HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

astoor

740 karma · joined March 31, 2021

https://arthurstoor.com/
submissionscomments
astoor··on Vitalik Buterin is worried about crypto's future
So within 7 years of the start of Bitcoin, pretty much every original Bitcoin developer had become disillusioned, with claims like it was "an experiment" and "has failed"[0]. We're now heading towards 7 years since the start of Ethereum, and it sounds like Vitalik is now too beginning to realise that it has turned into something a lot worse than what it tried to replace, e.g. because it magnifies the most terrible aspects of human nature.

[0] https://blog.plan99.net/the-resolution-of-the-bitcoin-experi...

astoor··on The Day George Soros Broke the Bank of England to Make $1.1B (2021)
He's the bad guy of the story because he's a billionaire who made a $1.1Gb at the expense of the ordinary people living in the UK at the time. He forced mortgage rates, for example, to shoot up to 15%, with crippling monthly payments for a large chunk of the population.

Note that the article author is a cryptocurrency cultist, so he'll be all in favour of unscrupulous people enriching themselves at the expense of others irrespective of the negative effects this might have on society or the environment or whatever.

astoor··on Scam e-mail impersonating Red Cross
> Blockchain is about never trusting anybody.

This is a common misconception - blockchain still requires trust, it simply shifts trust from central authorities to more nebulous entities such as anonymous developers, shady mining cartels, unregulated exchanges, the cryptocurrency oligarchs manipulating the prices, and even yourself to not lose your private keys. See also Bruce Schneier's https://www.wired.com/story/theres-no-good-reason-to-trust-b... .

astoor··on Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrency scheme
No, DApps didn't change into NFTs, and yes, DApps and ICOs still exist. But DApps and ICOs are not the current "revolutionary" "game changing" drivers for "line goes up" in the Ethereum world. Similarly I'd expect NFTs and DeFi to continue to exist after whatever supersedes them as the main attraction to draw in new members. Just like there are still people who talk about Bitcoin as "electronic cash" even though most have moved on to other narratives like "digital gold". That is the evolving self-sustainability aspect of plausible deniability. The schemes are flexible enough for existing scheme members to claim they are whatever they need to be to continue drawing in those all-important new scheme members, although most likely only for a finite period of time.
astoor··on Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrency scheme
Plausible deniability is one of ways the cryptocurrency schemes have continued for so long without collapsing - members can convince themselves that Bitcoin/Ethereum/etc. aren't ponzi/pyramid schemes because they "do something". Furthermore, that "something" can keep changing over time (e.g. for Ethereum it was first ICOs and DApps, currently it is NFTs and DeFi, and in future likely to be something else), which keeps the schemes self-sustaining. It is the plausible deniability and evolving self-sustainability which are the main advantages Bitcoin/Ethereum/etc. have over simpler schemes like BitConnect.
astoor··on Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists
This exhibits many of the classic signs you are in a cult - believing "crazy" things that non-cult-members would not believe, suspending rational thought processes and deferring to charismatic leader(s), and blaming objects of persecution for an unfeasibly wide range of issues (e.g. blaming the Fed for everything from the "breakdown of the family" to "the depletion of the soil of its nutrients").

The rest of the article exhibits many more classic indicators of cult membership - extreme obsessiveness with leader(s), any criticism or questioning characterized as persecution, special persecution of former members (Musk in the original article), denying it is a cult, etc.

astoor··on Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists
I haven't seen any profitable cryptocurrency companies which do anything genuinely useful for non-crypto people in the real world - all the profitable ones are inward-looking, i.e. engaged in "building out the ecosystem" (or "extending the pyramid scheme" depending on your perspective), e.g. the cryptocurrency exchanges. That's a big difference between the internet and cryptocurrency - the internet can be said to have started benefitting ordinary people within a few years, but there's no sign of cryptocurrency ever doing anything useful for the proverbial "man on the Clapham omnibus" after 13 years. In that sense cryptocurrency is more like the gold rush - some people find gold, most people make money selling the shovels, but the vast majority of the world are so far removed from it all that it doesn't impact them in any way whatsoever (except perhaps for the negative effect it has on their environment).
astoor··on A quick breakdown of what SWIFT is and why it matters
There's plenty of services which map Bitcoin addresses to real-world entities, e.g. Chainalysis Reactor, so coming up with a list of addresses to freeze/sanction would be the easy part.
astoor··on Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India
Not really like-for-like though - in this case a more appropriate saying would be "don't let a licenced professional purveyor of meat with provenance trails judge unlicenced masked street-vendors of meat-like substances of unknown origin during a time of unprecedented household pet disappearances".
astoor··on Confessions of a Bitcoin Widow
Just a thought: could Gerald Cotten have also been a stolen identity, as his co-founder Michael Patryn was (Michael Patryn was actually "Omar Dhanani who was convicted on identity theft charges in the U.S. and served 18 months in Federal prison"[0])? It would be much easier to fake the death of a stolen identity and reassume your real identity, rather than fake the death of your real identity and assume a stolen one for the rest of your life.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions

astoor··on Confessions of a Bitcoin Widow
Note that this wasn't a case of the money being lost because the key was lost when the owner died as per the initial headlines - in this case the money simply wasn't there in the first place: "Quadriga likely never invested the funds entrusted to it, according to Chainalysis, ... Either the funds were never received or quickly went missing" and "Ernst & Young found five Quadriga cold wallet addresses, but they were empty, containing no cryptocurrency since April 2018."[0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions

astoor··on Confessions of a Bitcoin Widow
It seems like withdrawals were in cash: "Quadriga used an unusual teller-window system for customers to withdraw their money. Rather than pay customers via bank wires, they were told to come to a nondescript building in Laval, Quebec to pick up the cash."[0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions

astoor··on Binance is taking a $200M stake in Forbes
It won't be the people at the top leading the revolt. It never is. They'll have creamed enough off to be safe whatever happens. It'll be the people at the bottom. They might not have large individual "investments", but it is large to them, and when one day all of that disappears, they won't be happy. And there will be a lot of them, the 99.999% who own a tiny percentage of the total wealth. Remember - strength in numbers...
astoor··on BBC cryptocurrency documentary pulled from air at last minute
From the now-deleted BBC article[0] he allegedly turned $50 into $10,000 in 5 days, but doesn't say with which coin(s) and/or token(s):

"Fifty dollars turned into $500 (£369) three days later," Mr Hassan said of his financial journey that began at the age of 19. "Two more days later, it was $5,000 (£3,690)."

He said he called his parents to discuss what he should do, but during that half-hour conversation, his investment had more than doubled in value again."

[0] https://archive.is/6taZ8 and https://web.archive.org/web/20220209102657/https://www.bbc.c...

astoor··on Ask HN: What Has Happened to Twitter?
If enough people don't like the changes in an open source system, they can get together and fix it or fork it. I see a number of others comments mentioning the already working (non web3) solution Mastodon - and that's a great example of this in practice.

To look at it another way, how would web3 actually help here? As far as I can tell it would only make this example worse - a more user hostile UI (faffing around with wallets and keys and whatnot), less decentralised (everything going through one API to interact with the blockchain), more resistant to change (forking blockchains is a big deal and only tends to happen when rich people at the top of the pyramid don't like something), more expensive (gas fees), less privacy (your wallet address being essentially an undeletable cookie), more likely to incentivise divisiveness and conflict (flamewars driven by the expectation of personal profit rather than just likes), etc. etc.

astoor··on Ask HN: What Has Happened to Twitter?
> "Nitter can only archive (and update) data Twitter allows them to access."

That's exactly what you'd expect from a Twitter archive site. The author's point was that this is the same tech you'd need for a Twitter replacement, and this doesn't need blockchain or web3.

Reminds me of the comment on HN from a few months back "On web2 music artists only get 18% of the revenue. Spotify gets 33%. The music industry takes 49%. Web3 flips the script." You don't need blockchain or web3 to fix that either - centralised solutions like bandcamp.com already give the artist 80-90%.

astoor··on When the Stagnation Goes Virtual
"This time is different. It’s not just speculation, it’s about community." (from article)

"Let me assure you that this is not one of those shady pyramid schemes you've been hearing about. No sir. Our model is the trapezoid!" (from The Simpsons)

But seriously, I can imagine that being in such a community would be all fun and games when there is a sufficient flow of new community members to keep the prices going up and so to keep making the existing community members richer and richer. However, at some point the music will stop and the party will come to an end, in which case what will happen to the sense of community then? And perhaps more importantly what will be its wider impact on society? If that community just forms a relatively small segment then the fallout could be contained, but if it sucks in an entire generation, or worse still an entire country, it could conceivably get physical. See also the collapse of pyramid schemes in Albania in 1997: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albanian_Civil_War .

astoor··on In second largest DeFi hack, Blockchain Bridge loses $320M Ether
Do you even have any incentive to find employees that won't steal, if you've already made off with millions in pre-mine or up-front no-commitment investment? Cryptocurrency and DeFi is one giant moral hazard.
astoor··on How will the correction in the stock market impact startup fundraising?
> "the crypto ecosystem looks more like 2000 than the current software market because most of the software companies today worth billions generate hundreds of millions of revenue"

The big difference between the dot-com bubble and the current cryptocurrency bubble is that there were lots of useful dot-coms which didn't make a profit while there are lots of profitable cryptocurrencies which aren't useful. That's because dot-coms put the use case first while cryptocurrency puts the monetisation first, leading to the monetisation of nothing and removing the incentive to actually build anything (whether useful or not). It remains to be seen whether any useful legitimate practical uses will come out of the cryptocurrency space, but it isn't looking promising after 13 years, while after that length of time the dot-com bubble had been and gone and recovered and led to mass adoption of lots of useful things we all use on a daily basis.

astoor··on Craig Wright suing developers to forcibly give him access to internet coins
I believe the last verified communication from Satoshi (before the account was compromised) was "I'm not Dorian Nakamoto" in 2014: http://p2pfoundation.ning.com/forum/topics/bitcoin-open-sour... .

Edit: See also the full list of forum posts at https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/posts/ .

astoor··on Craig Wright suing developers to forcibly give him access to internet coins
Just to clarify, the article is about the court case where he wants some transactions on the Bitcoin SV blockchain reversed. The question relating to whether he is Satoshi, and therefore owns Satoshi's 1.1M Bitcoins on the Bitcoin Core blockchain, is a separate court case.
astoor··on Craig Wright suing developers to forcibly give him access to internet coins
"They've all refused Wright's demands, though a firm called nChain Ltd is 'said to be working on a modification to the existing BSV client software, which would enable someone who owns but cannot access the BSV to regain control of them.'"

Note that Craig Wright is the Chief Science Officer of nChain[0].

It seems cryptocurrency enthusiasts love irreversible transactions until they have one of their own transactions they want reversed, although if you're high enough up the pyramid you can get yourself sorted, e.g. by rewriting the client software (as in this case) or by forking the blockchain (as per Butlerin and The DAO[1]).

[0] https://nchain.com/about/

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_DAO_(organization)

astoor··on €2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would own the IP
The fact that cryptocurrency schemes like DAOs allow people to raise vast sums of money in very short spaces of time with no evidence of anyone involved having the ability, skills or even intention of delivering anything, seems to be fundamentally flawed to me. It seems that you are only going to attract dreamers who want to be able to get rich really quickly without having to do anything much, and I wouldn't have thought those would include the sorts of people who would be most likely to put in the time and effort and attention to detail and hard work required to build things that are truly worthwhile and which will stand the test of time.
astoor··on €2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would own the IP
Will be interesting to see how this, as in the whole DAO space, works out. Part of the problem with the ICO craze in 2017* is that the founders got all the money up front without having any obligation to do anything, so the tiny minority of well intentioned ones ended up simply enjoying the money rather than doing something hard like actual work. Seems like this is still a risk here - the founder can string people along for a few months or years until they lose interest, all the while drawing down the money and living rather comfortably.

* The other problem with the ICO craze is of course that the combination of money up-front and no obligations and anonymity meant almost all were simply out-and-out scams.

astoor··on My First Impressions of Web3
It is very refreshing to see this from a primarily technical angle.

In common with many HN-ers, I actually did a lot of cryptocurrency and blockchain dev work 5+ years ago, and was actually very exited about it at first, before realising what was behind the curtains. It is a similar story with many early Bitcoin developers, including one famously describing it as an experiment that failed[0]. I also get the distinct impression that the vast majority of pro-cryptocurrency people on HN at the moment are relatively new[1].

I stopped looking at it primarily from a technical angle because I realised that, firstly, the technology isn't anywhere nearly as useful as some people make out and might never be able to do the things which are promised, but secondly and more importantly, the technology really isn't the important part - what matters is the belief that technology might work, and sustaining that belief for long enough to make money. Moxie hints at this when he says "you can’t stop a gold rush".

There were an increasing number of people at the tech meetups etc. who knew nothing about the technology. Many were gamblers, refugees from the 2011 "Black Friday"[2], who knew full well that many of the schemes they were putting money into would never work or were even out-and-out scams, but they enjoyed the thrill of trying to get in and out and make money before the collapse.

The was also a growing sense of people being involved just to be anti-establishment. The ironic thing is that, back in 2008, you could make a reasonable case that the established banks were the bad guys and the cypherpunks were the good guys, but the situation has now definitely reversed - the banks have cleaned up their acts considerably (anyone who has worked in one for a long time will say how completely different the cultures are now vs then) with new regulations (e.g. Dodd-Frank) and most have plans to become carbon neutral, etc., and it is all the cryptocurrency scammers and fraudsters and climate-destroyers who are the bad guys now.

But there is more to it than that. There was also an increasing undercurrent of very non-technical people coming in and trying to exploit the technologists excited to work on the next new and shiny thing. I know that kind-of thing happens with everything, but this was much deeper and more malicious than in other contexts.

So while the technology isn't the important part, it is useful to be reminded of the intractable problems with the technology.

[0] https://blog.plan99.net/the-resolution-of-the-bitcoin-experi...

[1] Yes I know there may be exceptions, but just for example compare all the newbie comments on the recent https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29635907 with the highly technical ones on the related post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7365663 from 8 years ago (including "I'm one of the thieves mentioned").

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Scheinberg

astoor··on Mozilla Foundation pausing cryptocurrency donations
There was an article[0] which estimated that the entire global banking system (down to lamps on desks in offices) used 100Twh a year, whereas Bitcoin used around 30Twh a year (for a relatively insignificant volume of transactions). I don't know how accurate that is, but despite the unfavourable statistics, the article was still from some pro-Bitcoin person concluding that we should "stop complaining about Bitcoin and start complaining about Xmas lights". Also note that Bitcoin's energy use has since risen to 110Twh a year[1].

[0] https://hackernoon.com/the-bitcoin-vs-visa-electricity-consu...

[1] https://hbr.org/2021/05/how-much-energy-does-bitcoin-actuall...

astoor··on Crypto: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
The author believes "a Twitter where your popular tweets earn you money" would be a good thing? Twitter is already full of people trying to shout the loudest - how can adding a financial incentive to shout even louder make things better rather than worse?
astoor··on Kosovo bans cryptocurrency mining to save electricity
Yes, but gold hasn't been explicitly designed to require ever increasing amounts of energy to extract ever diminishing quantities, and gold does have some practical use (approx 8% of annual production is used in mobile phones, televisions etc.)
astoor··on Real Problems That Web3 Solves, Part 1
IndieAuth[0] is an open standard decentralised authentication protocol which doesn't need blockchain or cryptocurrency.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IndieAuth and https://indieweb.org/IndieAuth

astoor··on Ask HN: What are you predictions for 2022?
- Hype around web3.0 will die down when people realise (i) most of what is promised isn't actually technically possible, and (ii) the limited applications that are actually delivered are so user-unfriendly that they get no traction outside the cryptocurrency sphere.

- The current cryptocurrency bubble will burst and most interest will evaporate. It will not go away completely though - it will be kept alive by the dream of getting rich with near-zero effort, like the casino and gambling industry, and there may even be another cryptocurrency bubble in a few years time.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →