'll get that sort of querying for free* as the semantic web matures, and we can better query federated linked data. university libraries are pretty keen on making that dream a reality (and this is the sort of use-case that makes them want to be able to do that, though they'd probably pitch the rosier version, where they show the indirect impact of a well-regarded paper or study, because that sells better than the doom-n-gloom version described here, even if that version is just as important).

* or if not "free", a very small marginal cost, in terms of say data aggregation and programming effort

arthur_pryor··on Thousands of AI researchers are boycotting the new Nature journal
because then you wouldn't get a chance to say "blockchain"
arthur_pryor··on Thousands of AI researchers are boycotting the new Nature journal
...right, but then you have to figure out explicit metrics for determining what "prestige" is, and you have to explicitly implement the mechanics of it. i think this is a worthwhile research project of its own (or many research projects). but the mapping is very much non-trivial. i think the amount that people complain about how poorly the usual social media ontology ("friends", "likes", etc) maps to the "real"-world equivalent shows that this isn't something were you can just be like "we'll implement a first-pass of the blockchain thing now, and we'll refine the granularity of our prestige tokens later". thanks, but no thanks.

which is all to say, like so many of the things people want to use a block chain for, the hard part is the politics and the real-world nuance, not the immutable ledger. the immutable ledger is not trivial. but compared to the other stuff, it's not all that hard (and is certainly more solved, at this point).

arthur_pryor··on ISPs Say They Don’t Make Enough Money
i'd prefer a robust public safety net to corporate welfare.

but again, i find it more likely that comcast and the like would become competitive and less obscenely profitable, as opposed to going out of business entirely.

and if the pension fund knows what they're doing, they'd get out of the ISP stock. municipal ISPs aren't going to ruin anyone's retirement plan. that's absurd.

or as the kids like to say, national ISPs deserve a little disruption. their employees and shareholders will survive, and we'll all be better off.

arthur_pryor··on ISPs Say They Don’t Make Enough Money
> Shareholders are also people. Some shareholders are large and rich. Some are small. Some are pension funds that want their members to receive dividends and returns.

right. i didn't say i'm happy that shareholders will lose money. just that i found the trade-off acceptable. presumably most of them will get out of for-profit ISP stocks and not totally lose their shirt over it, should things start going downhill. then others will decline to invest in the first place.

if e.g. comcast were to go out of business, then that would suck, because a bunch of people would have to look for other work. i'd hope that competition would just make those sorts of companies into better citizens, and then they could stay in business, and provide a better product at a fairer price.

> And maybe I am a pessimist, but I haven't seen that many examples of government run enterprises that can be said to be well-run.

i've read many articles on arstechnica where people have extolled the quality of their municipal ISP, and bemoaned the ISP-led legislation that banned their municipal ISP.

note that i'm not saying we should outlaw private ISPs. but my strong opinion, based on all the evidence i've read, and my own personal experience, is that national ISPs (comcast, at&t, etc) use their monopoly power to the fullest extent that they can. they have terrible service, they provide a product inferior to what other countries provide municipally for less money, and they do nothing but complain to congress about how they're hurting while bragging to shareholders about how well they're doing. in short, i think they're bad actors, and i'd rather see the thing they provide treated like a public utility, which i firmly believe it is at this point.

> I haven't seen that many examples of government run enterprises that can be said to be well-run

ARPA-E is a fine example of a current government project that is well run and highly lauded. it would also be good to remember that you wouldn't have the internet were it not for "government run enterprise" (it was ARPAnet before it was "the internet").

arthur_pryor··on ISPs Say They Don’t Make Enough Money
> The money has got to come from somewhere

sure, but the total operating cost can be lower, because they don't have to rake in profit. said another way, the profit-making imperative is operating overhead that a municipal ISP doesn't have.

since their total cost of operation is lower, and since their incentives are more aligned with the desires of their customers, they can provide a better experience for said customers, while using less resources overall. the only people who lose are shareholders of for-profit ISPs. i find that trade-off acceptable.

arthur_pryor··on Is there a fix for impostor syndrome?
B) for sure. i haven't had that used as an interview technique on me, but i've been on the interviewing end of that, and the feedback from the candidates was great. additionally, we felt it gave a great sense of what it'd be like to work with them, and based on the people we've hired so far using pairing as a component of the interview, it's a better predictor than anything else i've ever seen.

we also ask for a presentation on prior work or a prior project, we do some architecture whiteboarding, and we have talkier personnel type parts. but currently, the hour and change pairing exercise is the only programming exercise, and we were happy enough with the results last summer that we're doing it again for an upcoming round of interviews. our setup was a PM, a tech lead, and a "driver" (the person at the keyboard, which is what i was in the exercise). interviewee is the "navigator" (and by not having to type, we get rid of some of the stage fright for syntax errors and such, and just get to see their thought process since it's a pretty compressed timeframe). best microcosm of real work i've seen. one important thing is to give the same exercise each time (one possible risk in our case was that we gave the candidate 3 possible things to choose from, but settling on what we thought was the best choice was part of the test, and all the candidates ended up passing that part, so we never had to compare WIP from two different coding exercises).

apologies for rambling or repetition, dashing this off before i go to bed. but i'm a big fan of this interview approach, and i think it's probably the best thing we've hit on so far in this field, for positions where that would be a reasonable microcosm of what day-to-day work is like. i think it's much better than making someone code on a whiteboard, or giving them a take home or solo exercise, because you get so much more info about other things besides how well they can bang out a single well spec'ed piece of code.

arthur_pryor··on Is there a fix for impostor syndrome?
i'd posit that if an employer can't find a decent pool of current employees to potentially pair program with an interviewee, they have deeper problems than getting that upcoming interview right, and need to correct for some past hiring mistakes ASAP.

i would definitely be looking for employment elsewhere if i my co-workers were so unpleasant that i thought they'd turn every pairing session into a pissing contest (and i say that as someone who generally prefers solo programming as far as immediate enjoyment goes, but who finds that pairing is often useful and/or necessary).

arthur_pryor··on ICE held an American man in custody for 1,273 days. He’s not the only one
add to that the way they let him go:

> Surprised by his unexplained freedom, Watson walked out of a federal detention center in rural Alabama. He recalled how he was penniless, in prison garb and thousands of miles from home when he approached strangers at a gas station to borrow a phone.

arthur_pryor··on What the FOSTA/SESTA anti-sex trafficking bill means for sex workers
To me, it seems clear that Backpage was well outside of the safe harbor of section 203. They knew full well what they were doing, and knowingly helped facilitate a lot of illegal (and in my opinion immoral) activity.

EDIT: the part that i find immoral is the slavery and trafficking. i have zero problem with genuinely consensual sex work.

arthur_pryor··on What the FOSTA/SESTA anti-sex trafficking bill means for sex workers
oh interesting, esp in light of your other comment's statement that regulated legalization hasn't made things better for sex workers in vegas.

i think i need to run some errands and do some work instead of scouting bandcamp and reading HN, but i hope to read your time link and mull that stuff over later this afternoon/evening. thanks for the opinion/info, even if i don't have a reply while anyone's still reading this thread (though i'll try to reply regardless if i think i have something worthwhile to say, if only to get it out for myself).

i would say that even if i stay thinking that regulation is the right thing in principle, i'd hope that it'd not be so draconian as to impinge on small independent operators (a la the blind eye turned to homebrewing and your average poker game).

without further reading/consideration, i'd still think that a business composed of multiple people involved in prostitution, or a business space specifically devoted to it, might be things subject to regulation? or maybe not even that, i dunno. i'm a big believer in civil liberties and personal freedom, but i'm also not much for libertarianism (because it doesn't seem like it always does a good job of maximizing freedom for most people when you take into account how people behave in groups).

arthur_pryor··on What the FOSTA/SESTA anti-sex trafficking bill means for sex workers
I have nothing of substance to add to this comment, but I agree with absolutely everything you've said, and I hope you don't get downvoted. I can't really add any nuance, because I don't know where in the weeds we might disagree.

I realize that my comment isn't very substantive, and I'm pretty low-karma, but I think you're generally a thoughtful commenter from what I've seen, and I think more people need to read what you've said and mull it over and at least do the thought exercise of seeing how they might agree with you, even if they determine that they ultimately do not agree with you.

Please, let's legalize and regulate prostitution.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →