HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aschampion

804 karma · joined July 10, 2013

submissionscomments
aschampion··on Eminent Philosophers Name the Most Important Philosophy Books from 1950-2000
The list is analytically tilted, but you're talking about early 20th century philosophers for a list of books 1950-2000.
aschampion··on Ask HN: Are there any reasonable alternatives to MacBook Pro for developer?
I briefly had a Razer Blade for development and returned it for several reasons, the top two being:

1. Enormous screen bezel, which made it silly to lug around a laptop with the screen real estate of one much smaller.

2. Without careful, tedious manual power management in linux the cooling fans routinely spin up to dust buster sound levels under normal use, which is unacceptable if you exist around other human beings.

The Surface Book 2 is an interesting option, but the linux support, while improving through community effort, is still spotty [1]. At the moment it has many power draw, heat, and noise issues. Also, everyone I know who has had a surface device has had to have it serviced or RMA'd at least once, which is not acceptable for something so expensive from such a large vendor.

[1] https://github.com/jakeday/linux-surface

aschampion··on Fast, Safe, and Complete(ish) Web Service in Rust
For async, also worth considering Gotham: https://gotham.rs/

I only have minimal experience with it, since I've also eventually chosen actix-web for all my projects so far due to its simplicity.

aschampion··on Maybe you don't need Rust and WASM to speed up your JS
Since November WASM is enabled by default in the major browsers now:

https://caniuse.com/#feat=wasm

aschampion··on Maybe you don't need Rust and WASM to speed up your JS
Having micro-optimized and maintained JS code over years and dozens of browser versions, I cannot echo this enough. Tuning JS both the in face of fickleness of VM quirks and data/context is a losing proposition for all but the most speed- and core-functionality-critical code.

The point of rust+wasm benchmarks is that one can write reasonable, maintainable, functionality-focused code (not to mention all the rust-specific benefits) and get good performance out of the box.

aschampion··on Performance Benchmark 2018 – MongoDB, PostgreSQL, OrientDB, Neo4j and ArangoDB
Postgres is configured extremely conservatively by default. While it isn't reasonable to spend time tweaking each database, at least running pgtune would be reasonable for Postgres.
aschampion··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (February 2018)
HHMI Janelia | Software Engineer (computer vision) | Ashburn, Virginia | Fulltime | Onsite

We are looking to hire a software engineer for at least one year to work on the implementation of automatic neuronal arbor reconstruction from volumes of electron microscopy: a central problem in the emerging field of large-scale cellular connectomics.

The work will be centered on bringing automation to the software CATMAID[0], in particular by applying flood-fill networks and their tensorflow implementation[1] to build a workflow that will speed up the work of dozens of laboratories already using CATMAID for computer-assisted yet manual reconstruction of neurons for mapping wiring diagrams with synaptic resolution.

The engineer will be embedded in the Cardona lab at Howard Hughes Medical Institute Janelia Research Campus[2], among computer scientists and neuroscientists working together to map the wiring diagram of complete brains at synaptic resolution.

Optionally, solve an open GitHub issue for CATMAID, submit a pull request, and include this with your CV and statement. Applications including a pull request for an issue will be given priority consideration.

Official listing and more information: https://hhmi-openhire.silkroad.com/epostings/index.cfm?fusea...

[0] https://github.com/catmaid/catmaid [1] https://github.com/aschampion/diluvian [2] https://www.janelia.org/lab/cardona-lab

aschampion··on Why Create a New Unix Shell?
I and most other developers I know use zsh, because it's focused on features interactive use and not scripting. Who cares about bash compatibility? Bash scripts are run by, well, /usr/bin/env bash. For DevOps/IT I could understand the concern.

e: sorry some connection interruption and now this is redundant to other comments.

aschampion··on Google Memory Loss
What more infuriating is it using synonyms of "verbatim" that actually don't mean the same thing as verbatim in a particular technical context but match an avalanche of noise. I've yet to find a way to turn on synonym matching.
aschampion··on Magic Leap One
1. resolution 2. fatigue 3. (for VR) limited input options

Beyond these, the main reason is that gaming is a much better exploration and experimentation field than productivity because each app can have far less capital investment, lifecycles are short, and there's no need for a reliable, successful output.

aschampion··on Oh shit, git: Getting myself out of bad situations
> I think anyone who uses the CLI is either trying too hard or hasn't realized the beauty of a git GUI.

Or, you know, understands and thinks in the semantics of the underlying tool and is already working in other text-based tools.

aschampion··on 2017 Was Bad for Facebook. 2018 Will Be Worse
> I've never understood the pseudo-ephemerality of instagram. Even if you save stuff, or like it, the interface makes it very difficult to recall stuff from more than a few days ago.

Hypothesis: these businesses all monetize # of interactions (even if CPI is low), which they want to maximize by structuring interactions such that there is constantly new content that encourages obsessive checking. A sense of ephemerality of content reinforces that behavior ("I have to check because there is new content and it may be gone if I wait to check").

aschampion··on Basic Income Research Proposal
The 60 percentile income is < $46k. That people have little emergency funds on incomes less than this is largely explained away by necessary expenses. 20% have no savings -- the 20 percentile income is $17k. Show me a net savings budget on $17k.
aschampion··on Trello Desktop for Mac and Windows: Get More Done Without Distractions
> It is very expensive to build and maintain products across native desktop

Yet (modulo mobile) somehow companies managed to do this in the 90s with far less productive development tools. The difference is the diluted power of the consumer: when software was a purchased product made for Ks of subscribing customers, small contingents of customers being upset about subpar UI and performance was a real threat to the viability of your business. Now Outlook or any Amazon app can be absolute slow, buggy garbage on nearly every platform (and they are), but the enormous customer base (diluting collective action) and entrenchment of locked-in platforms and data mean there's little incentive to obsess about product quality. Instead companies prioritize cost reduction, new customer acquisition (focusing on product chrome refreshes instead of robustness), or just give over to development momentum apathetic to quality.

aschampion··on Trello Desktop for Mac and Windows: Get More Done Without Distractions
> but for some reason it uses a lot less resources than the actual native apps.

Because most "actual native apps" now are not native apps but electron or some other HTML + JS + CSS wrapper running an entire separate browser to render the app. By running the web page as separate windows you're effectively getting the same app but sharing the browser overhead.

aschampion··on Ask HN: Is Georgia Tech's Online Master in CS Worth It?
You may want to look at a previous recent discussion here on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13382263
aschampion··on 200 terabyte proof demonstrates the potential of brute force math
It's been a historically valuable heuristic -- algorithms/theories that provide cognitive scaffolding allow us not only to solve related problems but reason about the limits of applicability of that theory, successively guiding discovery of new theory. Obviously our cognitive envelope doesn't just include our own brains but the tools we use, including computational ones, so it's not as if pure proof/pure prediction don't also have value for guiding discovery, but it does require a lot of ingenuity to find ways to exploit them.
aschampion··on 200 terabyte proof demonstrates the potential of brute force math
It means the proof is explanatory, i.e., that it provides a framework of thought that extends our capability to reason about related problems within our very limited cognitive envelope. Pure proofs, like purely predictive models in science, often do not provide this.
aschampion··on How Checkers Was Solved
> It's been a few years, but I recall there being research into 100% mapping out crab or ant behavior and it was getting to a point of being quite accurate.

We are nowhere near this point. There are specific, intentionally constrained behaviors in model animals such that we can monitor the activity of specific sets of neurons and make predictions (meaning anywhere from better-than-chance to perfect accuracy) of behavioral output. This is far from "mapping out behavior" for an entire organism.

As for the GPP about a comprehensive look-up mechanism from all possible states of dynamics in the human brain to semantic descriptions of mental states: the problem is that trying to implement such a mechanism within the physical and thus computational constraints of our world will result, with high likelihood, in something that functions rather like a brain.

aschampion··on Open source electronic lab notebook
Neat! A dealbreaker for me is the lack of markdown or similar for the editor. I understand WYSIWYG is more important for most users, but it would be nice to have a plaintext entry alternative.

Also makes it easier for external clients (CLI, etc.) to use the service as an API.

aschampion··on Math That May Have Mapped the Brain in 11 Dimensions
Hess and Markram didn't invent topological analysis of neuronal networks. They are not mapping the brain. This is a fluff piece that didn't bother to check with anyone else in the field if this paper is as groundbreaking as it's being presented, which is the absolute minimum of journalistic rigor.

The claim this ended up in Frontiers because no one else in neuro theory has heard of algebraic topology is laughable.

e: To be clear, I don't think this rises to the level of "Sokal hoax" -- it looks like an interesting result. I also have an interest in the role massive simulation can play in discovery. But to misrepresent topological analysis as an entirely novel approach or package it with phys.org-press-release nonsense like "mapping the brain in 11 dimensions" is both a disservice to the rich field on which it's building and adds noise to public communication about neuroscience, which is already plagued with bullshit.

aschampion··on Vagueness
If you're intrigued by this SEP article I would recommend going through [1] and [2] together, since they are both grouped in similar order by schools of thought on sorites paradox. The former is a well edited collection of papers on each position, and the latter is Timothy Williamson's frequently persuasive critique of each. I'm generally disinterested in analytic philosophy of language, but find myself returning again and again to this discussion because it is a frequent analog to a vast set of related problems.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Vagueness-Reader-Rosanna-Keefe/dp/026... [2] https://www.amazon.com/Vagueness-Problems-Philosophy-Timothy...

aschampion··on Making a Game in Rust
Lua is great and generally the right tool for this sort of thing.

As an alternative, though, there are several Rust-based scripting languages that attempt to expose some of the power of the type system, etc., while being more amenable to dynamic loading, REPL, etc:

http://libs.rs/scripting/

aschampion··on How brains are built: Principles of computational neuroscience
A salient difference from astronomy is that computational neuroscience is typically concerned with describing neural systems in terms of information processing. Our principle technological example of an information processing system is the computer. So while there's a distinction between "computational" as (a) a tool used for analysis, (b) a methodology or model employed to describe a system, and (c) an statement about a property of the system under study, computational neuroscience refers to at least both ab and often abc. This isn't the case with astronomy, because we aren't typically using telescopes to study how stars bend and collect light like telescopes (although we of course sometimes do).
aschampion··on Backblaze B2 Drops Download Pricing by 60%
Just read it in a kiwi accent and all is fine.
aschampion··on Show HN: 'Hack' the user cursor
Modal function cues: paintbucket, eyedropper, etc.

Common interaction cues that span functions but aren't in the CSS set: multiaxis, rotation, etc.

Not to mention the innumerable domain-specific possibilities. It's another example of the tension between the idea of browser-as-the-future-ubiquitous-platform and browser-as-lowest-common-denominator-mobile-safe-sandbox, which is eroding the established niche of desktop software for deep, focused, domain-optimized work because of the tyranny of CRUDy consumption-focused web apps.

aschampion··on Show HN: 'Hack' the user cursor
> What are examples of legitimate use-cases for supporting custom cursors?

We build web applications serving expert users for which this is essential. For precise selection the default cursor often occludes important information. Think of how confusing something like Photoshop, AutoCAD or Maya would be without contextual cursors.

It would be sensible, however, to place behind a permission in the same way as location or notification APIs. Unfortunately most browsers' UX for permissions is awful.

aschampion··on U.S. FCC chairman plans fast-track repeal of net neutrality: sources
Policy is technology. Technology is not just engineered artifacts but the cognitive models and social practices surrounding them. Policy is a vastly powerful technology that mediates the social and economic resources necessary for technologies like the internet to be created, have utility for society, and thrive.

So, yes, we need to solve this with technology -- policy itself, technology for improving the creation of policy and the selection of those who turn it into legislation, technology for combating disinformation and educating the public on protecting their rights, technology for detecting and disseminating information on relationships between entrenched interests and policy makers. Networking technology of the kind you mention may be part of that, but on its own it can never be a panacea. Policy will always necessarily exist, and it will never be solved -- it's a dynamic system.

aschampion··on How much your computer can do in a second
> Because until now making a beautiful, powerful and modern app with a portable GUI was something only a few people would be able to do.

Except it's none of these things: electron apps suffer the same presentation-before-content problems as most of the web, they inherit all of the state bugs of web apps, and they're painfully slow despite usually just being menus of nested lists and text boxes. It's passing a burden from developers to users, which considering the huge asymmetry between these two groups that's typical (at least 3 orders of magnitude, and often 6 or more) is an enormous inefficiency.

I'm all for selecting tools and platforms to better optimize developer productivity, but it's not clear to me the web platform has actually accomplished that for all but a few types of applications, and pushing it to the desktop is resulting in cumbersome, unresponsive, needlessly fragmented interfaces.

Put simply: Amazon Music Desktop has untold development investment and a complete visual redesign every 6 months, but WinAmp circa 2001 is somehow a thoroughly better way of searching and playing music.

aschampion··on Dell’s 32-inch 8K UP3218K Display Now for Sale
For comparison, my 10 year old Dell 3007WFP (30" 16:10 1600p monitor for similar market segment) is 147W typical 177W max. So 8x the pixels for ~60% of the power consumption after a decade of improvement sounds good. Shame it's 16:9.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →