HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asdefghyk

831 karma · joined October 28, 2016

submissionscomments
asdefghyk··on 50 years ago, a young Bill Gates took on the 'software pirates'
The patent https://patents.google.com/patent/US5490216A/en

The MAC address was only one parameter (of many) that allowed the creation of a unique hardware id (apparently)

A wikipedia page specifically about the dispute with Microsoft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniloc_USA,_Inc._v._Microsoft_....

A AI summary reposted (sorry if this not allowed ?) below

Australian inventor Ric Richardson pioneered software activation in the early 1990s, developing a "try-before-you-buy" system (Demoware) using a unique machine fingerprint and key-code unlocking system, now used on billions of computers. His 1992 patent (US5490216) resulted in a major legal victory against Microsoft, ending in a confidential settlement valued at over $530 million.

Key details of the Ric Richardson patent and dispute: The Invention: Richardson created a method for software anti-piracy where, upon purchase, a user receives a code to unlock full functionality, addressing the need to try software before buying. Uniloc Company: Richardson founded Uniloc to develop and market this copy-protection software.

The Microsoft Dispute: In 1993, Richardson demonstrated his technology to Microsoft, which subsequently developed a similar activation system for products like Office, Windows XP, and Windows Server.

Legal Battle: After eight years of litigation, a US court found Microsoft infringed on the patent (Number 5,490,216), resulting in a settlement estimated to be in the low 9 figures (after earlier awards of $388 million, then over $530 million).

Legacy: The technology is widely used globally, and Richardson continued to innovate in cybersecurity, developing new, secure operating system methods.

asdefghyk··on 50 years ago, a young Bill Gates took on the 'software pirates'
Microsoft allowed piracy to gain a competitive advantage. To allow their software to be entrenched. Not so much these days because lots pirated softwave is now a VECTOR for malware.

Im not sure if the next part of my writing is allowed ... but here goes ... This google search link explains this in a much more fluet situation than I can. Specifically the AI over view https://www.google.com/search?q=Microsoft+allowed+piracy+to+...

My Journey with Microsoft started with Dos3.3 I think. Was a big win 3.1 and Word 2 user ... etc right up to Win 11 now. So I have seen a lot of MS dodgyness over the years.

asdefghyk··on 50 years ago, a young Bill Gates took on the 'software pirates'
In the quoted source from the inventor -the inventor mentions his disbelief that Microsoft used the exact same parameters (that the inventor used ) as determined from the PC - I think things like MAC address etc to uniquely id the machine

That's part of what I meant "... steal the idea ..."

Of course, the comment that there are lots copy protection methods ( previously ) is correct

THe inventor also had to spend cira about $15M in legal fees to bring his case. ANd that is many years ago 15-20? so a much bigger $ today. A small company would have no chance to be able to afford such a financial outlay ... Microsoft was often accused of obtaining information under NDA then developing their own similar product etc One case I recall was PEN computing. Pen Computing lost their case with the result "not proven" There where many more such cases, similar from smaller companies. Of course how many that where valid is unknown , since the court case often not go ahead, since small company not have resources ....

asdefghyk··on 50 years ago, a young Bill Gates took on the 'software pirates'
There is more that should be said about this story.

About Bill gates complaining about software pirates steal ing Microsoft software

When Microsoft grew large , rich and much more powerful, they where know to steal ideas from small companies . Companies that did not have financial resources to proceed with a some what court case. Since Microsoft had much larger financial resources.

Consider

These are some Google results for " Microsoft copied IP from smaller companies where they could "

AI Overview Microsoft has faced numerous lawsuits and allegations of copying intellectual property (IP) from smaller companies and competitors throughout its history, with some cases resulting in large fines and legal orders.

Specific examples include: i4i: In 2011, the U.S. Supreme Court denied a Microsoft appeal against a $290 million verdict for infringing on a small Canadian company's patent related to a text manipulation tool used in Microsoft Word 2003 and 2007.

Burst.com: Microsoft was sued by Burst.com, which alleged that Microsoft stole its patented media transmission technology and incorporated it into Windows Media Player 9 after a two-year collaboration that ended without a licensing agreement.

Apple: In 1988, Apple sued Microsoft, alleging that Windows 2.0 copied 189 different elements of the Macintosh operating system user interface. This case was eventually settled. The original graphical user interface (GUI) technology used by both Apple and Microsoft was initially developed at Xerox's PARC labs.

Disk Doubling Software: According to one report, Microsoft was accused of examining a third party's disk doubling software under the pretense of licensing it, only to produce a nearly identical "independently developed" product that even included the original's disabled test code and comments. This resulted in Microsoft paying millions in a settlement.

Netscape and Antitrust Concerns: Microsoft's business practices, particularly its inclusion of Internet Explorer with Windows to undermine competitor Netscape, led to a major antitrust lawsuit by the U.S. government in the late 1990s and early 2000s, which found Microsoft had engaged in unlawful monopolization.

These cases have contributed to a perception that Microsoft, in its pursuit of market dominance, has historically leveraged its powerful position to appropriate technology from smaller entities

AI Overview Microsoft has faced numerous lawsuits and allegations of copying intellectual property (IP) from smaller companies and competitors throughout its history, with some cases resulting in large fines and legal orders.

Specific examples include: i4i: In 2011, the U.S. Supreme Court denied a Microsoft appeal against a $290 million verdict for infringing on a small Canadian company's patent related to a text manipulation tool used in Microsoft Word 2003 and 2007.

Burst.com: Microsoft was sued by Burst.com, which alleged that Microsoft stole its patented media transmission technology and incorporated it into Windows Media Player 9 after a two-year collaboration that ended without a licensing agreement.

Apple: In 1988, Apple sued Microsoft, alleging that Windows 2.0 copied 189 different elements of the Macintosh operating system user interface. This case was eventually settled. The original graphical user interface (GUI) technology used by both Apple and Microsoft was initially developed at Xerox's PARC labs. Disk Doubling Software: According to one report, Microsoft was accused of examining a third party's disk doubling software under the pretense of licensing it, only to produce a nearly identical "independently developed" product that even included the original's disabled test code and comments. This resulted in Microsoft paying millions in a settlement.

Netscape and Antitrust Concerns: Microsoft's business practices, particularly its inclusion of Internet Explorer with Windows to undermine competitor Netscape, led to a major antitrust lawsuit by the U.S. government in the late 1990s and early 2000s, which found Microsoft had engaged in unlawful monopolization. These cases have contributed to a perception that Microsoft, in its pursuit of market dominance, has historically leveraged its powerful position to appropriate technology from smaller entities

asdefghyk··on 50 years ago, a young Bill Gates took on the 'software pirates'
One other thing , if you want to know all the dodgy court cases Microsoft got involved in and the penalty's that had to pay- it will be mentioned / disclosed in their annual financial reports - since these large amounts , even possible amounts needed to be advised to shareholders in case /if/when they lost .....

I should add a party to the court case , disclosed the amount Cira $250M USD

even though in wikipedia says its not disclosed ....

asdefghyk··on 50 years ago, a young Bill Gates took on the 'software pirates'
Is not generally well known but Microsoft stole the idea of product activation ( as used in Windows XP and more ) and copied the methodology of the activation parameters etc from the guy that invented and patented it . There was a big court case about it and appeals , it ended with Microsoft having to pay penalty of (I recall ) $250M USD . There is very brief info on this wikipedia page https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ric_Richardson

There is a much more detailed video by Ric RIchardson around I will see if I can find it and post the link .....

OK found the link. https://rss.com/podcasts/unemployable/1485621/

This link has blurb for another entrepreneur company, just ignore / skip that. There is a part where the inventor gives detailed info about the court battle with Microsoft and technical details of his product activation technology.

asdefghyk··on 50 years ago, a young Bill Gates took on the 'software pirates'
Bill Gates was a ruthless and predatory business man. It is well known - Used to build in deliberate incompatibilities with the Windows
asdefghyk··on A web server on a single floppy disk
Around year 2000 I had a camera that stored its images on a floppy disk.
asdefghyk··on Doin' It with a 555: One Chip to Rule Them All
Interesting links on Hans

https://web.archive.org/web/20260125061851/http://www.design...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Camenzind

( Please note , I posted the archive.org link to the Hans Camenzind site, because when I tried to access the site URl , my BitDefender virus thing popped up a warning about a certificate problem. I Have NO idea if this is a real problem (Im clueless) or not but just to be careful I use the archive.org link )

asdefghyk··on Ask HN: Books to learn 6502 ASM and the Apple II
RE "....Books to learn 6502 ASM and the Apple II...."

Suggest to look at some of the archives of old Apple Magazines from around the Apple I era , cira late 70s and early 80s.

Some of them would have had assembly language programming columns. I recall one Named Softtalk , but there where many. There are other Sites than Archive.org. Some archive sites solely devoted to early apple computers like Apple 2

asdefghyk··on Ask HN: Books to learn 6502 ASM and the Apple II
[Off TOpic somewhat] This post made me immediately recall, the hours I spent playing Apple Invaders, 1979

Pinball Construction Set, by Bill Bludge

Chop Lifter, modeled on 1979–1981 Iran Hostage Crisis, Dan Gorlin, Brøderbund 1982

Castle Wolfenstein (1981) (Muse) by Silas Warner

Red Alert (1981) Olaf Lubeck, Broderbund

I still have some of these original games and the artwork in the shed.....

All classic Apple games of very early 80s

At the time, the programming was recognized as amazing, the sound and graphics. It was a marvel that it was achieved on such a low resource machine ....

asdefghyk··on Ask HN: Books to learn 6502 ASM and the Apple II
The answer would depend on what programming experience you have? Do you have any assembly language experience ? with other targets? ie have you used an assembler ( and maybe linker ) before. Are you familiar with hex? bytes, bits etc , You will learn this and much more ...

Id look for a book that targets Assembly programming on a Apple 2, ie not a book on general 6502 programming.

   Such a book Id expect to discuss things like Apple 2 memory map , Apple 2 hardware and how they are used in assembler language. 
Hopefully the book would also provide guidance using a particular assembler ( hopefully still available)

I googled phrase Apple 2 assembly language programming for beginners?

and lots of very good looking links popped up.

You aim is a challenging task. Much to learn. Good luck. However entirely do able these days.

My background is electronics engineer, embedded programing on in assembler (some Motorola processors and others) and C for a few years before moving on to other things ....

The book Assembly Lines: The Complete Book available as a FREE PDF download from .... site https://ct6502.org/product/assembly-lines-the-complete-book/

INCLUDES All 33 of Roger Wagner’s Assembly Lines articles from Softalk magazine, plus appendices, in one complete volume.

asdefghyk··on Google Books removed all search functions for any books with previews
copyright reasons?
asdefghyk··on Linux kernel framework for PCIe device emulation, in userspace
Could add one or more (reprograble?) FPGA's for extra? processing power OR reconfiguration ease to such a card ......

I've often wondered why such a card (with FPGA) is not available for retro? computer emulation or simulation ??

asdefghyk··on De Deense strijdkrachten hebben het mandaat om terug te schieten ALS de VS Groe
How can I translate this to English?

Seems to be Dutch.

I got from the below Google Translate .... Not sure its all the article ...

The Royal Danish Navy's Thetis-class warship HDMS Vaedderen sails along sea ice off the coast of Nuuk, Greenland, on April 2, 2025. Photo: Juliette Pavy/Bloomberg via Getty Images

THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION has threatened that if it cannot buy Greenland, it will seize it by military force. Senior adviser Stephen Miller even stated that "no one will fight the United States militarily over Greenland's future." However, in the event of a military attack, Danish forces are obligated to shoot first and ask questions later.

"Danish military units have a duty to defend Danish territory if it is exposed to armed attack, including by taking immediate defensive measures if necessary," Tobias Roed Jensen, spokesperson for the Danish Defence Command, told The Intercept, citing a 1952 royal decree that applies to the entire Kingdom of Denmark, including Greenland.

Jensen said the decree ensures that "Danish forces can act to defend the Kingdom of Denmark in situations where Danish territory or Danish military units are attacked, even if the circumstances make it impossible to await further political or military instructions."

The fact that Denmark's small army claims to be ready to defend Greenland has not deterred US imperial ambitions.

"One way or another, we'll get Greenland," President Donald Trump said Sunday. On Monday, Florida Republican Congressman Randy Fine introduced a bill authorizing Trump "to take all necessary steps to annex or acquire Greenland as a territory of the United States."

That same day, a bipartisan coalition in the House, led by Democratic Representative Bill Keating of Massachusetts and Republican Representative Don Bacon of Nebraska, introduced the No Funds for NATO Invasion Act. This bill would prohibit federal funds from being used for the invasion of a NATO member state or territory, and would prohibit any US official or employee from taking action to carry out an invasion of a NATO member state or territory.

Three sources on Capitol Hill told The Intercept that Sen. Chris Coons, D-Del.—the ranking Democrat on the Defense Budget Subcommittee—has opposed adding similar provisions to the defense budget bill to avoid disrupting negotiations with Republicans.

“Frankly, it’s a huge, unnecessary mistake,” a congressional aide told The Intercept. “By refusing to commit to the NATO language, Coons is giving Republicans exactly what they want without getting anything in return, and he’s doing it at the expense of our most crucial alliances.”

Coons is also leading a bipartisan, bicameral group of lawmakers on a trip to Copenhagen this week to meet with Danish and Greenlandic government officials. His office did not respond to requests for comment before publication.

Meanwhile, the foreign ministers of Denmark and Greenland will meet with Vice President J.D. Vance and Foreign Minister Marco Rubio at the White House on Wednesday, Danish Foreign Minister Lars Løkke Rasmussen told reporters.

THE UNITED STATES already has a military foothold in Greenland, the world's largest non-continental island. The US has long maintained a military garrison there, Pituffik Space Base, formerly known as Thule Air Base. The War Department's northernmost installation is critical to US missile warning, missile defense, and space surveillance missions, including advanced radars and satellite command and control from Pituffik Tracking Station. Last week, defense contractor InDyne Inc. was awarded a little-noticed multibillion-dollar contract for missile warning, missile defense, and space surveillance mission services at six locations, including Pituffik.

On Sunday, Trump repeated his unsubstantiated claims that there are “Russian destroyers and submarines and Chinese destroyers and submarines everywhere” in Greenland and that “Russia or China” will take over if the US doesn’t.

Imbalanced is an understatement for the disparity between the armed forces of the United States and Denmark. The former has approximately 1.3 million active-duty troops. The latter only 13,100. “Their defense consists of two dog sleds,” Trump said of Greenland.

The Danish Defense Command acknowledged that the Sirius Dog Sled Patrol is part of the armed forces. This patrol, stationed in Daneborg in East Greenland, consists of about a dozen soldiers, in addition to the dogs, and maintains

asdefghyk··on Dementia smart glasses turn "moonshot" into reality
For the best part of a decade, Animorph Co-operative, a London-based software development organisation, had harboured a dream of improving memory for people with dementia through a device that builds cross-sensory associations.
asdefghyk··on Ask HN: How to make my website exist for 100 years?
RE How to make my website exist for 100 years?

Get it archived in Wayback machine and other web archive sites ....

asdefghyk··on Photos capture the breathtaking scale of China's wind and solar buildout
Re Wind and Solar Buildout.

The NEXT more challenging part is to build the necessary storage and "power network transmission lines" so that the supply can be made ( Large Scale ) reliable - 24/7 , independent of the weather.

asdefghyk··on Scott Adams has died
RE ".....Ronald Reagan -- a president who did many questionable/bad things..."

Not being in the common demographic of this site , I had to google this - as I was not aware of any ..... It educated me. It made me immedicably wonder where the current president would fit into ... since the google also had questions and claimed answers/OPINIONS too " who was worst US president etc... The current presidents situation is still being played out - obviously ...

asdefghyk··on Scott Adams has died
at age 68, which is relatively young
asdefghyk··on Don't fall into the anti-AI hype
About AI writing Code, fixing bugs, and other programmer tasks.

What's missing is (captured) the test of the changed software to verify the fixes solved the problem and no other problems where introduced ....

Then a analysis of the original software changes. An analysis of the test results, test cases, test evidence to ensure it is appropriate and adequate.

asdefghyk··on Landlords are using automated services to monitor tenant promotions
The name of the company that provides this service needs to be provided, would be interesting.
asdefghyk··on The US hacked Venezuela grids before Maduro raid
How did (US Military) turning off/( or interfering with ) Venezuela power grid SPECIFICALLY help capture Maduro?

WHat difference could UPS ( Un interuuptable Power Supply's ) have made? Maybe UPS at certain military locations Maybe UPS at certain communication systems / public communication - like mobile networks? Military communication system? At Maduros actual residence ? for lighting and other uses ?

asdefghyk··on Open source is dying because we all fucking suck
Id say its dying because many of us do not donate some amount of money? and or support to the authors .
asdefghyk··on Los Angeles ends strange rite of passage with new fridge law
RE "... do LA apartments not come with refrigerators?!!.” ...." a rental not coming with a fridge is very common in other parts of the world....
asdefghyk··on Simulate jamming Starlink – requires over 1000 drones
Chinese researchers conclude jamming Starlink over Taiwan is possible but requires an enormous EW force—about 935 to 2,000 airborne jammers—due to Starlink’s dynamic, resilient low-orbit network and frequency-hopping capabilities.
asdefghyk··on British ethical hacker granted rare visa after finding 'critical vulnerability
British ethical hacker granted rare visa after finding ‘critical vulnerability’ in government site

Jacob Riggs is a cybersecurity leader and security researcher recognised for high-impact vulnerability discoveries across governments, universities, and major technology companies worldwide. (Pix via Dakota Digital / SWNS) Jacob Riggs, 36, from Bexley, London, secured one of Australia’s rarest visas after uncovering a critical flaw in a live government system.

He helped demonstrate the exceptional expertise required for the invitation-only 858 National Innovation visa, one of the most selective pathways for highly skilled professionals.

The 858 visa, formerly the Global Talent visa, is awarded to fewer than 1 percent of applicants.

It requires evidence of internationally recognised achievement, typically seen in Nobel Prize winners and Olympic medallists.

asdefghyk··on Show HN: 22 GB of Hacker News in SQLite
FYI I did NOT see the size info in the title. Impossible to edit / delete my comment now ........
asdefghyk··on Show HN: 22 GB of Hacker News in SQLite
How much space is needed? ...for the data .... Im wondering if it would work on a tablet? ....
asdefghyk··on Ask HN: Best Ways to Save on Taxes?
RE "....Hire your kids to do legitimate work, zero tax on the first $14k....."

What is the benefit of that? That is unless you control / influence the spending of the child's earned income which would make claiming a tax deduction not legal ....

← PreviousPage 6 of 26Next →