HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

arturadib

1,906 karma · joined November 11, 2009

submissionscomments
arturadib··on Show HN: Burner, for temporary phone numbers
Neat idea. A couple of thoughts:

1- They better have a very large pool of unused numbers - otherwise it's likely my phone will be randomly ringing due to the many past users of the number I just bought... who knows where and how many times they would have posted the number at.

2- Personally, I don't immediately see how I'd go away from Google Voice, which is free, to a paid service. Because of the above, I prefer to have one or two fixed private numbers which I can always remember. If the number becomes a problem, I can always block the annoying caller or switch to a new number - for free. (I still haven't had to replace my year-old private number, btw).

That being said, it'd be neat to see what people end up doing with true throw-away numbers.

arturadib··on Why Men Can't Have It All
> Now, tell me how that is any different or less insulting than telling a women the opposite: "Sure, you're a good mother, but you're not cut out to be a CEO."

This is disingenuous. The answer is because modern men don't aspire to become good parents nearly as much as modern women aspire to holding top-level positions.

I do agree with the necessity to change the stereotype of the clumsy dad, but to bring that to the same level as that of women fighting for equality in the workplace is utterly unfair - it is by far a much Bigger Deal for modern women.

PS: If you have never seen a competent woman having frequent nervous breakdowns after putting in a disproportionate amount of work just to climb a ladder that most average men do with ease, you probably won't understand the difference.

arturadib··on Meteor chat app
According to the FAQ they're still working on a built-in user authentication.

If you have to implement a separate, server-side CRUD security check by hand, then I don't see why I would choose Meteor over say Rails or Express plus Backbone.

arturadib··on On Leaving Academia
I've tried to rationalize my own jump out of academia a while ago, which I did after passing my mid-term tenure review (I'm currently with Mozilla, happily pushing the boundaries of the web).

In doing so I came up with a (super-scientific!) "professional satisfaction formula":

http://blog.arturadib.com/the-formula-for-professional-satis...

arturadib··on Step by step from jQuery to Backbone
This was the main reason I wrote Agility.js - I too thought Backbone was too verbose (although these days CoffeeScript makes it more succinct, but still not as compact as Agility, as Backbone doesn't have any built-in model-view bindings).

I wanted to keep the same compactness of jQuery's semantics in an MVC framework so that everything from Hello World to complex apps would be more succinct.

For the interested:

http://agilityjs.com

arturadib··on Artificial jellyfish made from silicone and rat muscle (video)
> We built an animal

No they didn't. They built a sheet of biological material that pulsates when placed in an electrical field. Animals reproduce, and hence adapt and evolve.

It's a neat gadget, but let's not get too carried away.

arturadib··on Don’t Jump to Conclusions About the Killer
One more data source to support your point (the US accounts for 10 of the 20 worst rampages in Western democratic countries):

http://www.statista.com/statistics/1871/number-of-victims-of...

arturadib··on Don’t Jump to Conclusions About the Killer
Think outside the box.

I've lived in the US for 10 years, and I follow plenty of world news. It is clear that Columbine-like shootings are (mostly) an American phenomenon. [1]

So what is it so special about the US that makes this a recurring problem?

Is it poor parenting, without much communication? Is it societal pressure, i.e. Mr Popular vs Mr Loser? Is it easy access to guns? Is it the disproportionate amount of media attention that these cases give to depressed folks with low self-esteem? Is it all of the above? None?

I imagine severe depression happens everywhere, but there's got to be something in the US that turns depression into mass murder. I wish someone would analyze the problem from outside the box, not inside.

[1] Before someone jumps the gun about international news, note that terror and drug/gang crimes are very different. They have clear, consistent motives. Columbine-like stuff is puzzling- their motives seem to be all over the place, hence why to this date experts are still trying to figure them out.

arturadib··on Simperium announces pricing and open source strategy for new data layer
I'm curious: How's Simperium different from Parse.com?
arturadib··on Thoughts on Rails, Node, and the web apps of today
I'm disappointed that the discussion has (yet again) turned into debating the merits of Node rather than the much more important topic of where to place the MVC logic (client vs server), regardless of the language/framework chosen. Node was just a personal preference for the OP, based on his performance requirements.
arturadib··on Thoughts on Rails, Node, and the web apps of today
> I have abandoned Ruby and Rails in its entirety

So I thought he was talking about both. (As I once considered doing, too).

Also very frequently the distinction is rather blurry: Is Twitter an app or a site?

arturadib··on Thoughts on Rails, Node, and the web apps of today
I think the author emphasized performance. Sinatra might be Express's precedent, but it doesn't have Node's runtime behind it to deliver performance (async I/O, low-memory footprint, etc).
arturadib··on Thoughts on Rails, Node, and the web apps of today
> I see a picture emerge where the back-end will become purely an API component

Not so fast.

That makes sense for highly interactive apps with private content (Trello, Gmail, etc), not so much for public-facing and content-driven sites.

That is, unless you're OK with sacrificing that organic Google traffic to your site?

If not, you have two options: do the entire rendering + biz logic on the server (in which case Rails still makes a lot of sense, though some Node frameworks are getting there), or duplicate your client-side code on the server so that Google's hashbangs work.

The bigger picture is that the web + search engines are kind of broken right now: There's a tremendous opportunity to make progress and use the architecture pointed out by the OP, but as of today there is no simple solution to make the architecture play nicely with Google without duplicating the work on the server (Meteor seems to be making progress there).

Until a simple solution is found, I think we're stuck with the dilemma and will have to continue to do MVC both on the client and on the server.

It sucks.

arturadib··on Disruptive: uBeam Lands $750K To Let You Charge Gadgets Without Plugs
As already pointed out, they use ultrasound to beam the energy, and they claim to have filed some patents applications. Alas, there's a ton of prior art in this space, and I wonder how they're going to navigate them.

For example, ultrasound is already used to wirelessly charge pacemakers:

http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2011/11/wireless-pace...

And here is a very pertinent patent in this space (2004) that also contains a nice review of prior art:

http://www.google.com/patents?id=508SAAAAEBAJ&zoom=4&...

The central difficulty in this idea, as pointed out in the above patent, is automatically aiming a sufficiently focused beam at the receiver. Otherwise you get killed by 1/rˆ2 power decay. And this is a non-trivial task, which will force them to either go the royalties way or dodge the existing patents.

I don't doubt the team can move forward, but I wonder if the undergrads (and their investors) have underestimated the difficulty and history of the problem.

That being said, it's refreshing to see folks inspired by real-world problems that don't involve "social".

Wishing them best of luck!

arturadib··on Patent troll stalks travel site Hipmunk
The "green" movement seems to be making some progress.
arturadib··on Patent troll stalks travel site Hipmunk
I am getting on a plane and won't have internet access for days, but can someone please start a site like IAmATroll.com or whatever and compile a list - hopefully with profile pictures - of patent trollers, and who they're suing. I'd be happy to help promote and maintain it when I'm back.

If we can't win legally, let's at least try a grassroots approach. Perhaps shame will have some effect on these people.

arturadib··on How LinkedIn betrayed a 5-man startup
And, this case is singular in that not only do they depend on the API, they are also in direct competition with the provider of the API. It's risk^2.
arturadib··on Device turns Android phone into computer. A reason to make HTML 5 apps?
Interesting bet. While most are betting on having all your data and apps in the cloud so you can live device-agnostic (eg iCloud, GDrive, Chrome OS, etc), these folks are basically proposing a mobile-centered world.

The only advantage I see of this model over the existing cloud model is possibly cost, as presumably the device is much cheaper than a laptop.

But that comes with a UX price tag - as already pointed out here, app interfaces built for touch can be frustrating to operate with a mouse/trackpad cursor.

If they can pull off an attractive price point AND an elegant solution to the UX problem, this could be a serious sales machine.

arturadib··on Fred Wilson's response to "Paul Graham's Letter to YC Companies"
As much as I think FB's valuation was high, they have the advantage of having a Product That People Really Want. This means that they have a lot of room to adjust their business model (so long as they don't screw up the UX/product while at it).

Contrast this with GroupOn, whose product IS the business model...

arturadib··on Google Blockly - a visual programming language
Quick feedback: Would be great if the front page included some demos already built so we could have a better idea of what the final code looks like.
arturadib··on Parse launches JavaScript SDK: Parse for Websites
Hats off.

Parse is the first of all these backend-as-a-service startups to face and solve the biggest problem in the web context: user authentication and data security.

By offering a full signup service with email verification and user-level control over the database they have eliminated perhaps the most redundant piece of work that just about every web app has had to implement.

Lock-in is of course a concern, but that hasn't prevent some AWS services from taking off big time. Perhaps in the near future one will see an open source project that offers an off-the-shelf backend with a Parse-compatible API, much like what happened to S3 and etc.

Pricing on the other hand is a concern, particularly if your service requires background workers that constantly update the database -- every update is an API request hit, and one can only wonder what they charge beyond their Pro account.

Overall, I think this is a huge step in the right direction. Because it's the 21st century and one shouldn't have to reinvent the wheel every time one writes a new web app.

arturadib··on Facebook trades under $30, down 7%+
Alternate title: FB down 20%+ since IPO

You'd be gambling enough already if you bought FB stock at 20x earnings (the tech norm for well-established companies), let alone at 100x.

At 20x, you'd be speculating on FB's ability to sustain its current earnings power in an increasingly competitive and verticalized space. That's a tough proposition, particularly since social graphs are not as much of a competitive moat as people thought (Orkut for example had at some point virtually the entire online population of Brazil engaged with it, virtually none now), and everybody and their mother is investing in a new social network for a different vertical.

Of course, it is entirely possible that FB will not only maintain its market position, but also increase its earnings power five-fold or whatever. In that scenario, they would have squashed most other vertical social networks and found a sustainable business model (they haven't really yet, see [1]).

Again, not impossible, but bear in mind what assumptions the current valuation implies. It's not surprising to see the market re-adjust its valuation after the IPO craze.

[1] http://cdixon.org/2012/05/15/facebooks-business-model/

arturadib··on Why Facebook is killing Silicon Valley
There is nothing wrong with #LowHangingFruits. They can be just as good as harder-to-get fruits, and one would be silly not go for them first.

And it's not just social media that's low-hanging in the Valley -- that'd be an oversimplification. It's also the plethora of in-your-face B2B and B2C opportunities, thanks to the pervasive connectivity of business and individuals (which unlike the 90s is very real this time).

If you walk around America visiting businesses and industries you get a sense of how rudimentary most processes are, and how amenable they are to software automation. Companies like Square and OpenTable are examples of non-social ventures that are disrupting markets. Of course it's not science, but who cares? They are innovating and disrupting just the same.

I say go build your apps, whether social, B2B, etc. Find those low-hanging opportunities first. All signals say Go: connectivity is increasing; devices are selling like bananas; software companies are making real revenue; and most opportunities are yet to be exploited.

And in parallel to all that let the government/large risk takers support more pie-in-the-sky ideas, and when the opportunities are depleted let's refocus and aim higher.

But there's nothing wrong with enjoying a delicious fruit without having to climb trees.

arturadib··on To boldly go where Node man has gone before
Node is popular not only because it's very fast (yes, it's still pretty darn fast even if there might exist faster alternatives), but because it's JavaScript.

That's an enormous advantage for startups as (a) the JavaScript hiring pool is much larger than most other languages (particularly in comparison to nascent ones, like Go), and (b) the ability to write client- and server-side code in the same language means small teams can be far more integrated and collaborative than otherwise (and if the startup has a single coder, the point is even stronger).

Assuming these benchmarks are accurate and translate into similar results for more complex applications, I'd gladly pay the 10-20% performance penalty to get the above benefits. Node is fast enough for most startups.

arturadib··on Build Cross-Platform Applications for desktop using HTML, CSS, Javascript
There's no wheel being reinvented. XULRunner is based on XUL, which makes it fundamentally different from the goal of above projects (that is, to use HTML technologies alone to build 'native' apps).

Some of us at Mozilla Labs have tried to fill this gap through the Chromeless project (https://github.com/mozilla/chromeless), but we've stopped working on it in favor of a more general runtime for web apps (that's what I was talking about in the last sentence: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Apps/WebRT).

The very fact that XULRunner/Chromeless didn't take off like PhoneGap did in the mobile arena for example is evidence that there's room for innovation in this space.

Happy to elaborate on this, but only if you promise you'll be nicer :)

arturadib··on Build Cross-Platform Applications for desktop using HTML, CSS, Javascript
The hardest part of all of this is getting a runtime that builds/installs seamlessly across platforms. I just did an 'npm install appjs' as per docs, and it failed (Mac).

I myself have gone through great lengths to create a similar (minus Webkit) runtime for Mac, Windows, and Linux:

https://github.com/arturadib/node-qt

https://github.com/arturadib/node-five

Despite all my efforts there are edge cases where it simply won't install/build.

Keep up the good work though -- this is a much needed project. (Bear in mind too that Mozilla and other companies are coming out with their own runtimes for web apps, so such projects will likely be rendered obsolete by them).

arturadib··on Build Cross-Platform Applications for desktop using HTML, CSS, Javascript
appjs.purpose !== emberjs.purpose

(former gives a cross-platform runtime, latter is merely a JS framework)

arturadib··on Show HN: Simperium, a realtime data layer
I've been a SimpleNote user for a while, great to see the platform layer finally coming out.

I have a few questions:

- As a potential customer, I'm curious as to how sustainable is the company. I understand there was a YC seed investment in '10, but is the company well funded for the next couple of years at least?

- The platform seems to be ahead of Meteor, Firebase, etc, in that it already seems to have implemented a basic login and security model based on expiring tokens, but from the docs it seems like "finer grained control of these permissions are under development". Does this mean that presently any user can erase/modify data from any bucket, such as global data, data from other users, etc? If so, that's a big deterred for me.

- Are there any plans to allow querying the data? Key-value stores are fine for simple games, to-do lists, etc, but for any non-trivial app querying arbitrary fields is a basic requirement.

Thanks again, those are some great strides in the right direction.

arturadib··on Heroku’s early history: 4 home pages that made $212 million
This is all fantastic and crucial, but please don't assume that Heroku's success was solely due to these technological ideas. (It's the typical assumption us hackers make).

Being a YC company Heroku had immediate access to a bunch of startups (potential customers, AND early feedback givers), and I wonder how much biz dev such as talks at conferences, blogging, social-mediaing, etc, they did in parallel to these tech advances.

arturadib··on Node.js - Convincing the boss guide
That's silly. No one in their sane mind would serve web requests AND do heavy processing in the same thread - no matter what language.

In Node, you would have a process responding to web requests, and launch a separate process -- via a convenient child_process with built-in pipe communication -- for doing the heavy CPU work.

The only case where that wouldn't make sense is if you need BOTH a ton of concurrency AND heavy CPU work. In that case, threads would make sense as they would be cheaper memory-wise. But my point remains: CPU-heavy applications don't necessarily rule out Node as a feasible alternative.

PS: V8 was 40x slower, not 400, in that one benchmark result you picked.

← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →