HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on Solar sends energy prices below zero in middle of day
> However, the demand is nowhere near as volatile as the supply can be, and you can't keep power as inventory, so it's anyones guess how this all plays out. Certainly we can't become reliant on solar/wind supply as this would be disastrous.

This is bullshit. Our civilization has done this for thousands of years, in a different area - food. This is just a return to different mode of operation with regards to energy, but it's not really economically impossible.

asgard1024··on The biggest thing with small patches (2004)
I think, to some extent, Linus cultivates this image himself. Reminds me of Richard Feynman threads here on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8030010

Someone commented (not sure it was on HN) that Feynman also cultivated a different, more "rough", image in public than he actually was in the real life.

asgard1024··on Microsoft gears up to mass produce large-screen touch displays
Touch display? Nah, don't need it. But it would be nice if someone made a cheap netbook with a display of similar resolution that tablets have.
asgard1024··on Is De-Skilling Killing Arts Education?
Maybe it's unrelated, but I have a real beef with modern flat UI design and icons.

For worst examples, look up the modern Microsoft production, such as VS 2012 or Lync 2013. Is the future really that ugly?

These just seems to me, compared to old, nice colorful icons, as drawings of 6-year olds. I can't shave off the feeling that they are just cheap. Or maybe it's the consequence of de-skilling the article is writing about?

asgard1024··on The Expanding World of Poverty Capitalism
> The original definition was prior to that, first used by Anne-Robert-Jacques Turgot in a positive, anti-feudalist sense.

I think you're wrong. I looked around the Internet and it really seems that the word "capitalism" originated from "capitalist", first used by Marx in Communist Manifesto.

See e.g. https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=1005122700456

(I would be interested to see exact quote from Turgot, that uses the word.)

What you describe was called "economic freedom" or "economic liberalism". And I already said that, when I mentioned "free market". Markets obviously are prerequisite for capitalism, but they don't have to be free in this sense.

asgard1024··on The Expanding World of Poverty Capitalism
So what's your definition of capitalism?

I think the original definition originated sometime in the 19th century, probably from Marx, and it meant the actual, real world system (this is different from communism, which designated an ideal).

I always understood it as an economic system based on two characteristics:

1. Private ownership of capital.

2. Labor as a market commodity.

I think these two aptly describe both 19th century and current economic systems, and I don't think this implies anything about symbiosis (or lack of thereof) between government and business.

Addendum: Maybe you mean free market, which, in my view, is a different thing. At least because it, like communism, describes an ideal, not an factually existing system (I am not aware of sufficiently closed economic system which could be considered to be a free market).

asgard1024··on Lesson from Old India: When an Economy Just Doesn’t Get Better
I think he meant a real-world example. You gave him works of fiction. :-)
asgard1024··on Lesson from Old India: When an Economy Just Doesn’t Get Better
I wonder, to what extent was this about labor costs? Wasn't it higher price of labor in the west that forced it to industrialize more than India? Perhaps India got stuck in a local optimum, with low wages.

A similar situation may be happening today. Due to automation, there is not enough jobs for everybody, which may decrease the cost of labor, slowing down pressure on technological development.

asgard1024··on New Minecraft Mod Teaches You Code as You Play
Again, I actually find frames both more useful and more fun. In my final days of 1.2.5 world (which was more or less with RP2 as only tech mod), I had total 3 vehicles of my own design: http://integratedredstone.wikispaces.com/6-directional+Movin...

One was used for mining, other for paving, and third had attached two 7x5x7 trailers, one was mobile house with basic facilities and the other was mobile Thaumcraft 2 lab.

But most things can be automated quite easily with frames, and I find it more intuitive - you just look at it and see what it does when it's done.

I also later designed a fully programmable factory using RP2, Buildcraft crafting table and a conveyor belt.

I am glad to hear that Eloraam started working on RP again. I hope I will be able to design von Neumann machine in RP, eventually (that's my ultimate goal, but there are several blocks still missing in RP, so it's not yet doable). At the very least, next time I play I want to have a full base on a moving platform (may be of several independent "trucks"), so I could easily move all stuff I have somewhere else in the world. :-)

asgard1024··on New Minecraft Mod Teaches You Code as You Play
Yes, that's what most people tend to use for programming these days.

Although I personally have never enjoyed it as much as the famous Redpower 2 mod, which had computers as well, with 6502 assembler and Forth. It was less forgiving than Lua, but somehow more fitting the genre (of construction set, that is); programming in Lua feels almost like you could program the thing in Java and put it in a new block.

I also liked the logic gates and other stuff that came with RP2, I think that's good for kids to play with as well. Too bad Eloraam stopped developing RP2, it was the best mod for Minecraft ever.

(Also, CC computers seem to reset on world reload, while RP2 computers were persistent. They are also dirt cheap compared to RP2, and their runtime behavior is not well specified. I just kinda feel that CC computers break the fourth wall of the virtual world, in several different ways..)

asgard1024··on Project Euler Returns
I wonder if the people behind Project Euler have names or it has all been done by this prolific guy Bourbaki?
asgard1024··on Artificial music: Computers that create melodies
Still, you agree that the piece of computer music can be "interesting and worthwhile", so you already accepted it.

I don't feel like you, I don't care where the good music comes from. But I agree what we consider of quality depends quite heavily on our subjective experiences.

However, I feel similarly about theater and movies. If you want just to see a piece of storytelling, you will be more satisfied with a movie. But if acting is the part of the experience for you, then you're probably more interested in theater, where people do it live.

Actually, now that I think of it, we could compare it to live performance of musical works. Again, some people enjoy the effort of the musicians, and consider it to be a part of the work, but most don't care too much if the piece is recorded.

So perhaps this is a really old debate of whether the means or the end is more important in art.

Based on this analogy, I would predict that in the future, most people will listen to computer generated music, and music composed by actual humans will become comparatively rare.

asgard1024··on A Room Where Executives Go to Get Help from IBM’s Watson
Coming from IBM, I am sure it is green. :-)
asgard1024··on Things Political Scientists Know (2010) [pdf]
I really didn't - I wrote "intelectual-elitist". It's their choice to have disgusting opinions. Perhaps I am too cynical, I have been reading too much Chomsky lately. :-)

Edit: Let me give you a Chomsky quote:

"Actually, I should say, the term "manufacturing consent" is not mine, I took it from Walter Lippmann, the leading public intellectual and leading media figure of the twentieth century, who thought it was a great idea. He said we should manufacture consent, that's the way democracies should work. There should be a small group of powerful people, and the rest of the population should be spectators, and you should force them to consent by controlling, regimenting their minds. That's the leading idea of democratic theorists, and the public relations industry and so on, so I'm not making it up. In fact, I'm just borrowing their conception, and telling other people what they think."

This is what the paper appears to be advocating, as well.

asgard1024··on Things Political Scientists Know (2010) [pdf]
This seems to me as a "standard" intelectual-elitist paper which tries to insinuate that democracy, where people really decide the issues, cannot work. I haven't read it very deeply but the fact that he quotes Walter Lippmann says that lot.

Also, I think he misrepresents Arrow's theorem. First of all, it applies only to ordering of preferences; if you allow preferences to be number from interval, such as range voting does, there is no problem. Second, the non-dictatorship criterion is a bit disingenuous, because who is dictator depends on their own preferences - just like majority vote is not "dictatorship of the majority".

asgard1024··on Sweden just claimed the world’s second-largest Wikipedia
I agree with your point. It's generally better to have some article that no article. But Wikipedia is also supposed to be readable by humans, to provide insight and understanding. I am not sure that mere formatted collection of data, as opposed to a real article, does that. And I believe there are many Wikipedia editors who feel the same.

Though, wouldn't it be more efficient to put the data into some machine readable form, if they were already processed by the machines anyway? This would then allow anybody to create algorithm to extract information (meaning) from the data.

So I think there are also good reasons to keep the human and machine created articles separate.

asgard1024··on Sweden just claimed the world’s second-largest Wikipedia
This article poses a real question whether computer generated articles are suitable for encyclopedia consumed by humans.

Speaking of this, I would love to see Wikipedia in machine-readable language. Something like CYC project.

Edit: I know of WikiData, but there should be an unstructured analog to that.

asgard1024··on When Workers Own Their Companies, Everyone Wins
Yes, that's a big problem. The owners of capital want to have a say about what the company does, because their money are at stake.

Perhaps this is just a cultural thing though. Take money lending - although a bank gives capital to someone else in exchange for profit, it doesn't require strict controls over the actual use of the money; it relies on contract law to get the money back.

Similarly, the executives of the publicly traded companies have responsibility to shareholders. Perhaps a similar agreement could be institutionalized with the coops too (yet preserve their democratic nature).

asgard1024··on Reanimating Bertha, a Mechanical Behemoth Slumbering Under Seattle
> is going to make traffic worse

Is it? According to some, making more lanes makes traffic worse, according to some others, making less lanes makes traffic worse, so which is it? Can you ever make traffic less worse?

asgard1024··on Why blurring sensitive information is a bad idea (2007)
I can imagine you can computationally unblur mosaic on video, if the object (e.g. face) is not changing, just the camera is moving around a little.
asgard1024··on The Stanford Prison Experiment was flawed
I have the book Obedience from Milgram at home, although I just skimmed through it. I think the situation is similar, Zimbardo would probably do more experiments as well weren't the first result so horrific.

What I am a bit worried of is that we are not able to replicate (because of the ethical problems), in one way or another, results of these studies. How can future generations become educated about these problems? Especially if we cast doubt over their results. Are our descendants doomed to figure out these things the hard way?

asgard1024··on The Stanford Prison Experiment was flawed
Can someone explain why is SPE not relevant to Abu Ghraib? While you can argue the experiment was flawed, I am not sure its results are.

I am asking myself, if all the outrage about the SPE (and also Milgram) experiments being unethical (or flawed) isn't really about something that we don't want to really know about human nature.

asgard1024··on A Conversation with Edward Snowden at HOPE X [video]
He explained that once in an interview - basically, for public communication, there is no reason for him to care, so he uses whatever suits the other party the best.
asgard1024··on Keeping employees from discussing their salaries is illegal
Here's an idea for people who don't like the current social norm, but I am not brave enough to go with it (someone will probably find a good reason why it is not a good idea):

Publish your own salary unilaterally, on your blog or FB page. Don't worry about others.

If anyone complains, there are several arguments you can make:

- It's your money, you can spend them publicly, you can count them publicly.

- If the company pays you competitively, they should be proud. If they aren't proud, that's obvious sign they don't pay you competitively.

- Any threat will reflect on your salary, which is made public. Is it a good way to treat an employee?

- If you want to compromise, you can say you give certain percentage of your salary to charity and publish the amount. Then technically, you didn't publish your salary. And again, any reaction from the employer will reflect negatively on them (because it will reduce the amount you put to charity).

I believe, if someone does that, there will be good people in the same company that will be willing to privately tell him how is he standing. And if enough people do this, they can change the social norm eventually.

asgard1024··on A detailed exposé on how the market is rigged from a data-centric approach
I am not a game theorist, but take Centipede game for instance. If you know the exact number of rounds in advance, the optimal strategy is markedly different than if you don't know it. And I think there are many weird behaviors like that in iterated games, where optimal solution for infinite time horizon is not the same (or doesn't even exist) as the limit of optimal solutions for finite horizons approaching infinity.
asgard1024··on UN: Nations hide rise in private digital snooping
I think (and I implied) that non-violence is a necessary, not sufficient condition for non-shooting.

And I haven't frankly seen much evidence that 2nd amendment is effective deterrent. First, it's a bit of a fantasy - in the U.S., you hardly see gun owners among the revolutionaries. For a good reason - it's a bit naive to expect people go with handguns against tanks or drones. And U.S. government seems pretty oppressive compared to many countries which don't have equivalent of 2nd amendment.

Second, most people consider violent revolutionaries to be terrorists (e.g. compare how we view Unabomber and Martin Luther King), which actually supports the theory. The same is actually true in islamic countries - for example here: http://www.pewglobal.org/2014/07/01/concerns-about-islamic-e...

asgard1024··on UN: Nations hide rise in private digital snooping
It has been shown (for example in Altemeyer's research on authoritarianism) that violence increases authoritarian tendencies among population, while violent attacks against nonviolence decrease those tendencies.

This is where American Founding Fathers got it wrong, with the 2nd amendment. The reason why soldiers refuse to shoot against citizens is because they are unarmed and have moral upper hand. Once that happens, the powerful people have to give up, because they themselves can only rely on other people to stay in power.

asgard1024··on A detailed exposé on how the market is rigged from a data-centric approach
> If you want a reasonably efficient market, you need some participants to have close to perfect information.

Is this proven somewhere or you just assume the optimal strategy for markets is continuous?

I mean, it's not clear that the optimal strategy for "slightly imperfect markets" is at all close to the optimal strategy for markets with perfect information. And I actually doubt it can be proven, in the general case.

asgard1024··on Usable Live Programming
I am not sure how is that going to scale for bigger programs. In simple cases, I can model behavior of the program in my head, in more complicated cases, without aggregation, there will be too much data to make sense of it anyway. I think the aggregation of the statistical data is the crucial thing here.

Anyway, good that someone is playing with this.

asgard1024··on Usable Live Programming
I am not a big fan of "immediate feedback" in coding (such as instant compilation). I find it distracting.

What I think I would appreciate more than "live" values of variables etc. would be integration of some statistics into IDE. For example, how often was this function called? What is the usual value of this parameter? What is the mean/modus value? What are the outliers? How often was this condition true? And so on.

← PreviousPage 15 of 22Next →