HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arthurdent

482 karma · joined April 5, 2010

Flying is really quite easy. You just have to throw yourself at the ground and miss.

a.distinguished.englishman@gmail.com

submissionscomments
arthurdent··on Critique My First Start-up? (Not yet public)
depends who your target market is, but the predictions angle is a bit sketchy.

as far as i can tell, even the paid predictions are just a stock and a forecast, but there's nothing to let the eventual user know whether they are good or bad predictions.

historical performance information about the forecasting system, general principles or something might be helpful, but at the end of the day, as far as i know, they're just randomly pulled out of the hat and i have no reason to believe they've ever been profitable.

a buyer would need a reason to buy, especially since stock advice out there is frequently offered for free.

arthurdent··on I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work)
this is really not entirely correct.

when things started melting down in 2008, it was largely attributed to the fact that hedge funds basically all had the same strategies in their book. When one started liquidating, many started losing value and liquidating in a disastrous feedback loop.

There are plenty of strategies that are very robust, and in hedge-fund land, its not uncommon that many players are playing very similar hands.

In fact, there even exist strategies that get better as more people run them.

arthurdent··on Tell HN: Stocks are not a zero sum game and high frequency trading is great
oh, and btw. sproutrobot is awesome.
arthurdent··on Tell HN: Stocks are not a zero sum game and high frequency trading is great
define: mispriced = "value != market price"

Where you and i diverge is "Value is relative in one case and absolute in the other."

I think you're saying that HF Guy's definition of value is relative and Value Guy's definition of value is absolute.

If its even correct that any company has a single true value, I think this number is unknowable. Investors or traders make estimates of this value, and if their estimate deviates significantly from the market price, they transact with Mr. Market.

Nobody's estimate is more absolute or relative than any one else's.

edit: deleted a bunch of pointless words.

arthurdent··on Tell HN: Stocks are not a zero sum game and high frequency trading is great
Isn't "finding undervalued companies" fundamentally an infrequent activity

I guess I don't understand why this is necessarily true. ACN supposedly might have traded $.01 on the day of the flash crash (busted). It rallied back after the fact. It was likely undervalued at $.01. If such price behavior were to be an annual, monthly, daily, or hourly occurence, it'd probably still be considered a mispricing of the stock. My position is that "correct" valuation (if such a thing exists) and frequency are entirely independent.

I don't see how it's possible to assess the value of a company relative to market price fast enough to make even 10 trades a day.

i think you're making a comment about the speed at which valuation occurs. without sounding too obvious about the answer, computers are really fast at running numbers (not trying to be rude). there are all sorts of ways of valuing companies, even in the traditional space of "value investing". http://www.fool.com/investing/beginning/how-to-value-stocks-... gives 5 broad methods to start. if there were a method that involved only objective numerical data, then that valuation could occur continuously throughout the day.

I would say High Frequency Trading is, by definition, not about value, but about price only.

I think the 2 are necessarily related. When Value = Market Price, the issue is fairly/correctly priced. When the two diverge, there is an opportunity. High frequency trading is concerned with finding issues that are underpriced with respect to the "true value". So in that sense, I think High Frequency Trading is certainly about price, as is "long term value investing".

[Collecting rebates and high frequency trading don't so much apply to the claim i'm making here]

arthurdent··on Tell HN: Stocks are not a zero sum game and high frequency trading is great
flash orders is actually the main thing i was referring to when i said "There are flavors of HFT that aren't easily defensible "

a whole lot of HFT has nothing to do with seeing the orders before they happen.

"high frequency trading" encompasses a lot of different strategies (just like "computers" is a large and varied field).

imagine a high frequency strategy that finds mispriced securities, and trades them. as it happens, these trades tend to converge very quickly. would you consider this "fundamentally different" from long term investing (in any way other than the holding time horizon, which the agent can't possibly know before the trade actually realizes)?

arthurdent··on I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work)
I find myself excited over the preliminary results of my increasingly sophisticated simulations

This. The vast majority of the money being made in the market is being made by people with what you may consider a laughable lack of "sophistication".

Start simple. Complex modeling of stock market behavior only makes sense if you think the stock market has a complex underlying structure.

arthurdent··on Ask HN:How many of you nerds "read" wikipedia?
my colleague reads math entries in wikipedia at least 4 hours a day. obscure optimization and nonlinear fitting methods.

it blows my mind. in the last 6 months he has learned a TON of material and I am very envious of the knowledge he's gained.

i want to learn what he has learned, and more importantly i want to WANT to pore over wikipedia math articles and try out the techniques, but its just not in me.

i learn when i have to and i force myself to. he does it because its fun. he'd do it even if it didn't help him or have any application to his work (frequently it doesn't). reading, testing, confirming new algorithms is his "guilty pleasure" in the same way some people can't stop playing starcraft.

kind of awesome really.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: How do I turn 100K into 1 million?
great idea. that's exactly what you should do if you're insisting on an intelligent investor style value portfolio, and thats what Buffet does.

But the real point is that trading isn't a chump game and the entire notion of "long term holding is the best strategy" is premised on a lot of old notions that predate the current market environment.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: How do I turn 100K into 1 million?
this sounds like the most surefire way to achieve your goals.

seconded.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: How do I turn 100K into 1 million?
Its a fairly well documented phenomenon that option volatility increases going into earnings then immediately deflates after the fact.

An at the money "straddle option" is essentially purely a volatility play, but the problem is that once the stock moves, the "straddle option" accumulates various other risk factors that are harder to manage.

This is also why you can't just sell the position knowing that the volatility will go down after earnings, because the change in the risk characteristics other than volatility may be sufficiently costly so as to offset the gains from the decrease in volatility with a short straddle position.

This particular play is fairly common though and many option traders who feel they have insight into the magnitude of the future move relative to its pre-earnings pricing will make plays on it (largely based on historical evidence or earnings predictions).

arthurdent··on Ask HN: How do I turn 100K into 1 million?
Derivatives are mathematically zero sum minus costs. That's why. For traders in aggregate, they are a certain loss.

1. Fair enough. HSO makes the point that this is true for all financial transactions. So by your logic, investing in the stock market is also a guaranteed way to lose money over time. I don't think this is your contention, but this is really going to end up being a silly conversation if we have it. We'll just agree to disagree.

2. On a different note, in the interest of sharing something I learned recently. Options almost always trade at a volatility premium to their realized volatility. The reason for that is that vol traders want to price in the future uncertainty in vol.

Derman writes about this a bit here by comparing it to interest rate term structures: http://ederman.com/new/docs/gaim-trading_volatility.pdf

3. Also, historically (if that matters) selling vol is actually positive EV. BXM is a buywrite index and has outperformed the SP500 on a risk adjusted basis (http://ederman.com/new/docs/gaim-trading_volatility.pdf) indicating that option vols have not been fairly priced.

4. Countering #4 is the popular Taleb wisdom about selling vol. Taleb is a net buyer and won. His general contention though is that kurtosis of the distribution is mis(under)priced. So from those 2, you might think that selling at the money options is positive EV and buying "tails" is positive EV. Of course the rest of the Taleb intuition is that we have no idea what the actual yield distribution should look like, so all pricing is out the window.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: How do I turn 100K into 1 million?
I'm going to invite a flurry of disagreement here, but I'm just going to say it. Investing is not the answer, trading is.

II and SA are phenomenal books, but they are also more relevant to a different time in market history. The basic tenets certainly hold true. (Ben Graham famously loved buying companies under book value. Thats still a winning bet and will continue to be.)

Its important to realize the macro picture here as well though. The last 70 years have produced tons of literature saying that long term growth is the way to do it and that int he last 70 years long term investments have outperformed. This period of "proven returns" coincides with the US rising to the world superpower, becoming the richest nation on earth, and spending beyond our means.

I have a massive faith in America, but its irresponsible to not consider that times have changed. The next 70 years could be like the last 70, but we stand at a social/economic/global power precipice which could imply a dramatically different America in 10 years. If the American economy sucks hard for the enxt 10 years, returns are just going to suck. Long buy and hold portfolios have won in large part also because the American economy has expanded for the last 70 years.

The other huge difference is that HN is comprised primarily of extremely computer savvy people. The tools wielded by the readers here are uniquely suited to tackle financial problems that can produce excess returns that far exceed

The risks aren't significantly higher, yet the upside is disproportionately greater when utilizing the techniques (computing) and infrastructure (electronic markets and cheap execution) that have become available in the last 10 years that did not exist in almost the entire duration of the period that produced all of the "buy and hold is the only way to go" literature.

HN people are smart. REAL smart. That's why a lot of people have read mountains of literature to educate themselves. Unfortunately, the success of buy and hold strategies in the last X years produced a bias towards that sort of literature and everyone's drank the kool-aid.

The last 5 years, and even more the last 2 years have democratized the quantitative trading process, exposed the tools to those not in the industry, and changed the face of finance.

There's still a place for the Intelligent Investor. But if you're the average HN reader, Ben Graham style investing isn't your best shot in finance. Quantitative trading is. Both will take a lot of work. It won't be easy. But if you're going to invest serious time, think about how much the tools and the game have changed in the last 2 years and ask yourself if you really think that all the literature that predates this change is indicative of the new world.

I too believe you can turn 100k to $1mm. and I think you can do it a lot faster.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: How do I turn 100K into 1 million?
How did you find work at an investment bank without being sufficiently savvy to realize?

Is this deliberately intended to be disparaging? 1. There are plenty of people at investment banks whose principal function isn't to understand options. 2. What makes it so clear that buying options is a "guaranteed way to lose money over time".

At any rate, the only people profiting on derivatives are the market makers. And even they blow up eventually.

This is empirically false. There are a lot of people who make money in derivatives. Vol stat arb funds have performed very well over the last 5 years, dispersion has long been a popular trade.

Bear stearns did not blow out in its marketmaking capacity.

Typically the options traders that are said to "blow up eventually" are premium sellers, not buyers, which is in direct contradiction to your previous comment about option buyers being guaranteed to lose money over time.

This is unnecessary and not really in the spirit of providing help to someone asking for advice.

You either think he's full of BS and are trying to call him out or are just being rude. I think he sounds sufficiently accomplished and is trying to understand a new field. Don't discourage that.

edit: had to look up how to properly italicize

arthurdent··on Ask HN: Trading Algorithms
Seems there have been a lot of posts on HN in the last week or so about algorithmic trading.

There doesn't seem to be a shortage of interest in this field either, but the threads quickly get lost in the HN jumble. Does anyone want to volunteer to take this conversation somewhere else?

arthurdent··on Ask HN: Trading Algorithms
Interactive Brokers has paper trading and good docs http://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/p.php?f=tws&p=p http://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/p.php?f=programInterfac...

http://www.maxdama.com/ talks about the IB api a bit.

I skimmed your comments and kept seeing the word python. There's a 3rd party python-IB package here (can't vouch for it): http://code.google.com/p/ibpy/

http://epchan.blogspot.com/ talks a little bit about basic pairs trading strategies. My experience has been that adding complexity off the bat is usually not the way to go. I don't personally know anyone who is using AI/machine learning as their primary strategy generation mechanism, but maybe I just run with the wrong circles.

I'm interested in collaborating with smart people re trading ideas, so if you're interested as well, fire me an email.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: do I want to work at a trading firm?
email me, i'd be happy to provide some insight.
arthurdent··on Ask HN: A stock trading platform for hackers?
In my experience, between 4-7GB compressed per day for top level regional data in US equity markets.
arthurdent··on Ask HN: A stock trading platform for hackers?
I have also pulled 1 second bars for currency from IB. they throttle your query rate though, so it can take some time to get your data.
arthurdent··on Ask HN: A stock trading platform for hackers?
IB will give you up to 1 second resolution (open, high, low, close) for most US equity names.

getting bid ask tick data is harder/more expensive to come by.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: A stock trading platform for hackers?
More on IB: so you basically just have to fund an account with whatever their minimum is now (might be 10k now).

then to get most US stock/options/futures data, it only costs 10 bucks a month for their live feed. If you make trades, your commissions go towards paying down your data fee. If you don't trade for a few months, consider it 10 bucks a month for the opportunity to develop strategies in a real environment.

Also, they give you a "paper trading acct" which behaves like a real account, except it doesn't post real trades. you can forwardtest your strategies on live market data with this.

IMO, this is probably the best way for HN people to get involved.

I also realize that it probably sounds like I'm selling for IB, but i'm not. Just a happy customer for 4 years.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: A stock trading platform for hackers?
Forgot to mention: algodeal.com

Never tried it myself and can't vouch for them, but it seems to be an interesting concept and might let a lot of hackers get their feet wet without any monetary investment.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: A stock trading platform for hackers?
I was previously a professional trader.

For quantitative mid frequency trading on a retail size account that doesn't require ultralow latency: Many pros use IB personally and their java API is quite good. You'll be disappointed to know that MOST finance apps are built for windows environments and are frustrating to work with. IB's is quite reasonable. IB also lets you pull historical data that is quite decent, though they cap the rate at which you can pull historical data bars.

http://www.maxdama.com/ has written quite a bit about the IB API and I've found the provided documentation is actually quite good.

For pseudo HF type trading I'd say to take a look at lime brokerage.

REDI plus (Goldman sachs' platform) also has reasonable resources, though its harder to set up an account. for IB I think you just need 8k or so to open an account. Transaction costs are also the best for most retail/hackerish type applications (smallish quantitative based trading).

Also i'm interested in collaborating with HN people regarding trading strategies. I think the HN crowd is actually sort of the idea crowd to try to make it. There seem to be quite a few pros that actually read HN as well.

Would love to get in touch with anyone who is interested in working on strategies or even just talking.

arthurdent··on Stock prediction using Weather, Twitter, News & Stock sites...
just read this recently found it ok: http://www.puppetmastertrading.com/blog/2010/04/08/pairs-por...

ernie chan's blog is also a decent starting point: epchan.blogspot.com

arthurdent··on Rent a White Guy
friend of mine went to china on vacation and after a dinner with some acquaintances was asked by someone he met there to serve as an expert on an alternative energy panel at a conference.

he's the sort of person who find that amusing, so with no experience, he was a wind energy expert for a night.

arthurdent··on AI That Picks Stocks Better Than the Pros
depending on the strategy, its possible to build reasonable simulations of the affect your trades will have on the market, though the data you need to do so is harder to get and a lot more expensive. but for a strategy like the one described it'd be reasonable to take the existing market and assume that you could pay offers, hit bids, and maybe build in a little slippage to get a reasonable simulation.

academics though, typically don't care as much about simulating for transaction costs because they're more interested in perceived mispricing in the marketplace as an interesting economic/intellectual phenomenae. Frequently academic papers will assume a 1-price world where the 1-price is midmarket and build the model off that.

If the market were indeed entirely efficient, then the described trade wouldn't be better than chance even with no transaction costs or bid-ask.

arthurdent··on AI That Picks Stocks Better Than the Pros
That's not really accurate.

The stock market does not generally act as a mechanism to allow investors to funnel capital to companies. The stock market, as most people think about it, is really a secondary market for fractional ownership of companies.

The process by which that fractional ownership came to be owned by other people is the process by which companies are funded (companies go public and sell shares to the public. this is the major process by which the stock market helps companies raise capital (in exchange for equity)). So all the trading that happens intraday, or even holding some stock for years and years generally does not actually serve to invest in the company.

The question of whether this is a good thing is entirely orthogonal to the point of the article, which seems to be that reading news fast gives you information about markets.

While marketmaking is indeed a valuable market service as described by hugh3, the AI in question doesn't fill that role in any meaningful way (the AI stock picker seems to be a market taker -- it actually removes liquidity when it sees opportunities)

A defensible argument for algorithms like this is that they help maintain market efficiency/ensuring that risk in the marketplace is accurately priced (if such a thing is possible). The AI basically is incorporating news that the world knows and acting on it. If the AI didn't do it, then the markets would, but slower. The fact that its making money on 20 second timescales just means that its getting news 20 seconds faster than the rest of the market, which isn't particularly shocking because you might imagine that the rest of the world is responding without the benefit of an AI that reads/interprets articles in bulk.

arthurdent··on [dead]
False. I'm not sure why this post is catching as much flak as it did so quickly, but you don't seem to have read the post in its entirety.

From the 3rd paragraph: "Microsoft's market cap is 221 B, their book value is 46 B, and therefore 175 B of their market cap is projected future earnings. Their current profit is 46.28 B/year, and that works out to the market valuing them at their current earnings stream projected over a bit under 4 years."

As a finance professional I think its actually a fairly reasoned comment. Its not enough to make big decisions with, but investing is frequently about taking little scraps of information to formulate an opinion.

In this case, it portrays and interesting difference between companies that compete in similar spaces and I think the qualitative finding roughly corroborates most people's views about the future of MSFT's business based on their current execution quality.

arthurdent··on [dead]
I understood the author to be saying that the market doesn't have the ability to predict out beyond 10 years. The ~10 year prediction for AAPL and GOOG is less of an indication that those 2 companies will fall off a cliff in 10 and more of an indication that in that timeframe the businesses/economic environment could change, or maybe that they're discounting future cashflows very heavily in an uncertain rate environment.

On the contrary, < 4 years for MSFT is potentially within the ability of the market to predict and more likely an indication that the market actually believes that MSFT on its current trajectory won't hack it.

A lot of people might agree that trends in open source software, distributing computing away from home PCs to cloud applications, and their inability to compete effectively for search or hardware makes their CURRENT business a dying one.

On the other hand, MSFT has smart people and money and I wouldn't doubt their ability to reinvent themselves and start competing in new markets.

arthurdent··on Ask HN: Should I stay on board?
I'm in a similar-ish situation here.

I brought a friend onto an idea when it was in the very formative "barely an idea" stages. The initial idea was of the "good enough to try, but not enough to build an empire" variety.

He rapidly took the idea to a level where I think it might be an empire, but also a level where I can't really contribute. Its basically the idea done right, but more advanced than I can handle (he's a better mathematician and a better programmer than I) and I can't help but thing "well shit, maybe I should be just letting him do it on his own" (he can, and its not clear that having a second hand would be helpful (or worth it) in this venture).

I'm still sort of scared to have the conversation, but I've got to do it soon.

Anyone have any advice?

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →