HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arthurjj

802 karma · joined December 31, 2013

Programmer in San Diego My public work is at:

http://arthur-johnston.com/

submissionscomments
arthurjj··on Marc Andreessen is wrong about introspection
>The only access anyone has to those questions is through something like introspection: either their own, or someone else’s honest reports of their experience, or the accumulated testimony of literature and philosophy...

I'm broadly sympathetic to the point in this article but it's trying to slip in literature and philosophy with honest first hand reports of introspection is underhanded. There's no reason to expect them to be any less guilty of motivated reasoning than Marc Andreesen

arthurjj··on The 49MB web page
My favorite part of that site, besides it loading incredibly fast, is even though it has an ad, for a wholly subsidiary, on it it is hard coded in the html.
arthurjj··on The worst acquisition in history, again
Netflix pays like a Big Tech company, is valued like a Big Tech company and was part of FAANG. 10 years ago the streaming tech they had was fairly high tech, even if it's now pretty standard. So they're considered Big Tech for historical reason
arthurjj··on Leaving Google has actively improved my life
I was thrown by

> I do my best to boycott bad things. And I fail pretty often. I still use Amazon on occasion and I can’t get off Spotify. I use Uber and DoorDash a lot more than I’d like. And I have too many Apple products/services.

> Individual actions probably will not save the world, but big tech is bad

It's weird to see this without any context or justification or comparison to other industries. As if it's so self evidently true that the author never considered the reader might dismiss his wider point when coming across it with no explanation

arthurjj··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
Had a similar experience in around ~2017 and switched over to Linux. At the time I didn't have the time to build my own and bought a mid-range System76 laptop.

Best computer decision I've ever made. I'm not a heavy gamer so the machine is still running fine. I've only had one time in the last 9 years where I had to drop everything and fix my computer vs Windows where it felt like once a year

arthurjj··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (January 2026)
Is this so you can automate the spell casting via robotics?
arthurjj··on enclose.horse
My 10 year old loves this game. He started playing it Wednesday or Thursday of last week and basically all of his screen time. Both trying to optimize and the level design scratch an itch that few games do
arthurjj··on Ask HN: Those making $500/month on side projects in 2025 – Show and tell
It makes me so happy to see this genre taking off. We did "ABCs of Programming" [1] when our son was 2 at least partially because there weren't any real kid's books talking about what "dad does all day". Funnily enough it wasn't selling that well until I posted an article [2] on HN about my experience writing it. Then it did steady business for a few years

[1] https://www.amazon.com/dp/1548489778 [2] https://arthur-johnston.com/hacker_writes_a_childrens_book/

arthurjj··on Instagram chief orders staff back to the office five days a week in 2026
You still get in person for 1-1s, small team whiteboarding and pair programming.
arthurjj··on Instagram chief orders staff back to the office five days a week in 2026
My RTO'd team of 13 is distributed across 3 office and not evenly distributed (8, 4, 1) so the probability of the person you need being in the same physical office is ~43% instead of the 0%. So overall it's better if you value in person and I say this as the 1
arthurjj··on Cognitive and mental health correlates of short-form video use
I've definitely watched repair videos on tiktok. And one of my favorite (indie) tv shows was only on YT for some reason instead of Hulu or Netflix. My kid watches videogame playthroughs on YT, not twitch. And that's completely disregarding you can listen to music on YT.

When defining a monopoly you can't just say "only this subset of the market is the market we're considering" you have to look at everything it does. As the FTC just learned

arthurjj··on Cognitive and mental health correlates of short-form video use
But Youtube isn't a monopoly. It's competing with Netflix, Prime Video, Hulu Instagram, Tiktok and Twitch off the top of my head. So they do have to make Youtube competitive

Your theory of

> just a way for some product manager to fluff up their metrics for a promotion.

is the most likely culprit

arthurjj··on Short Little Difficult Books
It's likely I projected the complexity onto the Art & Fear. Reading it every few pages I thought about how what it was discussing applied to creating software. But that's not really what the author intended, it's more the mindset I brought to the book
arthurjj··on Short Little Difficult Books
He's upfront that it's novels only but I really enjoy short difficult non-fiction more.

* Exit, Voice and Loyalty - about how organizations and people work. Easily the best social science book I've ever read

* Art & Fear - gives a much better model for creating software than most books

arthurjj··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (November 2025)
I don't have a passion for racket sports but I have family who do (pickleball/tennis) and I could see them really loving this app. I can't count the number of times they've told me about a point or a game that they wish they could have shown me.

Also as an runner "strava for racket sports" is a great description

arthurjj··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (November 2025)
Only the manager role appears to be remote
arthurjj··on AI, Wikipedia, and uncorrected machine translations of vulnerable languages
This was my take from the article also. These languages are clearly dying and not many people speak them as their primary language so the human suffering is minimal. Which means keeping them around is a past time that some people happen to enjoy (unless there is a Saphir-Whorf hypothesis I'm missing)

But the sentence `well-meaning Wikipedians who think that by creating articles in minority languages they are in some way “helping” those communities` clearly shows the author hasn't really considered the issue.

arthurjj··on Write the damn code
"Two prompts and then do it yourself" is a pretty good heuristic. Last year I was simulating a boardgame [1] and wasted ~1 hour trying to get ChatGPT to solve a basic coding combinatorics problem. I needed a method in python to generate all possible hand decisions a player could make. I couldn't make it understand that certain choices were equivalent

[1] https://arthur-johnston.com/paths_of_civ_tech_tree/

arthurjj··on We already live in social credit, we just don't call it that
This article reminds me of those silly "Capitalism is the real super intelligent AI" or "is a burrito a sandwich" arguments from a few years ago. Saying a "system with the explicit goal of the government judging legal behavior to try and change it and punish you if you don't" is the same thing as "private entities deciding on how or even if they want to interact with you" is just stretching the definition too far to be taken seriously. By that argument me deciding I don't want to read more by this author is a social credit system.

>Your Uber rating doesn't affect your mortgage rate, and your LinkedIn engagement doesn't determine your insurance premiums. But the infrastructure is being built to connect these systems. We're building the technical and cultural foundations that could eventually create comprehensive social credit systems.

She doesn't provide any citation for this

> Corporate platforms increasingly share reputation data. Financial services integrate social media analysis into lending decisions

Again she doesn't provide any citation for this, but more importantly she doesn't explain why she thinks it's wrong. Someone who posts "Feeling lucky so headed to the craps table" probably shouldn't be lent to, if only for their sake

arthurjj··on Charting Form Ds to roughly see the state of venture capital “fund” raising
That graph doesn't perfectly match the OP's but is definitely close enough to be worrying if you were raising or looking to join a startup
arthurjj··on You can choose tools that make you happy
> They use Emacs because they read that Neal Stephenson essay and they feel VS Code is for normies and Emacs is Gnostic.

hit really close to home for me. When I read it I was coding on Windows, and at the time and it didn't have great support for CLI. But reading "In the Beginning... Was the Command Line" got me to really appreciate what could be done

arthurjj··on The Evolution of SRE at Google
Thanks for this detail, I worked at Google, with SREs, and didn't know it. It seems like the type of 'design' detail that might be more important than this entire article
arthurjj··on Limits to Growth (1972)
I don't have a copy in front of me but throughout the book there are many comments made against modern society and some of the examples that she gives are clearly 'set up' to be against growth. I didn't realize she also wrote Limits to Growth and according to wikipedia, used some of that work and was edited by an org called the Sustainability Institute which explains it.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thinking_In_Systems%3A_A_Prime...

arthurjj··on Limits to Growth (1972)
Strongly endorsed for middle/high schoolers introduction. I read it last year and thought it was a good introduction but will feel a little simple for the HN crowd. Most of the value is in The Appendix followed by Chapters 1, 2 and 6, so you could even shorten it more. My only caveat is there's a lot of degrowther propaganda in it that you would need to caution the kids against
arthurjj··on Scale Ruins Everything
I'm confused to the argument you're making as some of those are clearly ethically-problematic for Uber while legal challenges, government lobbying seems core to the business.

The taxi market, in the US at least, was a textbook case of regulatory capture to stifle competition. Google "taxi medallion prices nyc" for an example. Uber was clearly the 'good guy' in flouting those laws and later getting them repealed. The cartels that controlled the medallions had no interest in improving the technology until they had competition.

arthurjj··on Why the U.S. can't build icebreaking ships
This is a common communication problem between Americans and Europeans where we're using the same word to mean two different types of organization. In the US you should replace "union" with "cartel, likely criminal" eg the boilermakers

"A federal grand jury in Kansas returned an indictment yesterday charging seven defendants, including five current and former high-level officers of the International Brotherhood of Boilermakers, Iron Ship Builders, Blacksmith, Forgers and Helpers (Boilermakers Union) for their alleged roles in a 15-year, $20 million embezzlement scheme."

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/two-former-presidents-boilerm...

arthurjj··on Marc Andreessen's AI manifesto hurts his own cause
I think I'm missing something?

* Trust & Safety [1] seems to be about safeguarding PII and having a moderation

* Tech Ethics - I can't find a general definition but I think about new ethical situations caused by tech. eg if you train an generative AI on artist X is it ethical to have the AI create images that look like artist X

* risk management - I haven't follow the case closely, I think of the SBF case mainly being about fraud and less about their risk management.

So even if we count those 3 the other 9 reasons, including the first 7 Andreessen lists, are unrelated

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trust_and_safety

arthurjj··on Marc Andreessen's AI manifesto hurts his own cause
I clicked on this hoping it would be a deserved indictment of his personal NIMBY views [1] vs public statements. Instead it's basically 3 tweets worth of commentary, and illiterate commentary at that.

> Right now, we're watching what happens when risk management and tech ethics are ignored for the sake of unlimited growth, ... Andreessen would bristle at the comparison — his VC firm famously didn't back FTX — but the philosophical slope nonetheless slips in that direction.

Besides referencing that it's already a slippery slope argument this is completely unrelated to his complaints about.

> 'existential risk', 'sustainability', 'ESG', 'Sustainable Development Goals', 'social responsibility', 'stakeholder capitalism', 'Precautionary Principle', 'trust and safety', 'tech ethics', 'risk management', 'de-growth', 'the limits of growth.'"

Notice how fruad isn't listed there. Andreessen's combining 4 to 5 different things that slow down growth. Which isn't great if you think some of them might be net positives but the author's reading comprehension is comically bad.

[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/08/marc-andre...

arthurjj··on Is it time to stop using sentinel values for null / “NA” values? (2018)
>the summation works fine

This is only true if that summation is not used or compared anywhere else which isn't usually the case. For example if in sql you are reporting the SUM(column_A)/ SUM(column_B) and one column can be null without the other one being null you're likely reporting the wrong number

arthurjj··on Ask HN: Good introduction to LLMs and how they work?
Still reading through it but the detailed explainer looks like what I wanted. Thanks
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →