60 karma · joined January 29, 2016
Ireland applied 13.5% tax on a certain percentage of the profits, those declared in Ireland at the time, but did not apply it to all the profits. Although the book-keeping was done in an Irish company the sales where not all in Ireland. At the time Ireland sought clarification from the EU on how the tax should be applied, and were told they could only tax the profits generated in Ireland. Now, after discovering there is a sum of money in off-shore accounts that had not had the tax deducted, they have told Ireland to retrospectively apply the 13% tax on all profits unless another EU country could claim the profits were generated there.
So the original ruling was to use Ireland as a tax collector that the rest of Europe could then ask for the taxes they were due.
It seems that the Irish gov are seeking to overturn the original ruling as, according to the original information sought at the time, they were not doing anything illegal. In hindsight the accounting irregularity, refereed to as the double Irish, meant that Apple could accumulate these profits. The main issue is that these monies have not been declared in any EU country, so now because of the EU's ruling Trump has decided it belongs to America because American companies should only declare profits in America :D
The ruling, as far as the EU are concerned, is that Ireland gave Apple a deal more beneficial than anyone else. But the basis for this claim is how the tax was charged. Instead of charging Irish tax for all income for the company, they charged what was reported in Ireland. The issue that needs to be resolved is did they pay tax anywhere else on the remaining profits. The US said they did but the EU say they dont think so.
The EU has decided that all revenue income for that company should be charged in Ireland, although the US say they have also paid tax in the US.
Fundamentally Ireland is saying it did not give a "deal", the EU is saying it calculated the tax incorrectly and the US is saying that the EU's findings are based on no tax being paid elsewhere which was not the case.
As was also pointed oout, Ireland seems to be the scape-goat for all EU decisions. The Irish bail out has already been mentioned in this thread, but for those who are unaware of what happened here is a simple break down.
German companies bought binds in banks (like shares). When the banks started to fail, Germany told Ireland that the tax payer had to pay the bond holders all the investment money and the interest. However if the tax payer had purchased these bonds, they would have never received anything back. They also told Ireland that if they tried to burn the bond holders they would incur trade embargo's to stop Ireland trading in the common market (Ireland makes a loot of money from exports to Europe). So basically it was pay the bond holders or you will have no income.