HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

asgard1024

1,234 karma · joined July 27, 2013

submissionscomments
asgard1024··on Jeff Bezos Says Amazon Won’t Tolerate ‘Callous’ Management Practices
> Just about every human endeavor out there tends toward hierarchal structures

I agree, but why? It doesn't make much sense to me. Although I should have said "authoritarian" rather than "hierarchical".

> it's questioned whether all that's happened is that the hierarchy is implicit rather than explicit

In democracy, you can have hierarchy but it's not a big deal, because you have a formal rule that everybody has the same power (one vote). It is certainly different (although for some reason many people do not feel that way) than when there is no such rule.

asgard1024··on Jeff Bezos Says Amazon Won’t Tolerate ‘Callous’ Management Practices
Perhaps better would be if I said "authoritarian" rather than "hierarchical". I don't think democracy requires lack of hierarchy. Or take the development of Linux kernel - although hierarchical, everybody has the same power.

And it can scale quite well. Switzerland and Mondragon are good examples.

asgard1024··on An Argument for P=NP (2005) [pdf]
I wonder, is there a relationship between P!=NP and Hilbert's 10th problem? It seems to me that P!=NP is pretty much saying that integer solutions for certain class of polynomials are easy to check (once you have them) but hard to describe as a set (there isn't always a representation with the polynomial algorithm), but I don't know how to put it formally.
asgard1024··on Jeff Bezos Says Amazon Won’t Tolerate ‘Callous’ Management Practices
What a revolutionary idea!

Seriously though, I wonder why humans tolerate the hierarchical structures so much. I am proponent of direct democracy and worker cooperatives but curiously enough, to many people the idea seems wrong.

asgard1024··on What are the 10 most harmful jobs?
> Why don't we start at the IPCC?

Here are some analyses: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/05/hansen... http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2013/02/2012-u... http://www.skepticalscience.com/lindzen-illusion-2-lindzen-v...

Current climate models are pretty accurate in their predictions.

> Which isn't surprising at all, given no one has been able to show a working model of Earth.

I am not sure, at this point, if you are just trolling. Every model has a certain limits, but it doesn't mean it is "not working". If you actually knew history (I always recommend https://www.aip.org/history/climate/index.htm) it is a remarkable achievement that we can model climate at all.

> There's no way you can know that. CO2 may be completely dominated by other factors.

Sorry, this is just trolling. Of course, in the same sense, we cannot predict the path of the Earth around the Sun because what if an unknown dominating factor comes to its path?

When creating a model, we simply try to account for every important factor we know of. And given that the predictions are quite accurate (look at Lindzen comparison!), we probably know of all the important ones.

asgard1024··on Ask HN: What would you want in an ideal web browser?
I would like an ability to snapshot save the web page, with all the dynamically loaded stuff (content, JS, Flash..). Just like some emulator systems have.
asgard1024··on What are the 10 most harmful jobs?
> Well, sure, what we've measured isn't anything like what we predicted.

You still didn't answer the question, what exactly model you refer to?

Even if you look at work of Plass in 1950s, you will find very close estimates to climate sensitivity that we have today. And that's just from simple equilibrium models that include water vapor (his model is in fact wrong in several ways that pretty much cancel out).

In fact, no one has been able to show a working model of Earth that doesn't show a warming due to CO2. (Critics are trying to poke some holes but to have an alternate theory is a whole different ballgame.) The models are tested on historical data; they are not just statistical extrapolation of the current trend.

If you're young, I think eventually you're going to find that whether the rate of warming is 0.1 degree per decade or 0.2 degree per decade doesn't matter too much. Either way, it's too fast so it will cause mass extinction (and problems for agriculture), and either way, the new steady state temperature is driven by the amount of CO2 we emit.

asgard1024··on What are the 10 most harmful jobs?
All models eventually make predictions to the future that are difficult to validate; that's the whole point of having the model of something.

We have plenty of evidence what the steady state (based on historical data and our understanding of physics) will be; I suspect you are not familiar with it (you still didn't tell me what exactly is the thing that you find in a disagreement).

asgard1024··on What are the 10 most harmful jobs?
These are different objections. I get the feeling the problem is you, you don't want to understand the science. And I can't help you if you don't state more precisely what your objection is. For example, you say "data and model are wrong" - which data and what model?

Predicting rate of change is a tricky problem, because it's nonlinear transition phenomenon. We can easily predict the resulting steady state, though. So for instance, in some areas, scientists grossly underestimated the rate of change - for example Arctic sea ice. But that doesn't mean they don't understand what's going on - the resulting steady state (what amount of warming are we going to get, called climate sensitivity) is actually quite well understood both from history and models.

asgard1024··on What are the 10 most harmful jobs?
I downvoted you, mostly because of this sentence:

> but anyone who tells you he can predict the global surface temperature in 20 years is selling you something

They are predicting the averages, not exact numbers. It's like when someone is predicting average dice roll, it can be done even though the exact next dice roll cannot be predicted. This is one of the most misunderstood aspects of climate science.

asgard1024··on DEFCON 23 Badge Challenge
Try http://rumkin.com/tools/cipher/vigenere-keyed.php and enter LASTORY as both alphabet key and passphrase!
asgard1024··on DEFCON 23 Badge Challenge
All of it to some extent, I think the 3rd aspect the most (enjoyment of solving puzzles).

Similar puzzle hunts are very popular in Czech Republic (https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C5%A0ifrovac%C3%AD_hra) since around 2000; traditionally, there is a path of multiple locations (~15) and several kilometers (~20) that you have to get through, and they happen over night during about 20 hours.

I am going to one in 14 days and I certainly look forward to it! I think there is other factor that drives us - breaking the routine. Similar to hackathons, these happen overnight and are designed to stress you a little as you have to focus, which I think is a nice break from your day-to-day life.

asgard1024··on Show HN: Guess which government programs work
Would be nice if you explained in more detail what exactly do you mean. IMHO, this is too reductionist. I can only guess:

I imagine punishment works better on children but worse on adults. I imagine it works better against psychopaths than people who have empathy. I imagine it works better on people who coldly calculate than on people who impulsively give to emotions. I imagine it works better on people from the same ingroup than from the outgroup.

Each of these items alone can explain why you can see the effect psychologically but not socially.

asgard1024··on Show HN: Guess which government programs work
> Which likely has lead to the dismantling of state funded schools

I disagree this is a necessary outcome. It may as well happen that backward states will take notice and improve their higher education system in various ways.

But I think what you are saying is a fair point and I actually mentioned it. What I would add to my comment is the common solution to this is called "principle of subsidiarity" and it's used EU and Switzerland (which is another example of a federation that often tests different law variations in smaller scale first).

asgard1024··on Show HN: Guess which government programs work
> which doesn't deserve to use the word science

Why not? You don't think the outcomes of the presented solutions were evaluated using scientific method? It would be nice if you could elaborate.

I understand your point, but if we were fair then software engineering shouldn't be called engineering either. Just like in social sciences, there is a lot of normative judgement and opinion compared to observation and experimentation. But I think both are getting better with time, and as we continue discourse, we employ empiricism more and more.

asgard1024··on Show HN: Guess which government programs work
> One thing I've always wanted to see is a mandatory A/B test built into any new legislation

This is what I find great about US and EU (I am from Czech Republic), that in a federal system, you can test the legislation in one state first, and then see the results and this lets the other states to perhaps adopt or avoid that approach.

Unfortunately, strong moneyed interests break that model by lobbying strongly in Washington and Brussels from the start, which I think is a bad trend, but I have no idea how to prevent it. The effect of having more cultural diversity is very hard to quantify economically. (There is also other side of the coin though, which is too much state competition can lead to polarization and war.)

Although sometimes there are things where you have to be careful about this approach - for example, if one state engages in lower taxes or pro-export policies, it may gain, but the same policy enacted by everybody will make everyone lose.

asgard1024··on Show HN: Guess which government programs work
This is great! One of the interesting things about social sciences (and engineering, although just like computer hacking, social engineering has unfortunately strong negative connotations) is that the real world is often counter-intuitive. In particular, people tend to believe in punishment a lot, while it commonly escalates the problem (I like the quip "emphasis on punishment is the sign of an obedience frame").

I am dismayed that I didn't do better than random chance, even though I like to read about social issues. I think this really shows the importance of empiricism in social sciences and engineering.

asgard1024··on Exposure to Ideologically Diverse Information on Facebook
I have another conjecture. I think liberals are people who have a very inclusive ingroup, potentially including everybody on Earth; while conservatives have a smaller or better defined ingroup (e.g. Americans).

From this follows that there is only one type of liberals, but many types of conservatives (depending on their ingroup). So the view of liberals and conservatives to the others is different, because conservatives tend to perceive liberals as just another group that has them as outgroup, which is confusing to liberals.

I think in fact it's similar with religion. Atheism is often understood by religious people as another form of religion, but it isn't in fact, it has a unique position among all the types of religious belief; like liberalism is just an edge case of all possible conservativisms.

asgard1024··on Crafting Icons
Design - maybe. Craft - doubt it. The OP, as I read it, is talking primarily about craft being lost.

Maybe I am cynical, but it's easier to hire couple students filling outlines all day than to have proper artists that can do coloring, shading..

This happened to architecture and interior decoration before. We have a nice railing in my house (Prague, middle class appartment block from 1890s) that would be too expensive to replace today, you would be lucky to find a blacksmith who can do that.

Apparently, it was a normal thing 120 years ago. How come that with all the technology we have today, we can afford intricately crafted designs less and less? My only explanation is economic - people are cheap and so-called "simple" design is good enough. I think we are losing something. Instead having people skilled in craft we have them either unemployed or having some bullshit office jobs (I am no exception btw).

asgard1024··on Crafting Icons
I would think around the first iPhone.

In my opinion, flat design was "invented" as a cost saving measure. In fact the design of all other things around us follows a similar pattern - complexity and "vestigial" features are being reduced.

asgard1024··on Oracle’s license agreement as it pertains to reverse engineering
Actually it would be quite interesting to read about how the Web Archive accomplishes things like this.. Do they regularly scan news sites for new articles?
asgard1024··on The Hamburger Menu Doesn't Work
I hate the Nondescript Icon Movement. The Hamburger should die together with Three Dots, Angle Brackets and other geometric shapes that have a chutzpah to call themselves icons. Not to mention they killed the Tooltips!

These things don't appear in the vacuum - the Hamburger Menu originated from the Celtic Knot Menu, which was originally at the end of the Ribbon. The Ribbon itself confused the use cases of the Menu and the Toolbar, and was rightly criticized for that.

I am just learning Emacs and it's a little paradox that this aspie guy Richard Stallman is the one who got so many things around the UI right. We are unfortunately confusing "easy to learn" with "dumbed down so much there is nothing to learn".

asgard1024··on Parallels Between Math and Software Engineering
You are, of course, correct. It's strange no one brought up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curry%E2%80%93Howard_correspon... yet. In a very real sense, programmers are creating mathematical proofs!
asgard1024··on The help and harm of the “voluntourism” industry
I think I already addressed these objections, but let me try to be more specific.

> If I've identified what I believe is the most efficient way of doing good, why introduce middlemen

Because (unless you arrived to your conclusion by asking people globally what they need), you've just become the middleman! Then you are the one deciding what's good for the others, not the recipients.

I think it's very tempting, and that's why people should take extra precautions not to do it.

> Politicians simply think voters would vote them out of office if they increased foreign aid at the expense of making substantial cuts

(Assuming you avoid those $5K in taxes.) This is pretty much an age old question whether it is morally acceptable to steal a loaf of bread to feed a starving person.

What I am saying is that it is morally acceptable, but only as a kludge. What you really should strive for is a society which doesn't face these moral dilemmas. Likewise, I consider charity only a kludge. It can do good, but can be done far better.

> If a person legitimately wanted to become better than they are, how should they go about it if not through generosity of spirit and action?

Assuming "honestly wanted to become better", I think do three things:

1. If you want to be generous, do it through your own work (that you do for living). That means do not cheat your customers, or even maybe decrease your price. And it implies not trying to gain power or cheat other people in order to do good - that's often a delusion.

2. If you think your work doesn't have an impact it should, change your job.

3. Alternatively, to help other people, help them get the more equal political and economic power in having their own say about what their needs are (so they can better share resources). (This also carries a lot of risk and is more helpful than trying to figure out how to cheat on taxes. What I am really saying: Subterfuge is allowed if other people benefit, not you - so it's OK to break the laws and norms regarding point 3, not 1.)

All of them are very hard to do, because it's very hard to be honest with yourself and not to think you can do better if you actually become a middleman. And that's why I don't like charity - it's awfully tricky to get right.

asgard1024··on The help and harm of the “voluntourism” industry
It is always a dilemma if one should criticize efficacy of good intentions. I think at some point it is necessary, even though it may come of as "whining for the sake of it".
asgard1024··on The help and harm of the “voluntourism” industry
I know many libertarians here will not like this comment, and it is slightly OT, but I don't like charity. Charity is like weather, very unreliable and you don't want modern economy rely on it (and often when needed, there is actually too little charity). I think every society needs proper social assistance/redistribution mechanisms; unfortunately, this is difficult (if not impossible) to do without "coercion" (but I don't consider taxes to be a bad thing).

In addition, I consider charity to be very condescending. It makes recipient dependent, in terms of power relations, on donor. Many wealthy people use charity to rationalize their empire building, and that's a symptom of this power dynamics.

For example, I do find Linus Torvalds lot more charitable than Bill Gates. Gates took money from one group of people (having them buy Windows) and used this power to decide to give it to other group of people based on what he thought is important. Torvalds just left the money on the table, so the society could decide what to do with them. Even though I agree that Gates' choices what to do with money are really good, Torvalds did pretty much the same without the power grab. In other words, we are led to believe that Gates' actions are better just because we can measure them (in terms of money spent), but it's not obvious that is really the case.

(Just to quickly clarify - I am not against transfer of consumption pie to people like Gates, I am against transfer of power they have in the society. Money can designate both, unfortunately.)

Ultimately, I think charity is just a device for people to believe they are better than they really are. If you absolutely have to do it, do it anonymously without much ceremony, don't rationalize any power grabs with it (for example, don't avoid paying taxes just in order to put the money to charity), and let the recipient decide on their own what they want to do with the money.

I guess the disagreements will come down to whether or not you trust the society to do the right thing. But if you don't trust the society, why would you want to be charitable at all?

Although this should be read with caution. The above only makes sense in reasonably democratic societies. Then building a charity, with someone's name attached, is a non-transparent power grab from what should be a transparent democratic process. But in undemocratic society, there is really no difference, and it may as well be better for a different wealthy individual to decide. So in a sense the above is a first-world problem; charity is, in my view, simply inferior technology compared to democratic consensus.

Finally (libertarians listen!), I think there are technology solutions that could help to avoid relying on government only, but they are not much pursued.

asgard1024··on Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret
I disagree. There are examples and counterexamples on both sides. It's really hard to decide where the blame should go.

I am from Czech Republic, a former communist country. And it was nowhere as bad as Chile or El Salvador. Or, if you want just to compare Russian atrocities, occupation in 1968 was nowhere as bad as mass rapes in Germany after the end of world war, or Ukrainian famine, or Stalin's purges.

It's not just it's not black and white, it's not even one-dimensional. You can have regime without freedom of speech that puts couple tens people per year into jail (like Czech Republic in the 70s and 80s), or you can have a regime with freedom of speech that commits torture and war abroad, killing hundreds of people. To ask/answer which one is worse is meaningless.

And to compare it from economic perspective is just outright disgusting. Even if killing some people would indeed cause higher economic growth, no human should agree to such a trade.

asgard1024··on A Company Copes With Backlash Against the Raise That Roared
I guess it's OK for you not to treat your employees fairly but it's also OK for the society at large to shun you for that. You should not forget that you being able to have a company is a social contract too.
asgard1024··on Scheme vs. Python (2011)
> It affects the use (in very positive way), but does not affect the design.

It does, because the usage was one of the design criteria for Python. That's what I mean by "Python being conservatively non-ideological"; they don't want to add features that are controversial in the programmer's community.

> But, what is true, is that a majority of people using macros do not understand how to do it properly and do not follow the right discipline.

Maybe; maybe you don't want to accept that there are good reasons against. I accept it, even if I disagree; you can do the same.

In any case, opinion how should people be programming (e.g. use macros), is ideology. One ideology can be, in practice, better than the other, but it still is an ideology. Python tries to avoid the controversial ones and only adds those that have significant consensus.

> What is needed is to promote such discipline instead of spreading lies that "macros are dangerous".

You should be a little more honest with yourself and admit there is a grain of truth in it. Things of great power are almost always dangerous. Heck, even the Lisp community is divided whether or not the macros should be "hygienic".

> there is a very strong trend back to metaprogramming at the moment: Julia, C++, D, Clojure, Rust

First of all, I think macros and template metaprogramming is a different feature. So unless D or Rust have macros, you end up with Julia and Clojure.

Second, I am talking about languages used in the industry; in the 80s, macros were in widely used languages such as assembler, C, PL/I, Common Lisp, SAS, M4, Forth.. It's simply not what we see today. It may change in the future, but given the general trend in programming languages to add constraints (smartly) rather than remove them (I mentioned FP), I think it's unlikely (just to remind you - I actually like macros, at least in CL).

Finally, you can do (equivalent of) template metaprogramming in Python (mostly, templates are way to circumvent the type system, which is already done deal in Python). You can also define DSLs in Python pretty easily, especially with __call__() methods. The bottom line, for me, is that Python has lots of small niceties (mostly in the standard library) that collectively overweight the advantages of macros.

asgard1024··on Scheme vs. Python (2011)
> It's important to mention that macros do not affect the rest of the language design choices in any way whatsoever.

I think you're wrong. It affects how people use the language, and how the community develops around it, and other things. Perhaps if people would use macros as a sort of last resort thing, then it wouldn't matter, but from my experience, they don't. It's probably most visible in the Forth community - every implementation of Forth is subtly different from the others, and by design! Chuck Moore even said that the Forth standard goes against the very idea of Forth.

I now work on a large codebase in language with macros (SAS), and while it's powerful, it also causes problems; the code where any calculation can take place during compilation is harder to read, sometimes, and they cannot be easily translated to other language, for example.

The truth is, the programming community moved from macros, which are powerful and easy to implement, to other abstractions, less powerful but more specific to problems that people usually face (such as OOP). Many languages from 70s and 80s had macros, but today it's not so common. This transition is a little bit similar to transition from imperative to functional style, which will probably happen in the future.

← PreviousPage 9 of 22Next →