HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

at-w

213 karma · joined May 25, 2015

submissionscomments
at-w··on Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit
It seems another issue is simply the politicization of American media in general which Wikipedia relies on by design. Even if Wikipedia's editors were totally neutral, their reliance on mainstream media coverage to dictate what is worth covering in an article and what isn't ends up mirroring what American mainstream media sources cover (and don't cover).

Even in 1971, when the partisan divide had much more crossover than it does today, just 25% of journalists identified as Republicans. By 2014, that number was 7% according to the Washington Post (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2014/05/06/ju...). As the Post's Cillizza points out, that number is for all journalists in the US, and is likely much lower in major media outlets in urban centres that are already often 80%+ Democratic voting in the broader population. With further partisan polarization and the closure of local news outlets, it's likely that percentage is negligible in the major, invariably big-city based outlets used as sources on Wikipedia.

Whatever you think of Biden, the unanimous blackballing of the Hunter Biden laptop story as "Russian propaganda" outside of explicitly right-wing news sources, including banning it being sent over private message on the two largest communication platforms on earth, is a pretty astounding example of how far that's gone. Anyone who wasn't being deliberately obtuse that looked at the New York Post's reporting could see it was likely real. Seeing journalists ignore the story at best and widely cheer on censorship of stories based on their political implications is a massive deviation from the premise of a media generally willing to cover all important stories that Wikipedia is built around.

at-w··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
>Sources? Wasn’t the crack epidemic more related to Contra and the breaking of the family unit due to disproportionate incarceration of black males by the government in attempt to break their political power via the selective targeting of specific drugs by the govt, i.e marijuana and crack over cocaine?

The overwhelming majority of the rise in crime occurred between 1964 and 1974, in which time the murder rate in the US more than doubled and reached its all-time high in 1974.

Crack cocaine itself wasn't found in the US until the mid-1980s, i.e. well after the overwhelming majority of the rise in crime had already occurred. With no crack present in the US, it's clearly ridiculous to attribute the rise in crime to a drug-or laws targeting a drug-that didn't exist in the US until a decade later.

The crack vs. cocaine sentencing law you mention didn't exist until 1986, when it was pushed for primarily by black and progressive political leaders (notably the bill's author, then-senator Joe Biden) who believed it would address the rampant violence they associated with crack in their communities (https://www.npr.org/2017/07/17/537715793/how-black-leaders-u..., https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/how-an-early-biden-c...).

In other words, neither crack laws nor significant crack use itself existed until the vast majority of the rise in crime had already occurred. Even the most outlandish theories of Contra involvement in drug trafficking (which they were involved to some extent like many South American guerrilla groups) would attribute a literal drop in the bucket of the cocaine trafficked to the US to the Contras. Again, this is only even relevant if you think crack caused the rise in violent crime that occurred decades before it was introduced to the US.

To address your third point, the incarceration rates you mention didn't actually start rising until 1973 and remained much lower than in the 1950s until the mid-70s (https://nap.nationalacademies.org/read/18613/chapter/4#35). Moreover, they didn't begin their rapid climb until 1980, at which point crime had begun declining. For reference, about 5 times as many people are in jail/prison today as in 1975: https://nap.nationalacademies.org/read/18613/chapter/4#35 When incarceration rates truly began skyrocketing in the late '80s-2000s, violent crimes were rapidly dropping.

at-w··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
Can you see how '60s establishment types might think the same about people "hiding behind" peace and love gibberish to remain a cesspool of drug pushing, adulterous freeloaders, whose success in mainstreaming drugs and hostility to social institutions objectively coincided directly with an explosion in violent crime and social issues like single motherhood, drug addiction, rioting and urban decay, all of which rose to unprecedented levels from 1965-1975 in every Western country that experienced a similar "counterculture"?

That's not to make any judgement on the societal value of 4Chan vs. the 1960s counterculture. It's just that neither is/was a uniform group that can be defined as "rooted in X, Y, or Z," and people who claim they can are typically blind to the bias of their cultural perspective.

at-w··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
Or more objectively, they see murder rates literally doubling from 1964-1974, a rise never before seen in American history. They see a massive drug epidemic and an entirely unprecedented breakdown in the family unit that results in literally millions of children born to single mothers. They see a collapse of social institutions coinciding with an again unprecedented rise in suicides and antisocial activities. They see cities like Detroit, Newark (and to varying degrees nearly every other major city in the US) begin rapid declines that haven't been reversed to this day. Then they look to every other Western country that experienced the same "counterculture" in the same period and see these same issues to a similar or even greater extent.

It is either incredibly ignorant or intentionally dishonest to pretend that the 1960s counterculture was some uniformly benevolent force for peace and love, and says a lot about the person claiming so's lack of ability to see anything outside their contemporary/status-quo perspective.

at-w··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
"I don't think anyone will look back with fondness or positivity towards a bunch of drug-pushing, mentally stunted adulterous freeloaders that disrespect hard working people, people putting their lives on the line for their country, people devoted to their families, and the nation that allows them the freedom to exist in the first place--while jerking themselves into a froth over who's the edgiest edge lord."

Even as someone who favours liberal drug laws at this point, the social upheaval of the late '60s had objectively horrific consequences for the poor in particular. The massive drug epidemic that to this day kills more Americans than the entire Vietnam War every year, the unprecedented doubling of murder rates overall in nearly every Western country from 1965-1975, and collapse of the family unit seem like more tangible downsides than a small number of what you describe as edgelords jerking themselves into a froth on a forum read by other edgelords.

Nearly every major social issue of the late 20th century exploded as a direct result of hippie culture bringing drugs and hostility towards the family and social institutions into the mainstream. People often think of rising crime as the result of the 1980s crack "epidemic," but the explosion in murder rates occurred almost entirely from 1966-1975 and actually grew at a slower pace up to 1990 (outside the UK): https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/uRI8Y/1/ The US murder rate in 1974 was exactly the same as it was at the peak of the "Crack epidemic" in 1990, and more than double the rate it was in 1964.

You can still argue the benefits outweighed the costs, but it's simply ignorant to pretend 1960s counterculture was some uniformly benevolent movement for peace and love, any more than the movement you identify with 4chan is merely a benevolent movement for "national pride" or "family values."

How 4chan specifically got designated the "counterculture" in this thread is questionable, but so is the inability to look beyond the status-quo, contemporary perspective of major media, academia and corporations.

at-w··on Wait, Are We Supposed to Tip 25% Everywhere Now?
Are you okay with retail store workers asking you for a tip for pointing you to the right aisle? What about your doctor asking for a tip after a checkup? What about a relative that asks you for money every time they see you, and decides to "suggest" amounts? What about simple panhandling?

In all of those cases, you clearly have the ability to simply say no. At the same time, any socially aware person is likely to resent being pressured for money.

Your argument would make sense if tipping was something done for exceptional service. It makes less sense when it is essentially universal and implicitly risks worse service in the future at best. Even at restaurants, tipping disproportionately rewards the people who have arguably the least difficult job and does so in an empirically discriminatory way that has almost no relationship to service quality whatsoever (https://ecommons.cornell.edu/handle/1813/71781).

at-w··on Elizabeth Holmes bought one-way ticket to Mexico after convicted of fraud
The third person that came to your mind alongside Alexander Dugin and Mussolini was a Canadian professor and his fad diet promoting daughter?
at-w··on ‘Breakthrough’ obesity drugs that have stunned researchers
To be fair our ideas of normal are extremely skewed. If you look at photos from say 1962, you'd consider most people "skinny" (even photos of places like the US). Yet even then, 23% of American adults were obese according to the CDC. Even in 1987, the actor that played Private Pyle in Full Metal Jacket gained 75lbs to play a comically obese Marine. Today he looks fitter than most people you'd see everyday.

If you look at the US today, an average of just 1 in 4 people are not medically overweight or obese. What was considered (and is factually) obese, is now considered "chubby" or "curvy" if not normal by most Americans for whom that is normal.

at-w··on How Did Sam Bankman-Fried Get Bail?
With flight risk being accounted for in his bail being set at $250 million, surrendering his passport, and agreeing to remain confined in his parents' home. Those are incredibly strict bail terms for any crime, and clearly factor in his immense wealth.
at-w··on How Did Sam Bankman-Fried Get Bail?
Off the top of my head I'd look at who their crime affected and to what degree, why the perpetrator did it, whether it was premeditated or done in the spur of the moment, what other options the perpetrator had, etc.

Someone who is intellectually mediocre, grows up around violent scumbags, and ends up robbing others instead of working a job is reprehensible, but I would say less so than a Bernie Madoff who was already wealthy, highly capable, and decided to defraud people of their life savings over decades. Madoff is not someone like Martin Shkreli bullshitting wealthy investors out of some portion of their wealth, he's someone who ruined people's lives.

People often discount "economic" crimes that they can't directly see the harms of, like insurance fraud, welfare fraud, tax cheating, corruption etc. That's easy to do in places like the US, but becomes more obviously problematic in places like Southern Italy or Argentina whose economies have gradually been destroyed by a widespread acceptance of corruption, cheating and "economic" crimes.

at-w··on How Did Sam Bankman-Fried Get Bail?
>They also are objectively more likely to have the means to flee out of jurisdiction.

That is explicitly factored into the decision of whether to grant bail and determining flight risk. It's probably not going out on a limb to say SBF's $250 MILLION dollar bail had something to do with his wealth and the flight risk it presented, and isn't standard procedure.

>If a criminal is deemed extremely likely to commit violent crime on bail, they simply shouldn't get bail, the amount they pay or are able to should be moot

This is also how it works right now. Sometimes established systems have gotten some things right in their thousands of years of development, even when they're not perfect. Presumably nobody's arguing the pudgy crypto fraudster who has never been so much as accused of a violent crime is "extremely likely to commit violent crime on bail."

at-w··on How Did Sam Bankman-Fried Get Bail?
It's hard to believe that the likelihood of a criminal reoffending in the period awaiting trial (what bail relates to) is higher for someone who depends on committing violent crimes to support themselves than someone that's followed around by the media constantly, depends on their now ruined reputation to run their scam, and has never even been alleged to have committed any violent crime?

I believe many/most white collar criminals are morally reprehensible people who often deserve far greater punishment than even violent criminals for the harm that they do. That doesn't change the fact that in the generally brief period awaiting trial, they are far less of an immediate threat to those around them than even a low-level violent criminal.

at-w··on How Did Sam Bankman-Fried Get Bail?
I base that estimation on his offense being entirely reliant on a corporation (whose assets are now frozen), his own personal reputation (which is now destroyed), and his crime not alleged to involve violence in any form.

Morally, I think people like Madoff are worse than many gang members or low-level violent criminals. That doesn't change the fact that they are far less of an immediate threat to the people around them, particularly now that they have been exposed. A confidence scam fraudster who has been exposed is a bit like a paraplegic murderer. They may be morally reprehensible, but they're effectively unlikely to reoffend in a few months awaiting trial.

If you honestly would rather live next to the average person arrested for assault or robbery than Bankman-Fried while both await trial, be my guest, but you can probably understand why others might feel differently.

Like many things, cash bail is effectively "discriminatory" in that it tends to hurt poor criminals more than white collar ones. That still doesn't mean discrimination is the primary reason it exists, or that that somehow negates any of its benefits.

at-w··on How Did Sam Bankman-Fried Get Bail?
To play devil's advocate, extremely high profile white collar criminals like SBF are objectively less likely to reoffend while on bail in a way that would harm regular citizens than someone arrested for any violent or gang-related crime. His victims deserve justice too, but the odds of him defrauding more people while on bail now that this is widely known, he's under constant surveillance, and his/FTX's assets are frozen, is incredibly low.

Bernie Madoff, Elizabeth Holmes and the like are all scumbags, but if you give me the choice between living next to them, or someone arrested for almost any other crime, I'm picking the fraudster that depended on their now ruined public image to defraud people.

at-w··on Asbestos Cigarette Filters (2018)
This is misleading in the same way as saying "marijuana is a Schedule 1 drug, the same group as heroin!"

Class 1 just means it is a known carcinogen in humans, and says nothing about the degree to which it is carcinogenic, what cancers it is connected to, how that varies by intake or population, or much else. Sunlight, salted fish, charred foods, and just about any food packaged or prepared in plastic are all also known carcinogens. Any of those may well be very dangerous, but saying they're "in the same group" means almost nothing.

at-w··on Drowning in AI Generated Garbage: the silent war we are fighting
How would having additional content above the recipe change the copyright status of the recipe itself, divorced from the additional content? It prevents directly copying the entire article, but not the actual recipe (and Google already heavily penalizes exact duplicate content).

What would make more sense is that they are actually taking the recipes from elsewhere and adding the stories to avoid directly duplicating another page, and the Google ranking penalty associated with exact or close duplicates.

My moderate experience with SEO suggests it's a combination of factors. First, Google generally rewards longer content (https://www.sweor.com/seocontentlength), or at least content longer than the few hundred words a simple recipe would likely be limited to.

Secondly, there is (mixed) evidence that Google rewards sites on which people spend longer before clicking back.

Thirdly, the longer format allows them to insert more keywords/longer tail keywords vs. a short format where inserting lots of keywords would be seen as keyword stuffing.

I'd also guess that as much as some people dislike superfluous stories when looking for a recipe, it is a positive for a subset of users that are more likely to subscribe to/return to that site directly in the future.

at-w··on America’s syringe exchanges kill drug users
Just like fentanyl doesn't "kill" anyone either, respiratory arrest does.
at-w··on “Negative/hate tweets will be max deboosted and demonetized”
Like Comcast deciding they don't want workers discussing unionizing using the internet infrastructure that they privately own. Or financial institutions like PayPal freezing and seizing your money on their "private property" because of speech they don't like. Or when AWS, Microsoft, and the largest and most powerful corporations in human history coordinated to take a separate social network offline because of speech they didn't like.

Or when Twitter and Facebook coordinated to falsely label a true story "Russian disinformation" days before an election, literally preventing people from sharing it with each other privately on the world's largest communications networks. Whether Hunter Biden smoking crack with prostitutes would impact the election, or is even anyone's business, is questionable to me. But so is having billionaire tech CEOs decide what people can discuss through private communications with the express intent of suppressing information related to a political campaign.

The same goes for credit card monopolies like VISA and Mastercard coordinating to destroy businesses like Mindgeek because of moralist outrage from another "side."

at-w··on “Judas goats” were once key players in meatpacking plants
Most things we eat are chosen because they taste good in combination with other things, and better than the sum of the individual ingredients eaten separately. Eating a stick of butter probably isn't appetizing, but neither would your examples of eating pure salt or unprocessed pepper unless you have particularly odd tastes.
at-w··on Ask HN: Does anyone use Bayesian stats to filter interesting stories on the Net?
Doesn't the upvote system used by HN/Reddit/etc. accomplish the same thing? Outright spam of the kind detectable by a basic filter would presumably be detected by other users who vote on that content. It also has the added benefit of ranking content based on the kind of common appeal you mention, beyond just filtering outright spam, and avoiding the kind of false positives almost any spam filter would be susceptible to.
at-w··on Michael Burry’s warning for the index fund bubble
Did it go "terribly wrong"/do we know how large his position actually was?
at-w··on Meta stock price drops more than 20%
>Of course, there are arguments around the externalities of all of these things. I view most of those arguments as society contextual (people don't like others smoking, so it is an externality) as opposed to something like carbon which would have a negative externality regardless of this societal/cultural context.

I agree with you here and find the obsession many people here have with advertising weird. Still, alcohol pretty clearly has a negative externality "regardless of societal/cultural context." The consistently high percentage of vehicular deaths, assaults, rapes, damage to developing babies through FAS, and so on are all largely borne by people besides the drinker themselves.

at-w··on ACT Test Scores Drop to Lowest Levels in More Than 30 Years
Historically college applications have gone up during recessions as the opportunity cost of college drops due to worse job prospects (https://www.communitycollegereview.com/blog/why-student-enro...). With that said, significant changes in average scores are much more likely to be related to changes like who is taking the test, and massive shocks like the shutdowns during COVID that had a major impact on teaching and student outcomes across all age groups (https://www.theguardian.com/education/2022/sep/01/math-readi...).
at-w··on Ask HN: Have you noticed an increase in the number of Stripe Disputes lately?
I'm curious about your experience as I had a similar impression before dealing with disputes on a large scale, but since actually fighting them with detailed evidence have won ~80% of them. This is true of order not received, claiming the entire transaction was fraudulent etc. With that being said my business is a digital service so that may be the reason for our different experiences.

What kind of dispute claims do most of your customers make, and what kind of evidence do you provide besides USPS tracking?

at-w··on 2/3s of 1000 People Surveyed Canceled a Streaming Service in the Last Year
>No person who did not wish to dominate others would choose to use advertising

This sounds like a very weird interpretation of the word "dominate," at best. Emailing someone to introduce yourself, your product, or your services is also "interfering in people's thinking patterns." So is talking to anyone in person or online. So is linking to your book's Amazon page on your profile as a way to "dominate" the minds of people who visit your profile.

at-w··on Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production to India
China has been below 2.2 in 1990 and has remained well below that since, while continuing to have a growing population. If you're looking even three or four decades ahead it's not a huge problem for India.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2