482 karma · joined April 5, 2010
a.distinguished.englishman@gmail.com
I'm 5 years out of college and I think my position has changed significantly since then. Until probably a year out of college I only thought very abstractly about questions like this and believed there was a large class of problems for which there is no price.
Until a year or so after I graduated, I think I believed that most people (hookers excluded) wouldn't offer sex at any cash price. I always thought those transactions generally HAD to occur masked as "I'll buy you some beers/some dinners/we'll date/any time or cash value exchange in return for sex"
My more recent experience with regards to your experiment is almost the exact opposite of your findings. I'm consistently shocked by how LOW a price people are willing accept for all manner of tasks, including sex.
Not to sound way too shady, but I've since found that the cash price point for sex for most women is not only "no price", but in fact far lower than I would have imagined. Or maybe I've just met way sluttier girls since graduating. The price for most men is basically zero.
I'll also say there's likely some sort of phase transition here where the answer to "what kind of girl she is" is dependent on some socioeconomic indicator. Hypothesis: Money and status buy people a LOT of self importance and stricter adherence to a moral code. People don't have to bend their espoused morals unless faced with tough questions.
Re your experiment: - saying and doing are different, especially since the question seems to have been explicitly phrased as an exchange of sex for money. there are all sorts of ways to phrase the question where sex is understood but without actually saying it. - £1MM is doesn't even feel like a real number to most students. hypothetical questions get hypothetical answers.
Like @Confusion, I now generally believe there's a price for everything. If it can be measured in dollars, thats an easy question to answer. The hard questions are those that are measured in things money can't buy.
yes, people still do that by holding up the number of fingers of the price they want. yes, its archaic.
but frankly, the electronic markets tend to do really poorly in these situations. its hard to get a "real" 2-sided market in panics and all the liquidity is relly in the pits.
the word "for" typically only represents bids or purchases and the word "at" typically represents offers or sales.
so you can sell AT price X, but you don't sell FOR price X (some people say it wrong, but old timers tend to hate it).
typically to represent an offer you'd say "i'm [price] offered" or "i'm at [price]", but to represent a bid you'd say "i'm [price] bid" you'll notice he says "i'm offered AT [price]", but you wouldn't say you're bid "for" [price], you'd say "i'm [price] bid"
additionally in transactions, you'd say: sell [quantity] at [price] pay [price] on [quantity] inverting the structure gives another sanity check when people are checking trades verbally.
and those guys have insanely good memory, because they make these trades by word of mouth then card it (write up a paper slip) after the fact. when its busy, you can be carding trades up well after the fact and many trades later.
in the pit
a "handle" is the whole number value, so when he says "down 65 handles" S&P futures are trading 65.00 points under the closing price from yesterday.
in the pit they generally refer to just the unit place and the decimal value: "5 evens" = xxx5.00, "seven halves" are xxx7.50, "seventy evens" == xx70.00 (in this case it was 1070.00 in the SP 500 future price).
when he says "figure bid at oh five" at the end, figure refers to a hundreds handle, (in this case it was 1100), so the two sided market was 1100.00@1100.05.
I'm shocked that he's saying its the craziest he's ever seen because it was like that in about the same duration about 2 years ago. one morning S&P's printed down 80 handles or so in a few minutes and came all the way back up just like yesterday.
The notion of running a credit card company basically for free as a way to get information about the economy and made MUCH more profitable trades in the financial markets really appeals to me.
Friend of mine has been working on using google trends/blogs as such an indicator, but its a lot harder to tease tradable information out of that sort of data.
Camera: to start with and learn on, xsi is a great camera. if you're thinking nikon, i'd get a d40 if you want to stay in the same price range (skip the d60, its not better than the d40).
i generally recommend the d90 for nikon as a starter if you're a little more flexible with budget (same sensor as the d300, cropped sensor, but i think thats a nonissue for most beginners, especially if you're shooting for posting online).
between nikon/canon -- just pick one. this is basically the same sort of question as "ruby or python".
i've bought happily off craigslist, but if you're even slightly concerned that the seller is sketchy, skip it, unless you know what to look for. better to pay 50 bucks more as insurance that you're getting quality early on. B&H photo is a great place to buy online and they'll match any reputable vendor (usually they're the bst though).
read kenrockwell.com. he reviews a ton of cameras and generally has a higher concentration of quality information in one place than you can find elsewhere.
My POV = trading is zero sum (or worse, because transactions take money, and brokers are a guaranteed to win 3rd party in every transaction)
However, I don't think thats the right analogy.
Every trade in trading is like the credit card transaction you make towards Dropbox every month. That transaction is zero sum (with Amex skimming 1.7% and Spreedly taking some too, just like brokers). I buy a stock, for an agreed upon price.
Dropbox gets nothing if they don't provide value to the marketplace. You don't get customers in trading if you don't provide value to the marketplace. Every dropbox competitor takes dollars out of dropbox's pocket (so in that sense is zero sum across strategies). Every trade I take from Citadel is a trade they don't make.
There's lots of money flying around, its a big pie, I just want some crumbs.
Basically, startups get paid because they fill a market need.
Traders get paid because they fill a market need. If I create a strategy that nobody wants to trade against, I'll have no customers, make no trades, and will never get paid.
I'm not saying there aren't sketchy strategies (true in finance and web startups). I'm not on top of the whole flash orders story, and I think some people take advantage of weaknesses in the system. Thats true in every industry though.
In the same way taxes are a reason to not get into money making ventures.
Short term trading encompasses a lot of ideas. Some are good some aren't. Many "short term" trading strategies have significantly higher sharpe ratio's than Fool style investing. Fool investing is great. I learned a LOT from that site. But I also want returns in shorter time spans, so I'm willing to pay that capital gains tax.
Motley fool is a GREAT source for long term investing knowledge for anyone interested in that. A lot of other great classic investment texts are getting thrown around in this comment thread (Intelligent Investor, for one).
Recommended book for those interested in "Motley Fool"/Benjamin Graham/Warren Buffet type investing, I'd also recommend http://www.amazon.com/Little-Beats-Market-Books-Profits/dp/0...
Its sort of in the same vein, but slightly shorter term, backed up by a lot of statistics. Basic principle: Choose the best 20 companies every year. Define "best" as top PE or some other really simple metric. You can tweak it a little as well based on your personal risk profile, desired industry exposure. Consistently outperforms the market.
The motleyfool is a site that looks amazingly like spam and reminds you of all the "earn 50 bazillion percent every hour using options!" emails you get, but is actually chock full of great information.
Greenblatt's book sounds shady as hell, but its a quick, easy read and quite informative, backed by just enough logic to make you want to try it.
I haven't really looked into it, but what it sounds like to me is they provide you a platform to build strategies and test them, play with fake money. They may optionally take your strategy and run it in the market. If it is successful, they split returns with you.
When you say they're setting themselves up to get ripped off, I think you're suggesting that Evil Person X may come up with a strategy A that does well enough in backtests, but is paired with a strategy B designed to rip off that strategy A. Then after AlgoDeal applies strategy A, I put my secret millions to work and make better returns for myself.
They don't HAVE to run your strategy. I'm assuming they're smart guys and have some selection criteria other than "performed well in backtests", so they'd try to choose strategies that were less likely to get ripped off by the evil person's counter-strategy. Also, I think of this as being the VC who seems massive dealflow. Half of it is the fun of seeing all the good ideas and picking the top ones. Some will still fail, but choosing from a much larger base of ideas is great. Plus they utilize their own expertise to tweak strategies for themselves.
Its basically YC for algo strategies, except they don't have to pay you, they can steal your startup and change it a bit, and they take a much bigger percentage (i'd guess 50-80%, based on what I think are something like industry standards).
Its quite common place in finance to have people give you strategies and give them a cut of the profits. This takes it to the next level: crowdsources strategies and removes the barrier to entry for a lot of smart people (trading costs) in exchange for the right to tap those ideas.
Love it.
They're cheap. For US stocks its $.005 to $.01 per share (with a $1 min per order) or something. I think most people here are interested in trading stocks (if interested at all).
Regarding 20-30% returns on fake money, but 0-5% on real money, trading fees should be an assumption you make when you trade with fake money. I'm guessing you did, but if there's such a wide disparity, it just means you have to re-evaluate. Writing strategies is just like a software startup. Be agile, course correct often, when expectations differ from actual results, find out why.
If trading costs is really your primary issue, I guess I'm plugging http://www.algodeal.com since I just discovered them over the weekend and it sounds sort of cool and like a good platform to learn to do it with no cost (except the cost of many Hello World programs).
[I am in no way affiliated with Algo Deal. I haven't even really looked into it that much. But their splash page sounds cool and I'm frankly envious that its their startup and not mine]
It is noble that you prefer to fix it. I consider that "fixing" broken things is a task that adds value to the world. I think that value creation generally is something that is rewarded (not necessarily monetarily), and that "fixing" inefficiencies or loopholes in the markets is rewarded with money.
I'm not sure what "exploit" means or why you seem to use "make money" as a bad thing. Society uses "automation" in a wide range of tasks that was not previously possible. In finance, like in other cases where we automate previously rote tasks, I think its important to check it, because bad code running on tight loops can have disastrous consequences.
http://www.google.com/intl/en/jobs/uslocations/mountain-view...
People who write better code (and faster), know more VC's, first to market.
Finance, like startups, is a big world with room for many of players of different flavors.
Someone sent me this gem a few days ago.
I love the idea (for the guys who run it AND the guys who it opens up opportunities for).
Might be something you could play with.
Depending on what sort of HF strategy you want to run, I imagine this can be done relatively cheaply. (300K-800k? Pretty wide range I know... that's all I got though).
Obviously your strategies are limited, you're not competing with some of the super low latency firms for the fastest of opportunities because of hardware limitations or price prohibitive vendors/deals with exchanges or whatnot.
I was just reminded of this: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/9s9d7/iama_100_automat...
If I recall correctly, he got started with under 100k and has a pretty inexpensive setup.
"High Frequency" trading means a lot of different things to a lot of different people.
>.Big shot fund managers can't consistently beat the market...
1. My understanding is that literature regarding this generally refers to the mutual funds. I've also heard it voiced that the mutual fund community on average doesn't beat the market. That's not the same thing.
2. Renaissance. Quantum Fund. DE Shaw.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renaissance_Technologies#Invest...
I generally thing that HN types are the types who are smarter and likely competitive with the best and the brightest in finance.
>. Stocks should be a long term investment;
Why?
> the market has always had a positive return over any 20 year period.
1. Some people want returns in timespans of shorter than 20 years.
2. Not all markets have had positive returns over all 20 year periods. Even US equity markets have had losing 10 year periods, and inflation adjusted returns make the picture bleaker as well. I'd say the SPX has a good shot at not beating inflation adjusted returns for the 20 year period beginning in 2000. http://www.simplestockinvesting.com/SP500-historical-real-to...
3. "Positive" isn't good enough for everyone.
>.You're probably not paying with enough money to make it worth worrying about
Gotta start somewhere. My first program was "hello world."
Investing time in learning about financial markets isn't for everyone, just like software startups isn't for everyone.
Facebook:Renaissance :: <insert YC startup here>:Jane Street Capital :: "hello world":making your first trade
Learning to trade or invest or code or build startups is just another skill.