HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work – And What They Do Instead
First of all, you have to understand that "state where everybody is better off" is not something that's given. Everybody can be rational and still be worse off - prisoner's dilemma is a canonical example.

Economic fallacy there is, but it's in standard economic theory. Standard economics claims that only sensible things to do are investment and consumption, and considers savings to be a waste. But the savings are not waste for individual economic entities; savings are a way of gaining power in economics.

Let me give a couple examples, consider two companies, company A which saves (has large quantities of liquid capital), the other B which doesn't (and invests everything into machinery, better production, etc.).

First example: A stealthy startup appears with a completely new ("disruptive") technology. Company B cannot buy it, so the company A is at advantage.

Second example: Workers decide to strike for higher wages. Company A can survive the long strike by taking hit on it's monetary reserves, perhaps pay strikebreakers, etc. Company B cannot do anything and have to give in to the strikers demands.

In other words, savings are a way to break out of the market system, and so people do it and race who does it better, because they want power (which comes from ability to react). Economy as a whole suffers; but why should the winning actor care?

asgard1024··on A City That Is Moving 9 Kilometers Down the Road
Reminds me of town of Most (my grandparents lived near): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Most_%28Most_District%29

Big part of Most was demolished (and a new center was built about 2-3 km away) to allow for mining, only the church was moved, which was an interesting engineering accomplishment.

asgard1024··on Python 2.x vs. 3.x use survey
Funny. I wrote a really small utility program with BeautifulSoup in Python 3. Coworker wanted to host it on AppEngine, but it supported only Python 2 for some reason. So he ported it. I am not sure what they support now, but it seems that the WoS application itself has to be in Python 2. :-)
asgard1024··on Travis CI: From Open to Minimum Vacation Policy
I would go even further and postulate that lack of rules about who is in power kills societies. Many equate "lack of rules" with "freedom", but it's a problem. People without conscience will freely abuse the lack of rules or start to fight with each other, while the good people will get screwed. Eventually, the good people, who usually just want to do the work, will get unhappy and leave.

This applies not only to vacation, but to governance as well. So called "consensual democracy", where there is no hard and fast rule about who has how much power, has the same kind of problem. The most important thing about democracy is that it is very specific - everybody has the same amount of power. That discourages political fights, because you cannot (without explicitly changing the rule) accrue more power. In my opinion, many institutions (for example Wikipedia) suffer from this problem.

asgard1024··on How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
There is a difference, though. Wegener had an alternative theory. As far as I can tell, those "skeptics" don't have any good alternative explanation (or data), just a gut feeling. So they are not at all in the same position as Wegener.

Catastrophic claims do no good, that's true. But frivolous skepticism (without a good counter-theory) has policy implications (continuing business as usual, which is unsustainable). The scientists opposing AGW are not being mass criticized for their scientific opinion (because they don't have any), but for the policies they give support to.

I also disagree with your interpretation of climate gate, but let's leave that.

asgard1024··on How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
Come on. Nobody threatens opposing viewpoints to anthropogenic global warming. Competing hypotheses even get tested, things like CLOUD or BEST come to mind. They are just really weak explanations.

If you would read history, you would actually find that AGW had similar story as Wegener theory, if anything. Until Keeling and Plass came, nobody took the Arrhenius' and Chamberlin's idea seriously. And there was even experimental evidence from Calendar.

And the same goes for Milankovitch cycles, which are one of the most important pieces of evidence for AGW.

asgard1024··on Once Celebrated in Russia, Programmer Pavel Durov Chooses Exile
It wasn't negligible in my country (Czechoslovakia), where the USSR was the model. I think almost everybody felt relief when Stalin (and Gottwald) died. Maybe Stalin didn't oppress people much after the war, but he still got the _right_ to do so, and the Durov's sentence is 100% correct.
asgard1024··on Stop Changing UIs for No Good Reason
> allows for simpler app use, particularly for new users

Are you kidding me? So called "flat design", with nondescript icons indistinguishable from the surrounding text, is the worst thing ever for new users. How am I supposed to know that I can click (er, I mean, touch) something?

asgard1024··on What It Would Really Take to Reverse Climate Change
What hiatus? This is year is on track to become globally warmest on the record, see http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/sotc/global/
asgard1024··on What It Would Really Take to Reverse Climate Change
What is convincing evidence? Many prominent environmentalists consider the climate change to be the biggest problem. Even Mr. Lomborg eventually accepted that conclusion.
asgard1024··on What It Would Really Take to Reverse Climate Change
First of all, I am basing that on this article: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/global-warmings-te...

Now, this article implies that we need to leave some coal and oil in the groud, even if it's economic to mine and use it up. My main concern is I don't think that markets can handle this task. Markets are great at exploiting all available resources; but how do you constrain them not to do that? You cannot set any price on a resource that you do not want to use at all. In a way though, yes, it's about externalities.

asgard1024··on What It Would Really Take to Reverse Climate Change
Well, yeah, I was a bit hyperbolic. Linux also isn't entirely "free" - you have to spent effort configuring it and so on. But I just don't see renewables competing with oil and coal on the fair free market.
asgard1024··on EIZO Announces Monitor with 1920x1920 Resolution
Great to see that! I am only worried this will be ultra-expensive based on the assumption that people who actually want to do some real work on a computer (and not just play games or watch movies) do it for money, so they can pay the price.
asgard1024··on What It Would Really Take to Reverse Climate Change
I think main driver of why people deny climate change is that the market mechanism cannot deal with that situation. So if someone is a firm believer in market solutions to everything, the climate change reality is a tough attack on that personal belief.
asgard1024··on What It Would Really Take to Reverse Climate Change
I am not sure how they envision renewable energy (that just barely collects solar power) ever competing on the market with coal and oil that's just sitting there waiting to be picked up (that accumulated solar power for thousands years).

It's like trying to write new commercial Unix-like operating system, and expect profit, when the companies can already use Linux which is already there and into which the investment has been made.

The problem is that we really need to leave that coal and oil in the ground, and not touch it (at least for a couple hundred years), and there is no way markets alone can do that. Even price regulations like carbon tax may not accomplish that goal.

asgard1024··on Please grow your buffers exponentially
While I agree with the gist of the article, is the recommendation to use powers of 2 as the size correct? Every allocator adds a small overhead to the size, so one could be better off by using sizes like 2^n - 16 or so..
asgard1024··on The First Browser Dedicated to Developers Is Coming
They should fix the URL bar. When I used a webserver on local network, the URLs got constantly mangled.
asgard1024··on How My Employer Put the “FML” in FMLA
Why not? Sometimes people desperately organize boycotts of institutions that they want to behave, but it never succeeds, because everyone needs at least one of the institutions (for example, everybody needs to be employed).

I think maybe there could be a lottery and people could collectively agree and randomly single out one actor and boycott it for some time. That would force at least that one actor to care and enforce competition. Who cares about fairness, if everybody is guilty?

asgard1024··on YouTube Ready to Eliminate Ads [video]
I normally don't mind ads, especially if they are well done, but what is really annoying is that most Czech ads are unreasonably loud. I really have to skip those, because it tears my ears through headphones, even though I usually wouldn't skip.
asgard1024··on MLB, Homeland Security, and the Undercover Underwear Sting
I think you're right, the US culture indeed favors these unfortunate developments. The 2nd amendment is a misguided idea.

I had an argument with Czech expat living in the US, who was a staunch libertarian. At one point he was "either I have my freedoms, or I will defend myself with the gun". I told him that there is no need for guns, we can also have a peaceful discussion and agree on compromise that everybody will hate. Couldn't explain value of that..

And Americans can change this culture. Respect to rights of others doesn't come from "natural rights" or "republic", but from cooperation among people. Respect to individuals doesn't come from having guns, but rather determination to face guns (or other problems) without having any.

(It doesn't mean that guns are never necessary. It only means that it's often much less hassle and blood to make opponent part of your in-group rather than have fight with him as your out-group.)

asgard1024··on The Misfortunes of a Trio of Mathematicians Using Computer Algebra Systems [pdf]
I just read your blogpost about Sage mentioned above, and it made me a little sad (I actually expected it to be optimistic). I think it smells of burnout, and you should perhaps take a break. You certainly deserve it!

It's not your fault that economic resources in human societies are hugely misallocated, and that social progress is always painfully slow.

asgard1024··on I � Unicode [pdf]
Unicode kinda jumped the shark with all the emoji.. they might as well encode all frequent words/meanings.

Though I like them. The only emoticon(s) I always miss is for one "shrug", something like either "I don't know" or "I don't care".

asgard1024··on Who’s Collecting Kids’ Personal Data? Lots of People
Because we are humans, and care about our children? I don't have kids, but I suppose we will both understand this when we have one.

Children are an excellent argument. Many revolutions started because students were beaten by the police (or sent to war), and it made their parents angry. Children are other people in the world we care about the most, and only by caring about other people a just society can exist. So take it as a road to privacy regulations.

I wish engineers understood this better, and wouldn't shy from doing the same. The argument "think about the children" is often invoked by conservatives in support of authoritarian policies, but there is no reason why it can't be an argument for democratic and liberal positions.

asgard1024··on The Emacs Commune (2002)
I agree with most of what you said, although I wouldn't call Stallman a "strategist". He is an idealist who is unwilling to do moral compromises (which has positives and negatives).

As an aside, his "political notes" are a great news aggregator for anyone who cares about the world.

asgard1024··on The Labors of Leisure
> I wonder if "work" hours are not shorter because culture dictates it, so many people shift their habits to surf the web (i.e. leisure activities) while at work.

I think you're right and this is similar to what David Graeber wrote somewhere. In former communist countries, the working class people actually had more leisure at work, except they had to pretend they don't. This was probably part of the reason why these systems were so economically inefficient, compared to first world countries.

asgard1024··on Y U NO commit??
I think HN would do well with having a single sentence abstract on article submissions, because I have no idea what is this about.
asgard1024··on Some thoughts on asking for a raise
The problem I see with the article is that it focuses on rationality of monetary payment and ignores wider perspective of human thinking, which includes fairness, for example.

I never had to ask for raise at my job (for several years), but with the change of my boss, it looks like I will have to. I'm actually pretty happy with the money; what I more concerned about is the feeling of being treated unfairly.

My boss, unlike me, has all the information, so he can decide to treat people around him fairly. If he does not, and makes these decisions based on what people ask him, then he is certainly not being fair. Then, why on Earth should I want to work for a person like that? Doesn't that kill motivation too?

In other words, what's wrong with wanting to stay humble about your work (there are many articles that ask engineers to be exactly that, and it's certainly a great characteristic for a coworker), but at the same time, demand fair treatment?

asgard1024··on Distributed is not necessarily more scalable than centralized
I think you missed the point. The big question is, what is "one computer"? It surely isn't just one atom (one point in space). Is something running on a CPU with several ALUs a distributed system? Is something running on a multicore server a distributed system?

So it seems, distributed systems are not defined in terms of spatial or logical distribution of "stuff being done" (because everything is distributed in this sense), but rather by assumption of (un)reliability of the links between the components, and the choice of components. And this may depend on your vantage point, too.

So if that reliability is good enough, you don't need theory of distributed systems, and it all makes the system more efficient. In that sense, Dropbox is more efficient than P2P solution because you have hidden assumption (from the user perspective) that Dropbox servers will always be available.

Edit: Also reliability of components plays a role. Thinking about it more, it really seems to be a question of hierarchy. Distributed systems are less hierarchical than the centralized counterparts; there are less bottlenecks (that may fail) but more coordination required. So the OP is basically arguing that some hierarchy scales better than no hierarchy.

asgard1024··on Scenes from Google Street View
Definitely in Czechia, looks like http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Trinecke_zelezarny_Q1...
asgard1024··on The Curse of Increasing Marginal Work Utility, or Why I Work So Much
My company (rather big american software house) doesn't encourage me to work very hard. The harder I work, the more of my coworkers will be let go, but the software will still suck the same. The customers will pay the same. The competition adopts a similar strategy.
← PreviousPage 14 of 22Next →