HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asdkjh345fd

46 karma · joined March 30, 2020

submissionscomments
asdkjh345fd··on People are planting more vegetable gardens
We only did that for staples, because we have ways to easily mechanically harvest huge quantities of them. We went from a man with a scythe harvesting an acre of wheat per day, to a man with a combine with a 45 foot header harvesting 600 acres of wheat per day. Vegetables are still harvested by hand. With vegetables we have gone from 4 workers harvesting an acre per day to 4 workers harvesting an acre per day.

A whole family doesn't even need one acre to grow all their grains, fruits and vegetables, so the labor really isn't a big deal.

asdkjh345fd··on People are planting more vegetable gardens
>My argument would be that gardening has a very low barrier to entry: literally any one can (and should) have a garden. However, the top skill cap on gardening is very high and does take time to achieve

It really isn't. Gardening is very easy, and the skill cap is very low. The problem is that there is a TREMENDOUS amount of misinformation being promoted as knowledge, and beginners have no way to tell fact from fiction. Almost all of my learning curve was spent trying things that are based on incorrect assumptions or just plain memes. As soon as I learned "build soil instead of killing soil" everything became trivial.

asdkjh345fd··on People are planting more vegetable gardens
People have grown all those vegetables in summers with several 40+ degree heat waves since the 1930s at least. Most of the issues people are having are due to decreased moisture, which is because of soil destruction. Living soil holds massive amounts of water, dirt holds almost none.
asdkjh345fd··on People are planting more vegetable gardens
It is much more forgiving if you have the space to plant in the ground. The much higher thermal mass and lower surface area of the ground means the roots are able to stay in a cool medium through much hotter weather, keeping the plant cool.
asdkjh345fd··on People are planting more vegetable gardens
>due to the fact that weeds are either non existent (floating raft systems) or way easier to deal with (bio media beds) compared to gardening in soil

Gardening in soil also has essentially no weeds to deal with. The problem is most people till, and destroy any soil they may have had, so they are gardening in dirt.

asdkjh345fd··on ZipGrow: Vertical farming/urban agriculture system
>They have no land and one of the largest agricultural producers in the world.

That's a bit of a misconception. Most people get the impression from the headlines that they produce a lot of food, but that is not really the case. The Netherlands is the world's second largest EXPORTER of "agricultural products", by dollar value. 10% of that is consulting and equipment. Another 10% is flowers. Those are not food. Even in the remaining 80%, it is mainly products that are high in monetary value, but low in land efficiency, like cheese and flavorless hydroponic tomatoes. The Netherlands actually only produces 50% of the calories needs of their population, and exports away a good chunk of that. They rely on importing staples to feed their population.

>More efficient, cheaper, better for the environment

The Netherlands model is none of those things. It is just used as a propaganda tool for a corporate greenwashing campaign to convince people that spending lots of money on environmentally destructive and wasteful technology is good for the environment, when it is actually being done because it is good for the bank accounts of a small minority of wealthy people.

asdkjh345fd··on ZipGrow: Vertical farming/urban agriculture system
>They get everything they need from it

Except carbon which they get from the air.

>the taste is identical

Identical to what? Strawberries grown in boron deficient soil taste worse than strawberries grown in soil with adequate boron. There is no yield difference, the plant does not die from the low boron. But it is unable to make large enough quantities of certain flavonoids that contribute to the flavor of the berries. We do not know how to synthetically feed plants in hydroponic situations well enough to even get optimal yield, much less optimal flavor or nutrition. Maximum yields from healthy soil still exceed maximum yields from synthetic fertilization.

>There is no "magic" inside soil other than its a media that happens to allow nutrients to exist next to the roots that absorb them, while allowing the plant to support its own weight and stay fixed.

That is a really unfortunate misconception. The difference is very real, but it is science not magic. Soil is not an inert media, it is a massive and complex ecosystem with an entire food web. Fungi actually penetrate the roots of plants and directly exchange nutrients and energy with them. Microbes can create entire amino acids, and directly give them to plants in exchange for glucose. This is very different from an inert medium that simply holds ions in water for plants to absorb. Hormones released by the plant roots appear to change the organic acid production of certain fungi, which affects how much of which minerals are solublized from the mineral component of the soil (dirt). Millions of years of co-evolution have created a system where plants are able to direct microbes to meet their specific nutritional needs at any particular time. In the process, these microbes defend the plants they have formed these symbiotic relationships with from other microbes, such as those that cause fungal diseases like blight.

>it's the same as traditional farming except they have to be water-soluble

They have to be water-soluble with conventional farming too. This is the big problem with conventional agriculture, it is really just industrial scale hydroponics done using the ground as a cheap medium. Traditional farming predates synthetic fertilizer and relied on soil.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4