HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on Scrum seems to be mostly about having better alibis
> It's that you need to realize that the enemy of productivity has been siloing people and specialists that want to hand-off their work to others.

I think you're wrong. What you should realize that there are many enemies of productivity, and different for different people.

For instance, for me, having useless meetings (like standups or groomings) is mentally exhausting, and it kills a lot of motivation for the day.

I was most productive under well managed waterfall - where we had one longer status meeting each week, and instead of grooming interrupting work on the problem every week or so, we had time to think about the problem complexity at the beginning of the project.

In my view, the key to productivity in programming is focus. Whether you focus as a team or as a person doesn't matter. What is needed though is someone reliable who can shield you from all the distractions, and can do that without actually distracting you. In my experience with SCRUM, all the distractions are dumped onto developers (all of them in fact, via standup).

I am not against Agile development (in particular, just like author, I am not against iterative development or Agile manifesto), but the SCRUM I found rather silly. It's an attempt to do one-size fits all.

Not every feature requires exactly the number of people in the team. Not every feature requires one sprint of time. Some require less, some require more. If your work is managed correctly, you don't have worry about these arbitrary boundaries (which will always exist because time-boxing and standups, no matter how long the sprint or how big the team, are the key features of SCRUM).

asgard1024··on Scrum seems to be mostly about having better alibis
Ah, dammit, those creative types! Why can't they just follow orders like everybody else? :-) (I haven't downvoted you, I am just explaining it.)
asgard1024··on Scrum seems to be mostly about having better alibis
None of these complaints is in the original post, which I agree with - the things he talks about are problems of SCRUM. Also, AFAIK the standup is not about accountability, it's about communication.
asgard1024··on A Scholarly Markdown
Thanks, this is exactly what I was looking for. A simple syntax for documentation that is extensible with macros. I am glad AsciiDoc includes them, they are very useful.
asgard1024··on Companies with a flat structure are weird
Open Source is in fact a democracy. The most general definition of democracy is: Everybody in the group has the same amount of power, which is defined by "shared understanding" how things should be, and usually by having an explicit rule in place that enforces the same amount of power for everyone (in small groups, the rule may be just informal).

In OSS, everybody has the same access to the source code. That's the power from the definition, and the OSS license is the explicit rule.

Because of the explicit rule, if someone goes power hungry on one extreme, the rule guarantees that he will be ousted (via forking the source), and other extreme, if someone is not interested in politics (like someone actually working on the code), they won't get screwed, because they will always have the source code access according to the rule.

People in the past tried it, naively, without the explicit power rule. That was the MIT license. But they got screwed (divided and conquered) by people who wanted power, who wanted to close the source. That's why copyleft (i.e. democracy) was invented. (This actually happened on the metagame level - now the BSD type licenses mostly work because people always can fall back to GPL.)

asgard1024··on Companies with a flat structure are weird
> Which means that people who are naturally political end up with all the power

I am socialist/anarchist and that's exactly why I am against flat structures. The solution is so simple - democracy. It's pretty much a one rule, which is prescriptive - everyone gets the same amount of power. So it doesn't matter what you do, if you do politics, or do something technical, useful or not, at the end of the day, we clean the tables and have the same amount of power again. Then there is not much point in politics, if you can't amass power.

I wish more honest technical people (or those who don't want to be involved in politics) understand that. I don't know, sometimes I tend to think that majority of people simply want politics and the power hierarchies.

asgard1024··on Argument Cultures and Unregulated Aggression
Hm, interesting. This seems like a "Spock vs. Bones" type of worldview, although I would have never guessed that I would side with Bones (age, probably?).

Yeah, perhaps if you want fully rational discussion, then emotions are counterproductive. But should that mean we should have this sterile environment without any passion? And does showing a passion really means aggression? I just don't think so.

asgard1024··on Argument Cultures and Unregulated Aggression
Actually, I think this video sums up the main problem with the article: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8HdOHrc3OQ

Would you say the guy in the video is aggressive? He certainly speaks loudly and authoritatively, and uses a lot of emotional words and shortcuts.

Of course the answer is no. The article confuses, quite thoroughly, aggression and passion. That's why I said "she's reading too much into it", because she reads "aggression" where she should just probably read "passion".

asgard1024··on Argument Cultures and Unregulated Aggression
If she wrote what you did, then she might have a point. (My understanding of English really is that an argument can mean debate as well, or maybe confusingly, the debate consists of arguments.) If you're talking about people who have power over another, that's a different situation. But then, that wouldn't exactly fit with majority of "vim vs. emacs" type discussions I have ever had, even online, so the argument (see :-)) breaks down.

In cases where you are arguing with peers, I think people back off in debates in cases where their own argument is not very strong. If I tell someone strong in Java, say, let's do it this way, and he (loudly) says "no way", without explanation, I may think, "OK, this guy knows Java really well, I respect his authority on the matter, then probably my idea is not very good". And I may decide to drop it, not worry about it, and do more useful things. If I think I have a strong argument, I may pursue it and let him explain his reasoning. This is actually not submitting to authority, it's respecting it. If I think he doesn't know Java, I would always pursue. It may be sometimes wrong to do it, but it's also very efficient most of the time, not to have endless debates with people who know what they are doing. That's why it's always a call, and if you want to be really professional, you should not be afraid to pursue a good argument, regardless of what the other party is doing. (And if you work for a boss/authority who doesn't recognize it, I suggest change of job.)

I work for American company, and I can tell you, American act far more "professionally" than Czechs, and sometimes it is indeed really nice. Czechs are also a bit more honest - if they feel something is wrong, they will tell you straight. So trust me, what she describes has not much to do with competitivness.

asgard1024··on Argument Cultures and Unregulated Aggression
No, it isn't. Because my main point, which you missed, was "don't take these arguments too seriously, because they are not". They are basically child's play. You don't think children fighting each other are going to grow up criminals, do you? This is the same thing.

But everything I wrote was honest. I, being a leftist anarchist, am probably more for equal and harmonic society than the author is. For instance, I wish there was no authority from power, and the companies were run democratically.

asgard1024··on Argument Cultures and Unregulated Aggression
Frankly, that's a terrible article, full of sexist stereotypes. She is reading too much into it. Just briefly: Sometimes people argue because they genuinely think their favorite tool is superior, and want to help others be more efficient. Sometimes people speak loudly because they are genuinely excited about something. I doubt there is any authority or respect to win by good arguing about technology (especially on online forums). Furthermore, any authority to be likely won by arguing only exists if people respect it; if one stops caring about people "gaining authority" by arguing, then there will not be any authority to be gained by that. [Edit: She also underestimates curiosity - sometimes I argue and play devil's advocate just because I am curious why the other smart person has a different opinion, how good is their argument?]

The only valid complaint in the article is that people judge assertive women more negatively than assertive men, which is true and unfortunate.

It's also amusing that she blames engineer's arguing for the competitive atmosphere, while being from the US, which has this hyper-competitive capitalist culture, which I rather despise and I am not the only engineer who does. (Another fun fact - I am native Czech speaker, and we have two different words for "argument" - "debata" and "hadka", the former implying a civil one, the other one meaning one where people are angry at each other. I am not really sure which meaning the article uses, and I pretty firmly against the latter - being a sensitive male, but I greatly enjoy the former.)

The article is very clever in one thing, though. Now anyone who argues with it can be labelled as aggressive (or terrorist?). Humans and their mindgames, so funny.

asgard1024··on Stuff I've Messed Up While Interviewing
I thought about it too. Most biological systems that grow are examples of recursion (like trees). Most human manufacturing systems are examples of iteration (production line, building with a crane floor by floor).
asgard1024··on Software Estimation Games
> If there was a planning process that was consistently reliable for new, complex software I think people would use it. And I think the adoption of agile methodologies in software development is an example of people trying to implement an improved planning process.

There are such processes. But they require understanding of the problem, which takes time. I am not sure "agile" is really attempt at an improved planning process, it's at best not doing planning and just marching onto the problem, seeing what happens at regular intervals in the hope of better understanding it, and at worst, things like "planning poker" where you put a bunch of people into a room and let everybody make a (possibly educated but usually not very much) guess from the top of their heads.

asgard1024··on “Just remove the duck” (2013)
Similar thing was often done by writers in the Eastern bloc to fool the censors. They left some obviously bad things in the material to be censored, so the censor could complain about something, and they would leave more subtle references intact.
asgard1024··on Eye Sim – The eyesight simulator
I am not sure. It may contribute to it, but I still think the effect I see is something different. Most apparent it is when I am looking into a LED light with my bare eyes, compared to the unfocused camera. It really looks like the brain would amplify the small differences between neigbouring "pixels" in attempt to focus the image.
asgard1024··on Eye Sim – The eyesight simulator
I am nearsighted and it's not quite accurate. The optics is probably correct, however brain attempts to sharpen the image, so the perceived result is not just blurred. Especially the light sources - I see somewhat fuzzy spiky balls instead of evenly shaded blotches.
asgard1024··on Yanis Varoufakis: How I became an erratic Marxist (2013)
> Why is it that there is not - nor never was - a single prosperous country build on Marxist principles? Is it possible that Marx's theory is nonsense and all the rich mixed-capitalism economies are right?

It is possible. But let's not jump to conclusions. There wasn't any prosperous democratic country in Europe before cca 1600 either.

There are some smaller experiments. Things like Mondragon Cooperative or Kibutzes. These don't end too badly. It is even being claimed that they have higher productivity. They probably also exhibit lower outward growth, which tends to be bad when they compete with capitalist economies. Just like democratic societies tend to project less military force compared to dictatorships (because it doesn't help the general public, only the elites on top), these "marxist" economies also don't grow (compete in the market) very aggressively, to their disadvantage. But for the workers (I mean people doing stuff, majority of people and the ones that actually deserve to be paid) it may well be a better system, just like democracy is better than dictatorship.

asgard1024··on I don’t know what to do, you guys
There is nothing inherently leftist about feelings of moral superiority. It comes with various ideologies and is poisonous all the same. I can only recommend Altemey's excellent book on the topic. (By the way, my short definition is that if want to reduce social injustice and inequality, then you are a leftist.)

In fact, yesterday I just had a debate with my Czech coworkers (we work for an American company). In Europe, the ideology of "political correctness" is not so followed (and in fact many from minorities would find it plainly annoying), and in Czech Republic specifically is mostly ignored. Yet in many respects Europe could be considered more "leftist" (take employment law, for instance).

asgard1024··on Artificial Intelligence Will Kill Capitalism
Good riddance! Better start working on it.. :-)

Seriously, we have problems with distribution of capital already. There are two mainstream theories of value:

First pretty much argues that value is subjective, so the distribution of capital, whatever it is, is never a problem. It's more of a cop-out than an attempt to describe the world.

The second is the (Marxist) labor theory of value, which argues that all the value comes from human work. However, it is unfortunately logically inconsistent.

In the reality probably lots of value already comes from machines (and biological systems), and we have lots of social conventions and pretending (calling it "meritocracy" etc.) around it concerning how to distribute this added value to humans. In reality I don't believe there are many people (maybe some homeless ones) in the western society who deserve their current living standard, for the labor they do.

I don't think that this sort of social construction is going to be eliminated by artificial intelligence. We will just see more of it, if anything.

asgard1024··on When the Boss Says, 'Don't Tell Your Coworkers How Much You Get Paid'
> If you know the salary of the people you're directly working with, things can get awkward.

It's interesting that it isn't awkward for the managers, knowing how much their reports make.

asgard1024··on When the Boss Says, 'Don't Tell Your Coworkers How Much You Get Paid'
> When the Boss Says, 'Don't Tell Your Coworkers How Much You Get Paid'

You say, "Are you ashamed of how much you pay me?", and start looking for another job.

asgard1024··on Why Falling Prices Are Actually a Really Bad Thing
> What happens to the price of a single good over the lifetime of that good is not a useful lesson in what happens as a result of broad, economy-wide deflation.

True. But why then the article is titled "Why Falling Prices Are Actually a Really Bad Thing" and not "Why Deflation Is Actually a Really Bad Thing"?

I can imagine economy where you don't have deflation, prices of all products fall, and the economy is actually growing, because people produce and buy completely new products they could not afford before.

asgard1024··on Retiring Python as a Teaching Language
> Thus, I don't really think that learning Python offers solid programming foundations.

I agree. But there is a huge class of people that this argument tends to miss - all the people who learn programming as a tool and not a way of life, like scientists or engineers from other departments. For those, it's ideal to learn one language, and it's OK if they don't completely understand CS. For them it's better to know a language that has wide range of practical applications.

So unless you are absolutely sure that you're going to learn CS, I would still suggest Python as a first (and possibly only) language.

I would also say that doing GUI in like PyQt is really easy, but the documentation and tutorials are lacking.

asgard1024··on An Analysis of Minecraft-like Engines (2012)
> Which is why minecraft went for the retro-aesthetic

I though main reason why MC is retro is that Notch is not really an artist - he just wanted to create graphics quickly. And he brilliantly turned this into an advantage - I can't imagine MC without iconic square pigs and pixelated pickaxes.

asgard1024··on The Simple Proof of the Tetris Lamp
Yeah, if you form a perfect rectangle, all the pieces will disappear.
asgard1024··on In Wake of Charlie Hebdo Attack, Let’s Not Sacrifice Even More Rights
The "mind viruses" should be fought with "mind antibiotics", not by killing the host. The idea that "thought viruses" will somehow spread without limits (in a liberal society) is a very elitist one, and there is no evidence for that.
asgard1024··on How the “Down-Vote” Leads to a Vicious Circle of Negative Feedback
> Can you point out some "hive mind" ideologies here on HN?

I have a problem with HN voting conceptually, compared to Slashdot - on Slashdot, you were supposed not to downvote a comment that you disagree with. The purpose of upvotes and downvotes was to facilitate discussion. On HN, the policy seems to be - if you agree/disagree, upvote/downvote (although I am not sure it's official, that's what I have been told, I may have been trolled :-)).

asgard1024··on Ford Tries to Shut Down Independent Repair Tool with Copyright
> Ford was incredibly nosy into workers' lives.

Not sure about Ford, but it's the same thing with Tomas Bata, famous Czech shoemaking enterpreneur and contemporary of Ford. He is also still lauded as a progressive by some, and he was for his era (he built homes for his workers, paid them well, etc.); however, judging from the today's moral standards, we would consider him very elitist and also nosy. For instance, he put part of employee's savings into his own bank.

asgard1024··on The Performance Cost of Integer Overflow Checking
Ah well. I work on zSeries mainframes, and this architecture does support interrupts on integer overflows (as well as many other number formats). So I thought that x86 architecture already got that option too.
asgard1024··on The Performance Cost of Integer Overflow Checking
I wonder why not use interrupts for overflow checking? (Maybe x86 still doesn't support that - my knowledge of it is very old.) That seems smarter, if the overflow is really going to be an exceptional case..

I would think that the best approach is to set up a global overflow handler, driven by an interrupt, and then maybe for cases where you actually want to be able to overflow, a special C primitive (that would use instructions that avoid overflow in some way) could be useful.

I am just wondering why the article doesn't mention this possibility at all.

← PreviousPage 13 of 22Next →