HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on Can Algorithms Form Price-Fixing Cartels?
I think Keen makes two points. One is (as it often is the case in Debunking Economics) that this is "surprising" for students of economics. He cites various textbooks, like Mankiw. If economists know these things, why do they lie to students? It is indoctrination, plain and simple.

The second point, IIRC, is that the Cournot model of perfect competition is mathematically wrong. The assumptions that no firm can influence the price and decreasing demand curve are contradictory, regardless whether or not these provide a good model for the real world.

asgard1024··on Can Algorithms Form Price-Fixing Cartels?
It's actually not primarily based on complicated mathematical assumptions, but on the simulation and also empirical data about MR!=MC in the real world. That was his primary motivation to study this problem. See Steve Keen's book Debunking Economics if you want a bit more details.

Even if you would have an endless stream of market entrants, you would also need some companies to exit, otherwise everybody would get smaller and smaller piece of the pie. In the real world, those who come will usually set the price just below the current market value. If you think about it, it's nothing else than the Keen's model with just companies being renamed endlessly (after they make one step).

But go ahead and try to simulate it, and add more realism. I think you will find very similar result (that is, profit maximizing strategy will never be to compete on price). Except for the price wars, which (in my opinion) always happen only temporarily when the big company wants to drive smaller companies out of the market entirely to get more market share as a result (just like real wars). But you need to have inelastic demand for that, otherwise I doubt it can be considered a viable strategy.

asgard1024··on Can Algorithms Form Price-Fixing Cartels?
No. There is an excellent work by Steve Keen that shows how simple it is for non-communicating bots under perfect competition to collude: http://arxiv.org/pdf/nlin/0411006.pdf

I wish that mainstream economists would accept that the collusion and not competition (aka price war) is the normal state of affairs and updated their school models accordingly.

asgard1024··on “Information asymmetry” cuts both ways
While I agree with most of your post, I am not sure this:

> Typical human behavior is to want compensation proportional to productivity and to live in a system that allows this.

is entirely true. I think humans want "fairness" and in many ways it's different than raw productivity. Two main problems I see:

1. Other things than people (usually called capital) have productivity on its own (unless you believe in labor theory of value, which leads to logical contradictions). If you are paid for your productivity, you are not paid for the excess, things produced by the capital. For example, a new automation is invented which makes you more productive, but you now do less work. How should the surplus be distributed? In fact, I am of opinion that if I would be paid for my actual productivity (my contribution to it as a human being in contrast to contribution by machines and know-how) in modern society, I would be homeless next month. Yet, here I have an above average salary (maybe even global 1%).

2. Totally meritocratic system (say efficient free market, if such thing exists), even if we deal with the above problem, lacks one important things that humans have - forgiveness. Sometimes disasters happen or people are just plain stupid. Without forgiveness or outside help, a single disaster like that can affect you for life. So I don't think "meritocracy based on productivity only" is a desirable system and I am sure I am not alone.

asgard1024··on Why Do We Play Video Games That Feel Like Work?
> Maybe it's just me, but I find work to only suck when there is a long commute time and it's 2015 and our stupid company is still running Ruby 1.8 on rails 2.3, there is no automated testing, the javascript is an unreadable pile or .rjs mess, and literally every bug is some variant of "undefined is not a function" happening at run-time (for which I get yelled at).

That's why you come home and program in a perfect world of Haskell (or some other toy), just like the farmer chooses the virtual farm over the real one.

> The article calls this "the realities of work" and that the inherent difficulties and uncertainties are natural to the problems of the "real world" and must be accepted.

In a certain sense, you're correct - the challenges to overcome in a game can have the same magnitude. In other sense, you're not. At the end of the day, game is still a game. Maybe it is the responsibility that you feel that makes the difference. In the real world, the stakes are higher; cannot that be the ultimate reason why the work sucks?

asgard1024··on Is there a war instinct?
Thanks, that was an interesting article. Yet, in the light of the OP, it also seems to be tied to specific American culture. It seems that there are societies (like in Europe) where going to war doesn't have so much that connotation of "being a man". Maybe they just do the ritual differently, for example, in Nordic countries, by trekking and hill-climbing.

Now that I think about it, I am not sure this article is in disagreement with OP. The OP argues that war is a capacity, not some given natural trait. This article claims that people have need for "the ritual of manhood", whatever that is, but doesn't claim it has to be "going to a war". So even Junger may consider the war to be a capacity.

asgard1024··on The Most Diverse Cities Are Often the Most Segregated
I do consider maximum integration ideal.

The more you segregate people, the easier it is to start wars and other violent conflict. Many Americans have no problem with bombing (or droning) Iraqis, for example. There would be more outrage if you droned black people in Baltimore. But even in Baltimore the segregation causes problems.

It's just human nature, to create in-groups and have special morality for them, and modern societies should fight it, by intermixing people. Democracy and social equality are good instruments to do so. Ideally on planetary scale, but were not there yet.

It can also be seen as a tradeoff. With segregation, you get a more closely knit community in the inside, but less to the outside. Conflicts occur in both scenarios, but there are different ways to dissipate it. Interacting with people you don't know that well dissipates the conflict often and by very little, which may be frustrating and lead to less happiness. Closer-knit community may dissipate conflict to the outside at once, with violent results. So it's really choose your poison situation - be perpetually unhappy in individualism or be happier now but risk a larger war from time to time.

asgard1024··on TrueCraft, An Open Source Implementation of Minecraft 1.7.3
It seems to be a wrong choice to me, here's why. There is a lot of mods for Minecraft that use unofficial Forge API. If this project reimplemented Minecraft and made a similar API, many of the mods could be ported to it.
asgard1024··on Stop Misquoting Donald Knuth
Sure thing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radix_sort
asgard1024··on Python without an operating system
These modern "GRUB + interpreter" attempts reminds me of CP/CMS. CP was a hypervisor and CMS was a small single-user operating system that runs on top of it (scriptable in REXX).
asgard1024··on Giant Lego Machine Generates Churning House Tracks
Interesting. Not a fan of this type of "music", but it could be cool to tie my production system in Minecraft (logistic pipes) to play different sound effect each time some item was requested or produced. Perhaps the results would be similar and I would get an instant feedback on how well the system is running.
asgard1024··on You Have to Hack This Massively Multiplayer Game to Beat It
To be fair, it's very hard to do, especially in a sandbox game - the computer has not only to have a good model of the world, but also a model of how the client sees the world.

And in Minecraft it's not really a problem, because the game is more cooperative than competitive.

asgard1024··on The death of optimizing compilers [pdf]
He is soooo spot on! This "dialogue with the compiler" is going to be really big in the next decades, but it's in no way a death of automatic optimization, it's just the beginning of it.

Here's a simple example how I expect it to work: You write a code that uses a list-like data structure. The compiler then instruments the code and you run some tests. The tests will then be evaluated and the (post?)compiler selects what kind of data structure is to be used (let's make example simple, choices are array vs. list). For instance, if you need to look up elements a lot (based on the evidence from testing), an array will be chosen as the underlying data structure.

And you actually get (if you want to see it, normally this information will be hidden) a little box in the IDE, where the variable is used, that tells you: "Here, an array will be used." You can then with one click say: "I don't want array, make it a list." So for all the possible optimizations, there are two viewpoints presented: The viewpoint of the compiler (based-on evidence from the tests or static analysis) and the viewpoint of the programmer (which allows for confirmation or override in case there are some unknown assumptions).

And if the specifications change (say, we chose list earlier but now we have actually a lot of direct access to elements), you can just recompile the same code with the previously-agreed compiler choices removed! And without changing any line of code, a different and more fitting data structure will be used.

You can easily see this can apply to many things, not just data structures. You can also see that different ways how the dialogue can be implemented are possible, once we syntactically separate the "what" from the "how" in the programming language. In the future, I believe, we will program just with abstract data types, and the concrete type specification will be selected based on the evidence from the running program (or static analysis augmented with that information). So the dialogue will not happen just with the programmer, but the compiler will also observe the real world behavior of the program and facilitate adaptation to that.

In this way, it's even possible to input assumptions that doesn't have to be provably correct. This approach can potentially bridge the static vs dynamic types divide, and others.

Finally, Haskell and functional languages are very nice, but I don't think they are final word in programming. If we wanted the above, they have syntactical problems such as mixing of concrete and abstract types (type classes). Also, there are limits to static analysis in the real world. The future will be lot more interesting.

asgard1024··on Do Not Learn Frameworks – Learn the Architecture
Thanks, didn't know the book, looks like an interesting read.

However, I think when you program the pattern you have already instantiated it, anyway. At least when you used it several times throughout your program. In those cases I think it's then better to explicitly abstract it away (i.e. tell the computer you are using the pattern).

asgard1024··on Do Not Learn Frameworks – Learn the Architecture
I think patterns are stupid idea. You bother learning a way of doing things (the pattern), and you bother all you colleagues learning that way of doing things. OK, cool, that sounds good.

But you never bother to teach it the computer! The computer should understand the pattern as well, in form of some abstraction. Because now you force yourself and others to recognize pattern every time you need to use it (either read or write it in the code). That's ridiculous.

In some languages, patterns are commonly expressed via macros. Instead of learning patterns, you learn set of macros. That way, even computer understands those patterns and it is clearly obvious from the code what pattern was used, you don't have to translate code back to patterns. But the macros are not the only way to do it.

asgard1024··on Social Norms and Gendered Expectations
> I don't understand what problem you think she has that would be solved by "getting over it".

She will have to accept the fact that people are unconsciously biased and won't fix it.

> It's a lot like learning any other thing.

My point is - people won't do it. Especially people in power, who make decisions; they are often not "nice". What she wants is a micromanagement of social relationships.

It actually may only confuse a couple of nice nerds and make them socially more awkward as they honestly try to navigate the maze of these new social norms. If anything, I am worried that the result will be even worse perception of the IT profession.

asgard1024··on Social Norms and Gendered Expectations
I hate to say this, but she will just have to get over it. People have biases, and are not entirely rational (in fact, if anything, we are machines built to rationalize to other people what we deserve).

The article goes to the ridiculous area, which is trending in the U.S.: Taking on the impossible task to train people to avoid these "unconscious" biases. It will a be a lot wasted effort, for ultimately impossible goal.

Let's assume there is a surgical procedure that lets you get of your biases. Would you do it? Are you going to require people to undergo the procedure? At some point, we just have to accept the biases, because the cost to get rid of them is too high.

And even if I would accept her solution, one of the big biases is that we judge similar faces to our own more positively. How are we ever going to get rid of that bias? For a given minority, you can perhaps consciously think, "Am I here biased?". But for person which looks differently than you? How can you even know you are biased?

Finally, I would like to warn, attempts to correct bias may create more bias, overshadowing any bias that was originally there. For instance, if you have positive discrimination, people may think that minorities have a leg up thanks to it, and may judge them more harshly.

I don't think any amount of anti-bias training will change people's biases. What does change them is role-models, and yes, in biased environment, these require hard work, on part of people who don't want to be perceived in biased fashion. Tough cookie.

asgard1024··on The Shut-In Economy
Depression has certain criteria, for example things like you don't enjoy anything, you feel tired all the time, you consider that you shouldn't live, and so on. I had a mild depression, and I know this is not it. I am happy, I like to meet people from time to time, etc.

It's not addiction either - I spend my days on the Internet (or in computer games) a lot, but if I had to spend a week without it, it wouldn't be a problem. I don't have to be connected 24x7 either. I also sometimes abandon the game for no reason.

It's really just you don't feel so motivated by the things in the real world compared to virtual possibilities. Let me reiterate, I think parent was spot on when he talked about the "artificial Skinner box of instant rewards", and I don't think there is a psychiatric category describing this.

It's not a mental disorder, just like overeating (and being overweight due to that) isn't (usually) a disorder. But yeah, it may be a mental health issue. It's mentally unhealthy behavior, just like eating too much is unhealthy.

asgard1024··on The Shut-In Economy
No, I think parent is exactly right. I feel similar to the OP, but I know for sure it's not a depression. And I think I suffer the same problem the parent described. The real world just seems so messy and complicated compared to virtual worlds.

You may call it a mental health issue, but it is neither addiction nor depression; if anything, it's just not being addicted to real world enough.

asgard1024··on DemocracyOS
> Except that these oppressive acts are law-making: the oppressive act under discussion is the vote.

I don't understand how is voting oppressive. Bad laws can be changed; what cannot be changed are things like loss of human lives, that's irreversible. You are arguing very abstractly; perhaps more specific example of oppression (ideally from the real world) would help? I would like to see a historic example of law promoted by majority (and if possible, opposed by elites) that had extremely negative consequences for some minority.

> How is this anything but tyranny by majority?

No, you're misunderstanding. It's that majority will change their vote to conform the minority view (if the idea is good, of course), not other way around. Just look at my example - unemployment. Even though unemployed people are in ephemeral minority, unemployment is a big topic for everybody, the majority. Because many people have been unemployed in the past or know someone, who was. So if someone is proposing to help the minority of unemployed, majority will probably vote for it. Neither they are probably going to support harming unemployed people.

> the first thing it says is that it's "half-direct"

The half-direct is more precise term, direct democracy is not quite practical, but it has important advantages to representative democracy. Half-direct democracy is a good compromise between those features.

> Personally, my conclusion is that, for the United States to more likely attain a "consensual result", it needs a higher degree of homogeneity, not direct democracy.

Well, the causality is the other way around - Swiss are homogenous because they have decades of experience in building consensus. But think whatever you want.

> It's probably very difficult to understand my point when you aren't really reading what I wrote in good faith.

The point is, in a real democracy, you don't have to pick from (as little as) two packages of issues that some clever marketers designed. That really means that there is no clear minority and majority - in some issues you may be minority and in some majority. In other words, being in minority is an artifact of the representative political system (and the majority voting or two party system makes it worse).

> As far as I can tell, our actual difference of opinion can be demonstrated with this thought experiment.

You don't have to do thought experiments. There have been quite a lot of cases where Swiss people changed the majority view from conservative to more progressive one. It's a little slower process (may take several years), but it happens. There have been also some regresses (I think some anti-mosque laws and such), but these happen at the same glacial pace, and are no worse than anywhere else.

You know, Switzerland and U.S. (not on federal level, and in all states, unfortunately) both have half-direct democracy, and they have some highest living standards in the world. Is that just a coincidence? (I certainly don't see much oppression going on there, and that's why this "tyranny of the majority" argument always seemed to me as some ivory tower bullshit.)

asgard1024··on Why We Should Demand a Shorter Workweek
You can, but then your employer will be forced to pay extra by law (at least that's how the labor code in my, small European country, is). Or you can be self-employed and then the labor code won't apply.

(If you still don't like it, you must be from Mars or something. I don't know anyone who would hate to get the extra money, and in fact, I don't know anyone here who would want to work longer hours than 40.)

asgard1024··on Why We Should Demand a Shorter Workweek
> the entire Marxist system relies on the labor theory of value

I am no expert in Marx, so I cannot say that's invalid statement, but I do consider labor theory of value wrong and I agree with many of Marxs' views.

Interestingly though, the idea of meritocracy relies on labor theory of value as well. (As someone else above noted: "A large part of the problem for the working classes, according to Marx, is that they buy into the capitalist idea that people are paid what they deserve, rather than what the capitalist can get away with.")

If you believe that capital, or machines, or biological systems, or historical experience, do create value, and not all value comes from the human work, how are you going to split the extra value? Machines don't need it. Anyway you split it, it's not meritocratic, because merit is measured in work.

For example, if I automate something (let's say by happy accident), then I am doing less work now and should deserve less than my previous me, yet at the same time, more value is produced. Meritocracy fails to reconcile this difference unless you ascribe all value that is produced to human labor.

asgard1024··on DemocracyOS
> From my reading, doesn't this say nothing?

No, it's similar to pareto optimality. Democracy protects every possible minority equally. It won't give any minority an inch more rights so they could tyrannize the majority.

> How does "emergence" affect the possibility of tyranny?

A lot, because of human empathy. Why would you vote for a tyranny of relatively small group of people? Most people can see that one step ahead and know that they are the next. Also, in more direct democracies, people vote more often and have different views on issues, so they are minority and majority at the same time. This influences their willingness to compromise.

> So maybe the takeaway here is that pure democracy is insufficient?

It is insufficient, but not in the general sense "because of tyranny of the majority". Democracy doesn't try to solve specific cultural issues, it's a decision making mechanism. If your objection is just a general "tyranny of the majority", then I doubt there is anything better (because you have to start somewhere, and democracy gives everyone the same power).

> Isn't this just semantics?

No. There are different methods how to have same access to power. All of them can be considered democratic, although each has advantages and disadvantages. Also, to prevent Russell-style paradoxes, you cannot decide democratically whether or not you want to abandon (or establish) democracy. You can however decide that with a vote.

> Freedom to vote doesn't necessarily have to mean freedom to persecute--freedoms generally end at the boundary where they begin trampling other freedoms.

I think you misunderstand the sentence - I meant that people that are being persecuted can still have voting rights. Although historically, I would say any group with voting rights was being persecuted much less than without.

> Also, in which situations "It is a cultural issue"?

What I mean is that it's not just legal framework that causes oppression, people's beliefs cause oppression. The laws are, and always will be, reflection of those beliefs. If you don't like that someone is being persecuted, you can't just change the law, you have to change the culture.

> Do current elites participate in persecutions?

Depends on who you ask, what your specific persecution you have in mind. But in most cases it's just sitting by idly, whether or not it's participation again depends on your view.

> How will people in prison obtain fair representation under DemocracyOS?

I wasn't addressing DemocracyOS specifically, but in my country (Czech Republic), we have provisions for prisoners to vote if they want to. So in our country they have fairer representation than in the U.S. (at least some states).

> So the solution is to never protect minorities in the first place?

I am not sure what "protections" you have in mind. As I already explained, it's hard to conceive that e.g. Saudi Arabian elites would decide to protect women minority. It's a matter of culture and you cannot rely on any elite (even appointed one) to do that. Society as a whole has to believe that's a good value.

And as far as general protections go, I can't imagine anything better than democracy, which just gives everyone same rights. Any other solution will by definition have to give someone more say, and this person or group will be more fallible and can cause more oppression themselves.

asgard1024··on DemocracyOS
> Indeed, it's actually more poignant that the tyranny is both ephemeral and, more importantly, inevitable. This is the real issue. It's easy to comprehend the issue by looking at semi-permanent states [1], like Marxist class divisions or political polarization, but those are consequences.

I disagree; if the oppression is ephemeral, then it's nowhere as bad as when it is (semi)permanent. (Maybe an example would help - all the oppressions that come to my mind from history, that were formalized in law, are attempts to permanently subjugate or even eradicate the minority.)

(In fact, I can come up with an example of "ephemeral" oppression - unemployment. It's irony that people who argue that democracy leads to tyranny of majority often fail to see the tyranny of the markets.)

People do have empathy and memory; if you being in the minority is ephemeral, then you will remember it and vote differently. Oppression can only work if people are afraid; if they are not, they can change things and work toward consensus.

And if you look at direct democracy in Switzerland, for instance, you will find that direct democracy (I don't consider representative democracy only one or the best possibility) actually leads to more consensual result - people vote differently on different issues, sometimes they have minority view, mostly they have majority view (as it happens statistically), and because of that, the party or class tribalism you describe from American politics is greatly reduced. So empirically, exact opposite happens than what "tyranny of the majority" crowd tends to think that happens. (Another counterfactual claim is that direct democracy will lead to some torrent of crazy changes - in fact common voters are more conservative and less decisive than politicians.)

> This is a problem. It is the exact opposite of what you need to make sure that a majority is an emergent majority.

I don't understand what is your point here. In direct democracy, the majority is always emergent; it depends on your actual views, not on which party you decide to vote for.

asgard1024··on DemocracyOS
I think the Saudi only saw the end result and failed to appreciate the process that led to it. Many European countries have even better things, like social rights, and allowing prisoners to vote.

Democracy cannot change the culture in the country. It's just a tool for decision making in politics, better than fists. It can lead to culture change, though. Democracy causes people who didn't have power previously to be involved, and different moral view is dispersed in society.

If you would give Saudis the U.S. constitution, it would still take time before citizens would change the culture to consider women peers. The constitution itself doesn't guarantee the outcome either.

asgard1024··on DemocracyOS
Democracy does exactly that - it gives everyone the same vote, regardless what minority they come from. Therefore, it protects any minority for maximum possible extent. You don't need any formal rules on top of that; in other words, the solution to "tyranny of the majority" should not be "tyranny of the minority". (I really hate the phrase "tyranny of the majority", by the way, because it simply isn't a good way to describe democratic voting, where the majority is emergent and not determined ex ante.)

But let's say, indeed, majority wants to violate the rights of minority. Stripping other people from voting rights isn't democratic (even if it's voted by everybody), because it violates the basic democratic rule, "every person should get the same power in politics". Democracy is defined by the end result (same access to power), not the procedure (voting). (In fact, democracy allows for tradeoffs where a person gets little more power in exchange for more accountability.)

It's true that even without stripping other voter's rights, minorities can still be persecuted. But it is a cultural issue, which won't be resolved by formal constitutional framework. In fact, historically, it very often were elites (that you may think are the solution) who participated or even organized these persecutions.

For example, in the U.S., there is a large minority of people in prison who are not protected by democracy, because they don't have voting rights. I would appreciate proof of any claim as to how any sort of republican institutions in the U.S. helps these people be protected. I don't see that.

Someone wrote below that the solution could be super-majority vote, like 80% of citizens to agree to change the constitution. I think that's a wrong idea, which doesn't give enough credit to people. This can possibly protect a minority, but it can also delay progress in helping minority. The minority that needs to be overruled in super-majority voting can keep the status quo longer than desired by most, and that's unfair too. We don't know what the future morality will be; it may be different in positive, not negative, fashion compared to today's morality. We could perhaps say, though, that the future society will be more happy with their own morality than ours (because they can compare the two, we cannot); therefore, it should be possible for them not be too conservative and implement it.

Anyway, this debate is always rather academic, because politicians only rarely vote with the majority. (And no, pre-war Germany is not a good example, as I already explained above.)

asgard1024··on I Hate the News (2006)
Here are two ideas for non-traditional news, that would reduce the information overload, and make news more interesting and healthy:

- Actionable news. Only news to which you can (or have to), as a citizen, take some action. Examples: Changes in law, cultural events that will take place in the future, openings of new institutions, planned political demonstrations or petitions.

- Old news. Only give news about something after it is resolved, not when it is happening (avoid especially breaking news). Examples: Instead of speculation who will be appointed to some office, just tell me who was appointed. When disaster occurs, wait three days when the information is more complete about the aftermath. Reviews of products that have already been released.

asgard1024··on YouTube puts the final nail in the loudness wars' coffin
I am not sure it's the final nail. I think at some point they may start playing the commercials louder. I had to skip a lot of Czech commercials simply because they were too loud.
asgard1024··on Scrum seems to be mostly about having better alibis
Well, if my math is correct, 15 minute meeting every day still beats 3hr status meeting every week. Our status meeting was only about 0.5-1hr long, and we actually got a bit more done, because you're not supposed to go into detail during the standup.

Anyway, what you seem to praise is Agile (as per the manifesto), not SCRUM, and I agree (although some problems are actually suitable for upfront specification). Still, distractions can be a problem on the other extreme that needs to be managed too.

asgard1024··on Scrum seems to be mostly about having better alibis
> Scrum is designed for software teams working in a well-known problem space

I always have to wonder, if your problem was already solved, why don't you just buy off-the-shelf solution? If you aren't doing anything new, what is the point? It seems like you cannot organize the work correctly already! Frankly, if you have failed to use what was already done, no amount of management methods will help cover _that_ productivity screw up. :-)

← PreviousPage 12 of 22Next →