HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on The Case Against the Universal Basic Income
I propose a mechanism of free market being the wrong model of reality. ;-)

Some people are simply greedy and they will pay less at the expense of having less capable employees. These people will "poison the well", so to speak, for other market participants who actually wouldn't actually mind to pay higher wages. And as was eloquently put by Keynes - "Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent". In short, asymmetric information is the key problem of free markets.

asgard1024··on Corporations and OSS Do Not Mix
What you propose is a free market solution - make property out of it. (And I don't think free market is actually desirable for most people but that's for another debate.)

From a practical point of view, it's complicated to dual license their code to the employer. If the employer refuses to license it, then the employee has to find the job which lets him license it (if he wishes to use it). That may be difficult.

In other words, if you have software as property, the idea "I want to work on the same code base in the future for a living" may contradict with someone else's idea "I am paying for it therefore you do what I want". In theoretical free market this should work out, but in reality there is a lot of frictions.

asgard1024··on Corporations and OSS Do Not Mix
I guess you're right, that's a big loophole. In any case, I actually don't like trade secrets either. If anything, they are completely against the logic of free market (free choice).
asgard1024··on Corporations and OSS Do Not Mix
Most software corporations are actually wary about LGPL more than BSD. There is a valid reason, at the same time, it may be interpreted as trying to screw LGPL choice.

Yeah you can use LGPL software, but with libraries and stuff that can be incorporated into the product, it's tricky.

I think it's a hard problem because you cannot really fault developers for not wanting to change the world (in a fashion similar to what RMS did). So they accept wrong moral choice for the same reason most people accept wrong moral choice, that is, the right moral choice is a lot of work (and sometimes even risk).

asgard1024··on Corporations and OSS Do Not Mix
Well, in arts, OK, you can make some case for it. But I don't see why the plumber should need to have copyright for his "piping design" in my house.. The same is true for programmers, you would simply be hired to fix some problem (or build a complicated pipeline).
asgard1024··on Corporations and OSS Do Not Mix
I upvoted you, and I agree. However, as a professional developer, it is nice to be able to use OSS at work because you are sure it will always be available.

Therefore developers who release things under BSD license have a very good incentive - they want to use the thing they wrote (as a hobby) at work, yet they want to continue to use it even if they change jobs. I think this is actually a primary reason why BSD is favored by some developers.

I don't think there is an easy solution to this, at least as long as "intellectual property" exists. However abolishing IP would be digital communism and many people are for whatever reason adverse to that idea.

asgard1024··on Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership
Yes, but it is also kind of trivial. I mean isn't this philosophy something that every agent ultimately follows?

I would like to see an example that would be useful to classify social systems, as ctlby attempted to do. But I don't see it. Once you put "social system" into it, killing happens for collectivist reason.

asgard1024··on Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership
> Now you argue that killing another human being for philosophical reasons is always collectivist according to your [asgard1024's] definition. That does nothing whatsoever to make the quoted statement true.

What I said is true of (almost) any definition of "collectivist", including ctlby's.

> You dismiss any possibility that such a person is following an inexpressed philosophy.

Yes, because any inexpressed philosophies were not subject of the discussion; we can't assign killings due to inexpressed philosophies to any philosophy, since we don't know which one.

I mean, show me one non-collectivist philosophy according to which is OK to kill human (except in unavoidable self-defense). There is no such thing - all of them are collectivist.

asgard1024··on Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership
OK, consider this. Every (moral) philosophy exists to motivate other people, as a code to follow (if it didn't you wouldn't have reason to tell anyone!). This means there is a group, or a collective, which supposedly holds these values and is to be protected. If fulfilling this philosophy (or its protection) requires killing other humans, then this is (ostensibly) done in the interest of the group.

In other words, if someone is killing for individual reasons, he is not following any philosophy, because he doesn't need any; he's just crazy or psychopath. Killing for philosophical reasons always happens to protect some social order (albeit sometimes fictional).

If you don't agree, there is a simple solution. Just provide an example of philosophy that causes killing of people and is not in fact collectivist (by any definition you choose, it doesn't matter very much, and that's why I was able to do the bold claim I did).

Or to put it even simpler, it's contradictory to kill another human to fulfil any philosophy of individual freedom.

Hitler killed because he wanted to protect Germans from Jews, Pinochet killed because communists were danger to his social order, and so on. Even Winston Smith from 1984 was willing to kill in order to replace the social system (which is the passage in the book I really like, because it's one of the places that makes it actually morally ambiguous, just like real world).

asgard1024··on Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership
> So if 1990s Russia and Pinochet's Chile are examples of extreme free market experiments

You're confused. They're examples of free market experiments, however the Pinochet's deaths had nothing to do with the free market and all with his political power.

If you want to see deaths caused by free market, look at e.g. homeless people who freeze on the street during winter.

asgard1024··on Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership
You have presented a logical tautology. Killing another human being is always collectivist according to your definition.

However, that doesn't say anything about validity of ideas of free market or communism. What does say a lot though is that some free market proponents have the need to advocate Pinochet.

asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
OK, I'll bite.

Most girls/women have a very sensitive detector of social status or it's various proxies, because that's what they sexually select for. (It's kind of similar to how boys/men are attuned to detect physically attractive women.) And many of them are quite self-aware and honest about this capability, and they will confirm that having money is related power and status. Some will even openly admit that they're attracted to wealthy and powerful people.

So I was merely suggesting, if the GP doesn't personally believe there is a strong connection, he should find a honest girl and ask her, she will probably confirm that, it shouldn't be too hard. (Actually, Piketty makes a similar point indirectly by quoting various Jane Austen's works, where people are just obsessed with the question how to marry to wealth).

To clarify, it doesn't mean that men don't want to gain social status; men can do the detection too of course, but it's less of a concern for them, so they're probably less skilled at it (they are interested only indirectly).

Of course, this is not even remotely sexist, because I am not talking about anyone's preferences to begin with. But I was worried that explaining my point could cause derail of the discussion (not necessarily by you).

asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
> these are probably the biggest (in terms of $) examples of rent seeking in the US

LOL. You forgot big banks and "too big to fail", military-industrial complex and all the wars.. Your examples are peanuts compared to these.

asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
> could you explain

No. I am not in a mood to receive a false accusation of sexism.

asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
> I disagree. As long as you're referring to a non-coerced transaction

If both parties receive the benefit, obviously you can still model that as power exchange where both parties apply their power to the other party. Just like physical forces on an object can be nonzero and yet it stays still. It actually seems like smoother model of social interaction than all the kerfuffle around coercion, but I haven't thought about it in depth.

In reality though, there exist many coerced transactions. For example, I need to eat, and that's why I go to work. I am being coerced by nature. But maybe someone thinks it's better to die in freedom from hunger than to live under coercion with full stomach.

Regarding "political power". What is that? I don't see significant boundary between "political" and "economic" power, but rather smooth transition. Therefore, to me power is power regardless of the social domain where it manifests.

asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
> Other things being equal, a high inequality society is going to be less happy than a society with moderate inequality.

This is actually empirically true, someone recently mentioned the book The Spirit Level in another HN discussion about equality, this book shows that on some metrics like social issues.

asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
It's not really a subset, it's more like an intersection.

But to your example - I will be long time happy with social (in)equality before we get to 1% differences in income. I think in your example Joe absolutely deserves the unhappiness he has.

Meanwhile in reality, when I suggest that maybe there should be a limit of personal income/wealth like around 100x the average (which is amount of money I can't imagine reasonable person would know how to spend), I get shooed as crazy pinko full of envy. Yet, is that really envy, or is it just longing for fairness as in the ultimatum game example?

asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
You're correct (that's why on second thought I put "evolutionary" in parens), but I also argue that ability to deny bad offers (or revolt or whatever are the various forms this takes) is a good trait for people to have. Otherwise you are getting uncomfortably close to a Brave New World of always obedient individuals.
asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
I think the above explanation I made with ultimatum game may provide some insight. People have a notion of fairness, which is more subtle; they don't just want to force everyone on the same level.
asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
> This used to be called "envy", and seen as a vice to be avoided.

There are two sides to the coin. What you call "envy" has a very good (evolutionary) reason for its existence.

Take a look at ultimatum game (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimatum_game). If people didn't have capacity to deny unfair splits, even though they seem irrational, then they would be worse off.

I posit that denying unfair splits in ultimatum game is envy. Think about it, envy is the reason to do it - the other party doesn't deserve the bigger split, so let's kill it for both! The similar game can be for instance used as a model of worker's strike against a capitalist.

(I think in fact most people consider envy a vice only where it's extreme or there are other circumstances that make it unfair. But in general it's just an expression of longing for fairness.)

asgard1024··on Income Inequality: Empirical View
Why not, but how? No matter how you want to dance about it, money are strongly related to power. (To most girls this is probably obvious. :-))

It's not just literally true - you can exchange money for raw materials and energy (power), but every time you give money to someone else to do your bidding, you are exercising power over them.

The only time this power is not really being exercised (as in "power over other people") is when you're spending for your own pleasure, buying things like a new car or a spa visit. Investing money is almost always exercising power, depending how much and with what intent you will affect future of others. For example, you can buy a newspaper company to make good PR about you.

So to be able to "destroy the power", in capitalist society, you would have to very tightly control how people spend money. This is not only fiendishly difficult, but also undesirable from a free market perspective.

Reducing inequality is a much simpler way to remove power from too powerful people, because it simply gives more power to other people. And there is in fact not much need to be wealthy in the first place, unless you can have associated power - there is only so much cars one person needs.

asgard1024··on Confessions of a Right-Wing Liberal (1968)
Actually, I think I understand your position lot better now. :-)

> The comparison with theology is weird, considering that theology is based on the premise of revealed knowledge about the world.

Every book on libertarianism I have seen was lot more interested in some sort of ultimate, axiomatic moral truth, rather than empirical evidence that libertarianism works (by whatever criteria) in the real world. Ayn Rand with her fiction is probably the best example, but Rothbard is IIRC not much better. Heaps of theory and little evidence.

> Namely, that being libertarian is somehow contrary to helping others.

I think I finally understand what you're really saying. You basically think that helping others (say, economically) is something that shouldn't be enforced by society. I can see why people (including me) can wrongly interpret that as being against helping itself.

It seems kind of similar to moral view that we have in the West regarding adultery. Most of us find it immoral, but we don't agree it should be punished by law, or that there should be deliberate obstacles put in place in order to prevent it happening (such as separation of men and women). And here too, this can be interpreted by say, religious fundamentalists, that this view supports adultery.

(Originally, I thought you just think that not-helping others shouldn't be punished, but that's a weaker proposition that still doesn't explain why are you against say, taxes.)

I don't think though society can even exist in such framework. I pretty much agree with what wfo wrote you above. Seriously, some empirical evidence for your position would help. It may even be in a form of computer simulation.

asgard1024··on There’s No Escaping Competition: People Need a Way to Decide Who Gets What
I have seen it in market for Asus EEE PCs with Linux. There was a demand here in Czech Republic but Asus was not interested (it wanted to push Windows to the market). It had nothing to do with Linux being not in demand (the laptops were underpowered to run latest Windows), nor with U.S. antitrust laws; and everything with the fact that Asus preinstalls Windows on its other laptops.

You simply don't want to believe these things happen. But if you pay attention, you can see lot of incidental evidence that it happens. But there is always plausible deniability, it's never done too overtly.

> I never said that no one would ever try to "abuse" the consumer

Companies are selected for abusive behavior by evolutionary pressure. No person or company is really interested in being in competition (if survival really depends on it); everybody runs as fast (and as creatively) as they can to avoid it and reap maximal profits. It can be shown on rather simple multi-agent simulations.

I am not sure what leads so many people to conclusion that companies like MS or HP - which can build freaking computers and operating systems - cannot figure out a simple fact that in some cases acting together against consumer interests will in fact increase their profits.

asgard1024··on 'Escape Rooms' Challenge Players To Solve Puzzles To Get Out
Actually you don't have to be member or insider of any particular social group to attend most of them. It's really just register, send the money and you can go.

Regarding terminology, I struggled with that too, to explain to my american coworkers. I think "puzzle hunt" is probably the best translation of Czech original term "šifrovačka" or "šifrovací hra" (which would precisely mean "cipher game"). I have never participated in a scavenger hunt but my understanding is that it's a slightly different game.

asgard1024··on Economics Can’t Answer Why Inequality Sometimes Declines
> It reduces inequality between people, such as an American auto worker and a Chinese auto worker.

Between some people yes. But here's the big problem; we know the causal force for this "inequality reduction", and it's not that someone wanted to make Chinese or Mexican workers richer (or that they would get better at demanding better pay). The causal force was that capitalists in the U.S. and small group of people outside the U.S. (usually people in power in developing countries, like members of the Chinese communist party) wanted to get richer at expense of everybody else.

Based on this known causal force, there is no reason to think that capitalism itself causes more equality. (And in fact, globalization has been shown to counteract ability of countries to compete, see for example book Kicking Away the Ladder from Ha-Joon Chang, who is korean. Countries that depend on internal demand and supply rather than foreign investment and exports tend to fare much better in closing the economic gap with respect to developed world.)

asgard1024··on Economics Can’t Answer Why Inequality Sometimes Declines
> globalization drastically reduces inequality

Maybe it reduces inequality between countries, but does it reduce inequality between people (different social classes within countries)?

> some people (e.g. American auto workers) held extremely privileged positions by virtue of threats of violence against economic competitors - particularly those overseas

Really? I thought they produced cars mainly for the internal market.. I don't see much evidence of any "threats of violence" coming from auto workers to the rest of the world.

To make myself more clear, I am willing to accept the globalization (or capitalism) reducing inequality globally as a positive thing, if it wouldn't increase inequality inside the developed countries. But that's not what really happened (profits of Western corporations are all-time high) and that's why it's a cause for concern.

asgard1024··on 'Escape Rooms' Challenge Players To Solve Puzzles To Get Out
I am not aware of any, unfortunately. NotOscarWilde above described it correctly, IMHO.
asgard1024··on Multithreaded toolkits: A failed dream? (2004)
If the CPU bottleneck is on the store, maybe you need some sort of transactional store, where the change is signalled to the views only after a transaction completes? Just thinking out loud.

I am not sure what exactly is the original author trying to solve here. But it seems to me that if you want to expand the single GUI thread to multiple threads, for whatever reason, flux and/or FRP may be a good start.

asgard1024··on Multithreaded toolkits: A failed dream? (2004)
I thought than in flux, the worker thread could send "push button" message to the dispatcher and it will deal with it asynchronously. Likewise, the updates to the views are asynchronous (and can be potentially multi-threaded) to the actions that are coming into the dispatcher queue.
asgard1024··on Multithreaded toolkits: A failed dream? (2004)
What about functional reactive programming? And what about flux pattern? Didn't these resolve this "failed dream" of multi-threaded GUI update? (I am asking real, not rhetorical, questions.)
← PreviousPage 3 of 22Next →